
Robert Jenrick (Image: Getty)
Tory and Labour governments have allowed a million young people to be out of work, education or training. Instead they’re unemployed – languishing on benefits. It’s a scandalous waste of our country’s potential.
After waiting a year on a Review to turn things around, it emerged yesterday that Burnham’s plan will take 10 years to produce any savings.
By the time Labour are forecast to reduce the youth benefits bill we’re forecast to spend £1.7 trillion on working age welfare. We will have gone bust before reforms make any impact.
A lot of the changes recommended were simply undoing the mistakes Labour have already made. Rachel Reeves’s jobs tax has proven to be a disaster.
Burnham’s going an inch when we need a mile.
Each day Andy Burnham is in No10 he resembles Keir Starmer more closely. Aimless, drifting, and with no answers to the big problems facing our country.
We’ve had a nothingburger Budget that did nothing to help people with the cost of living.
A much-needed defence spending increase has been postponed.
Immigration restrictions have been watered down to stop rebellion from Labour MPs.
Burnham’s the procrastinating Prime Minister who boots anything difficult into the long grass.
He simply can’t face doing the job he spent so long scheming to get. Today was another case in point. His much-hyped plan to fix the youth jobs crisis flopped as the facts emerged.

Annual costs and savings (Image: Welfare State to a Working State report)
Reform would reverse Rachel Reeves’s jobs tax for British workers, paid for by a levy on migrant workers, to put them first.
We’d cut worthless Mickey Mouse degrees that laden students with debt.
We’d back apprentices with an Apprenticeship Retention Bonus and end reliance on foreign doctors and nurses by lifting the arbitrary cap on medical school places and training British applicants.
We won’t stand by while another generation of youngsters are lost.
Andy Burnham’s New Wheeze to Tackle Welfare Crisis Has Already ‘Flopped’
Andy Burnham is facing mounting criticism over his ambitious plans to tackle Britain’s welfare crisis, after opposition politicians accused him of offering little more than promises while delaying meaningful savings for years.
The Prime Minister’s proposed overhaul of the benefits system, based on recommendations from former Labour minister Alan Milburn, was supposed to provide a fresh solution to Britain’s growing youth unemployment problem. Instead, it has triggered a political row over public spending, benefit reductions and whether Labour has any realistic strategy for getting people back into work.
The criticism comes at a particularly difficult time for Burnham. Britain’s working-age welfare bill continues to attract attention, while almost one million young people are not in education, employment or training. The Government has promised to reduce benefit dependency, improve employment opportunities and strengthen the economy.
However, critics argue that the proposals will take far too long to deliver meaningful results.
Robert Jenrick has been particularly outspoken, describing Burnham’s plan as a failure before it has even been properly implemented. His criticism centres on the estimated timetable for savings, the cost of introducing new employment programmes and the possibility that welfare spending will continue increasing in the meantime.
For Burnham, the challenge is now to demonstrate that his approach can deliver results rather than simply produce another lengthy government review.
1. Robert Jenrick claims Burnham’s welfare strategy has already failed
The strongest criticism has come from Robert Jenrick, who attacked the Prime Minister in a Daily Express opinion article published on November 17, 2026.
Jenrick argued that Britain cannot afford to wait another decade for welfare reforms to produce substantial savings.
He described the Government’s approach as far too slow, suggesting that the country needs immediate action rather than another long-term programme.
His criticism focused on the fact that the Milburn review envisages a major transformation of youth employment and welfare support over ten years.
Jenrick argued that by the time the proposed changes have delivered their expected savings, the country will have accumulated an enormous additional welfare bill.
He also criticised the Government for failing to address what he described as the underlying causes of unemployment.
In particular, he attacked Labour’s previous employment and taxation policies, arguing that increased costs for employers have made recruitment more difficult.
His intervention represents a broader Conservative and Reform criticism of Labour’s economic strategy: that ministers are spending too much time announcing future ambitions while failing to address immediate financial pressures.
However, Jenrick’s description of the plan as having flopped is a political judgment, not evidence that the programme has already failed. Most of the proposed reforms have not yet been implemented.
2. Almost one million young people remain outside work and education
The scale of Britain’s youth employment problem is one of the main reasons the Government commissioned the Milburn review.
According to the report, approximately 981,000 young people aged 16 to 24 were not in education, employment or training during the second quarter of 2026.
These individuals are commonly described as NEETs.
The problem has serious implications for the British economy.
Young people who remain outside employment for extended periods can struggle to develop professional experience, gain qualifications and establish financial independence.
Long-term unemployment can also increase the likelihood of mental health difficulties and dependence on welfare support.
Milburn believes the existing system has failed to provide enough opportunities for young people to move into sustainable employment.
His proposed reforms aim to reduce the NEET rate from approximately 13 per cent to five per cent by 2036.
However, critics question whether a ten-year target is ambitious enough given the immediate scale of the problem.
The Conservatives argue that young people need opportunities now rather than promises about what might happen in the next decade.
The Government insists that meaningful improvements require investment in education, healthcare and employment support.
3. Welfare savings could take years to materialise
One of the most controversial aspects of the proposals is their financial timetable.
Milburn’s review recommends moving spending away from long-term benefit dependency and towards employment support, training and education.
The programme is expected to require approximately £500 million in initial investment during 2027/28.
Annual spending could eventually rise to £5.8 billion by 2036/37.
The review estimates that welfare savings could reach approximately £3.6 billion annually by the end of that period, with additional tax revenues generated by higher employment.
The Government argues that investing in young people now could reduce the financial burden on taxpayers in the future.
However, opposition politicians question whether the country can afford to wait.
The Office for Budget Responsibility has forecast that total welfare spending will rise substantially over the coming years.
Jenrick argues that the Government is failing to deal with the immediate financial consequences.
Kemi Badenoch has also challenged Burnham over the timetable, arguing that the country cannot wait ten years for meaningful reductions in welfare expenditure.
The financial disagreement is therefore central to the political controversy.
The Government believes that upfront investment is necessary to produce sustainable savings, while its opponents want a faster reduction in spending.
4. Burnham faces pressure over his promise to reduce benefits
The Prime Minister has repeatedly insisted that he wants to bring down the welfare bill as quickly as possible.
However, his statements have attracted criticism because he has been reluctant to commit to a precise timetable for achieving substantial savings.
During Prime Minister’s Questions, Badenoch challenged him over whether the Government would reduce welfare spending before the next general election.
Burnham responded that he would do everything possible to accelerate the reforms.
He also announced that he had asked the Cabinet to reprioritise spending plans for 2027/28 to begin funding a new Youth Opportunity Service.
The initial programme is expected to provide 25,000 quality work placements for young people aged 16 and 17.
Badenoch accused the Prime Minister of offering what she described as a ‘vibes-based’ approach to welfare reform.
Her criticism was that the Government was promising improvements without explaining exactly when the financial benefits would materialise.
Burnham rejected that assessment, arguing that the objective was to help young people into sustainable employment rather than simply remove financial assistance.
This distinction is important because cutting benefits without providing employment opportunities could leave vulnerable people facing greater financial difficulties.
Nevertheless, the Government will need to demonstrate that its strategy can deliver measurable improvements.
Andy Burnham’s New Wheeze to Tackle Welfare Crisis Has Already ‘Flopped’
Andy Burnham is facing mounting criticism over his ambitious plans to tackle Britain’s welfare crisis, after opposition politicians accused him of offering little more than promises while delaying meaningful savings for years.
The Prime Minister’s proposed overhaul of the benefits system, based on recommendations from former Labour minister Alan Milburn, was supposed to provide a fresh solution to Britain’s growing youth unemployment problem. Instead, it has triggered a political row over public spending, benefit reductions and whether Labour has any realistic strategy for getting people back into work.
The criticism comes at a particularly difficult time for Burnham. Britain’s working-age welfare bill continues to attract attention, while almost one million young people are not in education, employment or training. The Government has promised to reduce benefit dependency, improve employment opportunities and strengthen the economy.
However, critics argue that the proposals will take far too long to deliver meaningful results.
Robert Jenrick has been particularly outspoken, describing Burnham’s plan as a failure before it has even been properly implemented. His criticism centres on the estimated timetable for savings, the cost of introducing new employment programmes and the possibility that welfare spending will continue increasing in the meantime.
For Burnham, the challenge is now to demonstrate that his approach can deliver results rather than simply produce another lengthy government review.
1. Robert Jenrick claims Burnham’s welfare strategy has already failed
The strongest criticism has come from Robert Jenrick, who attacked the Prime Minister in a Daily Express opinion article published on November 17, 2026.
Jenrick argued that Britain cannot afford to wait another decade for welfare reforms to produce substantial savings.
He described the Government’s approach as far too slow, suggesting that the country needs immediate action rather than another long-term programme.
His criticism focused on the fact that the Milburn review envisages a major transformation of youth employment and welfare support over ten years.
Jenrick argued that by the time the proposed changes have delivered their expected savings, the country will have accumulated an enormous additional welfare bill.
He also criticised the Government for failing to address what he described as the underlying causes of unemployment.
In particular, he attacked Labour’s previous employment and taxation policies, arguing that increased costs for employers have made recruitment more difficult.
His intervention represents a broader Conservative and Reform criticism of Labour’s economic strategy: that ministers are spending too much time announcing future ambitions while failing to address immediate financial pressures.
However, Jenrick’s description of the plan as having flopped is a political judgment, not evidence that the programme has already failed. Most of the proposed reforms have not yet been implemented.
2. Almost one million young people remain outside work and education
The scale of Britain’s youth employment problem is one of the main reasons the Government commissioned the Milburn review.
According to the report, approximately 981,000 young people aged 16 to 24 were not in education, employment or training during the second quarter of 2026.
These individuals are commonly described as NEETs.
The problem has serious implications for the British economy.
Young people who remain outside employment for extended periods can struggle to develop professional experience, gain qualifications and establish financial independence.
Long-term unemployment can also increase the likelihood of mental health difficulties and dependence on welfare support.
Milburn believes the existing system has failed to provide enough opportunities for young people to move into sustainable employment.
His proposed reforms aim to reduce the NEET rate from approximately 13 per cent to five per cent by 2036.
However, critics question whether a ten-year target is ambitious enough given the immediate scale of the problem.
The Conservatives argue that young people need opportunities now rather than promises about what might happen in the next decade.
The Government insists that meaningful improvements require investment in education, healthcare and employment support.
3. Welfare savings could take years to materialise
One of the most controversial aspects of the proposals is their financial timetable.
Milburn’s review recommends moving spending away from long-term benefit dependency and towards employment support, training and education.
The programme is expected to require approximately £500 million in initial investment during 2027/28.
Annual spending could eventually rise to £5.8 billion by 2036/37.
The review estimates that welfare savings could reach approximately £3.6 billion annually by the end of that period, with additional tax revenues generated by higher employment.
The Government argues that investing in young people now could reduce the financial burden on taxpayers in the future.
However, opposition politicians question whether the country can afford to wait.
The Office for Budget Responsibility has forecast that total welfare spending will rise substantially over the coming years.
Jenrick argues that the Government is failing to deal with the immediate financial consequences.
Kemi Badenoch has also challenged Burnham over the timetable, arguing that the country cannot wait ten years for meaningful reductions in welfare expenditure.
The financial disagreement is therefore central to the political controversy.
The Government believes that upfront investment is necessary to produce sustainable savings, while its opponents want a faster reduction in spending.
4. Burnham faces pressure over his promise to reduce benefits
The Prime Minister has repeatedly insisted that he wants to bring down the welfare bill as quickly as possible.
However, his statements have attracted criticism because he has been reluctant to commit to a precise timetable for achieving substantial savings.
During Prime Minister’s Questions, Badenoch challenged him over whether the Government would reduce welfare spending before the next general election.
Burnham responded that he would do everything possible to accelerate the reforms.
He also announced that he had asked the Cabinet to reprioritise spending plans for 2027/28 to begin funding a new Youth Opportunity Service.
The initial programme is expected to provide 25,000 quality work placements for young people aged 16 and 17.
Badenoch accused the Prime Minister of offering what she described as a ‘vibes-based’ approach to welfare reform.
Her criticism was that the Government was promising improvements without explaining exactly when the financial benefits would materialise.
Burnham rejected that assessment, arguing that the objective was to help young people into sustainable employment rather than simply remove financial assistance.
This distinction is important because cutting benefits without providing employment opportunities could leave vulnerable people facing greater financial difficulties.
Nevertheless, the Government will need to demonstrate that its strategy can deliver measurable improvements.
