
Channel migrants (Image: Getty)
Shabana Mahmood’s new plan to immediately deport more failed asylum seekers will fall short because Britain is still “chained” to the ECHR, critics have warned. The Home Office will tomorrow (Tuesday) confirm plans to scrap a five-day notice period for removals, paving the way, they say, for more immediate removals. Officials are concerned the current window allows failed asylum seekers to lodge more last-minute legal challenges. But critics warned Britain’s membership of the ECHR will continue to thwart deportations.
Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp said: “Failed claimants should be on the first plane home. As long as Labour keeps Britain in the ECHR [European Court of Human Rights], removals will keep being dragged through the courts, leaving taxpayers to keep paying for the accommodation while they wait. The Government will not be able to immediately deport more failed asylum seekers because Britain is still chained to the ECHR. The Conservatives will take the UK out of the ECHR, so that illegal immigrants can be deported as soon as possible.”
Reform’s Zia Yusuf added: “Britain is being invaded and this has been facilitated by Tory and Labour governments. The only way to reverse this invasion is to leave the ECHR and then embark on the biggest mass deportation programme Britain has ever seen. Reform UK will detain and deport all illegal migrants the Tories and Labour allowed in.”

The migrant crisis has destroyed confidence (Image: Getty)
Immigration enforcement teams are set to be given a six-month period to remove failed asylum seekers. Shabana Mahmood’s allies hope this will also limit the length of time this cohort is in immigration detention.
Currently, Home Office teams have 21 days to deport a failed asylum seeker if the flight is grounded because someone was disruptive or due to bad weather.
This will be increased to six months, before the Home Office will be required to issue another Removals Notice.
Anna Turley, Minister for Border Security and Asylum, said: “This government is ramping up removals of those with no right to be here, with over 80,000 illegal migrants and foreign nationals returned since the general election.
“Now we are ensuring those migrants who have exhausted their right to appeal can be removed promptly, rather than being given an opportunity to frustrate their legitimate removal from this country.
“This Bill will restore order and control to the system, ensuring it is swift and fair.”
The development comes as Labour sensationally dodged claims the Piddington asylum camp plan could cost more than £1billion.
Border Security Minister Ms Turley admitted the Home Office can’t confirm the cost of the controversial project yet. Angela Rayner sparked fury after fast-tracking planning permission for asylum accommodation which will house 1,256 migrants.
And Ms Turley now faces fresh fury over the Government’s handling of MoD Bicester – next to the Oxfordshire village of Piddington which has a population of just over 300 people – including 133 women and 46 children.
The Liberal Democrat MP for Bicester, Callum Miller said: “People across Bicester and the surrounding communities are angry about this decision and they have every right to be.
“They took the consultation seriously. The Government recorded 3,177 objections and one response in favour. They raised serious and locally informed questions that deserved answers before planning approval.
“Instead, Government pressed ahead even though they accepted harm to public services, including policing and transport and wider concerns about public safety and community cohesion.
“The overwhelming impression is that the Government is hellbent on opening another large site and it simply doesn’t care about the real and specific problems with this site.
“I believe it will cost over £1bn to build and operate this centre.”
Ms Turley responded: “The Hon. Gentleman raised the issue of cost… the final per-person costs for MoD Bicester will depend on the outcome of the planning procurement process so I can’t comment at this point.
“But, for comparison, the cost of existing large sites, we already have two, Weathersfield and Crowborough, £135 and £138 per night respectively. This is significantly cheaper than hotels at £199 a night.
“Overall, asylum costs have fallen by over £1bn since this Government came to office.”
Campaigners declared “they have gravely underestimated us” as they consider multiple legal challenges to block the proposals for MoD Bicester.
But Ms Rayner appeared to dismiss the women’s safety fears, insisting they could be mitigated by CCTV and security guards.
Tory Equalities spokeswoman Joy Morrissey told MPs: “The Government made a choice. They chose to put women and girls in villages like Piddington, Ludgershall and Marsh Gibbon, at risk.
“Risks they know from the horrific crimes committed by other illegal migrant men against girls as young as 12.
“They chose to use emergency powers and ignore local opinion.
“Knowing that these men pose a direct risk to community safety.
“Men who broke the law in coming here and should be deported. Ministers have got this decision catastrophically wrong.
“Their choice will have consequences. Consequences they will have to live with.
“From Piddington to Linton-On-Ouse to Barnham this Government is choosing to ignore the very people they are supposed to put first.”
Reform’s Richard Tice said: “Constituents will be appalled the Government might spend up to £1billion of taxpayers’ cash on opening Piddington, and that the Government accepts that it puts women and girls in the locality at risk. Why not make it a proper detention centre and detain the illegals behind the wire?”
Villagers warned Prime Minister Andy Burnham, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood and Communities Secretary Ms Rayner they could face jail, under Labour’s Hillsborough Law, if anyone is raped or murdered in the village.
Villager Christina Gower, 26, said: “Disappointment barely scratches the surface of the anger, frustration and betrayal felt by our community.
“We are a village of approximately 300 adults, including 133 women, and 46 children.
“To this Government, we appear to be nothing more than collateral damage. A small, rural community whose objections could be brushed aside, whose concerns could be dismissed and whose residents would eventually fall silent.
“They have gravely underestimated us.”
Migrants Could Be Deported Within Hours Under HUGE New Change – But One Problem Remains
The Labour Government is preparing a major change to Britain’s immigration enforcement system that could allow failed asylum seekers to be removed from the country within hours of exhausting their legal appeals. The proposed reforms, announced by Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood, represent a significant shift in how the authorities handle people who have been refused permission to remain in the United Kingdom.
The announcement has reignited the immigration debate, with ministers insisting that the changes will restore control to a system that has struggled with lengthy legal proceedings, expensive accommodation and repeated delays to deportations.
However, despite the Government’s determination to accelerate removals, one major obstacle remains. Critics argue that Britain’s membership of the European Convention on Human Rights could continue to create legal complications, potentially preventing the new arrangements from delivering the immediate results promised by ministers.
For Labour, the proposals represent an attempt to demonstrate that the Government is serious about tackling illegal migration and restoring public confidence in border enforcement.
Under the existing system, people whose asylum claims and appeals have been rejected are generally given five working days’ notice before removal. During that period, they can receive information about the proposed removal and access legal advice or pursue relevant legal challenges.
The Government believes that this arrangement can create opportunities for last-minute applications designed to delay deportation.
Under the proposed changes, that additional notice period would be removed once an individual has exhausted their appeal rights. Immigration enforcement officers would then be able to arrange detention and removal without issuing another five-day notice.
In practical terms, this could mean that some failed asylum seekers are removed within hours of their final appeal being unsuccessful, depending on the circumstances and the availability of flights and other arrangements.
The reforms would also give the Home Office a six-month period in which to complete a removal without repeatedly restarting the notification process.
Ministers argue that this will make enforcement considerably more efficient and prevent people from using repeated last-minute applications to frustrate legitimate removal decisions.
The Government has presented the proposals as part of a wider effort to restore order and control to Britain’s immigration system.
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has made immigration enforcement a central part of her political agenda. She believes that people who have exhausted their legal rights to remain should not be able to delay removal indefinitely through repeated applications without sufficient justification.
The Government also argues that a more efficient system would reduce the amount of time people spend in taxpayer-funded accommodation.
The financial consequences of delays have become a major political issue. Hotel accommodation for asylum seekers has attracted widespread criticism because of the costs involved, particularly while local communities are struggling with pressure on public services and housing.
According to the Home Office, more than 80,000 migrants and foreign nationals have been returned or removed from Britain since Labour entered government in July 2024.
Ministers believe the latest changes could help increase that number by making the final stages of the removal process quicker and more predictable.
However, opposition politicians have questioned whether the proposals go far enough.
The Conservatives have argued that Britain cannot achieve effective immigration enforcement while remaining bound by the European Convention on Human Rights.
Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp has claimed that legal challenges under the convention will continue to delay removals, even if the Government removes the five-day notification period.
He has argued that failed asylum seekers should be returned as quickly as possible and that the Conservatives would take Britain out of the ECHR.
Reform UK has also demanded much tougher measures, with representatives arguing that the Government needs a more comprehensive approach to illegal migration.
The party has repeatedly called for Britain’s withdrawal from the ECHR and has presented mass deportations as a central part of its proposed immigration strategy.
However, there is an important distinction that has become confused in some political discussions: the European Convention on Human Rights is not the same as the European Union.
Britain left the EU in January 2020 and completed its transition period at the end of that year. The ECHR is a separate international human rights treaty associated with the Council of Europe.
The United Kingdom remains a member of the convention regardless of its Brexit status.
This distinction matters because leaving the European Union did not automatically remove Britain’s obligations under the ECHR. Consequently, arguments about the convention cannot simply be treated as another chapter of the Brexit debate.
The Government’s proposed changes will still need to operate within the country’s legal framework.
This is where the biggest uncertainty remains.
Removing the five-day notice period does not automatically eliminate every possible legal challenge. Individuals may still have relevant human rights claims, judicial review options or other legal grounds that could affect whether a particular removal can lawfully proceed.
For example, authorities must consider credible claims that someone could face persecution, torture or other serious harm if returned to their country of origin.
These safeguards exist because immigration enforcement must comply with domestic and international legal obligations.
The Government argues that its reforms will prevent people from deliberately withholding information until the last possible moment. Under the wider proposals, asylum applicants would be expected to present the relevant grounds for their claims earlier in the process.
Late applications without a satisfactory explanation could face additional scrutiny.
Ministers also want to introduce a new Independent Immigration Appeals Authority to create a more streamlined appeals system.
The intention is to reduce delays and ensure that cases are considered more quickly, allowing removals to proceed when appeals have been unsuccessful.
This is important because the existing appeals system has faced considerable pressure.
Parliamentary documents have highlighted a substantial increase in the immigration appeals backlog, which reached approximately 152,000 cases in March 2026. Average waiting times have also created difficulties for authorities attempting to enforce removal decisions.
The Government believes that a more efficient appeals structure, combined with changes to notification requirements, could address some of these problems.
Nevertheless, refugee organisations have expressed serious concerns.
Campaigners argue that removing the additional notice period could make it more difficult for vulnerable individuals to obtain legal advice and identify legitimate reasons why they should not be deported.
Some asylum seekers may have experienced trauma, exploitation or serious threats in their home countries. They may also struggle to access legal assistance or understand complicated immigration procedures.
Charities warn that a system designed to prevent abusive applications must not accidentally prevent genuine claims from being considered properly.
They also argue that speed should not become more important than accuracy when decisions could have life-changing consequences.
The Government rejects the suggestion that its approach will remove necessary protections. Ministers maintain that individuals will still have opportunities to present their cases through the revised appeals arrangements and that the changes are intended to prevent procedural abuse.
The disagreement illustrates the difficult balance between effective immigration enforcement and the protection of individual rights.
For Prime Minister Andy Burnham, the issue presents another significant political test.
Labour entered government promising to replace what it described as an ineffective approach to immigration with stronger enforcement and better management of the asylum system.
However, public frustration over small boat crossings and the cost of asylum accommodation has continued to place pressure on ministers.
The Government knows that voters want to see visible progress. Announcing tougher legislation is one thing, but demonstrating that it produces faster decisions and more successful removals is another.
If the reforms fail to deliver the expected improvements, opposition parties will argue that Labour has not addressed the underlying problems.
Nigel Farage and Reform UK are particularly likely to use any continued delays as evidence that the existing political establishment is unwilling or unable to take sufficiently decisive action.
The Conservatives will also face an opportunity to challenge Labour over its approach to the ECHR and the wider legal framework governing deportations.
Meanwhile, Labour must reassure voters that it can enforce immigration rules without abandoning the legal protections that remain part of Britain’s international obligations.
There is also a practical problem that political speeches cannot solve.
Even after a failed asylum seeker has exhausted their appeals, removal may depend on obtaining travel documents, arranging flights and securing cooperation from the destination country.
Some governments are reluctant to accept their nationals back, while others require additional verification before issuing the necessary documents.
These practical difficulties mean that removing the five-day notice period will not guarantee that every failed claimant can be deported immediately.
The Home Office will still need effective agreements with foreign governments and sufficient operational resources to carry out removals.
The six-month window could provide greater flexibility, but it will not eliminate every obstacle.
Another important question concerns the treatment of people whose removal cannot take place because of circumstances outside the Government’s control.
Weather disruptions, unavailable flights, medical emergencies and legal interventions can all affect deportation arrangements.
The revised system is intended to reduce repeated administrative delays, but the authorities will still need to respond appropriately when removals cannot be completed as planned.
Ultimately, the Government is attempting to send a clear message: exhausting the legal right to appeal should mean that a person with no lawful basis to remain in Britain can be removed without unnecessary additional delays.
For supporters of tougher immigration enforcement, this represents a necessary change after years of frustration with a system they believe has been too slow and expensive.
For critics, the concern is whether the reforms will weaken access to justice and place vulnerable individuals at risk.
The truth is that the success of the proposals will depend on how they work in practice. Faster administrative procedures could help the authorities, but they cannot replace effective border enforcement, international cooperation and a properly functioning appeals system.
Britain’s immigration debate is therefore far from settled.
Shabana Mahmood may have introduced a significant change to the removal process, but the question of human rights obligations remains central to the argument.
The Government now needs to demonstrate that its reforms can deliver faster deportations while respecting the law.
For Burnham and Labour, the political stakes are considerable. Voters will expect more than announcements and promises. They will want to see whether the new system actually reduces delays, controls accommodation costs and restores confidence in immigration enforcement.
The possibility of deportations within hours may sound like a dramatic transformation, but the real test will be whether the Government can overcome the legal, diplomatic and practical obstacles that have complicated removals for years.
