Prime Minister Andy Burnham said he will set out “different options” for the UK’s future relationship with the EU. Speaking to Labour’s conference in Liverpool, he did not reveal whether this would include rejoining the EU. But he said: “Brexit has done more harm than good”. There are reports that the Prime Minister is considering including plans to reverse Brexit , and rejoin the bloc, in Labour’s next election manifesto.
He told the Labour conference: “Brexit hasn’t given us control.” Mr Burnham said that in fact the UK had “lost some of our control” over the economy and immigration. He said: “Later this year there will be a UK-EU summit” where immigration would be on the agenda. But he said better immigration controls, and future trade deals, are “not enough.” Instead, the UK “must decide on a long-term relationship with what is still our largest market”.

Andy Burnham delivers his speech (Image: Getty)
Mr Burnham insisted “Brexit has done more harm than good … so I will take the opportunity around the summit to lay out to you, lay out to the country, what I belive the different options are”.
He said this would “give us clarity about our position and the future of the continent that we live in.”
In other announcements, Labour will fight the next election on a promise to introduce a form of proportional representation, Andy Burnham said as he announced a national commission on electoral reform.
A new National Care Service will be “free at the point of use”, and impose no charges on the basic state pension, Andy Burnham announced.
The Government will end the ban on public ownership of water companies paving the way for the nationalisation of firms that do not “serve the public interest”, Andy Burnham has told the Labour Party conference.
Councils will be given the power to take over poor quality homes if landlords refuse to improve them, Andy Burnham has announced.
Get the latest politics news – straight from our team in Westminster and more
Invalid email
You agree you are 18 or over. We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you’ve consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. You can unsubscribe at any time. More Info.
Mr Burnham confirmed he wants to end the current pensions triple lock, which guarantees increases in line with the highest of inflation, earnings or 2.5%, in order to free up cash to fund his long-held ambition of creating a NHS-style care service in England.
Mr Burnham, who replaced Sir Keir Starmer in No 10 in July, claimed there was a “sense of the powers-that-be pulling against the people, not with them”.
“If there’s one thing I want to put right, it’s that,” he said.
Taking aim at the changes introduced since the Thatcher administration in the 1980s, Mr Burnham said: “Britain has been on the wrong path for a long time.
“Deindustrialisation. Deregulation. Privatisation. Austerity. Brexit.
“And what has it given us? A country run for vested interests, not in the public interest.”
Andy Burnham Issues Two-Word Brexit Bombshell to Labour Conference – ‘More Harm Than Good’
Andy Burnham has reignited Britain’s bitter Brexit debate with a blunt verdict delivered to Labour Party conference: “more harm than good.”
The Prime Minister used his first Labour conference speech as leader of the Government to launch a major reassessment of Britain’s relationship with the European Union, arguing that the country cannot map out its long-term future without deciding what kind of relationship it wants with its biggest trading partner.
Burnham’s intervention marks a significant shift in the political language surrounding Brexit. Rather than simply promising to improve the existing post-Brexit arrangements, he told Labour delegates that the country must consider a much wider range of options.
“I cannot say to you truthfully that where we are is good enough,” Burnham said. “Brexit has done more harm than good.”
The statement immediately became the defining moment of his conference speech.
It also opened the door to a debate that Labour had previously attempted to keep firmly closed.
Burnham refuses to rule out rejoining
Burnham stopped short of announcing that Britain would seek to rejoin the European Union.
Instead, he said he would use an upcoming UK-EU summit to lay out different possibilities for Britain’s future relationship with Europe.
Those options could include maintaining the current arrangement, negotiating a customs union, seeking closer access to the single market or potentially going considerably further.
Asked about the possibility of full EU membership, Burnham subsequently said Britain could potentially “go all the way”, although he stressed that no immediate decision had been taken.
That careful wording is politically important.
The Prime Minister is not currently committing Britain to rejoining the EU. Nor has he announced a second referendum.
Instead, he is attempting to establish a political process through which the different possibilities can be examined.
His argument is that Britain needs to stop treating Brexit as a closed question if it wants to make long-term decisions about the economy, trade and immigration.
“Brexit hasn’t given us control”
Burnham’s criticism focused heavily on one of the central promises made by Brexit campaigners in 2016: taking back control.
He argued that Britain had not achieved the level of control promised by leaving the EU.
Instead, he claimed that the country had lost some control over the economy because of a decade of weak growth and had also lost some control over immigration.
His argument on migration was particularly significant.
Burnham acknowledged public frustration about small-boat crossings across the English Channel but argued that Britain’s departure from European structures had weakened cooperation with neighbouring countries.
He pointed to the importance of working with European partners to improve immigration enforcement and said the forthcoming UK-EU summit would include discussions about migration.
That represents a notable change in emphasis.
Rather than presenting European cooperation as something that necessarily conflicts with border control, Burnham is arguing that closer cooperation could actually help Britain regain control over migration.
For Brexit supporters, that is likely to be one of the most contentious elements of his argument.
A new debate over Britain’s economic future
Trade and economic growth sit at the heart of Burnham’s intervention.
The Prime Minister argued that Britain needs a higher level of growth and prosperity and said the EU remains the UK’s largest market.
His conclusion was that incremental improvements to the existing relationship would not be enough.
“Concrete steps” were necessary, he argued, but Britain also needed to decide what its long-term relationship with Europe should be.
The choice is therefore no longer being presented simply as “Brexit versus rejoining”.
Instead, Burnham is attempting to broaden the debate.
A future government could seek a closer trading relationship without pursuing membership. It could explore a customs union, negotiate deeper single-market access or pursue a bespoke agreement.
Full EU membership would represent the most dramatic option.
Each would carry different economic and political consequences.
A customs union could reduce some trade barriers but would also constrain Britain’s ability to negotiate completely independent tariff arrangements.
Single-market membership could provide businesses with much closer access to European markets while requiring Britain to accept a substantial degree of regulatory alignment.
Full membership would go considerably further and would require Britain to accept the rights and obligations attached to EU membership.
Burnham has not yet chosen between these options.
Macron sends an early warning
The response from Europe demonstrated that even discussing closer relations is not straightforward.
French President Emmanuel Macron welcomed the prospect of Britain eventually returning to the EU but warned that Britain could not simply select the parts of membership it liked while rejecting the rest.
He said there could be no arrangement in which Britain effectively “pick[s] and choose[s]” among the EU’s freedoms.
The message highlights one of the fundamental realities facing Burnham.
If Britain eventually sought a much closer relationship with the EU, negotiations would involve two sides.
The UK could identify what it wants, but European governments would have their own interests and conditions.
That is particularly relevant if the discussion eventually moves from a trade agreement towards single-market participation or full membership.
A dramatic departure from Labour’s 2024 position
Perhaps the most politically significant aspect of Burnham’s announcement is how far it moves beyond the position Labour campaigned on at the previous general election.
The 2024 Labour manifesto promised that Britain would remain outside the EU and ruled out returning to the single market or customs union, while also ruling out restoring freedom of movement.
Burnham’s new approach does not formally overturn those commitments overnight.
But his willingness to consider options previously excluded by Labour represents a substantial change in direction.
It also gives the next Labour manifesto potentially enormous importance.
Burnham has suggested that Britain’s future relationship with Europe could become part of the long-term political programme his party takes into the next election.
That does not necessarily mean a promise to rejoin.
But it does mean the question could be put back on the political agenda.
Reform UK prepares for the fight
The announcement has predictably drawn strong criticism from Reform UK and Brexit supporters.
Reform deputy leader Richard Tice accused Burnham of trying to take Britain back towards Brussels “via the back door”, arguing that the Prime Minister had barely begun his premiership before reopening the Brexit question.
For Reform, the development offers a clear political dividing line.
Nigel Farage has built much of his political career around Britain’s departure from the EU, and the possibility of Labour advocating a substantially closer relationship with Brussels gives Reform an opportunity to portray itself as the defender of Brexit.
That could make Brexit an important issue in future political campaigns even though the referendum itself took place a decade ago.
Burnham, however, appears willing to accept that confrontation.
His conference speech was explicitly framed around breaking with what he sees as the failures of the past.
Brexit was placed alongside deindustrialisation, deregulation, privatisation and austerity as part of what Burnham described as Britain’s wrong path.
The public mood has changed — but remains complicated
The political environment surrounding Brexit is also different from that of 2016.
Polling cited by Reuters showed that 55 per cent of voters in a June YouGov survey supported rejoining the EU, while 34 per cent opposed it. However, Reuters also noted that support can change when voters are asked about specific conditions attached to EU membership, such as contributions to the EU budget or adopting the euro.
That distinction matters.
There may be growing support for closer relations with Europe without necessarily being majority support for every possible form of reintegration.
Burnham therefore faces a delicate political calculation.
He has to convince voters that reconsidering Britain’s relationship with Europe is about practical economic and immigration questions rather than simply attempting to reverse the 2016 referendum.
At the same time, he must avoid giving the impression that his Government has already decided to pursue EU membership.
A decade after the referendum
The timing of Burnham’s announcement is impossible to ignore.
Britain voted to leave the EU in 2016. The country formally left the bloc in 2020, followed by the end of the transition period and the introduction of the post-Brexit trading relationship.
Ten years after the referendum, Burnham is effectively arguing that Britain should assess what has happened and decide whether the existing settlement remains appropriate for the decades ahead.
His language was not that Britain must immediately reverse Brexit.
It was that Britain needs a long-term answer.
That distinction could prove central to the political debate.
Supporters of his approach will argue that a decade is enough time to assess the consequences and that governments should be free to reconsider policies that are not delivering what they promised.
Opponents will argue that the referendum result created a democratic mandate that should not be casually revisited.
The Brexit argument returns
Burnham’s two-word verdict — “more harm than good” — has transformed the tone of Britain’s Brexit debate.
The Prime Minister has not announced an immediate return to the EU, nor has he committed to a second referendum.
But he has done something politically significant: he has declared that the current relationship is not good enough and that Britain needs to consider what comes next.
The forthcoming UK-EU summit will therefore take on greater importance.
Burnham intends to use it to set out different options and begin a national discussion about Britain’s long-term relationship with Europe.
Whether that eventually leads to closer trading arrangements, a customs union, single-market participation, a bespoke agreement or even full EU membership remains unresolved.
But the political argument has unquestionably reopened.
For Labour, Brexit is no longer simply a question of managing the settlement inherited from previous governments.
For Reform and other Brexit supporters, it is an opportunity to defend the decision taken in 2016.
And for Burnham, the gamble is that voters will see his approach not as an attempt to relive the past, but as an attempt to decide Britain’s future.
The Brexit question that once appeared settled has therefore returned to the centre of British politics — and Burnham has made clear that he intends to keep it there
