Labour risked plunging back into a Brexit row today as Sadiq Khan demanded an immediate push to rejoin the EU.
The London Mayor said it was ‘not enough’ for Andy Burnham to suggest that restoring ties with Brussels could be in the next election manifesto.
Instead he urged the PM to ‘start the work now’ of persuading the country about the ‘benefits’ of being inside the bloc.
He argued the UK should go back into the customs union immediately, seek ‘associate’ membership and then propose rejoining entirely without a second referendum in the manifesto.
The intervention, in a Labour conference interview with the i paper, came despite Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds delivering a stark warning against ‘political paralysis’ of re-running the Brexit debate.
Mr Reynolds said that would come with a ‘cost’, insisting he did not even support returning to the EU customs union.
+4
View gallery
London Mayor Lord Khan said it was ‘not enough’ for Andy Burnham to suggest that restoring ties with Brussels could be in the next election manifesto
+4
View gallery
The intervention, in a Labour conference interview with the i paper, came despite Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds delivering a stark warning against ‘political paralysis’ of re-running the Brexit debate
Europe has been rising up the agenda within Labour, with former prime minister Tony Blair suggesting last week that the UK should look to rejoin a ‘significantly reformed’ bloc over the next decade.
Mr Burnham has previously endorsed going back into the EU, although he has cooled on the idea somewhat since becoming PM.
In his interview, Lord Khan said it was not ‘enough’ to float rejoining after the next election.
He added: ‘You can’t, a week before a general election, pull out of a hat this rabbit of a manifesto and say we’re going to rejoin in six weeks’ time.
‘The heavy lifting, the pitch rolling must be done now, explaining to the country the disbenefits of being outside the European Union and the benefits of being part of this family.’
The comments came after Mr Reynolds struck a very different tone speaking to The Sunday Telegraph.
He suggested the UK should keep negotiating to improve ties within the current ‘red lines’ of not rejoining the single market or customs union.
Mr Reynolds said: ‘This approach of genuinely improving things across the board and not returning to political uncertainty, I think, is absolutely the right one because there was a cost of leaving the European Union. That was always going to be the case.
+4
View gallery
Mr Burnham has previously endorsed going back into the EU, although he has cooled on the idea somewhat since becoming PM
‘There was also a cost in the kind of political paralysis and uncertainty that came from that. So that would return if this became one of the dominant features again of British politics.
‘I wouldn’t say all of our economic problems were solved by being in the European Union.
‘You’re not going to get much more benefit than what we’re already going to get from the agreement that we have struck and are negotiating the details of, and then you’re going to lose out on all those opportunities around the rest of the world that we’ve got.
‘And I think if people recognise that the difference that, for instance, the UK-EU reset as it stands would give on the real practical benefits, that’s what we should be focused on.’
BREXIT ERUPTS AGAIN — Sadiq Khan’s Demand Sparks a Fierce New Clash
Britain’s Brexit debate has erupted once again after London Mayor Sadiq Khan urged Prime Minister Andy Burnham to begin preparing immediately for a possible return to the European Union.
Khan’s intervention came only days after Burnham opened the door to a much wider discussion about Britain’s long-term relationship with Europe, including options that could eventually involve rejoining the customs union, the single market or even the EU itself. The remarks have reopened one of Britain’s most divisive political questions and placed pressure on Labour to explain how far it is prepared to go.
Speaking during the Labour Party conference in Liverpool, Khan argued that waiting until the next general election before explaining the case for closer European ties would be too late. He said the government should begin what he described as the “heavy lifting” now, including explaining the disadvantages of remaining outside the EU and the potential benefits of closer integration.
His intervention goes beyond simply supporting a closer UK-EU relationship. Khan has previously called for Labour to commit to rejoining the EU at the next election, while his latest comments focus on preparing the political and public groundwork before that campaign begins.
Khan’s demand for immediate action
Khan’s argument is based on the idea that a future decision to seek closer ties with Europe would require substantial preparation.
He told the i Paper that the government could not simply publish a manifesto shortly before an election promising to rejoin the EU and expect voters to understand the consequences immediately. Instead, he said the government should begin explaining the issue well in advance.
That would mean making the economic, political and practical arguments for closer integration while also addressing the objections raised by those who supported Brexit.
Khan’s position is therefore not merely about announcing a future policy. It is about changing the political conversation before the next election.
He has argued that the circumstances surrounding Britain’s relationship with Europe have changed since the 2016 referendum. In March, he said that economic, social and geopolitical developments had altered the context in which the Brexit decision should now be considered.
His latest intervention puts that argument directly into the hands of Burnham’s government.
Burnham has opened the door
The Prime Minister’s recent comments have created the political opening for Khan’s intervention.
Burnham has said that Britain needs to consider the different options for its long-term relationship with European partners. Those options range from maintaining the current arrangements to closer forms of economic integration.
Reuters reported that Burnham told the BBC he was considering a range of possibilities, including the status quo, a customs union, the single market and even restored EU membership.
That represents a significant broadening of the discussion.
For years, Labour’s official approach was generally framed around making Brexit work rather than reversing it. The current debate is different because the government is now publicly discussing options that were previously treated as politically unrealistic.
However, discussing an option is not the same as adopting it.
There is currently no government commitment to rejoin the EU, and any move towards membership would involve substantial political, legal and diplomatic negotiations.
Why the argument has become so fierce
Brexit remains unusually sensitive because the 2016 referendum produced a narrow but decisive result: Britain voted to leave the EU.
The country subsequently spent years negotiating withdrawal arrangements, leaving the single market and customs union and developing a new trading relationship with Brussels.
Any discussion about reversing or substantially changing that settlement therefore touches questions of sovereignty, immigration, trade, regulation and Britain’s international position.
Supporters of closer European integration point to trade barriers and the economic importance of the EU market. Those opposed to rejoining can argue that Brexit restored Britain’s ability to make independent decisions outside EU institutions.
The debate is consequently about much more than trade.
It involves competing views about how Britain should exercise sovereignty and where its economic and strategic interests lie.
A changing public debate
Recent polling suggests that public opinion on Brexit has changed since 2016, although the precise level of support varies considerably depending on how questions are asked.
A Messina Group poll reported by The Guardian on October 3 found 49 per cent supporting EU re-entry and 28.5 per cent opposing it. The same research found support for several intermediate options, including a customs union and single-market membership.
The poll also found that 52.4 per cent of respondents believed Britain had been wrong to leave the EU, while 29.7 per cent thought leaving had been the right decision.
These figures are a snapshot of opinion rather than a forecast of future election results. Polling on constitutional questions can also be affected by the wording of the question and the precise option presented to respondents.
Nevertheless, the figures help explain why politicians such as Khan believe there is now greater room for discussion than there was immediately after the referendum.
The economic argument
Economic consequences sit at the centre of Khan’s case.
In his earlier calls for Britain to rejoin the EU, the London mayor pointed to research suggesting Brexit had reduced economic output and employment compared with a hypothetical scenario in which the UK had remained inside the bloc.
Khan has also argued that London’s economy has been particularly affected because the capital has extensive links with European trade, finance, tourism and labour markets.
Those claims are contested politically and depend partly on counterfactual economic modelling. It is not possible to observe directly what Britain’s economy would have looked like had the referendum produced a different result.
Nevertheless, economists have produced a range of estimates suggesting Brexit has created additional trade barriers and reduced economic activity relative to continued EU membership.
For the government, the practical question is whether closer alignment can recover some of those benefits without immediately reopening every aspect of EU membership.
Customs union and single market
One of the most significant parts of the emerging discussion concerns the customs union and single market.
Rejoining the customs union could reduce certain barriers to goods trade by aligning the UK more closely with EU customs arrangements. Membership of the single market would go further, restoring much deeper economic integration and involving rules governing goods, services and other areas.
Both options would involve trade-offs.
Closer alignment could reduce friction for British companies trading with European partners. At the same time, it could reduce the UK’s freedom to diverge from EU rules in areas covered by the agreements.
That tension explains why Burnham has not simply announced a return to the pre-Brexit settlement.
Instead, his government appears to be considering a spectrum of possibilities.
Brussels has its own conditions
The debate is not solely controlled by Westminster.
European governments would also have to agree to any major change in the UK’s relationship with the EU.
The Financial Times reported that European leaders are open to closer relations with Britain but would expect negotiations to take place according to EU rules and conditions. The report also highlighted differences among member states, including France’s more cautious approach.
A return to full EU membership would therefore be far more complicated than simply reversing the 2020 withdrawal.
Britain would have to negotiate accession arrangements, while EU member states would need to approve the process.
Questions surrounding the euro, free movement, budget contributions, regulatory alignment and the role of the European Court of Justice would all become relevant.
That is why Khan’s call to begin preparations now focuses on a long-term process rather than an immediate reversal.
The clash inside Labour
Khan’s intervention also exposes potential differences within Labour.
While some senior Labour figures have become increasingly open to closer European ties, others have warned against reopening a political conflict that dominated British politics for years.
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds, for example, has warned about the dangers of political “paralysis” caused by repeatedly revisiting Brexit rather than concentrating on economic priorities.
That creates a difficult balancing act for Burnham.
The Prime Minister can acknowledge the economic arguments for closer European ties while avoiding a commitment that could immediately divide the party and the wider electorate.
Khan, however, is pushing for a more explicit direction.
He wants the government to start making the case now rather than leaving the question until the next election.
Reform UK enters the argument
The renewed Brexit debate is also significant for Reform UK.
Nigel Farage has spent much of his political career campaigning against closer European integration and was one of the most prominent figures associated with the Brexit campaign.
The possibility of Labour openly discussing EU membership therefore gives Reform an opportunity to present itself as the party defending the existing Brexit settlement.
At the same time, the political landscape is different from 2016.
A decade has passed since the referendum, and the economic and geopolitical circumstances have changed. The challenge for both sides is therefore to explain what Britain’s relationship with Europe should look like in the future rather than simply repeating arguments from the referendum campaign.
What happens next?
The immediate question is not whether Britain will rejoin the EU.
It is whether Burnham’s government will turn its newly expanded discussion of European relations into concrete policy.
The UK and EU are already negotiating areas of closer cooperation, including trade barriers, emissions trading and youth mobility. Reuters reported that discussions about the longer-term relationship are continuing, although some major questions remain unresolved.
Khan wants the government to go further.
His demand is that preparations for a possible return should begin now, allowing Labour to spend years explaining the potential consequences before voters are eventually asked to decide.
That would inevitably provoke opposition from Brexit supporters.
It could also create disagreements within Labour over how far the party should go and whether closer European integration should become a central electoral commitment.
For Burnham, the challenge is therefore twofold: deciding how close Britain should move towards the EU while managing a debate that remains politically sensitive.
Khan’s intervention has ensured that the issue will not quietly disappear.
Britain’s Brexit argument is once again moving from questions about how to manage the existing relationship towards the much bigger question of whether the relationship itself should eventually be changed.
The coming years will determine whether this becomes a sustained political project or another chapter in Britain’s long-running argument over Europe.
