
Andy Burnham says Brexit has failed Britain (Image: Daily Express)
It pains me to say it, but Andy Burnham is right – Brexit has not worked.
Long has our ordinary-bloke Prime Minister waxed lyrical about the country’s failures since that historic vote.
But ask yourself honestly: ten years on from the referendum, do you feel materially better off? Are your taxes lower? Is your high street busier?
I do not know about you, but I struggle to find many people who can answer those questions with a “yes”.
So yes, Mr Burnham’s diagnosis is right, but as ever, his proposed cure is entirely wrong.
Brexit has not failed because leaving was a mistake. It has failed because we never used the freedom we voted for.
Britons voted to take back control of our laws, our borders and our country. Then the government of the day left that control on the shelf, gathering dust.
We signed on to EU rules where we could, and caved to demands to wed ourselves to the regulatory beast that is the European Parliament.
Where we did dare to diverge, the results were promising. Britain joined the CPTPP, a Pacific trade bloc the EU is not part of. England freed its farmers to grow hardier crops through gene editing.
Imagine, for a moment, that boldness everywhere. Imagine if we had used those freedoms to take an axe to red tape, unlock the housing market, allow more drilling, and create a tax system built to attract the world’s best businesses rather than drive them abroad.
Instead, successive governments treated Brexit as damage to be managed, not an opportunity to be seized.
Mr Burnham’s answer is to shackle us to a bloc that is going nowhere fast. The European Commission’s own forecast has the eurozone growing by just 1.2% this year, with inflation at 3.2%.
At the upcoming summit in Brussels, he wants to sign Britain up to EU food rules and link our carbon market to theirs. That means taking laws we have no vote on, from a club we chose to leave.
Rejoiners have a point on trade: agri-food exports to the EU did fall after we left. They are right to say that paperwork at the border has made things harder.
But the solution cannot be to hand Brussels the pen. Rejoining would be worse still. We would surrender the freedoms we have used, and almost certainly lose the rebate Margaret Thatcher fought so hard to win.
The honest answer to a Brexit that has not worked is not to give up on it. No – our government must finally deliver it.
Scrap the rules that hold back British business, cut the taxes that strangle growth and strike the trade deals Brussels never could.
Brexit was never meant to be the end of the story. It was meant to be the beginning of a new one, and it is time someone in Downing Street had the courage to write the next chapter.
Andy Burnham Is Right That Brexit Hasn’t Worked – Britain’s Broken Promises Exposed
Andy Burnham has reignited Britain’s political debate over Brexit by suggesting that leaving the European Union has failed to deliver the economic benefits promised to voters. His argument has struck a nerve across Westminster, reopening divisions between those who believe Brexit was a historic mistake and those who insist Britain simply needs more time to take advantage of its independence.
Nearly a decade after the 2016 referendum, the consequences of Brexit remain a major source of political disagreement. Supporters promised greater sovereignty, stronger control over immigration, new international trade opportunities and the freedom to establish Britain’s own economic policies. However, critics argue that many of those promises have failed to materialise, while businesses and households continue to deal with additional costs and uncertainty.
Burnham’s position is particularly significant because he is not necessarily advocating an immediate return to EU membership. Instead, he argues that Britain needs a more realistic relationship with its largest nearby trading partner if the country wants to improve economic growth and living standards.
His comments raise an uncomfortable question for politicians across the political spectrum: if Brexit has delivered so many difficulties, why are British households still waiting for the promised economic rewards?
1. Brexit has failed to deliver the economic transformation promised
One of the strongest arguments supporting Burnham’s position concerns Britain’s economic performance since leaving the European Union.
During the referendum campaign, Leave supporters argued that Britain would be able to redirect money previously sent to Brussels towards domestic priorities.
They also promised that independent trade agreements would create new opportunities for British companies and that freedom from European regulations would make the economy more competitive.
However, the economic picture has been considerably more complicated.
Leaving the single market and customs union introduced additional administrative requirements for many businesses trading with Europe.
Exporters have faced new documentation, customs procedures and regulatory checks, increasing the complexity of selling goods across European borders.
Smaller companies have often struggled to absorb these additional costs because they lack the resources available to larger international businesses.
The Office for Budget Responsibility has estimated that Brexit will reduce Britain’s long-term productivity by around four per cent compared with remaining in the EU.
This is a long-term economic forecast rather than a measurement of an already completed loss, but it illustrates why economists continue to question the economic consequences of leaving.
For Burnham, the central argument is that Britain cannot afford to ignore these challenges simply because Brexit remains politically sensitive.
2. British businesses are still struggling with European trade barriers
Another important issue is the effect of Brexit on British exporters.
Before leaving the European Union, UK businesses benefited from relatively straightforward access to the European single market.
Goods could move between Britain and EU countries under common regulatory arrangements, making international trade considerably easier.
Following Brexit, companies exporting certain products have had to deal with additional paperwork and certification requirements.
Food producers, agricultural businesses and manufacturers have been particularly affected.
For smaller exporters, even relatively modest administrative costs can make European sales less profitable.
Some businesses have responded by changing their supply chains, increasing prices or reducing their involvement in European markets.
Burnham believes closer cooperation with Brussels could help reverse some of these difficulties.
His proposed European reset focuses on reducing unnecessary barriers without formally restoring Britain’s EU membership.
Supporters argue that this is a practical approach to repairing economic relationships.
However, Brexit supporters insist that businesses should be given time to adapt and that Britain should not sacrifice regulatory independence simply to make trading easier.
The disagreement reflects a fundamental difference in priorities: economic integration versus national regulatory freedom.
3. The cost of Brexit continues to affect ordinary households
For millions of British households, the debate is not simply about constitutional arrangements or political sovereignty.
It is about the cost of everyday living.
Brexit has contributed to additional trade friction, particularly for businesses importing and exporting goods between Britain and Europe.
These costs can be passed through supply chains and potentially influence prices paid by consumers.
However, it would be inaccurate to blame Brexit alone for Britain’s inflation problems.
Energy prices, global supply disruptions, the pandemic, exchange-rate movements and domestic economic policies have also played important roles.
Nevertheless, the additional barriers created by Brexit have not made international trade easier.
Burnham argues that reducing these obstacles could help businesses become more competitive and improve economic efficiency.
The Government therefore faces pressure to demonstrate that its European reset will produce practical benefits for families rather than simply generate another collection of political agreements.
Lower administrative costs, more efficient supply chains and improved market access could help businesses.
Whether these improvements eventually translate into noticeably lower prices for consumers remains an important question.
4. Immigration remains one of Brexit’s most controversial promises
Immigration was among the most important issues during the 2016 referendum campaign.
Leave supporters argued that leaving the EU would allow Britain to regain control of its borders and establish an immigration system based on national priorities.
Britain subsequently introduced a new points-based immigration system, ending the previous freedom of movement arrangements for EU citizens.
However, immigration did not simply disappear as a political problem.
Net migration increased significantly in the years following Brexit, partly because of the expansion of non-EU work and study visas.
This disappointed some Leave supporters who had expected Brexit to produce a substantial and immediate reduction in overall migration.
The experience demonstrates that leaving the European Union did not automatically resolve the wider challenges surrounding immigration.
Burnham’s approach to closer European cooperation has therefore attracted criticism from politicians who believe the Government risks weakening the border controls that Brexit was intended to strengthen.
His supporters counter that practical agreements with European countries do not necessarily mean restoring unrestricted freedom of movement.
The Government will need to explain clearly how it intends to balance economic cooperation with its commitments on immigration control.
5. Brexit has created a difficult choice over national sovereignty
One of the strongest arguments in favour of Brexit remains the principle of democratic independence.
Supporters believe British voters should be able to elect governments that make decisions without being constrained by EU institutions.
This was a central argument behind the Leave campaign’s promise to take back control.
However, economic independence comes with practical complications.
Britain remains closely connected to European markets, supply chains and regulatory systems.
When British businesses want to sell products into the EU, they must often comply with European requirements regardless of whether Britain is a member.
This creates a dilemma.
The Government can maintain completely separate regulations, but businesses may then face additional barriers when exporting to Europe.
Alternatively, Britain can align with European standards in selected sectors, potentially making trade easier while accepting less freedom to establish different rules in those areas.
Burnham believes closer cooperation offers a more sensible balance.
Critics argue that it risks turning Britain into a rule-taker rather than a rule-maker.
Both sides raise important questions about what economic independence should mean in a country that depends heavily on international trade.
6. Nigel Farage refuses to accept Burnham’s argument
Nigel Farage remains one of the most influential defenders of Brexit and is unlikely to accept Burnham’s assessment without a fight.
The Reform UK leader argues that Britain has not fully exploited the opportunities created by leaving the European Union.
He believes successive governments have failed to implement a sufficiently ambitious independent economic strategy.
Farage has also criticised Labour’s European reset, arguing that closer regulatory alignment could reverse important parts of the referendum result.
For Reform UK, the political opportunity is considerable.
The party can argue that Britain does not need to return to European structures to improve its economy.
Instead, it should focus on reducing domestic taxes, improving productivity, encouraging investment and developing independent trading relationships.
Burnham faces the challenge of explaining why closer cooperation with Brussels is preferable to pursuing those policies independently.
The disagreement is likely to become increasingly important as the next general election approaches.
7. Britain’s relationship with Europe needs a more realistic approach
Despite the continuing arguments, there is growing recognition that Britain needs a practical relationship with the European Union.
The EU remains one of the country’s most important trading partners.
Millions of jobs depend directly or indirectly on international commerce, while British manufacturers, farmers and service providers need access to overseas markets.
Burnham’s European reset is intended to improve cooperation in areas where both sides have shared economic interests.
Agricultural trade, energy, security and scientific research are among the areas where closer cooperation could produce advantages.
However, any new agreement must be judged according to its actual costs and benefits.
Britain should not automatically accept every European proposal simply because it promises improved relations.
Equally, refusing beneficial agreements simply to demonstrate political independence could damage British businesses.
A successful strategy requires careful negotiation and a clear understanding of Britain’s long-term economic interests.
8. The real test is whether ordinary people become better off
Ultimately, the Brexit debate should be judged by its consequences for ordinary citizens.
Voters were promised a stronger economy, improved public services, greater control over national decisions and new opportunities.
Some benefits of leaving the EU, particularly the ability to establish independent trade and immigration policies, have been achieved.
However, the economic costs and additional trade barriers have also become increasingly difficult to ignore.
Burnham’s argument is that Britain should acknowledge these problems rather than continue defending every aspect of Brexit as an unquestionable success.
His critics respond that changing the relationship with Brussels will not automatically solve Britain’s domestic economic problems.
That is an important point.
The UK’s productivity challenges, housing shortages, pressure on public services and regional inequalities require domestic solutions as well as international cooperation.
The Government must therefore demonstrate that its European strategy forms part of a credible economic plan rather than serving as a political distraction.
Is Andy Burnham right about Brexit?
Andy Burnham has raised an uncomfortable but necessary question about Britain’s future.
Brexit was presented as an opportunity to transform the country, strengthen its economy and restore national control.
Although Britain has gained greater freedom over certain domestic policies, the economic benefits have not matched the expectations of many supporters.
Additional trade barriers, weaker investment prospects and the long-term productivity outlook have created serious challenges.
This does not mean every problem facing Britain can be blamed on Brexit, nor does it automatically mean that rejoining the European Union would be the correct solution.
However, pretending that leaving the EU has been an unquestionable success would be equally misleading.
Burnham’s strongest argument is that Britain must be prepared to acknowledge what has not worked and pursue practical solutions.
Closer cooperation with Europe could help reduce unnecessary trade barriers, support British businesses and improve economic opportunities.
But any agreement must protect democratic accountability and provide clear benefits for taxpayers.
Ultimately, the country needs an honest debate based on evidence rather than political slogans.
Brexit cannot be reversed simply by pretending it never happened, but its consequences can be addressed through sensible policy decisions.
For Burnham, the challenge is to prove that his European reset can deliver something Brexit promised but has so far struggled to provide: a stronger economy and a better standard of living for ordinary British families.
