
Ed Miliband and Andy Burnham aren’t quite in tune over Brexit (Image: Getty)
Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband is a strange combination of wild-eyed idealist and ruthless political operator. He wants a better world and doesn’t care how much damage he inflicts along the way, as David Miliband learned to his cost when he got in the way of his younger brother’s drive for power. The whole Labour Party suffered when Ed subsequently led it to defeat in the 2015 general election. Bacon sandwiches have learned to tread warily around Ed, but former PM Keir Starmer spotted the threat too late. Miliband’s net zero charge was a key reason for his unpopularity. Starmer indulged him, and Miliband helped replace him with Burnham.
Britain continues to pay a high price for his stint as energy secretary, when he went on a spending spree in a mad attempt to make the UK carbon neutral by 2030. We’re on the hook for tens of billions and facing potential blackouts, although new Chancellor John Healey is doing his best to clean up the mess. At first, I thought Burnham had woken up to the danger. Once PM, Burnham resisted pressure to make Miliband chancellor. He thought he’d safely parked him in the Foreign Office, only to discover too late that Miliband would use it to get us into a world of trouble, especially over Brexit.
Burnham has been playing a double game ever since promising voters in Makerfield at the June by-election that he wouldn’t rerun the divisive Brexit debate. Instead, he hasn’t stopped talking about it, nudging us ever closer to Brussels and potentially landing us with a massive bill. Today, Miliband unwittingly exposed the PM’s strategy.
Mindful of his Makerfield pledge, Burnham pretends he isn’t pushing Britain back into the EU. He says he won’t move ahead of public opinion, while repeatedly telling the public what it thinks. He keeps calling for an honest discussion, while being dishonest about how he wants it to end. And he says he won’t push to rejoin this Parliament, while admitting it’s his lifetime ambition. Basically, he’s gaslighting us.
This morning on BBC Breakfast, Miliband sounded supportive, saying Burnham was right to lay out the options facing Britain. He said the Brexit deal had failed and the situation had changed. Crucially, he made clear that this week’s agreement, pushed by Burnham, wasn’t the end of the reset. It was only the “first step”.
So much for Burnham’s claim that he’s “drawing a line” under Brexit divisions. That line will be crossed again and again as we are shunted ever closer to the EU. Miliband repeated Burnham’s line about “rerunning old arguments”, but of course they are. Repeatedly. And we all know why.
Burnham sends one message to the Left: we’re heading back to the EU. He sends another to voters: don’t worry, we’re only tidying things up. By admitting that this week’s deal is just one step, and there are plenty more to come, Miliband has showed everyone the ultimate direction of travel.
We know what they both want. And we know they don’t want to risk another referendum to get it. Miliband just let the cat out of the bag. They’ll shove us there “step by step”. Lay out the options, then do what they want to do anyway. People need to wake up.
Ed Miliband Just Let the Cat Out of the Bag Over Brexit – and Exposed Andy Burnham’s Lies
Ed Miliband has made a revealing intervention in Britain’s increasingly heated Brexit debate, raising fresh questions about the Labour Government’s ambitions for a closer relationship with the European Union. His comments have placed renewed attention on Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s plans to reshape Britain’s relationship with Brussels and have exposed the difficult political balancing act at the heart of Labour’s European strategy.
The controversy follows Miliband’s admission that the current Brexit arrangements have failed to deliver the economic improvements many voters expected. Speaking about the Government’s approach, the Foreign Secretary argued that the existing deal was not working satisfactorily and that Britain needed to confront the consequences of its departure from the European Union.
His remarks were particularly significant because he also refused to give a personal opinion on whether Britain should eventually rejoin the EU. Asked directly about the possibility, Miliband said he would not speculate, explaining that he was a member of the Cabinet and would not offer a separate personal position on such an important question.
That response has created another uncomfortable moment for Labour, especially as Burnham prepares to promote a major reset of relations with Brussels.
For critics, the refusal to rule out closer integration raises an important question: what exactly does the Government want Britain’s future relationship with Europe to look like?
Labour has repeatedly insisted that it does not intend to reverse Brexit during the current parliamentary term. Its manifesto commitments rule out returning to the single market, the customs union and freedom of movement. However, Burnham’s willingness to discuss Britain’s longer-term options has encouraged speculation about how far his ambitions could eventually extend.
The distinction between improving the existing relationship and fundamentally changing Britain’s position is becoming increasingly important.
Miliband’s intervention came as the Government prepared to defend its European strategy ahead of a major UK-EU summit. Ministers have argued that closer cooperation could remove unnecessary trade barriers, improve economic opportunities and make everyday life easier for businesses and consumers.
However, the political language surrounding the debate has become increasingly dramatic.
Burnham has openly criticised the way Brexit was implemented, arguing that Britain received a harder departure than many voters had anticipated. He has described the economic consequences as damaging and suggested that the country must reconsider whether the current arrangements are serving its national interests.
His position is based on the argument that the referendum result should not prevent Britain from improving its relationship with European neighbours.
Nevertheless, opponents believe that the Government risks using the language of practical cooperation to introduce changes that could gradually weaken the independence Brexit was supposed to deliver.
They argue that voters were promised control over national laws, borders and economic policy, and that any substantial movement towards European regulatory alignment should be explained honestly.
This is where Miliband’s comments become politically important.
By acknowledging that the existing Brexit settlement is not delivering the economic results Labour wants, he has reinforced the Government’s argument for changing the relationship. At the same time, his refusal to discuss whether he personally supports rejoining the EU has left an important question unanswered.
Does Labour see closer cooperation as the final destination, or merely the first step towards a much more significant change?
For Brexit supporters, this uncertainty is a source of frustration.
They believe politicians should be transparent about the potential consequences of their proposals. If the Government intends to negotiate agreements that require Britain to follow European standards, voters should understand precisely what those obligations would involve.
The argument is not necessarily against cooperation with European countries. Britain has important economic, diplomatic and security relationships with its neighbours, and maintaining those connections is widely recognised as valuable.
The disagreement concerns the conditions attached to that cooperation.
One of the biggest areas of discussion is trade. Since Brexit, British businesses have faced additional administrative requirements when exporting goods to the European Union. Food and agricultural producers have experienced particular difficulties because their products can be subject to detailed certification and border requirements.
Miliband has highlighted the economic difficulties associated with the current arrangements, including claims about businesses abandoning exports and reductions in food and agricultural trade.
Supporters of the Government’s approach argue that reducing these barriers could provide meaningful benefits without requiring Britain to reverse its departure from the EU.
Potential agreements covering food standards, agricultural trade and energy cooperation could help reduce administrative burdens and improve commercial relationships.
For British manufacturers, farmers and exporters, these changes could offer opportunities to reach European customers more easily.
However, Brexit supporters question whether regulatory alignment could eventually create new dependencies.
They argue that if Britain agrees to follow European rules in particular sectors, its ability to introduce different domestic standards could become more limited. The country might gain easier access to certain markets while accepting obligations over which it has limited influence.
This is an important distinction that the Government will need to address.
The controversy also creates difficulties for Burnham within his own party. Labour contains politicians with very different attitudes towards Brexit, ranging from enthusiastic supporters of closer European integration to MPs representing constituencies where leaving the EU remains an important democratic priority.
Some Labour MPs believe the Government should go further and reconsider its opposition to the customs union and single market. Others are concerned that reopening the Brexit debate could alienate voters who supported Leave.
Burnham must therefore balance economic arguments against the political consequences of changing Britain’s European relationship.
His leadership approach will be judged not only by the agreements he secures but also by whether he can explain them clearly to voters.
The Prime Minister has argued that any future arrangement must satisfy three important tests: it must respect Labour’s manifesto commitments, improve on the existing Brexit settlement and produce tangible benefits for ordinary people.
These conditions provide a framework for the Government’s negotiations, but they do not eliminate the underlying disagreement about Britain’s long-term direction.
The opposition has already identified an opportunity to challenge Labour on this issue.
Nigel Farage and Reform UK have consistently argued that the political establishment has failed to respect the spirit of the Brexit referendum. They are likely to scrutinise any agreement that involves closer regulatory alignment or greater European influence over British policy.
For Reform, the controversy offers an opportunity to question whether Labour’s promises about respecting Brexit are consistent with its ambitions for a closer relationship with Brussels.
The Conservatives also face pressure to defend their own record. They negotiated and implemented Britain’s departure from the European Union, yet the post-Brexit trading arrangements have continued to attract criticism from businesses and politicians across the political spectrum.
Consequently, the debate cannot be reduced to a simple argument between Labour and its opponents.
There are legitimate questions about whether the original Brexit arrangements were economically effective, whether closer cooperation could improve trade and whether the potential benefits would justify any additional obligations.
The answers depend on the specific agreements being negotiated rather than broad political claims.
Another important issue is democratic accountability.
The 2016 referendum produced a clear result, with 52 per cent voting to leave the European Union and 48 per cent voting to remain. That decision established the political mandate for Brexit, but it did not settle every question about the country’s future relationship with Europe.
Since leaving, Britain has faced changing economic conditions, international competition and new geopolitical challenges.
Governments must be able to respond to those developments. However, major changes to the country’s constitutional and trading arrangements require transparent explanations and meaningful political scrutiny.
Burnham has said that the public should ultimately decide any future fundamental change in Britain’s relationship with the EU. That position will be important as he attempts to reassure voters who fear that closer cooperation could eventually become a route back towards membership.
Miliband’s refusal to discuss his personal preference has also highlighted the distinction between individual political views and collective government policy.
As a Cabinet minister, he is expected to support the Government’s agreed position. That does not necessarily mean he has revealed a hidden plan or that his comments establish support for rejoining the EU.
Nevertheless, the public will reasonably expect senior ministers to explain what they believe the Government is trying to achieve.
For ordinary households, the debate is ultimately about practical consequences.
Will closer European cooperation help reduce food prices? Could British businesses find it easier to export? Will energy arrangements become more secure? And will the Government be able to deliver economic improvements without creating new complications for domestic industries?
These are the questions that matter far more to many voters than the political arguments taking place in Westminster.
Burnham’s challenge is to provide convincing answers while respecting the commitments Labour made during the general election campaign.
If the Government succeeds in reducing trade barriers and improving economic relationships without reopening the fundamental divisions of Brexit, it will argue that its approach has delivered practical results.
If the negotiations instead produce complicated obligations, additional costs or uncertainty about Britain’s regulatory independence, critics will demand explanations.
Ed Miliband’s comments have therefore added another important dimension to an already difficult political debate. His acknowledgement of the shortcomings of the current Brexit arrangements supports Labour’s case for change, while his refusal to discuss rejoining leaves the longer-term question unresolved.
The accusation that Burnham has misled voters remains a political interpretation rather than an established fact. What is clear, however, is that Labour must reconcile its manifesto commitments with its ambition to develop a substantially closer relationship with Europe.
Britain’s departure from the European Union was supposed to settle one of the country’s biggest political questions. A decade later, disagreements about trade, sovereignty and national independence continue to dominate the political landscape.
For Burnham, the real test will be whether he can demonstrate that his European strategy offers something more than political rhetoric.
For Miliband, the challenge will be explaining how the Government can acknowledge the problems associated with Brexit while remaining clear about the limits of its proposed changes.
And for British voters, the central issue remains whether the next chapter in Britain’s relationship with Europe will deliver the economic improvements promised by politicians while preserving the democratic choices made in the referendum.
