Andy Burnham faces censorship row over plans to pick the news on your phone . HYN

Andy Burnham Becomes The 59th Prime Minister of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

Andy Burnham has sparked a censorship row (Image: Getty)

Andy Burnham has sparked a censorship row over plans campaigners warn could let the Government pick the news you see on your phone.

Does Andy Burnham's pivot from press to social media put scrutiny at risk? - AOL

Ministers are said to be exploring options to force social media giants to push content from public service broadcasters such as the BBC and ITV higher up people’s feeds.

But critics warn the plans would see certain outlets branded “trustworthy”, handing Whitehall extraordinary sway over what the public reads.

It is not yet clear who would decide which outlets qualify.

Andy Burnham's complaint against the Sun rejected | The Sun | The Guardian

Tory MP Nigel Huddleston said the proposals had “alarming Orwellian undertones” and risked creating “a system of government-approved media, which would align Britain with some of the most authoritarian states on the planet”.

Writing for the Daily Express, he warned the plans could even end up regulating newspapers on social media, “adding new regulations to the likes of the Daily Express”.

He revealed he had asked Ofcom’s chief executive in Parliament how she would define “trustworthy” news, and that “she could not provide a clear-cut answer”.

PM Andy Burnham tells BBC he will not give "special interviews" to The Sun newspaper, after years of work with Justice for Hillsborough campaigners.

Citing reports of civil servants working as fact-checkers for broadcasters, he asked: “Is this the future, where government mandarins are roaming newsrooms looking over the shoulders of journalists checking that their work is trustworthy and meets government standards?”

The plans, set out in the Government’s Media Green Paper, are justified by ministers as a way to prop up broadcasters through the decline of traditional TV, and to tackle misinformation.

Jack Coulson, of Big Brother Watch, branded the proposals an “algorithmic land-grab” that was “bad in practice and worse in principle”.

He said platforms such as Instagram, and possibly YouTube, could be made to rig their algorithms in favour of approved outlets, with everyone else pushed down people’s feeds.

Mr Coulson said: “Being branded ‘trustworthy’ by the Government is rather like being the friend your parents describe as ‘a good influence’: true or not, it’s a quick way to make everyone wonder whose side you’re on.”

But Mr Coulson argued research shows false information online is mainly consumed by a small minority who actively seek it out, and who are the “last people” likely to change their minds because “a bit more Channel 4 is shoved into their feeds”.

Andy Burnham faces censorship row over your news feed | Politics | News | Express.co.uk

He said: “We believe you can be trusted to decide what news you see.”

He warned it was paternalistic for ministers to “‘protect’ us weak-minded members of the public from information and ideas of which ministers disapprove”.

 

The plans have also alarmed Britain’s newspapers. The News Media Association, which represents publishers including the Daily Express, warned that “the path of least resistance for platforms is to promote public service broadcaster content, transferring visibility and revenue from the commercial press”.

Andy Burnham shares exactly what THAT text he was shown during Covid row said - Manchester Evening News

Former Culture Secretary Sir John Whittingdale branded the proposals “a very dangerous extension of Government interference in the freedom of the press and the right to free speech”.

Big Brother Watch insists it is no fan of Big Tech either, arguing that if ministers want to rein in the platforms, they should hand control to users.

Mr Coulson said: “If someone wants a feed full of PSM content, or none at all, that’s their business, not the Government’s.”

A Department for Culture, Media and Sport spokesperson said: “We have no intention of restricting or censoring content. The government’s aim is to ensure that social media users can access high-quality, accurate and trustworthy information from a range of news providers.

“The criteria for a ‘trustworthy’ news provider is being decided in an open and transparent manner with regard to protecting media freedom. This includes engaging with stakeholders as part of our Media Green Paper consultation.”

Andy Burnham faces censorship row over your news feed | Politics | News | Express.co.uk

Andy Burnham Faces Censorship Row Over Plans to Pick the News on Your Phone

Andy Burnham is facing growing criticism over controversial proposals that could give the Government greater influence over the news people see on their mobile phones. The plans have sparked a heated debate about freedom of speech, media independence and whether ministers should have any role in deciding which news organisations receive greater visibility on social media.

At the centre of the controversy is the Government’s proposal to encourage, and potentially require, major technology companies to give greater prominence to news from organisations considered trustworthy. Public service broadcasters such as the BBC, ITV and Channel 4 could benefit from the changes.

Ministers argue that the proposals are necessary to protect reliable journalism, tackle misinformation and ensure that traditional news organisations remain accessible in an increasingly digital world.

However, critics fear that the policy could create a system in which government-approved news providers receive preferential treatment while independent newspapers and alternative media organisations struggle to reach audiences.

The controversy has raised an important question for British democracy: who should decide what news people see on their phones – technology companies, journalists, elected politicians or the public themselves?

1. Government plans could change what appears on social media feeds

The controversy centres on proposals contained in the Government’s media Green Paper, which explores ways to make trusted news more visible on digital platforms.

Under the proposals, companies such as Instagram and potentially YouTube could be required to give greater prominence to content from selected news organisations.

This could mean that articles, videos and reports from recognised public service broadcasters appear more frequently in users’ feeds.

The Government argues that social media algorithms currently give technology companies disproportionate influence over what people see.

Ministers believe high-quality journalism risks being pushed aside by sensational content, misinformation and material designed primarily to attract attention.

A new prominence system could therefore make established news providers easier to find.

However, the proposals have not yet established a definitive list of organisations that would qualify as trustworthy.

Nor has the Government provided a final explanation of who would determine eligibility or how the rules would operate.

That uncertainty has become one of the biggest sources of criticism.

If ministers or regulators have significant influence over which organisations receive preferential visibility, critics argue that the system could create opportunities for political interference.

2. Conservatives warn of an Orwellian threat to free speech

Conservative MP Nigel Huddleston has strongly criticised the proposals, describing them as having alarming Orwellian undertones.

He believes the Government risks creating a system in which certain news organisations receive official approval while others are treated as less trustworthy.

Huddleston has questioned how the authorities would define reliable journalism and what safeguards would prevent political considerations from influencing decisions.

He has also raised concerns about the potential impact on newspapers and independent publishers.

The central objection is that the Government should not become an authority responsible for determining which news organisations deserve to be promoted to the public.

Former Culture Secretary Sir John Whittingdale has also expressed concern, describing the proposals as a dangerous extension of government involvement in press freedom.

These criticisms reflect a broader democratic principle: governments should be subject to scrutiny from independent journalists rather than having the ability to influence which journalists reach the largest audiences.

Nevertheless, ministers insist that the objective is to improve access to trustworthy information rather than suppress alternative viewpoints.

The distinction between promoting reliable journalism and indirectly disadvantaging other publishers will be central to the debate.

3. Big Brother Watch warns of an algorithmic power grab

Civil liberties organisation Big Brother Watch has emerged as one of the most vocal critics of the proposed changes.

Jack Coulson, representing the organisation, has described the plans as an algorithmic land-grab.

His concern is that social media companies could be forced to adjust their algorithms to favour government-approved news providers.

If platforms are required to promote certain organisations, other publishers could receive less visibility even when their reporting is accurate and professionally produced.

This could have financial consequences for independent newspapers, which increasingly depend on social media to attract readers.

Coulson argues that people should retain the ability to decide which news sources they want to follow.

He also questions whether forcing additional traditional news content into social media feeds will actually reduce misinformation.

According to the organisation, people who actively seek out misleading information may not change their behaviour simply because more BBC or Channel 4 content appears in their feeds.

Big Brother Watch believes a better solution would be to give users greater control over their recommendations and make platform algorithms more transparent.

Its position is that protecting people from misinformation should not require the Government to decide which news organisations deserve preferential treatment.

4. The BBC and ITV could benefit from the changes

Public service broadcasters are among the organisations potentially affected by the proposed prominence rules.

The BBC, ITV, Channel 4, Channel 5, STV and S4C all have important roles in Britain’s broadcasting system.

However, traditional television audiences have increasingly moved towards online platforms.

Younger viewers often obtain news through TikTok, Instagram, YouTube and other digital services rather than watching scheduled television bulletins.

This has created financial and audience challenges for established broadcasters.

The Government believes that making public service journalism more visible online could help protect its future.

Ministers argue that these broadcasters provide professionally regulated news coverage and contribute to public understanding of important national issues.

They also believe that people should be able to discover reliable reporting without having to search extensively for it.

However, critics question whether giving established broadcasters greater algorithmic visibility is necessarily the right way to protect journalism.

They argue that public service broadcasters should compete for audiences on the strength of their reporting rather than receive special treatment through government-backed rules.

The challenge is finding a way to support high-quality journalism without weakening media competition.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *