Andy Burnham will hand a raft of powers back to Brussels at the surrender summit but it is just the start of the Great Brexit Betrayal. In just six months the Prime Minister has gone from promising the voters of Makerfield he would not re-run the debate, to giving speeches at white tie dinners in the City trashing Britain’s independence from the bloc. Express readers will not be surprised that Burnham is already failing to keep his promises.
His history of shape-shifting has been well documented in these pages and the issue of Brexit was always the one he was most likely to betray the public on. The question is why and there is one clear answer – because he is completely out of his depth. Burnham’s coup saw him installed much quicker than expected, catapulting him into No 10 before he had a proper plan for government.
Four months on and the evidence is clear. A damp squib budget and lots of promises about what happens after the next election are all there is to show for this new premiership. A country driven to distraction by political turmoil has been willing to give Burnham a chance, hopeful that he will be the one to bring stability.
But his casual disregard for the 17.4 million voters who chose to free Britain from the suffocating grip of Brussels bureaucrats reveals so much. Burnham managed to bypass the national electorate when he quit as Manchester’s mayor and then stitched up the Labour party to avoid a vote there too. It’s little surprise then that what voters want is not his top priority. But by blundering into the Brexit debate without a plan he has reignited a fire that he will be unable to control.
Kemi Badenoch nailed it when she said the Prime Minister must “stop obsessing about Europe” and get on with fixing Britain. The Tory leader pointed out that the UK doesn’t need Europe to sort out the economy, fund defence, boost employment and back business. But Burnham is a political mirage. From afar he seemed like the answer for a desperate Labour Party grasping around for a solution.
Up close, it turns out there is nothing there, other than a Metropolitan mayor who built his popularity on giving out taxpayers’ money while blaming the government for everything else. Now he is the government, the decisions are ducked and delayed and he has had to find a new enemy to blame and Brexit fits the bill perfectly. On Friday, Mr Burnham will sign the so-called reset deal with Brussels that was originally negotiated by Keir Starmer.
Brussels will lift some of its red tape on some British producers but in return has demanded the UK permanently aligns with all EU regulations on food and farming. Then he will set out options for what happens next, including rejoining the single market or going all the way back in. Burnham could try to seize the opportunities freedom from the bloc has offered instead of trying to overturn it.
In fact he already has. The government announced a VAT on household electricity bills to help with the cost of living that is only allowed now the UK has left the bloc. Trade deals, animal welfare, subsidies, state aid, AI regulation are all now under Britain’s control.
It’s up to the government to use those powers to make the country a success. Doomsters predicted a mass exodus from the City after Brexit but it has enjoyed major successes since leaving the EU stranglehold. Latest polls show support for rejoining dramatically melts away if Britain was forced to take the euro and no longer enjoyed a rebate.
Few want to be caught up in another decade of debates and negotiations about going back in. Even half the Cabinet knows it would be a bad idea, burning any trust Labour has regained in the Red Wall. But EU leaders are already rubbing their hands with glee at the thought of an extra £30bn being paid into their coffers. Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babis was asked if he would support the UK’s return. “Yes, of course,” he replied. “We need more money.”
Burnham is already trampling over the wishes of the Makerfield voters that he looked in the eye and pledged not to betray Brexit. We should not be surprised that his promises to the rest of us count for nothing either.
Andy Burnham’s Brexit Betrayal Is Just the Start – He Is Completely Out of His Depth
Andy Burnham is facing growing political criticism over his approach to Brexit and Britain’s future relationship with the European Union. His willingness to pursue closer ties with Brussels has raised concerns among Brexit supporters, who fear that the government could gradually reverse the democratic decision made by millions of British voters in 2016. Critics argue that the controversy is only the beginning of a much bigger political problem, questioning whether Burnham has a clear understanding of the economic, constitutional and political consequences of his proposals.
Brexit was one of the most important political decisions in modern British history. In the referendum held on 23 June 2016, approximately 52 per cent of voters chose to leave the European Union, compared with 48 per cent who wanted to remain. The result reflected widespread concerns about national sovereignty, immigration, democratic accountability and the ability of Britain to determine its own future.
For millions of people, leaving the EU represented an opportunity to regain control over national policies. Supporters believed that Britain should have the freedom to establish its own trade agreements, control immigration and make domestic laws without being required to follow decisions made by European institutions.
However, nearly a decade after the referendum, Brexit continues to generate disagreement. Businesses have experienced additional trading requirements, exporters have faced administrative complications and successive governments have struggled to establish a clear long-term economic strategy. These problems have strengthened arguments from politicians who believe that Britain needs a closer relationship with its European neighbours.
Burnham has attempted to position himself as someone willing to reconsider Britain’s relationship with Brussels. His approach appears to recognise that the current arrangements have created difficulties for certain industries and that closer cooperation could offer economic advantages.
Nevertheless, critics argue that there is a significant difference between improving trade relations and gradually reversing Brexit. They fear that regulatory alignment, additional European agreements and closer institutional cooperation could eventually reduce Britain’s independence without giving voters another opportunity to express their views.
A growing controversy over Britain’s sovereignty
One of the biggest criticisms facing Burnham concerns national sovereignty. Brexit supporters argue that the referendum was fundamentally about democratic control and the ability of British institutions to make decisions independently.
They believe that accepting European regulations in exchange for easier access to markets could undermine one of the main objectives of leaving the EU. If Britain follows rules established in Brussels without having an equivalent role in creating them, critics argue that the country could find itself in an uncomfortable political position.
Supporters of closer European cooperation reject this interpretation. They argue that international agreements do not automatically represent a surrender of sovereignty and that Britain can cooperate with other countries while maintaining democratic control over domestic affairs.
This is an important distinction. International cooperation can benefit trade, security, scientific research and environmental protection. However, the government must explain exactly what obligations it is prepared to accept and how those commitments would affect Parliament’s ability to make independent decisions.
The economic consequences cannot be ignored
Another major problem is the uncertainty surrounding Britain’s economic future. Burnham’s supporters argue that closer relations with Europe could help British businesses overcome some of the difficulties created by Brexit.
Small exporters, agricultural producers and food manufacturers have faced additional paperwork and regulatory requirements when selling products into European markets. Reducing these barriers could help companies save money, improve efficiency and reach more customers.
However, critics question whether the government has properly assessed the long-term costs of its proposed approach. Regulatory alignment may make certain aspects of trade easier, but it could also create new obligations for British businesses.
The government must demonstrate that any agreement offers measurable economic benefits rather than simply presenting closer relations with Brussels as an achievement in itself.
There are also wider concerns about taxation, employment and investment. Businesses need predictable rules and a stable economic environment before committing substantial amounts of money to new projects. Constant political uncertainty could discourage investment and make Britain less attractive compared with competing European economies.
Immigration remains a difficult political issue
Immigration is another sensitive area that Burnham cannot afford to overlook. One of the main arguments made by Brexit supporters was that leaving the EU would allow Britain to regain control over immigration policy.
However, changes to migration arrangements have not automatically reduced overall immigration. Britain continues to depend on overseas workers in important sectors, including healthcare, agriculture, hospitality and social care.
Supporters of closer relations with Europe may argue that cooperation could make it easier to recruit workers and address labour shortages. Nevertheless, any changes to immigration arrangements would need to be explained clearly to voters.
The government must also consider the need to invest in domestic training and education. British businesses should have access to the skilled workers they need, while young people should receive better opportunities to develop careers at home.
Without a coherent immigration and employment strategy, Burnham risks creating further uncertainty among businesses and ordinary households.
Political opponents are ready to exploit the controversy
The Brexit debate also presents an opportunity for opposition parties. Nigel Farage and Reform UK have consistently argued that Britain must protect its independence and resist attempts to restore European influence over domestic policy.
The Conservatives have also raised concerns about the possibility of regulatory alignment and closer integration with Brussels. Their argument is that the government should focus on improving Britain’s competitiveness rather than reopening political divisions surrounding the referendum.
For Labour, the situation is particularly complicated because many traditional Labour constituencies voted to leave the European Union. Voters in former industrial communities and economically disadvantaged areas may be especially sensitive to proposals that appear to disregard the referendum result.
Burnham must therefore recognise that Brexit is not simply an argument between politicians in Westminster. It remains an issue that affects people’s sense of democratic representation and confidence in the political system.
Is the government prepared for the consequences?
The most important question is whether Burnham has a sufficiently detailed plan for Britain’s future relationship with Europe.
Political statements about improving cooperation are not enough. The government needs to explain which agreements it wants to negotiate, what financial commitments might be involved and how Parliament will maintain oversight of future arrangements.
It must also be honest about the potential disadvantages. Closer cooperation could improve trade in certain sectors, but it may involve difficult compromises involving regulation, taxation and immigration.
A responsible government should publish independent assessments before making major commitments. Voters deserve to understand the consequences rather than being expected to accept complicated agreements without proper explanation.
In my opinion, Burnham’s biggest political mistake would be to underestimate the importance of public trust. People who voted for Brexit should not be dismissed as unreasonable simply because they disagree with closer European integration. Equally, those who believe Brexit has created economic difficulties should be able to express their concerns without being accused of betraying the country.
Britain needs an honest national debate that recognises the advantages and disadvantages of different approaches.
Britain needs leadership, not political uncertainty
The country is already dealing with serious economic and social challenges, including weak productivity, pressure on public services, high living costs and difficulties facing businesses. The government should be concentrating on policies that improve employment, encourage investment and strengthen household finances.
International cooperation can contribute to these objectives, but it cannot replace a credible domestic economic strategy.
Burnham must demonstrate that his approach to Brexit is based on practical national interests rather than political calculations. He should explain how closer relations with Europe would benefit workers, businesses and consumers while protecting democratic accountability.
He must also recognise that rebuilding Britain’s relationship with the EU will require negotiation and compromise. Brussels will pursue its own interests, and Britain cannot assume that every proposed arrangement will automatically benefit the country.
Conclusion
Andy Burnham’s Brexit strategy has opened another major political battle over Britain’s future. His proposals for closer relations with the European Union may offer economic opportunities, but they have also raised legitimate concerns about sovereignty, immigration, taxation and democratic accountability.
Critics believe that the controversy could become a much bigger problem if the government fails to explain its objectives and the consequences of its decisions. They argue that Britain cannot afford another period of political uncertainty while businesses and households are already facing significant economic pressures.
Ultimately, Burnham must prove that he understands the complexity of the Brexit debate and has a realistic plan for the country. Improving relations with Europe is not necessarily a betrayal of the referendum, but reversing important elements of Brexit without transparency or democratic scrutiny would create serious questions about political accountability. Britain needs leadership that puts the interests of its citizens first, protects economic opportunities and respects democratic decisions. The real test will not be how many agreements Burnham can negotiate with Brussels, but whether his policies deliver a stronger economy and a more secure future for the British public.
