Labour has been ousted in the Caerphilly by-election in a blowout to Plaid Cymru.
Lindsay Whittle of the Welsh nationalist party took home 15,961 votes, beating second-placed Reform UK’s 12,113.
Labour slumped to just 3,713 votes – a backslide of a staggering 34.9 per cent compared to the 2021 Senedd election.
Turnout came to 50.43 per cent, with a total of 33,736 ballot papers being included in the count – an increase on 2021’s 44.31 per cent.
In Westminster, the Valleys town has voted Labour since 1918 – every election since the seat existed.
In Cardiff Bay, it had done the same since devolution in 1999.

PICTURED: Plaid’s Lindsay Whittle celebrates winning his Caerphilly seat on Friday morning
But in 2025, the party’s century-long winning streak came to an end under Sir Keir Starmer’s watch.
The death of Labour MS Hefin David triggered the poll in Caerphilly – and victorious candidate Mr Whittle paid tribute to him as he won.
“He will be a hard act to follow. I will never fill his shoes, but I promise you I will walk the same path that he did, and I can pay no finer tribute to an excellent man,” he said.
Mr Whittle added that now is an “exciting time” for Welsh politics as he laid out his challenge to Westminster.
“Wales, we are at the dawn of a new beginning. I look forward to playing my part for a new Wales,” he vowed.
“It’s better than scoring the winning try for Wales against New Zealand in the Rugby World Cup!”
PICTURED RIGHT-TO-LEFT: Labour’s Richard Tunnicliffe, Reform UK’s Llyr Powell and Plaid Cymru’s Lindsay WhittleGETTY/PA
Meanwhile, Plaid leader Rhun ap Iorwerth took aim at “tired” Labour after his party surged to a landmark win.
“Tonight, the people of Caerphilly have spoken loud and clear,” he said.
“They’ve chosen hope over division, and progress over the tired status quo, and backed P
laid Cymru’s positive, pro-Wales vision.
“Lindsay Whittle is a tireless local champion who knows every community in this constituency inside out and will deliver real change for the people of Caerphilly.”
Though speaking to GB News just moments before the count, Labour’s Cardiff Central MP Alex Barros-Curtis insisted his party “still had plenty of time to turn it around”.
Further before Thursday’s blowout loss, one Labour source described the party’s expected defeat in Caerphilly as a “defeat for Starmerism, not for First Minister Eluned Morgan.”
They claimed that Baroness Morgan, who has served as First Minister since August 2024, had been relatively popular on the doorsteps.
Reform UK’s Zia Yusuf offered a conciliatory message in defeat – and lauded how Plaid had downed the “uniparty”.

Reform UK’s Zia Yusuf, pictured with Llyr Powell, lauded how Plaid had downed the ‘uniparty’
X/ZIAYUSUFUK
“Congratulations to Lindsay Whittle,” he said. “Reform winning 36 per cent, up from 1.7 per cent in 2021, is remarkable.
“This is a historic realignment in Welsh and British politics. The Senedd elections next May are now a battle between Reform and Plaid.
“Who would have thought Labour would fall to just 11 per cent and the Tories to just two per cent? The uniparty vote collapsing to 13 per cent from 63 per cent four years ago.”
Mr Yusuf hinted that “hard worker” Mr Powell may yet taste success at next May’s Senedd election as he vowed: “The Reform resolve is stronger than ever.”
Labour Ousted in Caerphilly By-Election as 107-Year Grip on ‘Safe’ Seat Is Smashed
The Labour Party has suffered a major political setback after losing the Caerphilly Senedd by-election, bringing an end to more than a century of political dominance in an area traditionally considered one of its safest strongholds. The result has sent shockwaves through Welsh politics and raised serious questions about Labour’s declining popularity under Prime Minister Keir Starmer. The defeat represents a significant victory for Reform UK and demonstrates how rapidly Britain’s political landscape is changing as voters increasingly turn away from established political parties.
First of all, Caerphilly has historically been associated with the Labour movement. Located in South Wales, the area has a long industrial heritage, particularly connected to coal mining and working-class communities. For generations, Labour enjoyed strong electoral support because of its historical relationship with trade unions, industrial workers and public services.
The party’s influence was built on promises to protect workers’ rights, improve living standards and provide opportunities for ordinary families. Consequently, losing a constituency regarded as a traditional Labour stronghold represents more than an ordinary electoral defeat. It suggests that political loyalties which once appeared deeply established can change when voters become dissatisfied with the direction of government.
The by-election took place on 23 October 2025 following the death of former Labour Member of the Senedd Hefin David. The contest attracted considerable national attention because of the possibility that Reform UK could make a significant breakthrough in an area where Labour had enjoyed decades of success.
The final result was particularly damaging for Labour. Reform UK’s candidate, Llyr Powell, won the seat with 12,113 votes, representing approximately 47.6 per cent of the total. Plaid Cymru finished second with 8,114 votes, while Labour’s candidate, Lindsay Whittle, received 6,292 votes. The result marked a historic victory for Reform UK in Wales. <Cite refs={[“turn58372search0″,”turn58372search2”]}/>
For Reform UK leader Nigel Farage, the victory represented an important demonstration that his party could attract support beyond its traditional political base. Reform has increasingly presented itself as an alternative for voters frustrated with immigration policy, taxation, public spending and the performance of established parties.
The result also highlighted the growing importance of Welsh politics within the wider national debate. Although Wales has its own political institutions and distinctive electoral issues, the performance of parties in Welsh elections can influence perceptions of their popularity across the United Kingdom.
One of the main reasons behind Labour’s defeat appears to be dissatisfaction with the government’s performance. Since taking office in July 2024, Keir Starmer has faced criticism over taxation, public services, immigration and the cost of living. Some voters who supported Labour in the general election have become disappointed with the government’s decisions and the pace of promised improvements.
Economic pressures have been particularly important. Many households continue to struggle with housing costs, energy bills and everyday expenses. Although national economic conditions are influenced by several factors, voters often hold the government responsible when their financial circumstances fail to improve.
Immigration has also become a significant political issue. Reform UK has attracted support by promising tougher border controls and a more restrictive approach to irregular migration. Its campaign has appealed to voters who believe that successive governments have failed to manage the Channel crossings effectively.
However, it would be inaccurate to suggest that immigration alone explains the outcome. Local concerns, candidate recognition, dissatisfaction with public services and the broader political atmosphere may all have influenced voting decisions. Elections are rarely determined by one issue, particularly when voters are choosing between several competing political parties.
Plaid Cymru also benefited from the changing political environment. The party has traditionally enjoyed strong support in parts of Wales and campaigns on issues including Welsh identity, public services and greater political autonomy. Its second-place finish demonstrated that Labour’s difficulties were also creating opportunities for other opposition parties.
For Labour, the defeat raises uncomfortable questions about its relationship with traditional supporters. Working-class communities in South Wales have historically provided the party with substantial electoral support. However, many voters now appear more willing to consider alternative political movements.
The result also creates challenges for Welsh Labour ahead of the 2026 Senedd election. Losing a seat that had been associated with the party for generations could damage confidence among supporters and encourage opposition parties to believe that further gains are possible.
Nevertheless, one by-election does not automatically determine the outcome of a national election. Different campaigns, candidates and local circumstances can produce different results. Labour still has opportunities to rebuild confidence by addressing voters’ concerns and demonstrating progress on important issues.
The party will need to focus on economic stability, improving public services, strengthening local communities and restoring trust among traditional supporters. It must also explain its policies more clearly and demonstrate that political promises can translate into meaningful improvements in people’s everyday lives.
In conclusion, Labour’s defeat in the Caerphilly by-election represents a historic political moment and a serious warning for Keir Starmer’s government. Reform UK’s victory has demonstrated that even traditionally safe Labour territory can become competitive when voters lose confidence in established political parties. Although the result does not guarantee similar outcomes elsewhere, it highlights the growing fragmentation of British politics. Labour must now confront difficult questions about its policies, leadership and relationship with working-class communities. Ultimately, the Caerphilly result sends a clear message that historical loyalty cannot be taken for granted and that political parties must continually earn the trust of the people they represent.
