Big Brother Watch warns Government plans to push ‘trustworthy’ news up your social media feed are bad in practice and worse in principle.

Andy Burnham has sparked a censorship row (Image: Getty)
Andy Burnham has sparked a censorship row over plans campaigners warn could let the Government pick the news you see on your phone.
Ministers are said to be exploring options to force social media giants to push content from public service broadcasters such as the BBC and ITV higher up people’s feeds.
But critics warn the plans would see certain outlets branded “trustworthy”, handing Whitehall extraordinary sway over what the public reads.
It is not yet clear who would decide which outlets qualify.
Tory MP Nigel Huddleston said the proposals had “alarming Orwellian undertones” and risked creating “a system of government-approved media, which would align Britain with some of the most authoritarian states on the planet”.
Writing for the Daily Express, he warned the plans could even end up regulating newspapers on social media, “adding new regulations to the likes of the Daily Express”.
He revealed he had asked Ofcom’s chief executive in Parliament how she would define “trustworthy” news, and that “she could not provide a clear-cut answer”.
Citing reports of civil servants working as fact-checkers for broadcasters, he asked: “Is this the future, where government mandarins are roaming newsrooms looking over the shoulders of journalists checking that their work is trustworthy and meets government standards?”
The plans, set out in the Government’s Media Green Paper, are justified by ministers as a way to prop up broadcasters through the decline of traditional TV, and to tackle misinformation.
Jack Coulson, of Big Brother Watch, branded the proposals an “algorithmic land-grab” that was “bad in practice and worse in principle”.
Andy Burnham grilled on his use of social media
He said platforms such as Instagram, and possibly YouTube, could be made to rig their algorithms in favour of approved outlets, with everyone else pushed down people’s feeds.
Mr Coulson said: “Being branded ‘trustworthy’ by the Government is rather like being the friend your parents describe as ‘a good influence’: true or not, it’s a quick way to make everyone wonder whose side you’re on.”
But Mr Coulson argued research shows false information online is mainly consumed by a small minority who actively seek it out, and who are the “last people” likely to change their minds because “a bit more Channel 4 is shoved into their feeds”.
He said: “We believe you can be trusted to decide what news you see.”
He warned it was paternalistic for ministers to “‘protect’ us weak-minded members of the public from information and ideas of which ministers disapprove”.
The plans have also alarmed Britain’s newspapers. The News Media Association, which represents publishers including the Daily Express, warned that “the path of least resistance for platforms is to promote public service broadcaster content, transferring visibility and revenue from the commercial press”.
Former Culture Secretary Sir John Whittingdale branded the proposals “a very dangerous extension of Government interference in the freedom of the press and the right to free speech”.
Big Brother Watch insists it is no fan of Big Tech either, arguing that if ministers want to rein in the platforms, they should hand control to users.
Mr Coulson said: “If someone wants a feed full of PSM content, or none at all, that’s their business, not the Government’s.”
A Department for Culture, Media and Sport spokesperson said: “We have no intention of restricting or censoring content. The government’s aim is to ensure that social media users can access high-quality, accurate and trustworthy information from a range of news providers.
“The criteria for a ‘trustworthy’ news provider is being decided in an open and transparent manner with regard to protecting media freedom. This includes engaging with stakeholders as part of our Media Green Paper consultation.”
Andy Burnham Faces Censorship Row Over Plans to Pick the News on Your Phone
Andy Burnham has become the focus of a growing debate over media freedom, political influence and the future of digital news after concerns emerged about proposals that could give public authorities a greater role in determining what information people receive on their phones. The controversy has raised important questions about the relationship between government, technology companies and the public’s right to access independent information.
In an age when millions of people rely on smartphones for their daily news, even small changes to the way information is distributed can have significant consequences. Mobile notifications, personalised news feeds and digital platforms have become essential sources of information for people who want to understand what is happening in their communities and across the country.
However, the idea that political leaders or publicly funded organisations could have a greater influence over what appears on people’s screens has prompted concerns about censorship. Critics want to know who would decide which stories deserve attention, what standards would be applied and whether controversial political opinions could be excluded from certain platforms.
The debate surrounding Burnham comes at a time when trust in traditional media and political institutions is already under pressure. Many people believe that the news they receive is influenced by powerful interests, commercial priorities and political agendas. Any proposal involving greater official involvement in news distribution is therefore likely to attract considerable scrutiny.
The central issue is straightforward: should public authorities have a role in selecting or promoting the information citizens receive through their mobile devices, or should that responsibility remain primarily with independent publishers and technology platforms?
Supporters of more coordinated digital communication may argue that modern technology provides opportunities to improve public access to reliable information. Local authorities, for example, need effective ways to communicate during emergencies, announce changes to public services and inform residents about developments affecting their neighbourhoods.
A well-designed digital service could help people find important local information without having to search through numerous websites. It could provide updates about transport disruptions, healthcare services, severe weather warnings and community events.
Yet providing practical public information is not necessarily the same as selecting political news. The distinction matters because citizens should be able to access a wide range of reporting, including investigations and criticism of the authorities responsible for running public services.
If a digital platform begins determining which news stories receive prominence, questions about editorial independence inevitably arise. Even if its original purpose is to improve communication, its design and operating rules could influence what users see and what they miss.
For critics, the concern is not simply about technology. It is about the concentration of influence over public information.
Smartphones have transformed the relationship between newspapers, broadcasters and their audiences. In the past, readers generally chose which newspapers to purchase and viewers selected television programmes. Today, algorithms and notification systems increasingly determine which stories appear in front of users.
This means that whoever controls the distribution system can potentially influence the visibility of particular subjects. A story that receives prominent placement may attract millions of readers, while another may struggle to reach its intended audience.
Such influence does not automatically amount to censorship. However, transparency becomes essential whenever an organisation has the power to promote, restrict or organise information for large numbers of people.
Burnham’s political position makes the discussion particularly significant. As a prominent Labour figure and Mayor of Greater Manchester, he has regularly been associated with debates about regional democracy, public accountability and the role of local institutions.
Greater Manchester has also developed a substantial digital infrastructure for communicating with residents. Public services increasingly depend on online systems, making the relationship between technology and local government an important issue for the region.
Nevertheless, any proposal involving news distribution must be examined carefully. Residents need to understand whether a service would simply provide official announcements or whether it could also influence access to independent journalism.
There is a major difference between receiving a notification about a road closure and receiving a curated selection of political stories chosen by an organisation connected to public authorities.
The former is a straightforward public information function. The latter raises more complicated questions about editorial control, impartiality and democratic accountability.
One concern is that people could gradually become dependent on a limited number of official digital channels. If those channels become their main source of information, alternative perspectives might become less visible, even without an explicit decision to suppress them.
Another concern involves the definition of reliable information. Governments and public bodies may argue that they want to protect citizens from misinformation, fabricated stories and misleading online content. These are legitimate concerns, particularly when false information can affect public safety.
However, deciding what constitutes misinformation can sometimes involve difficult questions. Political disagreements, investigative reporting and criticism of government decisions should not automatically be treated as unreliable simply because they challenge established positions.
Independent journalism plays an essential role in a democratic society precisely because reporters are expected to question people in positions of power. Investigations into public spending, government decisions and political controversies often begin with information that those in authority would prefer not to receive widespread attention.
Any system that influences news visibility must therefore protect the ability of journalists to investigate public institutions without fear of political interference.
Transparency should be at the centre of any proposed digital news system. Users should know who operates the platform, who selects its content, how recommendations are generated and whether political organisations can influence its editorial decisions.
There should also be clear safeguards preventing public money or institutional authority from being used to promote particular political interests.
If a service is intended to provide public information, its responsibilities should be clearly defined. Official announcements should be distinguishable from independent reporting, and users should retain the ability to access different sources.
The issue also extends beyond Greater Manchester. Digital communication systems are becoming increasingly important throughout Britain, and decisions made by local authorities could influence how other regions approach similar projects.
As technology becomes more deeply integrated into everyday life, the boundaries between public communication, journalism and political messaging may become harder to identify.
This creates a responsibility for elected representatives to explain their proposals in detail. Voters should not have to guess whether a new service is designed to improve access to information or influence the news people encounter.
Burnham’s supporters may argue that modern public services need modern communication systems. They may point out that traditional methods of delivering local information are increasingly inadequate for a population that expects immediate updates through smartphones.
That argument deserves consideration. Effective communication can help residents understand public services and make informed decisions about their daily lives.
However, critics are entitled to demand guarantees that any new system will not undermine editorial independence. The existence of good intentions does not remove the need for strong protections.
The controversy also highlights the wider crisis of trust facing political institutions. Many people already approach official statements with scepticism, particularly when political disputes become intense. A system perceived as giving authorities greater control over information could deepen that mistrust.
For that reason, public confidence should be treated as an essential part of the discussion rather than an afterthought.
Independent oversight, published editorial standards and meaningful opportunities for public scrutiny could help address some of these concerns. Users should also have control over notifications and the ability to choose which information sources they follow.
Ultimately, the question is not whether technology should help people access news. Digital innovation has already transformed journalism, and there are clear benefits to making information easier to find.
The important question is who controls the process.
A democratic society depends on citizens being able to compare different accounts of events, challenge official explanations and form their own opinions. That freedom becomes more difficult to exercise if access to information is shaped by systems that lack transparency.
Andy Burnham now faces questions about how any proposed approach would protect those principles while delivering the benefits of modern digital communication.
The debate is likely to extend beyond one politician or one proposed service. It touches on fundamental issues about the future of journalism, the responsibilities of local government and the influence of technology over public debate.
Britain has a long tradition of independent reporting and political criticism. Preserving that tradition requires more than protecting newspapers and television broadcasters. It also means ensuring that the digital platforms increasingly used to distribute information remain open, transparent and accountable.
People should be able to decide which news sources they trust rather than being left uncertain about who has selected the stories appearing on their screens.
As the controversy develops, the most important answers will concern the practical details: who controls the content, what safeguards exist and whether users retain genuine freedom of choice.
Without clear explanations, even proposals presented as improvements to public communication risk generating suspicion.
The future of digital news should be shaped around access, independence and informed choice. Those principles must remain central whenever politicians and public institutions consider taking a greater role in the way information reaches the public.
