Britain’s migration crisis has been fuelled by France’s failure to deport tens of thousands of illegal migrants, new analysis suggests.
The analysis, carried out by Facts4EU and Stand For Our Sovereignty, examined official data from British and French statistics agencies.
It found that despite having issued 132,750 deportation orders to illegal migrants during Sir Keir Starmer’s first year in power, French authorities were able to effect 6,395 actual enforced returns to third countries, meaning either the migrant’s home country or another one.
This represents just 4.8 per cent of the total.
The report found that France was only able to effect 6,395 actual enforced returns to third countries during the 12 month period
In that same 12 month period, the report claims France was able to send – or allow to be sent – nearly seven times as many migrants across the ‘illegal channel’ to England as President Macron was able to deport to all other countries combined, via the legal channel of deportation.
The report further found that deportations of illegal boat migrants in Britain fell by 7.4 per cent per cent in Sir Keir’s first year in power.
In the year ending June 2025, there were 2,330 returns of people who had arrived by small boat, which is 7.4 per cent fewer than the previous year.
Of the small boat returns in the latest year, 75 per cent were of Albanian nationalities, the analysis found.
The report also found UK deportations of illegal boat migrants dropped in the first 12 months of Sir Keir being in power
FACTS 4EU/STAND FOR OUR SOVEREIGNTY
Unlike in EU countries, the Home Office does not report on the number of migrants ordered to leave, but instead only on the number who were deported.
In the UK, Albanian nationals were the most common nationality of all enforced returns over the last four years and accounted for 28 per cent (2,562) in the latest 12 months, the report stated.
Enforced returns of other nationalities however have increased, with numbers of Romanians up 28 per cent (1,696), Brazilians up 90 per cent (861) and Indians having more than doubled (615) over the same period.
The analysis also found the majority of those subject to deportation orders in France between July 1, 2024, and June 30, 2025, were not forced to leave.
Despite having issued 132,750 deportation orders to illegal migrants, figures show France only enforced deportations of 6,395
FACTS 4EU/STAND FOR OUR SOVEREIGNTY
How can a deportation be defined?
In France, deportations fall under what is called the Obligation de Quitter le Territoire Français (OQTF) – the Obligation to Leave French Territory.
In outline, the Prefect of Police of the region issues the notice to a migrant, which either gives 30 days’ notice to leave or it is of the immediate variety.
If 30 days’ notice is given, the migrant must leave in that time (with or without state assistance) or be placed in a detention camp.
As in the UK with asylum claims being rejected, the process is subject to legal challenge and is more complex than indicated above.
In particular, assuming the migrant does not voluntarily depart, the State must obtain a “consular pass” from their country of origin.
This document certifies the individual’s nationality and authorises their entry.
Without this pass, deportation cannot take place.
It is also the case that the EU’s “Dublin Agreement” requires the migrant to have any case for asylum to be heard in the EU country they first entered.
Questions have been raised about how well this system works when put into practice
Three SHOCK Graphs Expose France’s Key Role in Britain’s Migrant Crisis – and Leave Labour Facing Another Unwanted Record
Britain’s ongoing immigration crisis has once again become a major political controversy after three revealing graphs reportedly highlighted France’s significant role in the growing number of migrants crossing the English Channel. The figures have raised questions about border security, international cooperation and the effectiveness of Labour’s immigration strategy under Prime Minister Keir Starmer. As pressure continues to mount, the government is facing criticism over the number of small boat arrivals and its ability to deliver meaningful reductions. The situation has also renewed debate about whether Britain’s partnership with France is providing sufficient results to justify the financial and political commitments involved.
First of all, irregular migration across the English Channel has become one of the most challenging issues facing the United Kingdom. Every year, thousands of people attempt to reach British shores in small, overcrowded boats. These journeys are organised in many cases by criminal smuggling networks that exploit vulnerable individuals and charge substantial sums of money for dangerous crossings. The Channel is one of the busiest shipping routes in the world, making these journeys particularly hazardous.
The three graphs mentioned in the controversy are particularly significant because they reportedly illustrate the relationship between migrant departures from French territory and arrivals in Britain. Understanding these figures is essential when examining the wider immigration crisis. However, statistics must be interpreted carefully, including the period covered, the number of recorded arrivals and the distinction between attempted crossings and successful journeys.
France occupies an important geographical position in this debate. Much of the coastline used by people attempting to cross the Channel is located in northern France, particularly around Calais and Dunkirk. Migrants frequently gather in these areas before attempting dangerous journeys towards Britain. Consequently, cooperation between French and British authorities is essential to preventing irregular departures and disrupting criminal smuggling organisations.
Since becoming Prime Minister in July 2024, Keir Starmer has attempted to establish a different approach to immigration enforcement. His government abandoned the previous Conservative administration’s Rwanda deportation scheme, describing it as an expensive policy that had failed to deliver its intended results. Labour instead promised to strengthen international cooperation, improve intelligence sharing and target the criminal networks responsible for organising small boat crossings.
However, the continued arrival of migrants has created difficulties for the government. Opposition politicians argue that Labour has failed to demonstrate sufficient progress in controlling the Channel crossings. Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has repeatedly criticised the government’s immigration strategy, while Conservative representatives have questioned whether existing arrangements with France are delivering meaningful improvements.
One of the government’s main initiatives has been the ‘one in, one out’ agreement with France. Introduced in 2025, the arrangement allows certain migrants arriving irregularly in Britain to be returned to France, while an equivalent number of eligible individuals can enter the United Kingdom through an authorised legal pathway.
Supporters argue that the agreement provides a mechanism for discouraging dangerous crossings while maintaining legal migration routes. Nevertheless, critics question whether the number of returns is sufficiently large to influence the decisions of people considering travelling across the Channel. They argue that the government needs to demonstrate measurable results rather than relying on diplomatic announcements.
Another important concern involves the effectiveness of French border enforcement. French authorities have responsibility for policing their coastline, preventing dangerous departures and investigating criminal organisations operating within their territory. However, monitoring extensive coastal areas is a difficult task. Smuggling networks frequently change locations, methods and departure times to avoid detection.
This creates significant challenges for both countries. Britain depends partly on French cooperation to prevent departures, while France must manage migration pressures within its own territory. Effective coordination therefore requires intelligence sharing, sufficient police resources and a consistent approach to investigating criminal networks.
The financial cost of Britain’s immigration system has also attracted considerable attention. The government spends substantial amounts on asylum accommodation, application processing, border enforcement and immigration administration. The use of hotels to accommodate asylum seekers has generated particular criticism because of the pressure it can place on public finances.
Many taxpayers want to understand why significant amounts of public money are being spent on temporary accommodation while families across the country face rising housing costs, energy bills and food prices. Local communities may also experience pressure on housing availability and public services. These concerns have contributed to wider frustration with the government’s handling of immigration.
Nevertheless, it is important to recognise that migrants arriving in Britain have different circumstances. Some are escaping war, persecution and serious threats to their lives, while others may be seeking economic opportunities. Under international law, people who request asylum are entitled to have their applications assessed individually. The government must distinguish between individuals who qualify for protection and those who have no legal right to remain.
The humanitarian consequences of Channel crossings must also remain part of the discussion. Overcrowded vessels, dangerous weather conditions and criminal exploitation place migrants at serious risk. People-smuggling organisations frequently prioritise profit over human safety. Therefore, disrupting these networks is important not only for immigration enforcement but also for preventing deaths and protecting vulnerable individuals.
There are several measures that could improve the situation. Firstly, Britain and France should strengthen intelligence sharing and cooperation between law enforcement agencies. Secondly, criminal organisations responsible for arranging dangerous crossings should be investigated and prosecuted. Thirdly, asylum applications should be processed more efficiently, ensuring that genuine refugees receive protection while unsuccessful applicants can be removed lawfully. Finally, both governments should publish transparent information about enforcement activities and the results of their agreements.
In conclusion, the three graphs highlighting France’s role in Britain’s migrant crisis have renewed scrutiny of Keir Starmer’s immigration strategy and the effectiveness of cooperation between the two countries. Although France’s geographical position makes its involvement essential, Britain must also take responsibility for developing an effective domestic asylum and border enforcement system. Political promises alone cannot resolve a complicated international problem. Ultimately, a successful strategy requires stronger international partnerships, effective action against criminal smuggling networks, fair asylum procedures and transparent public accountability. The government must demonstrate that its policies are producing measurable improvements while ensuring that border security and humanitarian responsibilities are both respected.
