
Labour MP Jonathan Hinder (Image: BBC)
A Labour MP has warned that Andy Burnham‘s push to change the Brexit deal risks alienating the party’s traditional working-class voters. Jonathan Hinder said many people in Labour’s heartlands have felt ignored and dismissed as “thick northern racists” by the party in recent years.
He added that to “tear our country apart again” over the EU row would be a “big mistake”. The Red Wall MP told BBC Newsnight: “I think there is something here about what Labour is supposed to be and who we’re supposed to be for.
“You know, put aside the voter demographics right now, do we want to be for people in Putney or people in Pendle?
“In industrial Britain, where working-class people traditionally would have voted Labour, and now they feel like they’re not really listening to us anymore.
“And actually, the Brexit referendum accelerated that realignment, where you have working-class people turning away from Labour in their millions, not just because of Brexit, but over decades, because they feel like you’re not listening.
“So for us to turn back now and say, “You’re wrong, you’re a thick northern racist,” or whatever…”
Pressed that the PM had not used those words, Mr Hinder added: “But that’s the kind of thing that a lot of my constituents and people like them had and have had for the last decade.
“I’m not talking about what the Prime Minister said. Obviously, he’s not saying that.
“But to tear our country apart again and push ourselves away from our traditional working-class base, admittedly doesn’t support us as much anymore, I think would be a big mistake.”
Reform deputy leader Richard Tice said: “For once this Labour MP is right. Burnham’s attempts to rejoin the EU are the slap in the face for working-class communities like mine that voted to leave the EU. The Labour Party is once again sneering at working people it disagrees with.
“This a recipe for cratering what remains of the Labour vote in the Midlands and the North. Reform will proudly champion the millions of voters Labour has betrayed.”
Mr Hinder’s comments also prompted Labour MP for Putney Fleur Anderson to hit back on X, saying: “I hope you can visit Putney with me very soon. I have a few people I’d like you to meet.”
It comes as the PM will sign a series of deals with the EU at a summit on Friday as part of his Brexit reset on food, emissions trading and youth mobility.
He is also exploring options for the long-term future relationship with Brussels and has not ruled out rejoining after the next general election.
Labour MP Issues Warning Over Andy Burnham’s Bid to Reverse Brexit
Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s efforts to bring Britain closer to the European Union have triggered growing divisions within the Labour Party, with one Labour MP warning that reopening the Brexit debate could seriously damage the party’s relationship with traditional working-class voters. The controversy highlights the continuing political sensitivity of Britain’s decision to leave the EU and raises questions about whether the government should reconsider the country’s long-term relationship with Brussels.
The warning came from Jonathan Hinder, Labour MP for Pendle and Clitheroe, who expressed concern about Burnham’s increasingly ambitious European strategy. Speaking on BBC Newsnight, Hinder argued that many traditional Labour supporters in northern England and other former industrial communities already feel ignored by politicians in Westminster. He warned that reopening the Brexit debate could reinforce the perception that the political establishment does not respect the democratic choices made by ordinary voters.
Hinder believes that Brexit was more than a political disagreement about trade and immigration. For many working-class communities, the 2016 referendum represented an opportunity to express frustration with economic inequality, declining industrial employment and a feeling of being disconnected from national decision-making. Although voters supported Brexit for different reasons, the result demonstrated that a substantial proportion of the population wanted a fundamental change in Britain’s relationship with Europe.
The Labour MP warned that attempting to reverse this decision without carefully considering public opinion could create further divisions. He argued that politicians should avoid giving the impression that people who voted Leave were mistaken or politically uninformed. Such an approach, he suggested, could alienate voters who already believe that Westminster does not listen to their concerns.
His intervention is particularly significant because Labour has historically depended on support from industrial communities across northern England and the Midlands. Many of these constituencies voted strongly in favour of leaving the European Union in 2016. If the government moves towards rejoining the EU or restoring freedom of movement, it could face difficult questions about how to reconcile its European ambitions with the preferences of these voters.
Burnham, however, has defended the need for a more constructive relationship with Europe. He argues that Britain’s current arrangements have failed to deliver the economic benefits promised by Brexit supporters. In his view, closer cooperation with European countries could improve trade, encourage investment, strengthen security and create additional opportunities for young people.
In recent speeches, the Prime Minister has suggested that Britain should examine different options for its long-term relationship with the EU, potentially including rejoining the bloc. However, he has also maintained that the immediate priority is to negotiate practical improvements to the existing Brexit arrangements. He has repeatedly stated that the public will have a say in any future major changes.
Another important aspect of the disagreement concerns immigration. Freedom of movement was one of the most controversial features of Britain’s former EU membership. Supporters argue that allowing European citizens to live and work in Britain helped businesses recruit workers and supported economic activity. Critics, however, believe that unrestricted movement placed additional pressure on housing, public services and local infrastructure.
Hinder has argued that returning to freedom of movement would be politically sensitive, particularly in communities where immigration has been a major concern. He also warned that rejoining the EU would involve more than simply restoring easier trade arrangements. It could require substantial financial contributions and acceptance of a wider range of European rules.
The debate has also attracted attention from other Labour politicians. Some senior ministers support Burnham’s willingness to reconsider Britain’s relationship with Europe, arguing that the economic consequences of Brexit deserve an honest assessment. Others are more cautious, believing that the government should concentrate on improving the existing agreement rather than reopening fundamental disagreements about EU membership.
Former foreign secretary David Lammy has also encouraged Burnham to make rejoining the European Union an explicit objective in Labour’s next general election campaign. He argued that voters should eventually be presented with clearly defined alternatives and given the opportunity to decide between them. This position has further intensified the discussion about whether Labour should move beyond its existing manifesto commitments.
Nevertheless, the economic arguments surrounding Brexit remain complicated. Leaving the European Union changed Britain’s trading arrangements, regulatory relationships and access to the European labour market. Supporters of closer relations argue that reducing trade barriers could improve productivity and help British companies compete internationally. Opponents question whether these potential benefits would justify the financial and regulatory obligations associated with renewed membership.
For businesses, stability and predictability are particularly important. Companies involved in manufacturing, agriculture, financial services and international trade need clear rules when making investment decisions. Constant changes in government policy could create uncertainty and discourage long-term investment. Therefore, whichever direction the government chooses, it must explain its objectives clearly and provide businesses with sufficient time to adapt.
In my opinion, the disagreement between Burnham and Hinder demonstrates that Brexit remains an unresolved political and social issue. The government should be willing to examine the economic consequences of leaving the European Union, but it must also recognise the concerns of communities that supported Brexit. A successful national strategy cannot simply dismiss the views of one group of voters in favour of another. Instead, politicians should encourage an informed debate based on economic evidence, democratic accountability and the practical consequences of different policy choices.
In conclusion, Jonathan Hinder’s warning highlights the political difficulties facing Andy Burnham as he seeks closer relations with the European Union. While Burnham believes that a stronger partnership with Brussels could benefit Britain’s economy and international position, Hinder fears that reopening the Brexit debate could alienate traditional Labour supporters, particularly in northern and industrial communities. The disagreement reflects wider divisions within British politics over immigration, sovereignty, trade and democratic representation. Ultimately, any decision about Britain’s future relationship with Europe must be based on transparent negotiations, careful economic analysis and respect for the views of the British public. Rebuilding relations with Europe may offer opportunities, but maintaining public trust will be equally important.
