
Former Health Secretary Alan Milburn (Image: Getty)
Labour grandee Alan Milburn has completed a major study into the youth unemployment crisis. He looked at why almost a million young people are not in education, employment or training – the so-called NEETs – and what can be done to help them,
His key recommendations include:
End the NEET crisis within a decade
Mr Milburn wants the Government to commit to more than halving the rate of young people not in education, employment or training (Neets) by 2036.
A drop from the current rate of 13% to 5% in 10 years from now would be “an effective rate of Neet Zero”, his report stated.
He said: “I believe we should set ourselves a new national ambition: every young person should be learning, earning or actively participating.”
He states that different young people will require different opportunities and levels of support and that a small group “will require secure long-term protection because conventional participation is not a realistic expectation”.
Cut welfare
The report proposes an “entirely new benefit system for young people”, with a so-called youth allowance replacing both the health element of universal credit (UC) and personal independence payment (Pip) for 16 to 24-year-olds.
The new system would give every young person a legal entitlement to a route into education, training or work, and a guarantee of support to get the health, employment, functional and practical help they need to get into and stay in work.
Savings in welfare would begin by the end of this Parliament in 2029/30, with cumulative savings of £13.7 billion by 2036/37 – consisting of savings of £3.6 billion in that year alone.
Schools should equip pupils for work
Half a million additional employment and education opportunities could be needed by 2036, according to the review’s modelling.
Schools should better equip pupils for the future world of work, the report stated.
Starting from early childhood, the report recommended the Government raises the target for reception-age children in England to be school ready aged five from 75% to 90%.
Mr Milburn also argued that technical education should be on an equal footing with academia and further education and apprenticeships must become one of the main routes into skilled employment, with 270,000 under-25 apprenticeship starts a year by 2036 as well as a major expansion in further education for 18 to 24-year-olds.
NHS to help young people get out of their homes
The report warned that poor mental or physical health “should not become a one-way route out of education and work”.
Young people should, as a starting point, be able to get help online “through trusted channels and via the NHS app”, ensuring they get immediate advice and support rather than waiting for a diagnosis or assessment, the report said.
Those deemed to have lower-level needs should have these addressed as soon as possible “and at the least intensive effective level”, with specialist clinical capacity “reserved for those who need it most”, it added.
He criticised a “cash for diagnosis” approach in some private providers carrying out ADHD and autism assessments, and said some young people are being failed when they get a diagnosis despite not meeting the appropriate threshold, “or when they should not get one”.
He urged the Government to also take swift action on the private sector by restricting or cutting their NHS funding if they fail to meet required standards, and bringing in a new payment mechanism by 2028 “based on quality and outcomes rather than assessment or diagnosis volumes”.
Help for employers
Mr Milburn said he wants to see employers given more incentives to hire young people, while also committing to guarantees to do so.
To that end, bosses would be offered between £3,000 and £7,000 for hiring those who have been Neets for six months.
The report also recommended lowering the rate of national insurance contributions for employees between 21 and 24 over a five-year period, with retail and hospitality prioritised for the tax cut.
If the policy was adopted by the Government, it would be a partial U-turn on a tax hike introduced by Rachel Reeves when she was chancellor.
In return for the extra support, the Government should also ask employers to do more on their part to solve the Neets crisis and should also lead by example and hire more young people in the public sector.
Five Huge Changes in Alan Milburn’s Youth Unemployment ‘NEET’ Report
The growing number of young people who are not in education, employment or training has become one of the most serious challenges facing the United Kingdom. A major report led by Alan Milburn has highlighted the scale of the problem and called for significant changes to the way Britain supports young people entering adulthood and the labour market. The findings have raised important questions about the effectiveness of the education system, employment services and welfare policies under the Labour government.
The term NEET refers to young people who are not currently participating in education, employment or training. Although some individuals may temporarily leave work or education for personal reasons, a growing number face prolonged periods without opportunities to develop their skills or establish stable careers. This situation can have serious consequences for individuals, businesses and the wider economy.
Alan Milburn’s report identifies several areas where the government needs to make substantial improvements. Its recommendations focus on early intervention, employment support, education, financial assistance and greater cooperation between public services. Five major changes stand out as particularly important.
1. A new approach to identifying and supporting young people at risk
One of the most important recommendations is to identify young people at risk of becoming NEET much earlier. The report argues that the government should not wait until individuals have already spent months or years outside education and employment before offering assistance.
Schools, colleges and local authorities should work together to identify students who are struggling academically, experiencing personal difficulties or showing signs of disengagement. These young people could then receive individual guidance, careers advice and additional support before leaving education.
Early intervention is important because the transition from school to employment can be difficult. Some students leave education without the qualifications, confidence or practical skills required by employers. Others experience mental health difficulties, family problems or financial pressures that make it harder to continue studying.
A more coordinated support system could help prevent temporary difficulties from developing into long-term unemployment. Instead of treating every young person in the same way, services should consider individual circumstances and provide appropriate assistance.
2. Stronger employment support and more opportunities for apprenticeships
The second major recommendation concerns improving access to employment. Many young people struggle to obtain their first job because employers often demand previous experience. This creates a frustrating situation in which applicants cannot gain experience without first being given an opportunity.
The report calls for a stronger connection between employers, training providers and employment services. Businesses should be encouraged to offer apprenticeships, work placements and entry-level positions that allow young people to develop practical skills.
Apprenticeships are particularly valuable because they combine workplace experience with structured training. Participants can earn money while learning a profession, making this an attractive alternative to traditional academic education.
The government should also ensure that training programmes reflect the actual needs of employers. Courses that do not lead to recognised qualifications or meaningful employment opportunities risk wasting both public money and valuable time.
Industries such as construction, engineering, technology, healthcare and renewable energy could provide important opportunities for young workers. Developing targeted training programmes in these sectors would help address skills shortages while reducing youth unemployment.
3. Reforming the welfare system to encourage young people into work
The third significant change involves reforming the welfare system. The report highlights the importance of ensuring that financial support helps young people move towards employment rather than leaving them disconnected from the labour market.
However, welfare reform must be approached carefully. Some young people face serious obstacles that prevent them from working immediately, including disabilities, mental health conditions, caring responsibilities and other personal difficulties.
A successful system should distinguish between individuals who need additional support and those who are ready to enter employment but require practical assistance. Young people should have access to careers guidance, skills training and personalised employment plans.
The government must also ensure that benefit rules do not create unnecessary financial insecurity. For people entering low-paid or temporary employment, the transition away from welfare support can be difficult. If taking a job leaves someone financially worse off, the system may unintentionally discourage employment.
The objective should therefore be to make employment a realistic and sustainable route towards financial independence.
4. Better mental health support and personalised assistance
The fourth recommendation focuses on mental health and the wider difficulties experienced by young people outside education and employment.
Unemployment can create feelings of isolation, anxiety and low self-esteem. Young people who repeatedly receive rejection from employers may gradually lose confidence in their abilities. For those already experiencing mental health difficulties, the pressure of finding work can become overwhelming.
The report recognises that employment support cannot succeed if it ignores these underlying problems. Mental health services, schools, colleges, local councils and employment advisers need to work more closely together.
Young people should have access to appropriate counselling, wellbeing services and specialist support when necessary. They should also receive individual guidance that takes account of their personal circumstances rather than being placed into standardised programmes.
This approach could help more young people overcome barriers that traditional employment services may not adequately address.
5. Greater accountability and a coordinated national strategy
The fifth major change concerns how government departments and local authorities work together.
Youth unemployment is not the responsibility of one organisation alone. The Department for Work and Pensions, Department for Education, local authorities, schools, colleges and employers all have important roles to play.
However, fragmented services can make it difficult for young people to understand where to obtain assistance. Individuals may be required to contact several organisations, repeat information and complete different applications before receiving meaningful support.
The report therefore highlights the need for better coordination and clearer accountability. Government departments should establish measurable objectives and regularly assess whether their programmes are helping young people enter employment.
Local areas should also have sufficient flexibility to develop solutions that reflect their economic circumstances. A strategy that works in London may not be equally effective in a former industrial town or a rural community.
Regular reporting would allow the government and taxpayers to understand how public money is being spent and whether the policies are producing lasting improvements.
Why the NEET crisis matters to Britain’s economy
The growing number of young people outside education, employment and training has consequences that extend far beyond individual households.
When young people remain unemployed, businesses lose access to potential workers, the economy loses productivity and the government receives less revenue from income tax and National Insurance contributions. At the same time, public expenditure on welfare and other support services may increase.
The consequences can continue for many years. Someone who spends a prolonged period outside employment may find it increasingly difficult to develop professional experience and compete for better-paid positions later in life.
There is also a wider social impact. Long-term unemployment can delay financial independence, increase pressure on families and contribute to inequality between different communities.
For these reasons, reducing youth unemployment should be considered a major economic priority rather than simply another welfare policy.
The challenge for Rachel Reeves and the Labour government
Alan Milburn’s recommendations create an important test for Chancellor Rachel Reeves and Prime Minister Andy Burnham. The government must decide how to finance the proposed reforms while managing already considerable pressure on public finances.
Training programmes, employment advisers, mental health services and apprenticeship incentives all require investment. However, spending money does not automatically guarantee successful outcomes.
The government must also consider whether its wider economic policies are encouraging businesses to recruit. Higher employment costs, taxation and uncertainty can make employers more cautious about taking on additional workers.
There is little value in preparing thousands of young people for employment if businesses are not creating enough vacancies. Education and training policies must therefore be supported by a wider strategy for investment, productivity and economic growth.
In my opinion, the most effective approach would combine early intervention, practical training, personalised support and incentives for businesses that create sustainable employment. Young people should not be treated simply as statistics or numbers in government reports. They need genuine opportunities to develop their abilities and build independent lives.
Conclusion
Alan Milburn’s youth unemployment report highlights five important areas requiring reform: early identification of vulnerable young people, stronger employment and apprenticeship opportunities, improvements to welfare support, better mental health services and greater accountability across government departments.
These recommendations address some of the underlying reasons why young people become disconnected from education and employment. However, their success will depend on whether the government can turn ambitious proposals into practical improvements.
Rachel Reeves and Andy Burnham must recognise that youth unemployment is not only a financial challenge but also a threat to Britain’s long-term economic future. A generation unable to access meaningful work represents a serious loss of talent, productivity and opportunity.
Ultimately, young people need more than promises and government announcements. They need accessible training, supportive employers, effective public services and real jobs. If the government can deliver these changes, it could help thousands of young people build better futures while strengthening the British economy. If it fails, the NEET crisis could become an increasingly expensive and damaging problem for generations to come.
