Andy Burnham’s jobs chief issues NHS with major warning over migrants . HYN

Prime Minister Andy Burnham is considering the findings of a major study

Prime Minister Andy Burnham is considering the findings of a major study (Image: Getty)

Employers including the NHS must stop depending on immigrant workers and give British young people a chance instead, according to the Labour grandee who led an inquiry into the youth unemployment crisis. Local workers “have to come first”, said Alan Milburn.

He was speaking at the launch of his 267-page report looking into almost a million youngsters not in education, employment or training, known as NEETs. Mr Milburn, a former health secretary, called the figure a “national failure” which had “dire economic and fiscal consequences”.

But the price would grow even higher as numbers rose, he said. He insisted: “A lost generation is not inevitable. A work generation is possible. Young people need a working state and a new settlement to bring it about.”

Andy Burnham accused of 'inciting disorder' over migrant crisis | Politics | News | Express.co.uk

Presenting the findings of his government-commissioned study, he called for radical changes to the education system so schools were judged on whether pupils went on to find employment, not just on exam results.

Health services should help young people with mental health conditions into work, rather than simply providing a diagnosis, he said. And he argued young people should be given a legal guarantee of a job or course placement, to give them a first step on the career ladder/

Andy Burnham issues dire warning NHS will collapse if social care isn't finally fixed - AOL

Mr Milburn also demanded radical changes to the benefits system, with many young people on health-related benefits receiving less than today – and potentially losing their entitlement unless they accept help finding work. The proposal was immediately condemned by trade unions, and could spark a huge battle with Labour MPs, who last year forced the Government to back down over plans to limit disability payments.

Mr Milburn called on the Government to provide funding of £500 million next year to begin making his plans a reality.

The changes would eventually cut the benefits bill by £3.6 billion and bring an extra £2.4 billion through taxes, a total saving of £6 billion. But Conservative critics pointed out that the cost to taxpayers would initially rise, and may not fall for a decade.

Our goal is to stop all migrant boats, says Andy Burnham

Launching the report, the former MP urged employers to recruit British youngsters. He said: “My message to the country, not just to the politicians but to employers, is that young people in those disadvantaged communities have to come first. They are the priority.

“In some ways what has happened in the youth labour market over the past 15 or 20 years is, there has become an over-dependence on migrant labour.

“Migration has fallen now, and that creates an opportunity for employers to reorientate back to employing young people from their communities, and that’s what they should do in my view.”

Turning to the NHS, he said: “The public sector has got to give a lead. It has a special responsibility to do that. Take something like the NHS – it’s a huge employer, the biggest in the country. We say in the report, look – you have a very diverse workforce, that’s great, and you recruit from all over the word, and that’s fantastic. But you need to do more to recruit from your local communities, particularly amongst the young.”

Andy Burnham's 12-point plan for Britain as he takes over as PM including immigration and taxes - Yorkshire Live

The study called for legislation to prevent future governments adopting policies likely to destroy jobs for young people. Mr Milburn insisted this was a long-running problem, but the report highlighted recent decisions taken by ex-Labour Chancellor Rachel Reeves, including increasing National Insurance rates for employers.

Workers under the age of 21 are largely exempt, but Mr Milburn pointed out that those aged 21 to 24 became more expensive to employ. Highlighting research by watchdog the Office for Responsibility (OBR), he said the change “increased the cost of a full-time worker on the National Living Wage by around £800 per year. The OBR estimated this package would raise £25.7 billion annually by 2029-30, directly from the bottom line of businesses.”

Andy Burnham promises to end Labour infighting as he becomes party's leader | Andy Burnham | The Guardian

He also highlighted increases in the minimum wage, as well as Labour’s Employment Rights Act, which he said had “unintended consequences”. The report said: “The potential impact is already being felt with more than a third (37 per cent) of employers planning to reduce permanent hiring because of Employment Rights Act reforms.”

Trade unions hit out at the prospect of cuts to benefits such as Personal Independence Payments (PIP), which goes to people with disabilities. Maryam Eslamdoust, General Secretary of the Labour-affiliated transport and travel union, said: “Cuts to PIP payments for young people seem like a justification for needless cruelty and will not incentivise anyone into work. Not only that it is discriminatory, pushing people into poverty and homelessness.”

The PCS union, which represents civil servants in the Department for Work and Pensions, also condemned the plans. General Secretary Fran Heathcote said: “The mental health crisis among our young people is not the fault of public services but is a result of decades of under-funding by successive governments. Moving now to cut payments for under-25s will not fix their issues or provide them with a better future, they will need both financial and specialised work-coach support to help bring them into the working environment.”

The Government announced the creation of a new youth opportunities unit reporting directly to Prime Minister Andy Burnham, but Ministers did not immediately commit to implementing all Mr Milburn’s proposals. Mr Burnham said: “It is an economic and moral catastrophe and a moral failure that we now have a million 16 to 24-year-olds who are not in education, employment or training.”

He added: “Put simply, this will be our approach: jobs rather than crude cuts; investment and prevention rather than abandonment; opportunity matched by responsibility; a safety net for those who cannot work; and a welfare system that helps people fulfil their potential rather than writing them off.”

Our goal is to stop all migrant boats, says Andy Burnham

Andy Burnham’s Jobs Chief Issues NHS With Major Warning Over Migrants

Andy Burnham is facing a fresh political challenge after his own youth employment adviser issued a stark warning to the NHS and other major employers over their reliance on migrant workers. Alan Milburn, the former Labour Health Secretary who led a major investigation into Britain’s youth unemployment crisis, has insisted that British young people must be given priority when employers recruit new staff.

His intervention has reignited the debate over immigration, public services and the growing number of young people struggling to find work. With almost one million people aged between 16 and 24 not in education, employment or training, Milburn believes Britain must rethink its approach to recruitment.

The NHS has become a particular focus because it is one of the country’s largest employers and has historically relied heavily on international recruitment to fill vacancies.

Milburn argues that public institutions should lead by example and provide more opportunities for young people from local communities. However, his comments have also raised difficult questions about whether the NHS can reduce its dependence on overseas workers without making existing staffing shortages even worse.

The controversy places Burnham in a difficult position. His Government wants to tackle youth unemployment while maintaining a functioning health service that continues to depend on workers from around the world.

1. Alan Milburn tells the NHS to recruit more British young people

The central message from Milburn is that employers must stop treating migrant recruitment as the easiest solution to workforce shortages.

Speaking at the launch of his 267-page report into youth unemployment, he argued that British employers should give greater consideration to young people living in disadvantaged communities.

He said:

“My message to the country, not just to the politicians but to employers, is that young people in those disadvantaged communities have to come first. They are the priority.”

Milburn believes that the British labour market has developed an excessive dependence on migrant workers over the past 15 to 20 years.

He argues that falling migration creates an opportunity for employers to reconsider their recruitment strategies and provide more opportunities for domestic workers.

The NHS received particular attention because of its enormous size and influence.

Milburn acknowledged that the health service has a diverse workforce and benefits from recruiting internationally. However, he believes it should do considerably more to attract young people from the communities it serves.

His argument is that public sector organisations have a special responsibility to help address Britain’s youth unemployment problem.

Rather than relying disproportionately on international recruitment, the NHS should develop stronger pathways into nursing, administration, technical occupations and other healthcare careers.

The proposal does not necessarily mean ending international recruitment. Instead, it challenges public employers to consider whether they are doing enough to develop Britain’s domestic workforce.

<Cite refs={[“turn805192search0″,”turn805192search2”]}/>

2. Nearly one million young people are missing from the workforce

Milburn’s warning comes against the backdrop of a serious youth employment crisis.

His investigation examined the circumstances of almost one million young people aged 16 to 24 who are classified as NEET.

This means they are not currently participating in education, employment or training.

The scale of the problem has raised concerns about Britain’s long-term economic prospects.

Young people who remain outside the labour market for extended periods can struggle to develop professional experience, establish financial independence and build stable careers.

The consequences can extend well beyond unemployment.

Long periods without work may contribute to mental health difficulties, social isolation and greater dependence on welfare support.

Milburn described the situation as a national failure with serious economic and financial consequences.

He believes the Government must stop treating youth unemployment as a problem that can be solved simply by encouraging people to submit more job applications.

Instead, Britain needs a system that connects young people with genuine employment opportunities.

His report calls for major changes to education, vocational training, mental health services and the benefits system.

The NHS is expected to play an important role because of its size and its ability to provide structured career opportunities.

3. The NHS must rethink its dependence on overseas recruitment

The NHS has relied on international recruitment for decades.

Doctors, nurses, healthcare assistants and other professionals from overseas have made substantial contributions to Britain’s health service.

According to analysis by the Health Foundation, employees with non-UK nationalities held approximately a quarter of all health and care jobs in Britain.

The proportion is even higher in some areas.

In London, approximately 32 per cent of NHS staff reported a non-UK nationality in 2025, compared with 13 per cent in the North East and Yorkshire.

These figures demonstrate just how important international workers have become to the health service.

The NHS has recruited overseas because domestic training and recruitment have not always produced sufficient numbers of workers to meet demand.

International recruitment has helped hospitals maintain staffing levels and provide essential services.

However, Milburn believes the system should not become so dependent on overseas workers that British young people struggle to access available opportunities.

He wants NHS organisations to invest more heavily in local recruitment, apprenticeships and training programmes.

The objective is to create a stronger domestic pipeline of healthcare professionals rather than continually relying on recruitment from abroad.

Nevertheless, reducing international recruitment without expanding domestic training could create serious difficulties.

The NHS already faces pressure from waiting lists, workforce shortages and rising demand for services.

Any transition must therefore be carefully managed.

<Cite refs={[“turn805192search5″,”turn805192search0”]}/>

4. Migrant workers remain essential to Britain’s health service

Although Milburn wants the NHS to recruit more British young people, his intervention has exposed a difficult contradiction.

The health service cannot simply replace overseas workers overnight.

Internationally recruited doctors and nurses provide essential services across hospitals, GP surgeries and community healthcare organisations.

Many have spent years working in Britain and have developed specialist skills that would be difficult to replace quickly.

The Health Foundation has highlighted the significant contribution made by migrant workers, including their importance in maintaining staffing levels.

Its research also found that internationally recruited NHS employees were more likely to work additional paid hours than UK-recruited colleagues.

This demonstrates why immigration remains an important part of Britain’s healthcare workforce strategy.

However, there are also concerns about the long-term sustainability of international recruitment.

Recruiting healthcare professionals from countries experiencing their own shortages can place additional pressure on global health systems.

Britain must therefore find a balance between developing its domestic workforce and maintaining the international recruitment necessary to deliver healthcare services.

Milburn’s warning is not that migrant workers should be excluded from the NHS. Rather, he believes British employers must stop overlooking the potential of young people in their own communities.

5. Labour’s immigration policies could make NHS recruitment more difficult

The controversy comes at a time when the Government is considering significant changes to immigration and settlement rules.

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has been examining proposals to extend the qualifying period for indefinite leave to remain for certain migrant workers.

Under the wider proposals, the standard qualifying period could increase from five to ten years for many migrants, although shorter routes would remain available for some workers, including doctors and nurses.

The changes have generated considerable opposition from healthcare organisations.

The Royal College of Nursing has warned that making it more difficult for internationally recruited nurses to settle permanently could encourage experienced staff to leave Britain.

Its General Secretary, Professor Nicola Ranger, has argued that migrant nursing professionals are essential to the future of the NHS and social care.

There are concerns that uncertainty over settlement arrangements could make Britain less attractive compared with countries offering clearer routes to permanent residency.

This creates a difficult situation for Burnham.

On one hand, Milburn wants public employers to prioritise British young people.

On the other, the NHS must continue attracting and retaining experienced international professionals.

If immigration restrictions are introduced too quickly, the health service could lose workers before sufficient numbers of domestic replacements have been trained.

The Government will therefore need to ensure that its immigration strategy and workforce planning operate together rather than working against each other.

<Cite refs={[“turn805192search6″,”turn805192search5″,”turn805192search3”]}/>

6. Employers could face pressure to change their recruitment strategies

Milburn’s report goes beyond the NHS.

It challenges businesses across the country to reconsider how they recruit workers and whether they are doing enough to provide opportunities for young people.

For years, some industries have relied heavily on overseas labour to fill vacancies.

Hospitality, agriculture, social care, retail and food manufacturing are among the sectors where migrant workers have played important roles.

Milburn believes employers should develop stronger connections with local communities and provide more opportunities for young people who have struggled to enter employment.

He also argues that businesses should not automatically turn to international recruitment when domestic applicants could be trained to perform the same jobs.

The report proposes financial incentives to encourage employers to recruit disadvantaged young people.

Under the proposed Youth Jobs Grant, qualifying businesses could receive £3,000 for employing an eligible young person who has been NEET for at least six months.

Additional support could increase the incentive to as much as £7,000 for qualifying employers.

These measures are intended to make hiring inexperienced young people more attractive.

However, employers will still need to consider skills, qualifications, training requirements and workforce needs.

Financial incentives alone cannot guarantee that businesses will recruit people who require substantial training.

The Government must therefore make sure that education providers and employers work together to create practical routes into employment.

7. Young people could receive a guaranteed opportunity to work

One of the most ambitious recommendations in Milburn’s report is the proposed Youth Opportunity Guarantee.

The scheme aims to ensure that young people who become disconnected from employment and education receive meaningful support.

Eligible people aged 18 to 24 would receive assistance from a named adviser who could help them identify suitable opportunities.

This could include apprenticeships, vocational qualifications, further education or paid employment.

The report also recommends that eligible young people who remain unemployed for 12 months despite engaging with support should have access to a guaranteed six-month paid job, where employment is realistic.

The NHS could become one of the major organisations providing these opportunities.

There are numerous healthcare occupations that do not require someone to become a doctor or nurse.

Young people could pursue careers in hospital administration, laboratory support, pharmacy assistance, digital healthcare, facilities management and patient services.

Apprenticeships could also help young people develop the qualifications needed for more specialised roles.

For people from disadvantaged backgrounds, these opportunities could provide an important route towards financial independence.

However, the success of the programme will depend on whether sufficient positions are available.

The NHS must have the funding, training capacity and workforce planning necessary to support additional recruits.

8. Burnham faces a difficult political balancing act

The political consequences of Milburn’s intervention could be considerable.

Labour wants to demonstrate that it is tackling youth unemployment and improving opportunities for British workers.

At the same time, the party must avoid alienating migrant communities and healthcare professionals who have contributed significantly to public services.

The Government also faces pressure from different groups within its own political coalition.

Some Labour MPs support stronger domestic recruitment and believe employers should do more to train British workers.

Others are concerned that an overly restrictive immigration approach could damage the NHS and social care sector.

Trade unions have also warned against using welfare reform or reduced benefits as a substitute for proper investment in employment support.

The debate is therefore about more than immigration numbers.

It concerns the type of economy Britain wants to develop and how the country should prepare its young population for the future.

Burnham must demonstrate that encouraging British recruitment does not mean treating migrant workers as the cause of unemployment.

The real challenge is creating enough training and employment opportunities for everyone who wants to contribute.

A major warning for Andy Burnham and the NHS

Alan Milburn’s intervention has exposed an uncomfortable reality facing Britain’s public services.

The NHS has become heavily dependent on international recruitment, while hundreds of thousands of young people remain outside employment, education and training.

His warning that local British workers must come first has placed pressure on employers to reconsider their recruitment strategies.

There is a strong argument for giving young people better access to healthcare careers through apprenticeships, vocational education and targeted recruitment.

However, Britain’s health service cannot afford to lose experienced migrant professionals without having sufficient domestic workers ready to replace them.

International recruitment and domestic training should therefore be treated as complementary parts of a sustainable workforce strategy.

For Burnham, the political challenge is particularly difficult.

He must show that Labour can create opportunities for British young people while protecting the NHS from further staffing problems.

If the Government succeeds, it could help tackle youth unemployment and strengthen the long-term resilience of public services.

If it gets the balance wrong, hospitals and care providers could face even greater recruitment difficulties.

Ultimately, the question is not whether Britain needs migrant workers or British workers. It needs both.

The real test will be whether the Government can build a system in which young people have a fair opportunity to enter the workforce while the NHS continues to attract and retain the skilled professionals it urgently needs.


Sources and further reading:

  • <Link ref=”turn805192search0″ title=”AOL / Daily Express – Alan Milburn’s warning to the NHS and employers”/>

  • <Link ref=”turn805192search5″ title=”The Health Foundation – Immigration and the NHS: The Evidence”/>

  • <Link ref=”turn805192search6″ title=”Royal College of Nursing – Concerns over immigration reforms”/>

  • <Link ref=”turn805192search2″ title=”Sky News – Milburn review and public-sector recruitment targets”/>

  • <Link ref=”turn805192search3″ title=”The Independent – Andy Burnham’s position on immigration”/>

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *