
Payrolls fell by 34,000 in October (Image: Getty)
Labour has been accused of wiping out 200,000 jobs since it swept to power, as official figures showed firms are slashing payrolls and shelving hiring.
The number of workers on company payrolls fell by 34,000 in October, the Office for National Statistics revealed on Tuesday, leaving 95,000 fewer than a year earlier.
Job vacancies sank to their lowest level outside the pandemic since 2014, with small businesses blaming soaring labour and operating costs for putting the brakes on hiring.
Critics say that the grim picture lays bare the damage done by Labour’s hated jobs tax, the hike in employers’ National Insurance.
Headline unemployment did dip to 4.6% in the three months to September. But the ONS warned the fall partly reflected changes in who was taking part in its survey, rather than a genuine jobs boom.
ONS Director of Economic Statistics Liz McKeown said: “The latest figures provide a mixed picture overall.”
Regular pay growth also slowed to 3.5%, just 0.4% ahead of inflation.\
Shadow Chancellor Andrew Griffith said: “Labour’s job tax and (Un)Employment Rights Act have destroyed 200,000 jobs since they took office.
“The result is fewer people picking up a pay packet and more people signing on. You cannot tax employers for hiring, bury them in red tape and then wonder where the work went.”
The National Insurance raid was brought in by then-Chancellor Rachel Reeves in her first Budget, despite Labour’s election promise not to raise taxes on working people.

Andrew Griffith blamed Labour’s jobs tax (Image: Getty)
Ms Reeves hiked the rate employers pay from 13.8% to 15% and slashed the threshold at which they start paying from £9,100 to £5,000.
A Department for Work and Pensions spokesperson said: “Despite the difficult global backdrop, the unemployment rate is falling and the number of people in work is rising.
“We are determined to go further. Our £2.5 billion youth employment support will give almost one million young people opportunities to earn and learn.”
They added: “But we won’t be complacent and the Milburn Review will help shape our next steps for young people not in education, work or training.”
Andy Burnham Accused of Wiping Out 200,000 Jobs as Work Opportunities Fall
Andy Burnham is facing mounting criticism after fresh employment figures revealed a worrying decline in the number of workers on company payrolls and a sharp reduction in available job vacancies. The Prime Minister’s economic strategy has come under renewed attack, with Conservative politicians accusing Labour of damaging businesses, discouraging recruitment and putting thousands of livelihoods at risk.
The controversy centres on claims that approximately 200,000 jobs have disappeared since Labour came to power. Opposition politicians argue that the Government’s decision to increase employers’ National Insurance contributions and introduce additional employment regulations has made hiring more expensive, particularly for small businesses.
The latest figures have intensified concerns about Britain’s labour market, with employers becoming increasingly cautious about recruitment. Although unemployment has shown some improvement in the latest reporting period, the wider picture remains troubling.
For Burnham, the political challenge is becoming increasingly serious. He must convince businesses that Labour understands their financial pressures while reassuring workers that the Government has a credible plan to create sustainable employment.
1. Labour faces a major jobs crisis
The latest figures from the Office for National Statistics have raised fresh concerns about the health of Britain’s employment market.
According to figures published on November 17, 2026, the number of employees on company payrolls fell by 34,000 in October.
This left approximately 95,000 fewer employees on payrolls compared with the same period a year earlier.
The figures also showed that job vacancies had fallen to their lowest level outside the pandemic since 2014.
For businesses and jobseekers, this represents an increasingly difficult environment.
Companies are becoming more cautious about expanding their workforces, while people searching for employment are facing fewer opportunities.
The situation is particularly worrying for young people attempting to secure their first jobs.
Employers are increasingly concerned about recruitment costs, economic uncertainty and the additional responsibilities associated with hiring staff.
ONS Director of Economic Statistics Liz McKeown described the latest figures as a mixed picture, highlighting the different trends emerging across Britain’s labour market.
Although the unemployment rate fell to 4.6 per cent in the three months to September, the figures did not necessarily indicate a dramatic improvement in employment conditions.
The ONS also warned that changes in survey participation had influenced the latest unemployment estimates.
Consequently, the apparent improvement needs to be considered alongside the continuing decline in payroll employment and vacancies.
2. Conservatives blame Labour’s National Insurance increase
One of the strongest criticisms concerns the increase in employers’ National Insurance contributions introduced by Labour’s previous Chancellor, Rachel Reeves.
The rate employers pay increased from 13.8 per cent to 15 per cent.
At the same time, the threshold at which employers begin paying National Insurance was reduced from £9,100 to £5,000.
The changes significantly increased employment costs for many businesses.
Conservative politicians argue that the decision effectively introduced an additional tax on employing people.
They believe businesses faced with higher wage bills and additional National Insurance contributions have responded by reducing recruitment, limiting working hours or reconsidering expansion plans.
Shadow Chancellor Andrew Griffith has been particularly vocal.
He accused Labour’s jobs tax and Employment Rights Act of destroying approximately 200,000 jobs since the party entered government.
His argument is that employers cannot be expected to create additional positions when the Government continually increases the financial burden associated with hiring.
Small businesses are particularly vulnerable because they often operate with limited financial reserves.
A restaurant, independent retailer or small manufacturing company may have little flexibility when employment costs suddenly increase.
For these businesses, even a relatively small increase in the cost of employing each worker can influence decisions about whether to recruit additional staff.
3. Small businesses are struggling with rising employment costs
The National Insurance increase has become a major political issue because of its potential impact on Britain’s small-business sector.
Small and medium-sized businesses employ millions of people and play an essential role in supporting local economies.
However, many are already dealing with higher electricity bills, rent, supplier costs and borrowing expenses.
Adding higher employment taxes to these pressures can make recruitment considerably more difficult.
Some employers may decide to delay hiring until economic conditions improve.
Others may reduce overtime, limit working hours or increase prices to compensate for additional expenditure.
The hospitality and retail industries are particularly exposed because labour represents a significant proportion of their operating costs.
Restaurants, cafés, pubs and independent shops frequently depend on relatively large numbers of employees working different shifts.
When employment costs increase, businesses may have fewer opportunities to expand their teams.
Conservative critics believe Labour has underestimated these pressures.
They argue that the Government cannot simultaneously demand higher employment standards and increase the cost of recruitment without considering the financial consequences for employers.
However, Labour maintains that its policies are intended to protect workers and create a fairer employment environment.
The Government also points towards increased employment allowances designed to reduce the impact on smaller businesses.
The disagreement is therefore about whether the benefits of stronger worker protections justify the additional costs imposed on employers.
4. Youth unemployment is becoming an even bigger concern
Perhaps the most worrying aspect of Britain’s employment problems is the situation facing younger generations.
Almost one million young people are currently not in education, employment or training, commonly described as the NEET population.
This represents a serious challenge for the Government because young people who struggle to enter employment can experience long-term consequences.
Without work experience, qualifications or professional connections, securing a first job can become increasingly difficult.
Many employers expect applicants to have previous experience, creating a frustrating situation for school leavers and university graduates.
Labour has acknowledged the scale of the problem and commissioned Alan Milburn to investigate the reasons behind rising youth economic inactivity.
The Government has also announced an additional £2.5 billion in youth employment support, intended to help almost one million young people access employment, education and training.
Its plans include financial incentives for employers recruiting young people, expanded apprenticeship opportunities and subsidised employment placements.
However, critics argue that government-funded schemes cannot compensate for a wider shortage of genuine vacancies.
They believe the priority should be creating an economic environment in which private businesses feel confident enough to recruit.
5. Alan Milburn’s review puts additional pressure on Burnham
The publication of Alan Milburn’s review has added another dimension to Labour’s employment difficulties.
The investigation examines why so many young people are struggling to find work or remain outside education and training.
It is expected to consider the roles played by schools, universities, employers, welfare arrangements and the healthcare system.
One of the major concerns is that Britain is failing to provide effective routes from education into employment.
Graduates are finding it increasingly difficult to secure entry-level positions, while employers continue demanding previous experience.
Milburn’s recommendations could lead to significant changes in employment support, education policy and welfare arrangements.
The Government hopes these reforms will help reduce youth inactivity and improve Britain’s long-term productivity.
However, Burnham will face difficult decisions about how to fund the proposed changes.
If additional spending is required, ministers must explain where the money will come from.
If welfare eligibility is tightened, Labour could face criticism from campaigners concerned about vulnerable young people.
The review therefore represents an important test of whether the Government can move beyond short-term employment schemes and tackle the underlying causes of economic inactivity.
6. Unemployment figures provide a mixed picture
Despite the criticism, Labour has defended its economic record by highlighting the fall in the headline unemployment rate.
The unemployment rate declined from 4.7 per cent to 4.6 per cent in the three months to September.
The Department for Work and Pensions has also argued that the number of people in work is rising despite difficult global economic conditions.
A government spokesperson said Labour remained committed to creating opportunities through its youth employment programme and improving support at Jobcentres.
However, the figures need to be examined carefully.
The decline in unemployment does not necessarily mean businesses are creating jobs at a healthy rate.
Payroll employment, vacancies, economic inactivity and unemployment measure different aspects of the labour market.
The reduction in payroll numbers suggests that employers remain cautious, even as the headline unemployment figure has improved.
This creates a complicated picture for policymakers.
Burnham cannot simply point to one positive statistic and claim the employment crisis has been resolved.
Equally, opposition politicians cannot automatically attribute every lost job to a single government policy.
The wider economic environment, changing consumer demand, technological developments and business investment decisions all influence employment.
7. Labour’s employment rights reforms face criticism
Another major source of disagreement is the Employment Rights Act.
Labour argues that stronger employment protections are necessary to improve working conditions and provide greater security for employees.
The legislation includes changes intended to strengthen workers’ rights and establish clearer responsibilities for employers.
However, business organisations have raised concerns about the potential costs and administrative burdens.
Critics fear that additional employment obligations could discourage businesses from recruiting, particularly when companies are already facing higher taxes.
The Office for Budget Responsibility has acknowledged that the Employment Rights Act could have a negative economic effect, although its assessment suggests the impact on potential output is unlikely to exceed 0.1 per cent.
This is an important distinction.
The legislation may create additional costs for businesses, but it would be misleading to suggest that every job lost since Labour entered government was directly caused by employment reforms.
The Government insists that better employment standards can coexist with economic growth.
Ministers argue that secure workers are more productive and that businesses benefit from retaining experienced employees.
The challenge is ensuring that new protections do not unintentionally make employers reluctant to create additional positions.
8. The hospitality and retail sectors are particularly vulnerable
The latest employment figures reveal that some industries are experiencing significantly greater difficulties than others.
Wholesale and retail businesses recorded a reduction of approximately 71,000 payroll jobs.
Accommodation and food services lost around 46,000 positions, while manufacturing recorded a decline of approximately 32,000.
These sectors are important because they provide employment opportunities for people without extensive professional qualifications.
Retail shops, restaurants, hotels and manufacturing businesses often provide the first opportunity for young people entering the workforce.
When recruitment slows in these industries, the consequences can extend throughout local communities.
Fewer jobs mean less income for households and potentially reduced spending at other local businesses.
Small towns and economically disadvantaged areas can be particularly affected because they may have fewer alternative employers.
The Government therefore faces pressure to introduce policies that encourage businesses to expand rather than simply providing financial support after employment opportunities have disappeared.
9. Could Labour’s economic policies damage its election prospects?
Employment is likely to remain one of the most important political issues facing Burnham.
Labour entered government promising economic stability, improved living standards and greater opportunities for working people.
However, declining payroll employment and falling vacancies provide opposition parties with an opportunity to question whether those promises are being fulfilled.
Nigel Farage and Reform UK are likely to highlight the employment figures as evidence that established political parties have failed to create the conditions necessary for economic growth.
The Conservatives are also attempting to position themselves as stronger supporters of businesses and employers.
For Labour, the political danger is that criticism from businesses could gradually undermine confidence among traditional working-class voters.
People who cannot find employment may become increasingly frustrated, particularly when politicians continue announcing ambitious economic programmes.
The Government must therefore demonstrate that its policies are producing real opportunities rather than simply generating additional promises.
The real test for Andy Burnham
The latest employment figures have created another difficult moment for Andy Burnham’s Government.
The accusation that Labour has wiped out 200,000 jobs is politically damaging, but it is important to recognise that this is an opposition claim based on payroll changes rather than proof that 200,000 jobs were directly destroyed by government decisions.
Nevertheless, the fall in company payrolls, declining vacancies and continuing youth employment problems cannot be ignored.
The increase in employers’ National Insurance contributions has clearly created additional costs for businesses, while the Government’s employment reforms have generated further debate about recruitment incentives.
Burnham must now demonstrate that Labour can support workers without discouraging businesses from hiring them.
His Government needs to focus on encouraging investment, reducing unnecessary administrative burdens, improving vocational training and creating better opportunities for young people.
The £2.5 billion youth employment programme could make a meaningful difference, but its success will depend on whether it leads to genuine, sustainable jobs.
Ultimately, Britain’s employment crisis will not be solved through political arguments alone.
Workers need secure incomes, businesses need confidence and young people need realistic opportunities to begin their careers.
If Burnham cannot deliver improvements in these areas, the accusations surrounding Labour’s jobs record could become an increasingly serious threat to his political future.
Sources and further reading:
-
<Link ref=”turn247574search0″ title=”AOL – Andy Burnham accused of wiping out 200,000 jobs”/>
-
<Link ref=”turn247574search1″ title=”Sky News – Youth unemployment and the Milburn review”/>
-
<Link ref=”turn247574search2″ title=”GOV.UK – £2.5 billion youth employment support”/>
-
<Link ref=”turn247574search4″ title=”House of Lords – Business hiring intentions and employment figures”/>
