David Lammy’s plan to win over France reveals the true price of rejoining the EU

David Lammy wants Britain back in a ‘more interventionist’ EU, with free movement and no rebate. Read his case closely and it is the best reason to stay out.

Foreign Secretary David Lammy Delivers Speech On FCDO's Priorities And The Government's 'Plan for Change'

David Lammy wants a vote on rejoining the EU (Image: Getty)

There are remarkably few times in which anything David Lammy says, writes or does should be taken seriously. Yet he has just written the most honest case yet for heading back into the European Union – and here’s why that should worry you.

Taking to the pages of a national newspaper, the former Deputy Prime Minister has urged Andy Burnham to put a return to the bloc on the ballot at the next general election. It marks a staggering change in direction from a man once boldly committed to adhering to those infamous ‘red lines’.

But in doing so Mr Lammy has given the game away. He waxes lyrical in his piece, as a great many state-loving socialists are wont to do, about his love of the European Union. He admires that Brussels has championed a “total rethink of market orthodoxies”, he says, crowing that the EU has become “more strategic, more interventionist and more industrial”.

For those on the left it is clear that a heavier-handed state is a selling point – for those with access to a calculator and a working understanding of economics, it is a warning flag.

Britain’s problems have not been caused because we simply didn’t have enough government. The country faces a combination of worklessness, declining productivity, overspending and borrowing, and a stagnant economy bereft of real growth and opportunity. We have far too much government, and the fact our former Deputy Prime Minister cannot see that is damning in itself.

Taxes throttle growth and drive the creators of wealth overseas. Our planning system blocks the construction of the homes and infrastructure we desperately need. The ever-increasing cost of hiring a new worker has driven more young people onto the dole. Yet Mr Lammy’s answer to this is to sign us back onto a club that wants more intervention, not less.

BBC Breakfast: David Lammy says Cyprus is a part of NATO

Underpinning his argument is the claim from the Bank of England that the economy is some 6 to 8 per cent smaller in 2025 than it otherwise would have been. This of course ignores the war in Ukraine, the Covid pandemic, and the lack of cheap housing, energy, and our long-standing productivity challenges.

Political failure to make the most of Brexit and deregulate the economy to spur economic growth must surely not be answered by demanding we rejoin a bloc that would continue the same failed lessons of the past? Not to mention the price of entry would be extortionate – and Mr Lammy admits it.

Free movement “would return”, he says. Now, whilst free movement of workers and the economically productive is not a bad thing for an economy, border controls to safeguard the bounties of a welfare state are surely sensible. Additionally, the rebate Margaret Thatcher fought for, worth around £5billion a year, would go up in smoke.

He insists that “like Ireland” we could stay out of Schengen and “like Sweden” keep the pound. But he neglects to mention that Ireland won its opt-out as an existing member, not as one attempting to rejoin the club. Sweden is legally bound to join the euro and simply drags its feet, and all new members are expected to commit to both. Any exemption would be a favour from Brussels, not an automatic right.

At the end of his staggering tract of dishonesty and foolishness lies the most revealing line of all. Should Marine Le Pen win the French presidency, Mr Lammy fears she could veto our return. His solution? Win her round, because Britain rejoining “would reduce France’s EU budget contributions”.

I would urge you to read that again. Mr Lammy’s masterplan is to charm Paris by promising our money to pay them off. His defence is that membership would give us “a say” in Europe’s decisions. A say, yes, but a veto over most of them, no. We would be one voice among 28, bound by rules we can, and would, be outvoted on.

Mr Lammy dismisses free-trading Britain as “the Jacob Rees-Mogg fantasy”. The truth that he handily seeks to ignore is it was never tried. Successive governments, his own included, kept the EU rulebook and raised taxes on the very businesses that might have used the freedom.

The answer to a botched Brexit is not to hand back the keys, it is to finally use them.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *