
Andy Burnham’s Government wants to pick the news you see (Image: Getty)
The Government says it will “explore legislative options” to have certain news makers branded as “trustworthy”, and then have platforms like Instagram, and possibly YouTube, rig their algorithms to ensure you get big portions of their content. It is unconfirmed who will decide who is “trustworthy”.
The Government gives two justifications for this intrusion into our phones and homes – to help the Public Service Media (PSM) providers, like the BBC and ITV, financially through the decline of traditional TV broadcasting, and to protect the public from mis- and disinformation.
You may well think both of those problems deserve a solution, but this algorithmic land-grab is bad in practice and worse in principle.
It will do traditional PSMs no good to be seen as mouthpieces for the Government’s preferred news and media agenda. Being branded “trustworthy” by the Government is rather like being the friend your parents describe as ‘a good influence’: true or not, it’s a quick way to make everyone wonder whose side you’re on.
And for news outlets not blessed by the Government, the result will be that platforms simply reduce how much their content appears on your feed. The News Media Association, in its own response to the consultation, warns that “the path of least resistance for platforms is to promote public service broadcaster content, transferring visibility and revenue from the commercial press”.
Parliamentarians are concerned. Sir John Whittingdale MP is a member of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee and former Secretary of State for Culture Media and Sport. He, like Big Brother Watch, has concerns about disinformation, especially foreign disinformation. But he is clear that the prominence proposals are “a very dangerous extension of Government interference in the freedom of the press and the right to free speech”.
Rigging the country’s online feeds is no solution to mis- and disinformation. There is no denying that the internet has become a more tawdry place recently. However, the academic research indicates that mis- and disinformation is primarily consumed by a small minority who actively seek it out. These are the last people who will suddenly change their minds if a bit more Channel 4 is shoved into their feeds.
Like a company putting on voluntary HR training, the Government’s approach will reach the people who need it least and the people who need it won’t be touched.
Even if this kind of policy could magically work, we should all take offense at the paternalistic insistence that the Government, by deciding for us, should ‘protect’ us weak-minded members of the public from information and ideas of which ministers disapprove.
We believe you can be trusted to decide what news you see. The consultation even admits that “evidence shows that in times of major news events or local incidents, citizens turn to more traditional forms of news outlets such as the local newspaper, local radio stations or PSM news”.
None of this means we at Big Brother Watch are Big Tech enthusiasts. YouTube and Meta shouldn’t be deciding for us either, and too many of us have outsourced our judgment to algorithms we often neither control nor understand. The green paper lists “user empowerment” as a principle – so why won’t the Government take that seriously? If ministers want to rein in the platforms, they should hand the reins to users, not take them for themselves.
We should demand better from the firms, from the Government, and maybe even ourselves in how we engage with these systems. But fundamentally, if someone wants a feed full of PSM content, or none at all, that’s their business, not the Government’s.
Andy Burnham’s Government Wants to Pick the News You See
The British government’s proposal to influence the news content people see on social media has sparked an important debate about freedom of speech, media independence and the role of the state in a democratic society. The plan, associated with Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s government, involves exploring legislative options that could allow certain news organisations to be recognised as trustworthy sources. Social media platforms such as Instagram and YouTube could then be encouraged or required to prioritise content from these approved providers through their recommendation algorithms. Although the government argues that the proposal would help protect the public from misinformation and support traditional public-service broadcasters, critics fear that it could give politicians excessive influence over the information citizens receive.
One of the government’s main arguments is that the traditional media industry is facing serious financial difficulties. Newspapers, television broadcasters and other established news organisations have experienced significant changes in their business models as audiences increasingly turn to digital platforms for information. The BBC and ITV, for example, operate in an increasingly competitive environment in which social media companies attract large audiences and substantial advertising revenues. The government believes that supporting public-service media providers could help preserve reliable journalism and ensure that important national information remains accessible to the public.
However, the proposal raises an important question: who will decide which news organisations are trustworthy? If the government is responsible for identifying approved news providers, there could be concerns about political independence. A government might favour organisations whose reporting is sympathetic to its policies while treating critical or alternative publications less favourably. Even if the original intention is to improve the quality of information, the process of deciding which sources deserve greater visibility could become controversial.
Freedom of the press is one of the foundations of a democratic society. Journalists must be able to investigate government decisions, expose wrongdoing and challenge those in positions of authority without fearing political interference. A free media environment allows citizens to access different perspectives and make informed decisions about public affairs. If the government gains too much influence over the distribution of news, there is a risk that independent journalism could become less visible.
Another concern involves the role of social media algorithms. Millions of people use platforms such as Instagram, YouTube and Facebook to obtain information about politics, economics and international events. These platforms already influence what users see through recommendation systems designed to predict their interests. If legislation requires platforms to give preferential treatment to government-approved news organisations, the balance of information available to users could change significantly.
Supporters of the proposal may argue that prioritising established news providers would help reduce the spread of false information. Misinformation can create confusion, damage public trust and sometimes threaten public safety. During elections, public health emergencies and international conflicts, inaccurate information can spread rapidly through social media. Reliable journalism is therefore essential to helping citizens understand complicated events and distinguish verified facts from misleading claims.
Nevertheless, identifying trustworthy information is not always straightforward. Even established media organisations can make mistakes, publish incomplete reports or express particular editorial perspectives. Similarly, independent journalists and smaller news organisations may produce valuable investigative reporting despite lacking the financial resources and institutional recognition of major broadcasters. A system that concentrates visibility among a limited number of approved organisations could unintentionally disadvantage smaller publishers and reduce media diversity.
The proposal also raises questions about the independence of public-service broadcasters. Organisations such as the BBC and ITV have important responsibilities to provide news, educational content and information to audiences across the country. Supporting these institutions may be justified by their public-service role. However, financial assistance should not create a situation in which broadcasters become dependent on government approval or political favour. Their credibility depends on maintaining editorial independence and reporting objectively, including when their findings are uncomfortable for the government.
Furthermore, the government must consider the potential consequences for freedom of expression online. Social media platforms provide opportunities for individuals, community groups and independent journalists to share information directly with the public. Although this environment can create challenges involving misinformation, it also allows different voices to participate in public debate. Excessive regulation could make smaller organisations less competitive and discourage people from expressing opinions that challenge established political or media narratives.
A more balanced approach would focus on transparency, media literacy and independent regulation rather than allowing politicians to determine which news organisations deserve greater visibility. Social media companies should explain how their recommendation algorithms operate and provide clear information about the standards used to assess news sources. Independent regulatory bodies could establish objective criteria for identifying reliable journalism, with appropriate safeguards against political interference. Citizens should also retain the ability to choose their preferred sources of information.
Education is equally important in addressing misinformation. Rather than relying entirely on government-approved news providers, schools and universities should teach students how to evaluate sources, check evidence and recognise misleading headlines. People need to understand the difference between factual reporting, political commentary, advertising and unverified information. Developing these skills would help individuals make independent judgments instead of relying exclusively on recommendations generated by social media algorithms.
In addition, transparency should apply to all media organisations, regardless of their political position or institutional status. News providers should be encouraged to correct mistakes, identify conflicts of interest and distinguish verified information from opinion. These principles would help improve public confidence in journalism without requiring the government to control the flow of information.
Ultimately, the debate is not simply about whether traditional broadcasters deserve greater support or whether misinformation should be controlled. It is about finding the right balance between protecting the public and preserving democratic freedoms. Governments have a legitimate responsibility to address harmful misinformation, but they must also recognise that criticism and disagreement are essential elements of democracy. Any policy affecting the distribution of news should therefore be carefully scrutinised and subject to independent oversight.
In conclusion, Andy Burnham’s government’s proposal to influence the news people see through social media algorithms has raised serious questions about media independence, freedom of expression and political accountability. While supporting reliable journalism and combating misinformation are legitimate objectives, allowing the government to determine which news providers are considered trustworthy could create risks if adequate safeguards are not established. A democratic society requires a diverse and independent media environment in which citizens can access different perspectives and challenge those in power. The government should therefore prioritise transparency, independent regulation and media education rather than allowing political authorities to exercise excessive influence over what people read, watch and believe. The freedom to access information and form independent opinions must remain a fundamental principle of British democracy.
