Ed Miliband just lit a fire under Labour – now Andy Burnham will go down in flames . HYN

Miliband-Burnham-beating

Ed Miliband knows his own mind, I’m not sure Andy Burnham does (Image: Getty)

Miliband is now Foreign Secretary, where he has been distinguishing himself on the world stage by shaking hands with Iran’s foreign minister, virtue signalling on the slave trade, and pushing the UK ever closer to Brussels. But he’s never been a man to stick to his brief. He views himself as keeper of Labour’s left-wing flame, and will rampage into any area of policy if he sees fit. As former energy secretary, he’s particularly keen to intervene in the debate over whether to exploit our North Sea oil and gas reserves.

We're fiddling while the world burns': Inside Labour's climate splits

This is a massive issue on the left. While most of the country is saying just get on with it, we need the money, Labour is torn in two. Party activists want to set an example to the world by blocking all new drilling. The row has centred on the Jackdaw gasfield and Rosebank oilfield, both of which Miliband effectively blocked. When Burnham became PM, he signalled he was willing to let them go ahead. But he also send mixed messages by appointing Miliband’s left-wing protégé Miatta Fahnbulleh as energy secretary. She’s no friend of the drillers either. But she’s hugger-mugger with Miliband.

Eventually, Jackdaw got the green light. That was the easy one. The gas will flow directly into British homes, boosting energy security, cutting imports and creating jobs and tax revenues. It could even reduce carbon emissions by replacing liquefied natural gas shipped from the US and Qatar. Labour could just about swallow that.

Ed Miliband splits Labour in two – feeble Andy Burnham lets him run riot | Personal Finance | Finance | Express.co.uk

Now Burnham faces a much bigger decision over Rosebank. Its oil will mostly be sold overseas rather than used at home. But it will still generate jobs and tax revenues, boost our balance of payments and support the pound. Oil industry sources estimate its value at £28.7bn, money that could be used to cut bills or fund the green transition.

The cabinet is split. Chancellor John Healey is keen to press ahead. My bet is Burnham would dive in, too. But Miliband is dead against it, having previously branded drilling Rosebank “climate vandalism”. Fahnbulleh is opposed too. Now the pair have been accused of stirring up a backbench revolt against the plan.

Andy Burnham faces major Labour rebellion as PM warned 'honeymoon is over' - AOL

Whipping up Labour backbenchers isn’t exactly difficult. They’ve been in a constant state of rebellion since Keir Starmer became PM. But this is the most serious one Burnham has faced, with 75 MPs signing a private letter warning him that Rosebank won’t reduce energy bills (while ignoring the benefits). Some estimate rebel numbers could hit 200.

Burnham faces a hellish decision. After the summer we’ve had, only a die-hard climate change denialist can claim fossil fuels aren’t doing damage. We need to move on but the world still runs on oil, so we’re not there yet. And given the miserable state of the nation’s finances, £28.7billion is not to be sniffed at.

Ed Miliband 'furious and let down' after being snubbed for Chancellor by Andy Burnham, says New Labour ally Ed Balls | Daily Mail Online

Burnham will mostly be looking at the politics. He’s desperate to unite the left and win voters back from Zack Polanski’s Green Party. That helps explain Miliband’s Hamas-friendly Gaza policy. If Rosebank gets the go-ahead, eco-minded leftists will throw Miliband’s “climate vandalism” accusation straight back in Burnham’s face.

Our people-pleasing PM likes everybody to be happy, but sometimes it just isn’t possible. This is one of those times.

Ed Miliband humiliated as Andy Burnham makes major Labour U-turn | Politics | News | Express.co.uk

You’ve got to give it to Miliband. For all his virtue signalling, he’s a ruthless operator. He’s made it clear he won’t resign from his plum cabinet job if Rosebank gets the go-ahead. But behind the scenes, he’s doing everything he can to block it. Fahnbulleh has her career to think of, too. She doesn’t want climate vandalism on her CV. Lefties won’t like her then.

Burnham’s reputation is also on the line. If he caves and blocks Rosebank, he’ll look weak and Britain will be poorer. If he gives it the thumbs up, lefties everywhere will fly back to Polanski. Burnham struggles to make simple decisions, so this one must be agony. But he has to make it. And he’s going to go down in flames either way.

Labour leadership: best of Ed Miliband and Tony Blair will help us win, says Andy Burnham | Labour party leadership | The Guardian

Ed Miliband Just Lit a Fire Under Labour – Now Andy Burnham Will Go Down in Flames

Andy Burnham is facing an increasingly difficult political battle after Ed Miliband reignited divisions within the Labour Government over the future of Britain’s energy policy. What initially appeared to be a disagreement about North Sea oil and gas has developed into a major test of Burnham’s leadership, with Labour MPs divided over whether the controversial Rosebank oilfield should receive approval.

The Prime Minister now faces an uncomfortable choice. Approving Rosebank could anger climate campaigners and MPs who strongly support Miliband’s environmental agenda. Blocking it, however, could create serious questions about energy security, investment, employment and the Government’s willingness to develop Britain’s remaining natural resources.

The dispute has exposed the difficulty of keeping Labour’s competing political factions united. Miliband has made his position clear, while Burnham must decide how to balance economic arguments against the environmental commitments that helped shape Labour’s identity.

1. Ed Miliband has reignited Labour’s internal divisions

Miliband, now Foreign Secretary, remains an influential figure within Labour and has maintained a strong interest in the party’s environmental direction.

His opposition to Rosebank is particularly significant because he previously described the development as “climate vandalism”.

The oilfield, located approximately 80 miles north-west of Shetland, is one of the largest undeveloped oilfields in the UK North Sea.

Miliband’s position reflects his longstanding argument that Britain should accelerate its transition towards cleaner energy rather than approving additional fossil-fuel developments.

However, his intervention has created difficulties for Burnham, who must also consider the economic implications of refusing the project.

According to reporting published on November 20, 2026, Miliband has indicated that he would not resign if Rosebank receives approval. Instead, he would accept the Government’s final position under the principle of collective cabinet responsibility. <Cite refs={[“turn966592news15″,”turn966592search0”]}/>

That leaves Burnham facing an unusual situation: a senior Cabinet minister can maintain his opposition while remaining in government even if the Prime Minister ultimately reaches a different conclusion.

2. Rosebank has divided Labour MPs into rival camps

The second major problem is the scale of opposition within Labour itself.

Reports suggest that at least 75 Labour MPs have signed a private letter urging the Government not to approve Rosebank.

Their concerns focus on the environmental consequences of extracting and burning additional fossil fuels, as well as whether the project would deliver meaningful reductions in energy bills.

However, another group of Labour MPs supports development, arguing that the project could provide employment, investment and additional tax revenues.

Politics.co.uk reported on November 21 that approximately 80 MPs were lobbying in favour of approval, demonstrating how closely divided the parliamentary party has become. <Cite refs={[“turn966592search1”]}/>

This is not simply a disagreement between Labour’s traditional left and right.

The debate involves competing priorities across the parliamentary party, including environmental protection, industrial employment, energy security and economic growth.

For Burnham, the difficulty is that whichever decision he makes could leave a substantial group of MPs dissatisfied.

3. The economic argument is putting Burnham under pressure

The third challenge concerns the financial consequences of rejecting Rosebank.

Supporters of the project argue that developing Britain’s domestic oil resources could generate billions of pounds in economic activity, support thousands of jobs and provide additional tax revenues.

Industry estimates cited in the current debate put the potential value of Rosebank at approximately £28.7 billion.

Chancellor John Healey is reportedly among those supporting development, believing that the project could provide economic benefits at a time when the Government is facing considerable pressure over public finances.

Supporters also argue that Britain will continue using oil for many years, regardless of whether domestic production increases or decreases.

If the country does not develop its own resources, they argue, it may become more dependent on imported supplies from countries such as the United States and Qatar.

There are also concerns about the consequences for Britain’s energy security.

However, opponents question whether approving Rosebank would actually reduce household energy bills. Much of the oil produced is expected to be sold internationally rather than used directly by British consumers.

Environmental campaigners also argue that burning the extracted oil would generate substantial greenhouse gas emissions.

The Government therefore faces a difficult economic calculation involving employment, investment, taxation, energy security and environmental commitments.

Burnham cannot simply assume that approving the project will solve Britain’s energy problems. Equally, rejecting it could disappoint businesses and workers who believe North Sea development remains important to the economy.

4. Miatta Fahnbulleh could become central to the political confrontation

Another important figure in this dispute is Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh.

Fahnbulleh previously expressed strong opposition to approving new oil and gas developments, arguing that Britain should prioritise renewable energy and its climate commitments.

She is also regarded as politically close to Miliband, making her position particularly significant.

However, the formal decision concerning Rosebank rests with the Energy Secretary and must take account of the relevant legal and environmental requirements.

The controversy is complicated by the previous legal history of the project.

Rosebank’s earlier approval was overturned following a legal challenge because the environmental assessment had failed to account properly for emissions resulting from the eventual burning of extracted fossil fuels.

The Government must therefore consider the legal requirements before making a fresh decision.

The recent approval of the Jackdaw gasfield has added another dimension to the debate.

Although ministers have stressed that the Jackdaw decision does not determine the outcome of Rosebank, opponents believe it could indicate a more permissive approach towards North Sea development.

Fahnbulleh must now navigate the competing demands of environmental campaigners, industry representatives and senior Cabinet colleagues.

Her decision could become one of the most closely watched moments of Burnham’s premiership. <Cite refs={[“turn966592search1″,”turn966592news15”]}/>

Miliband’s influence creates an uncomfortable situation

One of the most interesting aspects of the dispute is Miliband’s continuing influence over Labour’s political direction.

Although his current Cabinet position is Foreign Secretary, his previous work as Energy Secretary helped establish the Government’s environmental strategy.

He remains closely associated with the party’s commitment to achieving net zero and reducing dependence on fossil fuels.

His intervention on Rosebank demonstrates that his influence extends beyond the responsibilities of his current department.

For Burnham, this creates a complicated leadership problem.

He must demonstrate that Cabinet ministers can disagree over difficult decisions while still supporting the Government’s overall direction.

At the same time, he cannot allow every major policy disagreement to become an open-ended political confrontation.

If Miliband’s supporters continue campaigning against Rosebank, the Prime Minister could face growing pressure from MPs who believe the Government should maintain its environmental commitments.

If Burnham decides to approve the project, he will need to explain why the economic benefits justify the environmental concerns.

Neither option is politically straightforward.

Could the Greens benefit from Labour’s disagreement?

The dispute could also have consequences beyond Westminster.

Zack Polanski and the Green Party have repeatedly argued that Labour must maintain a stronger commitment to climate action.

The Greens could use the Rosebank controversy to appeal to voters who believe Labour is compromising its environmental principles.

For environmentally conscious Labour supporters, the decision could become an important test of whether Burnham’s Government genuinely intends to prioritise the transition towards renewable energy.

However, approving Rosebank could also attract support from communities and workers concerned about employment opportunities in the North Sea.

The political challenge is therefore not limited to Labour’s parliamentary party.

It concerns the wider coalition of voters Burnham hopes to keep together, including traditional Labour supporters, environmental campaigners, industrial workers and people concerned about energy costs.

A decision that satisfies one group could create difficulties with another.

Burnham’s leadership faces its most difficult energy test

The Rosebank controversy highlights a broader problem facing the Prime Minister.

Burnham has attempted to establish a political culture in which different Labour factions can express disagreements without immediately facing disciplinary action.

He previously criticised the atmosphere of internal conflict under Keir Starmer and promised to create a more inclusive approach to party management.

So far, that approach has helped maintain a degree of unity.

However, Rosebank presents a much more complicated challenge because the disagreement involves fundamental questions about Britain’s economic and environmental future.

According to The Spectator’s political analysis published on November 21, the dispute could become a particularly difficult test of Burnham’s ability to maintain unity between competing groups of Labour MPs. <Cite refs={[“turn966592search10”]}/>

The Prime Minister must decide whether to prioritise economic development or maintain a stricter approach to new fossil-fuel projects.

He must also consider the consequences for his Cabinet if senior ministers and parliamentary supporters refuse to accept the final decision.

The decision that could reshape Labour’s direction

Ultimately, the Rosebank dispute is about more than one North Sea oilfield.

It raises fundamental questions about how Labour intends to balance climate commitments with economic growth, energy security and employment.

Miliband believes that expanding fossil-fuel development risks undermining Britain’s environmental objectives.

Supporters of Rosebank argue that domestic production can generate economic benefits and help maintain energy security during the transition towards cleaner technologies.

Both arguments have important implications for the Government’s long-term strategy.

For Burnham, the challenge is to reach a decision that can withstand legal scrutiny while maintaining confidence among Cabinet colleagues and Labour MPs.

If Rosebank is approved, environmental campaigners could accuse him of abandoning important climate commitments.

If it is rejected, supporters of domestic energy production could question why Britain is turning away from potential investment and employment opportunities.

The coming decision will therefore reveal how Burnham intends to manage the competing priorities within his Government.

Miliband has already demonstrated that he is prepared to defend his environmental position, even if the final decision goes against him.

Burnham, meanwhile, must demonstrate that his leadership can accommodate disagreement without allowing it to become a permanent division.

The central question is no longer simply whether Rosebank should proceed. It is whether Labour can maintain a coherent political and economic strategy when its leading figures disagree so fundamentally about the country’s future.

For Andy Burnham, this could become one of the most important tests of his leadership yet.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *