Andy Burnham Is Right That Brexit Hasn’t Worked
Brexit remains one of the most controversial political decisions in modern British history. Almost a decade after the 2016 referendum, the debate over whether leaving the European Union has benefited the United Kingdom continues to divide politicians, businesses and ordinary citizens. Andy Burnham has reignited this discussion by arguing that Brexit has failed to deliver the economic improvements promised to voters. His comments have attracted criticism from supporters of leaving the EU, but they have also encouraged an important conversation about Britain’s economic performance, international relationships and future direction.
When British voters went to the polls on 23 June 2016, approximately 52 per cent supported leaving the European Union, while 48 per cent voted to remain. The Leave campaign promised greater national sovereignty, stronger control over immigration, independent trade agreements and the opportunity to establish policies that better reflected Britain’s national interests. Many voters believed that leaving Brussels would allow the country to become more prosperous and regain control over its future.
However, the economic reality has proved considerably more complicated. Leaving the European Union introduced new barriers to trade, additional administrative requirements and uncertainty for businesses that had previously operated within the single market. Although Britain has maintained a substantial trading relationship with Europe, companies exporting goods have had to adapt to new procedures, including customs documentation and regulatory requirements.
One of the most significant consequences has been the additional pressure placed on small and medium-sized businesses. Large international companies often have specialist departments capable of dealing with complex customs procedures. Smaller businesses, however, may lack the financial resources and administrative capacity to manage additional paperwork.
For some companies, the cost of exporting to European markets has become less attractive. Businesses involved in food production, agriculture, manufacturing and seafood have faced particular challenges because their products can be subject to strict regulatory checks. Delays at borders and additional documentation can increase costs and make it harder for British exporters to compete.
Burnham’s criticism is based partly on the argument that Britain has lost valuable economic opportunities since leaving the EU. The European single market provides access to hundreds of millions of consumers, and maintaining relatively frictionless trade with European partners is important for many British industries.
Another major concern is the impact of Brexit on investment. International companies consider access to markets, regulatory stability, labour availability and operating costs when deciding where to establish businesses. Before Brexit, Britain offered companies a convenient base from which to serve customers across the European Union.
Following the withdrawal, some businesses reconsidered their operations and investment strategies. Although Brexit is not the only reason for changes in investment decisions, uncertainty surrounding future trading arrangements has contributed to concerns about Britain’s competitiveness.
The issue of immigration has also become increasingly complicated. One of the central arguments made by Leave supporters was that Brexit would allow Britain to regain control over its borders. The end of free movement gave the UK greater control over immigration from the European Union, but it did not automatically lead to lower overall migration.
Instead, immigration patterns changed, with increased recruitment from countries outside Europe in several sectors. Businesses in healthcare, hospitality, agriculture and social care have continued to rely on international workers to fill vacancies. This demonstrates that controlling immigration is not simply a matter of leaving an international agreement; it also depends on domestic labour market conditions and government policy.
Another important issue concerns the cost of living. Brexit supporters argued that leaving the European Union would allow Britain to negotiate better trade agreements and reduce costs for consumers. However, household finances have remained under considerable pressure.
Food prices, energy bills, housing expenses and borrowing costs have all affected living standards. Brexit cannot be blamed for every increase in household expenditure, since international conflicts, the pandemic, energy markets and domestic economic decisions have also played important roles. Nevertheless, additional trade barriers can contribute to higher costs for businesses and consumers.
The relationship between Brexit and public services has also attracted attention. The NHS and social care sector continue to experience staffing pressures, while employers in several industries report difficulties recruiting skilled workers. Changes to immigration arrangements have altered the way organisations recruit from overseas.
Supporters of Brexit argue that Britain should use its freedom outside the EU to train more domestic workers and reduce its dependence on overseas recruitment. This is a reasonable long-term objective, but developing a skilled workforce requires investment, effective education policies and time. Simply changing immigration rules cannot immediately resolve shortages in essential industries.
Burnham’s argument for closer relations with Europe therefore deserves serious consideration. He believes that Britain should pursue practical agreements that reduce unnecessary barriers and improve economic cooperation. This does not necessarily mean reversing every aspect of Brexit or immediately seeking full EU membership.
A closer partnership could involve cooperation on food standards, energy, scientific research, security and trade. British businesses could benefit from simpler procedures while the country retains important areas of independent decision-making.
However, any attempt to rebuild relations with Brussels will face political resistance. Nigel Farage and other Brexit supporters argue that Britain should not gradually return to European regulatory control after voters explicitly chose to leave. They believe that accepting European rules without having an equivalent vote in their creation would undermine the democratic principles behind Brexit.
There are also concerns about the financial consequences of closer integration. Any future agreement involving regulatory alignment, financial contributions or changes to immigration arrangements must be examined carefully. The government should provide clear explanations of the costs and benefits before making long-term commitments.
Nevertheless, refusing to reconsider Britain’s relationship with Europe simply because Brexit has already happened would be equally unhelpful. Governments should be prepared to examine the evidence and change policies when circumstances demonstrate that improvements are necessary.
In my opinion, Burnham is right to question whether Brexit has delivered what voters were promised. The British economy has faced persistent challenges, and businesses continue to experience difficulties when trading with European markets. However, the solution should not necessarily be to reverse Brexit completely. Britain needs a realistic strategy that combines economic cooperation with democratic accountability and national interests.
The government should prioritise reducing trade barriers, improving investment conditions and supporting British exporters. It should also strengthen domestic skills training, invest in infrastructure and create a more stable environment for businesses. These measures could help Britain become more competitive regardless of its formal relationship with the European Union.
Most importantly, politicians must be honest about the limitations of their arguments. Brexit supporters should acknowledge the additional costs and complications created by leaving the single market, while supporters of closer European relations must explain the potential financial and regulatory obligations involved.
Ultimately, the British public deserves a debate based on facts rather than political slogans. The success of any future policy should be measured by whether it improves living standards, creates employment, strengthens public services and supports sustainable economic growth.
In conclusion, Andy Burnham’s argument that Brexit has not worked deserves serious attention. Although leaving the European Union fulfilled the referendum result and restored certain areas of national control, the economic benefits promised by supporters have not materialised as clearly or as quickly as many voters expected. Additional trade barriers, investment uncertainty and continuing economic difficulties have raised legitimate questions about the country’s current arrangements. However, rebuilding relations with Europe must be approached carefully, with full consideration of financial obligations, national sovereignty and democratic accountability. Britain should not be trapped by the political divisions of 2016. Instead, it should learn from the experience of Brexit and develop a practical relationship with Europe that delivers genuine benefits for businesses, workers and ordinary households.