Andy Burnham’s blind EU giveaway will cost us our money and our democracy . HYN

UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham Tells City Audience That Brexit Has Not Worked

Andy Burnham wants to rejoin in his lifetime (Image: Getty)

In the past few weeks there has been an extraordinary cacophony of voices advising our hapless PM against pursuing an EU reset let alone an attempt to join the EU.

The very PM who fired the starting pistol on Brexit and who campaigned to remain in the EU and lost, David Cameron, has said that joining would lead to major problems for a long period and is not in Britain’s interests.

Andy Burnham says he doesn't need to call a general election upon entering Downing Street, despite being unelected by voters.

The Financial Services sector have warned against dynamic alignment (accepting EU regulation) as this would destroy the Brexit benefits accrued so far. The Food and Drink federation have highlighted that linking with the self serving and protectionist EU would damage British producers. Even the CBI have warned against the disruption of joining the EU.

This week the most recent report of the Independent Business Network (IBN) reflects why family businesses, including sole traders and Entrepreneurs (85% off all businesses) do not want a reset less still to join the EU , a very different EU to that of 2016.

Watch: Andy Burnham Pledges Cost Of Living Solutions In FIRST Address As New UK PM.

The campaign group , “Stay Out” have estimated the cost to the U.K. would be £750 million per week , over £39 billion per annum and these figures tally with other groups.

Brexit Britain is well placed to be leaders in AI, Financial and related services, Biotech and extraction industries, all of which would be quashed by an over regulated and protectionist EU. The EU would require all businesses to comply whether or not they export to the EU. As for the reset only 1.3% of all exports are food and agriculture going to the EU.

We now have trade deals with fast growing economies and some old friends like NZ whose trade with the U.K. has grown by around 16%. The application of tariffs to protect EU producers would not only kill these deals but also increase the cost of living for consumers.

Andy Burnham says he wants 'honest discussion' about freedom of movement with EU | Andy Burnham | The Guardian

On the other side the only arguments repeatedly deployed are two fold. That we can have a seat at the top table in the EU, a useless figment given the EU is in sharp relative decline and we have no veto. We become a slave of the EU machine. Secondly that a bunch of random, out of date financial figures have been floated suggesting, theoretically, that the economy could have been 4 or 8 % larger had we not had Brexit.

These forecast figures do not pass the “smell test” as they would have required unbelievable , super growth. The famous economist, Galbraith once said that “The only function of economic forecasting is to make astrology look respectable.”. By contrast the real world figures show the U.K. economy to have grown faster post Brexit, than the Eurozone, than Germany and than France who are “basket cases” riven with major political unrest.

Resource 2016 (£bn) 2028 Projection (£bn)
Customs duties 3.32 5.50
VAT-based resource 2.67 4.75
Unrecycled plastic packaging n/a 0.85
Emissions trading (ETS1) n/a 0.58
Carbon border adjustment n/a 0.14
Uncollected electrical waste n/a 2.31
Tobacco excise (TEDOR) n/a 0.35
Corporate resource (CORE) n/a 1.17
GNI-based resource 13.12 23.65
Total gross contribution 19.11 39.30
Gross contribution per week 0.36 (~£350m) 0.76 (~£750m)

Source: StayOut (figures in £ billions).

Will Burnham put 'brake' on push to rejoin EU? | Politics Weekly | European Union | The Guardian

And then there is the most important thing of all, our democracy, the rule of law and the ability to determine our own future, making our own decisions. Something the dictatorial Mr Burnham would have us give up.

PM Burnham has said he wishes to take us back to a fictitious golden age of the 1970’s. The horrendous decade of IMF bailouts, Union power, strikes, the three day week with power cuts, Britain in decline and joining the EU based on a lie. “Eyelash Andy” had better be careful what wishes for.

Since joining the EU now would be insanity, it is most puzzling as to why “Bambi Burnham” wants to join the EU, starting with the sneaky and damaging reset?

Is it a personal characteristic? Like “Bambi” he seems to want to be loved , even if the price of this is payed for by the rest of us.

Or is he playing to the gallery, fearful of his own backbench, Marxist MPs? Why does he want to give away self determination and control and impoverish people?

Whatever his reasoning it all points to a very weak and narcissistic individual. The entire future of our country is to be decided by an unelected PM, with no mandate. If it were France we would call it a Coup.

John Longworth is an entrepreneur and Businessman, Chairman of the Independent Business Network of family businesses and a former MEP

Andy Burnham’s Blind EU Giveaway Will Cost Us Our Money and Our Democracy

Andy Burnham’s renewed push for closer relations with the European Union has reopened one of Britain’s most divisive political debates. Ten years after the Brexit referendum, the Prime Minister is arguing that the country must reconsider its relationship with Brussels, claiming that closer cooperation could strengthen the economy, reduce costs and create new opportunities. Yet his approach has also raised difficult questions about public spending, national sovereignty and the extent to which decisions affecting Britain could once again be shaped by institutions outside the country.

The latest UK-EU summit in Brussels on 20 November 2026 produced agreements covering food and drink trade, emissions trading and a youth mobility scheme. Burnham described the package as a major opportunity for Britain, suggesting that the arrangements could contribute significantly to economic growth. The Government estimates that the agreements could add up to 0.5 per cent to UK GDP by 2040, equivalent to approximately £17 billion a year. However, that figure is a projection of potential economic benefits, not a guaranteed return or a direct payment into the Treasury. <Cite refs={[“turn263136search0″,”turn263136search12”]}/>

For critics, the central concern is that the Government is presenting closer European integration as an uncomplicated economic opportunity while the financial and political obligations remain less clear to ordinary voters. Any substantial change in Britain’s relationship with the EU would involve negotiations over contributions, regulatory alignment, trade arrangements and the movement of people. These are not minor administrative details. They affect the way the country spends public money, controls its borders and makes laws.

The question is therefore not simply whether Britain should cooperate with European neighbours. Cooperation already takes place in areas such as security, trade and diplomacy. The more important question is how much authority the country should transfer, what it should pay and whether the benefits would justify the obligations.

One of the most contentious possibilities is a return to the EU single market. This would potentially make trading easier by reducing barriers and increasing regulatory consistency. British companies that export goods and services to Europe could benefit from more predictable arrangements. Businesses in sectors affected by customs checks and regulatory differences have repeatedly argued that post-Brexit friction has increased costs and complicated their operations.

However, single-market participation would also involve accepting a substantial body of EU rules. Britain would be expected to align with regulations governing areas of economic activity, while having no automatic right to participate in the EU institutions that make those rules. That distinction lies at the heart of the sovereignty debate. The UK could gain easier access to European markets while having less direct influence over some of the regulations it would need to follow. <Cite refs={[“turn263136search1″,”turn263136search10”]}/>

Supporters of closer alignment argue that this is a practical compromise. They point out that businesses often need common standards to trade efficiently and that influence can also be exercised through negotiations and cooperation. Critics, however, argue that accepting rules without a full vote in their creation would leave Britain in an uncomfortable position: following decisions made elsewhere while being unable to hold the decision-makers directly accountable through British elections.

This is why the argument about democracy cannot be dismissed as nostalgia for the Brexit referendum. It concerns the practical relationship between economic access and political authority. If the Government chooses closer integration, it must explain precisely which rules Britain would accept, how disputes would be settled and what mechanisms would allow Parliament to scrutinise the arrangements.

The financial question is equally important. The EU has previously made clear that deeper forms of participation can involve financial contributions. A leaked negotiating document reported by Sky News before the November summit indicated that Brussels wanted an appropriate British contribution towards reducing economic and social disparities between EU regions as part of discussions about access to the bloc’s electricity market. That report concerned a particular negotiating demand, not proof that Britain has agreed to an unlimited payment obligation. Nevertheless, it illustrates why the financial terms of future cooperation require close examination. <Cite refs={[“turn263136search5″,”turn263136search6”]}/>

The Government should publish clear estimates of any proposed contributions, explain how they would be calculated and identify what Britain would receive in return. Taxpayers deserve to know whether payments would be temporary or permanent, whether they could increase over time and what safeguards would prevent costs from rising without proper parliamentary scrutiny.

The youth mobility agreement is another example of how the debate involves both opportunities and obligations. The package includes a scheme intended to allow young people aged 18 to 31 to live, work, study and travel in Europe for periods of up to three years. The reported arrangement envisages opportunities for up to 100,000 young people from each side. For British students and graduates, this could open doors to employment, education and cultural experiences that became more complicated after Brexit. <Cite refs={[“turn263136search0″,”turn263136news24”]}/>

There are genuine advantages here. Young people may gain valuable professional experience, universities could develop new partnerships and businesses may find it easier to recruit people with particular skills. But the Government must also explain how eligibility, enforcement and the impact on domestic services will be managed. A mobility scheme is not the same as unrestricted freedom of movement, and the details matter.

Burnham has also indicated that he wants an honest discussion about freedom of movement as part of Britain’s longer-term relationship with Europe. He has acknowledged that returning to such arrangements would involve significant challenges. Rejoining the single market would generally require accepting the principle of free movement, making immigration policy an unavoidable part of the debate. <Cite refs={[“turn263136search2″,”turn263136search9”]}/>

For communities concerned about housing availability, pressure on public services and the ability of local authorities to plan for population changes, these questions deserve detailed answers. Equally, employers in sectors facing labour shortages may argue that access to European workers could help fill vacancies and support economic activity. A serious national discussion must recognise both perspectives rather than treating immigration as either an automatic economic benefit or an automatic problem.

The issue of democratic accountability becomes even more significant when considering the possibility of full EU membership. Burnham has said that Britain should examine the available options, ranging from maintaining current arrangements to a customs union, single-market participation or potentially going all the way towards rejoining the bloc. He has not announced an immediate plan to take Britain back into the EU, and his Government remains constrained by Labour’s previous manifesto commitments during the current parliamentary term. <Cite refs={[“turn263136search3″,”turn263136news23”]}/>

That distinction matters. Discussing future possibilities is not the same as implementing them. However, the public is entitled to know whether the Government is preparing the ground for a fundamental change in national policy. If a future administration wishes to pursue full membership, it would need to address questions about the UK’s voting rights, financial contributions, regulatory responsibilities and the terms on which membership could be secured.

There is also an immediate practical complication surrounding the latest summit agreement. Although the Government announced progress on several areas, negotiations over tuition fees for European students remain unresolved. Reports indicate that the EU wants students from its member states to receive access to domestic-rate university fees, while the British Government has not accepted the proposed terms. The two sides have given themselves six months to continue discussions. <Cite refs={[“turn263136news24″,”turn263136search7”]}/>

This disagreement demonstrates that negotiations with Brussels are rarely a simple exchange in which Britain receives benefits without difficult conditions. Agreements in one area can become connected to disputes in another, and the final balance may differ from the initial political presentation. The public should therefore be cautious about treating summit announcements as proof that every detail has been settled.

Burnham’s supporters argue that Britain cannot ignore its largest neighbouring market. They point to the economic disruption associated with post-Brexit trade barriers and say that closer cooperation could help businesses, consumers and workers. The Government also argues that cooperation on food standards, emissions trading and youth opportunities could reduce friction while preserving the UK’s formal independence outside the EU.

Opponents respond that economic convenience must not become an excuse for weakening democratic control. They want ministers to explain whether regulatory alignment could limit future choices, whether financial contributions would represent good value and how Parliament would retain meaningful oversight. These are legitimate questions in any major international agreement, regardless of whether the proposed partner is the EU or another institution.

Ultimately, the debate should not be reduced to a choice between unquestioning support for Brussels and refusing all cooperation with Europe. Britain can maintain constructive relations with its neighbours while insisting on transparent negotiations, clear financial limits and proper democratic accountability. The challenge is finding an arrangement that delivers practical benefits without creating obligations that voters have never had a meaningful opportunity to examine.

If Burnham believes his European strategy will improve living standards, he must demonstrate how those improvements will reach households, businesses and public services. If the Government believes the new arrangements will cost less than the economic problems they are intended to solve, it should publish the calculations and make them available for independent scrutiny.

The public also deserves a clear explanation of the democratic consequences. Which rules would Britain follow? Which decisions would remain entirely in Westminster’s hands? How much would taxpayers contribute? What would happen if a future British Government disagreed with a decision made in Brussels?

These questions are not obstacles to cooperation. They are essential conditions for public consent.

Ten years after the Brexit referendum, Britain is once again debating the balance between economic integration and national independence. Burnham may believe that closer ties with Europe offer a route towards stronger growth and a more stable trading relationship. But the Government cannot expect voters to accept sweeping changes simply because ministers describe them as pragmatic or beneficial.

Money, sovereignty and democratic accountability must be examined together. Any agreement that affects all three deserves detailed parliamentary scrutiny and an honest explanation to the country. Before Britain takes another significant step towards Brussels, voters should be told not only what the Government hopes to gain, but also what it is prepared to pay and which powers it is willing to share.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *