David Lammy wants Britain back in a ‘more interventionist’ EU, with free movement and no rebate. Read his case closely and it is the best reason to stay out.

David Lammy wants a vote on rejoining the EU (Image: Getty)
There are remarkably few times in which anything David Lammy says, writes or does should be taken seriously. Yet he has just written the most honest case yet for heading back into the European Union – and here’s why that should worry you.
Taking to the pages of a national newspaper, the former Deputy Prime Minister has urged Andy Burnham to put a return to the bloc on the ballot at the next general election. It marks a staggering change in direction from a man once boldly committed to adhering to those infamous ‘red lines’.
But in doing so Mr Lammy has given the game away. He waxes lyrical in his piece, as a great many state-loving socialists are wont to do, about his love of the European Union. He admires that Brussels has championed a “total rethink of market orthodoxies”, he says, crowing that the EU has become “more strategic, more interventionist and more industrial”.
For those on the left it is clear that a heavier-handed state is a selling point – for those with access to a calculator and a working understanding of economics, it is a warning flag.
Britain’s problems have not been caused because we simply didn’t have enough government. The country faces a combination of worklessness, declining productivity, overspending and borrowing, and a stagnant economy bereft of real growth and opportunity. We have far too much government, and the fact our former Deputy Prime Minister cannot see that is damning in itself.
Taxes throttle growth and drive the creators of wealth overseas. Our planning system blocks the construction of the homes and infrastructure we desperately need. The ever-increasing cost of hiring a new worker has driven more young people onto the dole. Yet Mr Lammy’s answer to this is to sign us back onto a club that wants more intervention, not less.
BBC Breakfast: David Lammy says Cyprus is a part of NATO

Underpinning his argument is the claim from the Bank of England that the economy is some 6 to 8 per cent smaller in 2025 than it otherwise would have been. This of course ignores the war in Ukraine, the Covid pandemic, and the lack of cheap housing, energy, and our long-standing productivity challenges.
Political failure to make the most of Brexit and deregulate the economy to spur economic growth must surely not be answered by demanding we rejoin a bloc that would continue the same failed lessons of the past? Not to mention the price of entry would be extortionate – and Mr Lammy admits it.
Free movement “would return”, he says. Now, whilst free movement of workers and the economically productive is not a bad thing for an economy, border controls to safeguard the bounties of a welfare state are surely sensible. Additionally, the rebate Margaret Thatcher fought for, worth around £5billion a year, would go up in smoke.
He insists that “like Ireland” we could stay out of Schengen and “like Sweden” keep the pound. But he neglects to mention that Ireland won its opt-out as an existing member, not as one attempting to rejoin the club. Sweden is legally bound to join the euro and simply drags its feet, and all new members are expected to commit to both. Any exemption would be a favour from Brussels, not an automatic right.
At the end of his staggering tract of dishonesty and foolishness lies the most revealing line of all. Should Marine Le Pen win the French presidency, Mr Lammy fears she could veto our return. His solution? Win her round, because Britain rejoining “would reduce France’s EU budget contributions”.
I would urge you to read that again. Mr Lammy’s masterplan is to charm Paris by promising our money to pay them off. His defence is that membership would give us “a say” in Europe’s decisions. A say, yes, but a veto over most of them, no. We would be one voice among 28, bound by rules we can, and would, be outvoted on.
Mr Lammy dismisses free-trading Britain as “the Jacob Rees-Mogg fantasy”. The truth that he handily seeks to ignore is it was never tried. Successive governments, his own included, kept the EU rulebook and raised taxes on the very businesses that might have used the freedom.
The answer to a botched Brexit is not to hand back the keys, it is to finally use them.
David Lammy’s Plan to Win Over France Reveals the True Price of Rejoining the EU
David Lammy has reignited Britain’s Brexit debate with a proposal that could have major consequences for the country’s political, economic and diplomatic future. His call for Labour to campaign on a promise to rejoin the European Union has raised questions not only about the price of returning to Brussels, but also about the concessions Britain might have to make to secure the support of key European countries, particularly France.
The former Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Secretary has urged Andy Burnham to take Labour into the next general election with a clear commitment to restoring full EU membership. Rather than simply seeking closer trading arrangements, Lammy believes Britain should negotiate a return to the bloc and then allow voters to decide on the final agreement through a referendum.
His intervention comes at a sensitive moment, as the British government prepares to discuss the future relationship with European leaders. However, the suggestion that Britain could return to the EU has immediately raised difficult questions about national sovereignty, immigration, financial contributions and the country’s ability to negotiate special arrangements.
One of the most revealing aspects of Lammy’s argument concerns France. He has suggested that if Marine Le Pen were to become French president, she could potentially oppose Britain’s return to the European Union. His proposed response is to make the economic benefits of British membership attractive to Paris, including the possibility that Britain’s contribution could reduce France’s financial burden within the EU.
This argument exposes an important reality about the process of rejoining: Britain would not simply be able to announce that it wanted to return and expect European governments to welcome it without conditions.
France Could Hold a Crucial Position
France remains one of the most influential countries in the European Union. Its government has a significant voice in discussions about the bloc’s future, its financial arrangements and its political direction.
Any British attempt to regain membership would therefore require careful diplomacy with Paris, Berlin and other European capitals. Britain would need to demonstrate that its return would benefit the wider European project rather than simply provide an opportunity to reverse the political consequences of Brexit.
Lammy’s reference to France’s financial contribution is particularly significant. The argument suggests that Britain’s return could alter the balance of contributions between member states, potentially creating financial advantages for countries such as France.
However, the precise financial arrangements would depend on negotiations. Britain previously benefited from a budget rebate negotiated by Margaret Thatcher in the 1980s. Whether a returning United Kingdom could secure comparable arrangements is far from certain.
The rebate was an exceptional agreement developed under particular historical circumstances. There is no automatic guarantee that Brussels would agree to restore it.
This means that the financial cost of membership could look very different from the arrangements Britain enjoyed before leaving.
The Financial Question Britain Cannot Ignore
One of the central questions surrounding rejoining concerns how much British taxpayers would have to contribute to the EU budget.
Membership would involve financial obligations, and the final amount would depend on the terms negotiated. Britain would also need to consider the wider economic consequences of returning to the European single market and accepting the regulatory framework associated with membership.
Supporters argue that these costs should be considered alongside the potential economic benefits. They believe closer integration could reduce barriers to trade, improve investment opportunities and make it easier for British businesses to operate across European markets.
Lammy has argued that leaving the EU damaged Britain’s economic position by creating additional friction with an important trading partner. He believes that full membership would provide a stronger foundation for economic growth than simply returning to a customs union or negotiating limited agreements.
Critics, however, question whether the promised economic gains would justify the financial commitments and regulatory obligations involved.
They argue that Britain must examine whether the problems facing its economy are primarily connected to Brexit or whether domestic issues such as weak productivity, housing shortages, high taxation and inadequate infrastructure also play major roles.
The debate cannot be settled by comparing a single economic estimate with the cost of membership. It requires a detailed examination of the potential benefits, financial contributions and long-term obligations.
Freedom of Movement Returns to the Debate
Perhaps the most politically sensitive issue is immigration.
Lammy has acknowledged that returning to full EU membership would involve accepting freedom of movement. This would represent a significant change from the immigration arrangements established after Brexit.
Under EU membership, British citizens would regain rights to live, work and study in other member states, while eligible EU citizens would enjoy corresponding rights in Britain.
Supporters see this as an opportunity to restore mobility, address labour shortages and create new opportunities for young people. Businesses could benefit from a wider recruitment pool, while British workers would have greater access to employment across Europe.
However, opponents argue that freedom of movement would reduce the government’s ability to control migration from EU countries independently.
The issue is particularly important because immigration was one of the central arguments during the 2016 referendum campaign.
Any political party proposing full membership would therefore need to explain clearly what freedom of movement would mean in practice, including its implications for public services, employment, housing and border management.
It would not be enough to promise the economic advantages while avoiding the difficult questions surrounding immigration policy.
Could Britain Keep the Pound and Stay Outside Schengen?
Lammy has suggested that Britain could potentially return to the EU while retaining the pound and remaining outside the Schengen passport-free travel area.
He has pointed to Ireland’s position outside Schengen and Sweden’s continued use of its national currency as examples of arrangements that might be relevant to Britain.
However, the circumstances are complicated.
Ireland’s position reflects longstanding arrangements connected to its relationship with the United Kingdom, while Sweden’s position on the euro involves specific legal and political circumstances.
A returning Britain could not simply assume that every previous exception would be available again. The terms of accession would have to be negotiated, and European governments would have their own interests and priorities.
The question is therefore not merely whether Britain wants to keep its existing arrangements. It is whether the EU would agree to them as part of a new membership agreement.
That distinction could become one of the most important aspects of any future negotiations.
Andy Burnham Faces a Difficult Political Choice
Lammy’s proposal also places pressure on Andy Burnham, who has been discussing the possibility of a closer long-term relationship with Europe.
Burnham has indicated that he intends to examine the available options following discussions with European leaders. However, he has maintained that Labour’s existing manifesto commitments remain in place before the next general election.
Those commitments ruled out returning to the single market, customs union or freedom of movement during the current parliamentary period.
Lammy’s intervention goes considerably further.
He wants Labour to make full EU membership part of its next election offer, with negotiations taking place if the party receives a mandate from voters.
This would transform the European question into a major dividing line between political parties.
Conservatives and Reform UK would have an opportunity to challenge the proposal, focusing on sovereignty, immigration, financial contributions and the consequences of reversing Brexit.
Meanwhile, Labour would have to explain why it believes full membership is preferable to a more limited relationship.
The challenge is that the country remains divided over Brexit. Many voters believe leaving the EU created unnecessary economic difficulties, while others continue to regard independence from Brussels as an important democratic achievement.
A new referendum campaign would therefore reopen arguments that have shaped British politics for more than a decade.
What Would Britain Actually Gain?
Supporters of rejoining argue that Britain would regain influence over European legislation rather than simply following rules negotiated by others.
They also believe membership could strengthen cooperation on security, defence, scientific research, trade and international diplomacy.
The single market could offer businesses a more predictable environment, while closer political cooperation might improve Britain’s ability to respond to international challenges.
There are also potential advantages for universities, students and workers who have experienced additional barriers since Brexit.
Nevertheless, membership would involve accepting shared rules and obligations. Britain would regain a voice in European institutions, but it would also become subject to collective decisions made through those institutions.
It would not necessarily have the power to dictate the direction of European policy.
This is the fundamental trade-off at the heart of the debate: greater access and influence through shared institutions in exchange for accepting common rules and financial responsibilities.
The French Question Reveals the Wider Challenge
Lammy’s approach to France highlights how complicated the negotiations could become.
Even if British voters supported returning to the EU, the final agreement would depend on the willingness of European governments to accept Britain’s application and agree on its terms.
France would be an important participant in that process, but it would not be the only country whose approval mattered.
Other member states would consider their own financial interests, political priorities and concerns about the future relationship between Britain and the bloc.
The suggestion that Britain’s return could reduce France’s budget contributions may form part of a political argument, but it does not guarantee French support.
Nor does it establish what the final financial settlement would look like.
Britain would have to approach negotiations with a clear understanding that returning to the EU would mean compromises on several important issues.
A Debate That Will Shape Britain’s Future
The renewed debate over Brexit is no longer simply about whether leaving the European Union was the right decision in 2016. It is increasingly about what kind of relationship Britain wants with Europe over the coming decades.
Lammy believes full membership offers a stronger answer than partial agreements. His proposal would require Labour to make a clear electoral commitment, negotiate the terms and eventually allow the public to vote on the outcome.
But the price of rejoining cannot be measured in money alone.
It would involve difficult decisions about freedom of movement, national sovereignty, financial contributions, regulatory obligations and Britain’s influence within European institutions.
France’s position adds another layer of complexity, demonstrating that Britain’s return would depend on negotiations involving governments with different political and economic interests.
For voters, the most important question will be whether the potential advantages justify those commitments.
The next phase of Britain’s relationship with Europe could therefore become one of the defining political debates of the coming years. Whether the country moves towards full membership, a closer economic partnership or maintains its current position, the decision will have consequences far beyond Westminster.
Lammy has reopened the door to a debate that many politicians once hoped to leave behind. Now Britain must confront the practical details, the financial implications and the political compromises that any return to the European Union would involve.
