
Ed Miliband has opposed the Rosebank oil field (Image: Getty)
Ed Miliband has said he will “definitely not” resign if Labour approves the controversial Rosebank oil project he previously branded “climate vandalism”. Prime Minister Andy Burnham is facing growing backlash from his MPs, with more than 100 backbenchers expected to oppose the giant oilfield.
Foreign Secretary, Mr Miliband, has refused to back North Sea oil drilling which would need approval from his protégé Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh.When asked if he would quit if the Government approved it, Mr Miliband said: “No, definitely not.”
Speaking to the BBC on Monday, he said: “I’m a member of the Government and I will abide by collective responsibility on this.” But when he was in opposition, he described the Rosebank scheme as a “colossal waste of taxpayer money and climate vandalism”.
Labour inherited decisions on Rosebank and the Jackdaw gas field when it took office after legal challenges about their environmental impact overturned previous approvals.
The Government has already approved the Jackdaw scheme, with gas now flowing from the site.
But the larger Rosebank development faces resistance from Labour MPs concerned about fossil fuels.
Critics say 90% of Rosebank’s oil reserves are destined for international markets and all of it will be sold at global market prices, meaning no cheap oil reserved for UK consumers.
But the Prime Minister has been urged to listen to more than 1,000 North Sea workers instead of his backbenchers and critics.
They have signed an open letter to Mr Burnham urging him to give Rosebank the green light before Christmas.
Aberdeen and Grampian Chamber of Commerce (AGCC) has support from offshore workers, engineers, technicians and professionals working across the wider energy supply chain.
Russell Borthwick, chief executive of AGCC said: “75 Labour MPs might be making headlines in Westminster, but more than 1,000 people whose lives and livelihoods are directly affected by North Sea policy are sending the Prime Minister a very different message.
“These are the people who produce Britain’s energy, employ our workers, invest in our economy and support the communities that have powered this country for generations. Their voices deserve to be heard loudest.”
He added: “The Prime Minister deserves credit for his pragmatic decision to approve Jackdaw. It demonstrated that supporting domestic energy production and pursuing our climate ambitions are not mutually exclusive.
“Let’s also put to bed the suggestion that approving Rosebank would somehow diminish Britain’s global leadership on climate change.”
Shadow Energy Secretary Andrew Bowie said: “One gas field does not make an energy strategy. Labour cannot claim to back the North Sea while continuing to block new licences, undermine investor confidence, and hammer the industry with a punishing windfall tax. “Jackdaw must be a starting gun, not a sticking plaster. Britain cannot afford another Prime Minister who talks tough but lacks the backbone to act. We need Rosebank.”
Ed Miliband Makes Bombshell Statement as Andy Burnham Faces North Sea Rebellion
Ed Miliband has delivered a major statement on the future of Britain’s controversial North Sea oil industry, placing Prime Minister Andy Burnham in an increasingly difficult political position as divisions within the Labour Party threaten to deepen. The Foreign Secretary has confirmed that he would not resign from the Government if the controversial Rosebank oil field receives approval, despite previously describing the project as an act of climate vandalism.
His comments have intensified an already explosive debate over Britain’s energy future, with Labour MPs, environmental campaigners, trade unions and North Sea workers increasingly divided over what should happen next.
The Rosebank oil field, located off the coast of Shetland, has become one of the biggest political challenges facing Burnham’s Government. The project represents a significant opportunity for the British energy industry, but it has also become a symbol of the conflict between economic growth and the Government’s environmental commitments.
Miliband’s position is particularly interesting because of his previous opposition to the development. When serving as Energy Secretary, he repeatedly questioned the environmental and economic justification for new fossil fuel projects. He had described Rosebank as a colossal waste of taxpayers’ money and climate vandalism.
Now, however, he has made clear that he will remain in the Cabinet even if the Government ultimately decides to approve the development.
Asked whether he would resign in such circumstances, Miliband reportedly responded: “No, definitely not.” He explained that he was a member of the Government and would respect the principle of collective responsibility.
The statement represents a significant political moment. Although Miliband has not abandoned his environmental concerns, his willingness to remain in government demonstrates the difficult compromises facing senior Labour figures.
For Burnham, the situation could hardly be more complicated.
The Prime Minister is facing pressure from different directions, with some Labour MPs demanding that the Rosebank project be blocked while others argue that refusing permission would damage British industry, threaten employment and undermine energy security.
Reports suggest that at least 75 Labour MPs have already signed a letter opposing the development, with the number potentially rising above 100.
Such opposition would represent a serious challenge to Burnham’s authority, particularly because it comes from within his own parliamentary party.
The rebellion is not simply about one oil field. It reflects a much wider disagreement about the economic direction of the country and whether Labour can realistically pursue ambitious environmental policies without damaging industries that continue to provide thousands of jobs.
Supporters of Rosebank argue that Britain cannot afford to ignore its own natural resources while continuing to import significant quantities of oil and gas from overseas.
They believe domestic production could generate substantial tax revenues, support skilled employment and strengthen the country’s ability to respond to international energy disruptions.
North Sea workers are particularly concerned about the consequences of restricting further development. For communities connected to offshore production, oil and gas are not abstract political subjects. They represent employment, family incomes, local businesses and decades of industrial expertise.
More than 1,000 North Sea workers have reportedly urged Burnham to approve Rosebank, arguing that their livelihoods deserve serious consideration.
Industry representatives have also warned that continued uncertainty could discourage investment and accelerate the decline of Britain’s offshore energy sector.
They argue that domestic production should form part of a realistic transition towards cleaner energy rather than being treated as incompatible with environmental progress.
However, opponents of Rosebank strongly disagree.
They argue that approving another major oil development would undermine Britain’s climate commitments and send the wrong message at a time when governments are being urged to reduce dependence on fossil fuels.
One of their main arguments is that much of the oil produced at Rosebank would be sold on international markets rather than reserved for British consumers.
Consequently, they question whether approving the project would actually reduce household energy bills or provide the immediate benefits promised by its supporters.
For these Labour MPs, the issue is also about political credibility. The party made ambitious environmental commitments during the 2024 general election campaign, including its promise to end the issuing of new oil and gas exploration licences.
They fear that approving Rosebank could create the impression that Labour is abandoning its promises whenever economic or political pressure becomes difficult to manage.
This places Burnham in an uncomfortable position.
If he approves the project, he risks provoking environmental campaigners and a substantial section of his parliamentary party. If he rejects it, he could face accusations of sacrificing British jobs and investment for ideological reasons.
The Prime Minister must also consider the wider economic situation. Britain needs investment, stronger industrial production and reliable energy supplies. Businesses are already concerned about operating costs, international competition and the uncertainty surrounding future government policies.
North Sea development could provide an important source of economic activity, although the benefits would depend on investment decisions, production levels and the wider international energy market.
The Government has already faced criticism over its handling of the smaller Jackdaw gas field, which was approved and has begun supplying gas to Britain.
That decision angered environmental campaigners but was welcomed by supporters of domestic energy production.
The contrast between Jackdaw and Rosebank has made the Government’s overall strategy increasingly difficult to explain. Ministers must demonstrate how they intend to balance energy security with the transition towards renewable sources.
For Miliband, the controversy creates another difficult political balancing act.
He has spent years building his reputation around environmental policy and the need to accelerate Britain’s transition away from fossil fuels. His previous statements about Rosebank are now being compared with his current willingness to remain in a Cabinet that could potentially approve the project.
Critics may question whether this represents political compromise or a retreat from principles he previously defended.
Supporters, however, could argue that collective responsibility is a normal part of government and that ministers cannot expect every final decision to reflect their personal preferences.
The distinction matters because the decision on Rosebank formally rests with Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh. The Government has indicated that the process will be handled carefully, with environmental obligations and legal requirements taken into account.
Nevertheless, Burnham will inevitably face political consequences whatever decision emerges.
The rebellion also creates opportunities for opposition parties.
The Conservatives and Reform UK have repeatedly criticised Labour’s approach to North Sea production, arguing that restrictions on domestic drilling could threaten economic growth and leave Britain increasingly dependent on imported energy.
Reform deputy leader Richard Tice has been particularly vocal in defending the oil and gas industry, presenting domestic production as essential to employment and national economic security.
The Conservatives, meanwhile, are likely to use the controversy to question Labour’s ability to deliver a coherent energy strategy.
For Nigel Farage and his party, the issue could become another opportunity to attract voters who feel that Labour is prioritising environmental ambitions over the concerns of ordinary working people.
The political consequences may be especially significant in Scotland and other areas where the North Sea industry supports thousands of jobs.
Aberdeen and surrounding communities have a long-standing relationship with offshore energy production. The industry has created employment for engineers, technicians, transport workers and countless businesses supplying equipment and services.
A sudden decline in investment could have consequences extending far beyond the companies directly involved in oil extraction.
At the same time, environmental campaigners argue that communities dependent on fossil fuel production deserve a carefully managed transition towards alternative industries rather than an indefinite extension of existing operations.
They believe the Government should invest in renewable energy, offshore wind, hydrogen and other technologies capable of creating long-term employment without increasing dependence on fossil fuels.
The difficulty for Burnham is that both sides are demanding immediate action while offering very different visions of Britain’s future.
There is also the question of energy prices. Supporters of Rosebank argue that increasing domestic production could strengthen security of supply and generate economic benefits. Opponents counter that oil is traded internationally and that additional British production would not automatically translate into cheaper fuel for households.
This distinction is crucial because millions of families remain concerned about the cost of living. They want reliable energy at affordable prices, not another prolonged political argument that produces little practical improvement.
Burnham therefore needs to explain exactly what approving or rejecting Rosebank would mean for consumers, workers and the wider economy.
Miliband’s statement has not resolved the disagreement. Instead, it has highlighted how difficult it will be for Labour to maintain unity when major economic and environmental priorities come into conflict.
The Prime Minister now faces a potentially defining test of his leadership. He must manage an increasingly vocal parliamentary rebellion while reassuring businesses and workers that the Government understands the importance of Britain’s energy industry.
The decision could also influence the future of Labour’s environmental programme and the credibility of its wider economic promises.
Ultimately, Rosebank has become much more than an offshore oil development. It represents a fundamental disagreement about how Britain should generate wealth, protect employment, secure its energy supplies and meet its climate obligations.
Miliband may have ruled out resigning, but his statement does little to remove the pressure surrounding Burnham.
With dozens of Labour MPs already opposed to the project and thousands of workers demanding approval, the Prime Minister faces an increasingly difficult choice.
Whatever decision the Government makes, somebody within Labour is likely to be disappointed. The real question is whether Burnham can prevent the disagreement from turning into a damaging internal conflict that weakens his authority at a crucial moment for the country.
