Lucy Powell’s victory has sparked fresh turmoil inside Labour, with GB News political correspondent Olivia Utley warning it is “very bad news” for Sir Keir Starmer.
Speaking on GB News, Olivia said Powell’s win over Bridget Phillipson, who was seen as No10’s preferred candidate, will cause major tension within the party.
“Lucy Powell was leader of the House of Commons until eight weeks ago and was viewed as the anti-Government candidate,” Olivia explained.
“This shows Labour members are voting with their feet and expressing discontent with Keir Starmer himself.”
Olivia Utley said that this is ‘very bad news’ for Keir Starmer
Ms Powell’s close ties with Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham, a long-time critic of Sir Keir, are also raising eyebrows.
In her acceptance speech, Ms Powell appeared to take thinly veiled digs at the Prime Minister, saying the party had “allowed Nigel Farage to take control of the political mic” and insisting that “debating, listening and hearing is our strength.”
Olivia said such remarks will not go unnoticed by Sir Keir’s team: “She’s pitching herself as a bridge between the members and the leadership but that could quickly become awkward if she sounds even slightly critical of the Government. She could become a rallying point for Labour rebels.”
The GB News correspondent also noted that No10 appeared keen to downplay the announcement, with reporters barred from asking questions and the Prime Minister giving only brief remarks.
“All in all,” Olivia said, “it’s bad news for the PM.”
“She’s in cahoots with Andy Burnham, who’s been openly critical of Starmer,” Olivia added.
“He set up a think tank called Mainstream, which many view as a platform to attack Mr Starmer from within Labour. The two of them together could become a real problem for No10.”
The Manchester Central MP was sacked from the Cabinet in September.
Ms Powell secured 87,407 votes, almost 14,000 more than Ms Phillipson, on a turnout of just 16.6 per cent.
In her victory speech, Ms Powell said Labour must be “bolder” and promised to be a “champion for our Labour values”, adding that the party “must change how we are doing things to turn things around”.
She told supporters she would use her new role to “bring voices” from across the movement “to the heart of our party”, insisting she wanted to “help Keir and our Government to succeed”.
Ms Powell said: “I’ll be a champion for our Labour values and boldness in everything we do. And I know that you, Keir, as our leader, want that and I will be your ally in that fight.”
Ms Powell’s victory comes at a turbulent time for the Government, which has faced scrutiny over the grooming gangs inquiry and the mistaken release of a migrant sex offender from prison.
Labour also suffered a major blow in a Senedd by-election in Caerphilly, losing a seat it had held for more than a century.
Lucy Powell’s Victory Exposes Deep Labour Rift as Keir Starmer Faces Rebellion Warning: ‘Bad News for the PM!’
Prime Minister Keir Starmer is facing renewed questions about his authority within the Labour Party after Lucy Powell secured a significant victory in the party’s deputy leadership election. The result has exposed disagreements over the government’s political direction, leadership style and relationship with ordinary party members. Although Starmer publicly congratulated Powell, her victory has been widely interpreted by political commentators as a warning that growing dissatisfaction within Labour cannot simply be ignored.
First of all, Lucy Powell’s election represents an important moment for the Labour Party. The Manchester Central MP defeated Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson in a closely contested leadership race to replace Angela Rayner, who resigned from the deputy leadership following controversy over her tax affairs.
Powell received 87,407 votes, representing approximately 54 per cent of the votes cast, while Phillipson secured 73,536 votes. Turnout was just 16.6 per cent of the 970,642 eligible party members and affiliated voters. The result was announced on 25 October 2025. <Cite refs={[“turn901494search0″,”turn901494search12”]}/>
The outcome attracted considerable attention because Phillipson was widely regarded as the candidate preferred by Downing Street. Powell, meanwhile, had been removed from her position as Leader of the House of Commons during Starmer’s September reshuffle.
Her victory therefore raised questions about whether Labour members were expressing dissatisfaction with the Prime Minister’s leadership and the direction of his government.
During her victory speech, Powell made several comments that appeared to challenge the way Labour was being managed. She argued that party members and elected representatives should be treated as valuable assets rather than potential sources of disagreement.
She also delivered a pointed message about political leadership, declaring that unity and loyalty should come from a shared purpose rather than a system of command and control.
Her remarks were particularly significant because they suggested that Labour needed to become more open to internal discussion. Powell argued that listening to MPs and party members should not be interpreted as disloyalty or rebellion.
She also acknowledged that the government had not been sufficiently bold in delivering the changes promised during the general election campaign. According to Powell, Labour needed to communicate its values more clearly and demonstrate greater determination in addressing the country’s problems. <Cite refs={[“turn901494search1″,”turn901494search3”]}/>
One of the most important challenges facing Starmer concerns the growing dissatisfaction among Labour’s traditional supporters. Many voters expected significant improvements after the party’s victory in July 2024. However, concerns about taxation, public services, immigration and living costs have created difficulties for the government.
Powell’s victory suggests that some Labour members want a different approach. They believe the government should place greater emphasis on its traditional principles, including social equality, workers’ rights and investment in public services.
Another important issue concerns the party’s relationship with its parliamentary representatives. Several Labour MPs have previously expressed opposition to government policies, particularly controversial decisions involving welfare reforms and public spending.
Powell has positioned herself as an independent voice capable of communicating concerns from MPs and party members to the leadership. Her supporters believe this could help improve internal democracy and prevent disagreements from becoming more damaging.
However, critics within Labour have warned that having a deputy leader who openly challenges the Prime Minister could create further divisions. During the election campaign, Phillipson argued that choosing Powell could encourage internal disagreements and make it harder for Labour to present a united political message.
This disagreement illustrates the difficult balance between maintaining party unity and allowing legitimate criticism. Political parties need a common direction, but they also need mechanisms through which members can question decisions and propose alternative approaches.
The result also creates an interesting political situation because Powell’s responsibilities differ from those of a government minister. Although she became Labour’s deputy leader, she did not automatically become Deputy Prime Minister or a member of the government. David Lammy had already been appointed Deputy Prime Minister following Rayner’s resignation.
Nevertheless, Powell was expected to participate in political Cabinet discussions, giving her an opportunity to influence the party’s wider strategy without being bound by the same collective ministerial responsibilities as serving government ministers. <Cite refs={[“turn901494search2″,”turn901494search9”]}/>
This distinction could become important if disagreements emerge over future policies. Powell may be able to express concerns about government decisions more openly than a serving minister.
The Conservative Party has already attempted to use the result to question Starmer’s authority. Conservative chairman Kevin Hollinrake described Powell’s victory as another setback for the Prime Minister, arguing that Starmer had effectively been presented with a deputy leader who did not represent his preferred political direction.
However, it would be premature to interpret the result as an immediate challenge to Starmer’s position. Powell has not announced an intention to replace him, and her public statements have focused primarily on improving Labour’s performance rather than removing its leader.
Another challenge facing Labour is the growing competition from Reform UK under Nigel Farage. Reform has attracted voters who are dissatisfied with immigration policy, taxation and the performance of established political parties.
Powell acknowledged this challenge during her speech, arguing that Labour had allowed Farage and Reform UK to dominate important political debates. She urged her colleagues to communicate their policies more confidently and offer voters a stronger alternative.
For Starmer, this presents a difficult task. He must maintain a clear government strategy while demonstrating that he is willing to listen to concerns from within his own party.
The Prime Minister also needs to address practical issues affecting ordinary households. Improving NHS services, expanding affordable housing, supporting economic growth and managing public finances responsibly will all be important in restoring confidence.
Furthermore, Labour must rebuild its relationship with members and activists who play an essential role in election campaigns. The low turnout in the deputy leadership election suggests that participation among eligible members and affiliated voters was limited, although the reasons for this cannot be established from the turnout figure alone.
In conclusion, Lucy Powell’s victory has highlighted significant differences within the Labour Party over leadership, political strategy and internal democracy. Her election represents a clear mandate from participating members for a deputy leader who promises to listen more closely to MPs and party supporters. Although the result does not automatically threaten Keir Starmer’s leadership, it demonstrates that the Prime Minister cannot ignore concerns within his own party. The coming months will be important in determining how Powell uses her position and whether Labour can maintain unity while allowing genuine debate. Ultimately, the party’s future will depend on its ability to reconnect with voters, deliver its promises and establish a clear political direction.
