Some state pensioners will need to give back their £300 winter fuel payments this year.

HMRC is sending new tax codes to state pensioners (Image: Getty)
HMRC will send new tax codes out to state pensioners in order to take their winter fuel payment back if they broke the earnings threshold this winter. Following changes made to the previous, unpopular winter fuel payment system which was tied to Pension Credit, winter fuel payments have since been made with the new £35,000 earnings threshold in place, which means most (but not all) state pensioners get to keep their £200 to £300 payments.
The new system for the payments of up to £300 means that everyone receives a payment, but an estimated two million state pensioners who earned more than the £35,000 threshold will be made to pay it back to HMRC. State pensioners aged under 80 receive £200, and those aged 80 or over receive £300 by default. In HM Revenue and Customs’ guidance published via Gov.uk, state pensioners have been told how it will work in practice for those who need to surrender the payment.
The ‘qualifying week’ for the winter fuel payment has now passed, and if you missed the deadline to surrender the payment, you will need to go through the process of receiving and returning it the tax office.
State pensioners who earned more than £35,000 from any income sources, whether it’s work or savings income, will have to wait for HMRC to take back the money via a change in their tax code, unless they normally submit a self-assessment tax return, or are asked to by the taxman.
This means HMRC will adjust pensioners’ tax code and send them a letter to tell them what their new tax code is, and recover the payment from their income each month.
Their guide says: “You’ll need to wait for us to take back the payment, you cannot pay it sooner.
“We’ll take your payment for the 2025 to 2026 tax year by changing your PAYE tax code for the 2026 to 2027 tax year. This means you’ll pay more tax each month to pay back the full payment that you received in the 2025 to 2026 tax year.
“For example, for a typical payment of £200, you’ll pay approximately £17 per month extra in tax.
“You’ll get a letter or a notification in the HMRC app to tell you that we’ve changed your PAYE tax code.
“We’ll review all of the tax you paid against the tax you were due to pay. If we have been unable to collect the full amount due during the tax year, in your tax code, we’ll send you a tax calculation.”
The qualifying week wa September 21 to 28, so you needed to inform the Winter Fuel Payment service before those dates if you wished to surrender the payment.
An HMRC spokesperson said: “The majority of people who need to pay back a Winter Fuel Payment will do so automatically via their tax code. For those already registered for Self Assessment, it will be collected via their tax return.
“We’ve provided online guidance clearly explaining how recovery of payments works, and a calculator so people can see if they’ll need to pay back the payment.”
State Pensioners Forced to Hand Back £300 Winter Fuel Payments by HMRC – Thousands Face Unexpected Tax Bills
Millions of British pensioners are facing renewed concerns over their winter finances as HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) prepares to reclaim Winter Fuel Payments from older people whose annual income exceeds £35,000.
The policy means that some pensioners who receive payments of up to £300 to help with heating costs will subsequently have to repay the entire amount through the tax system.
For older households already struggling with rising energy bills, food prices and everyday living expenses, the news has raised serious questions about whether the government’s winter support scheme is providing the help pensioners actually need.
Although the payment is initially made automatically to eligible people, receiving the money does not necessarily mean they will be allowed to keep it.
HMRC will recover the full amount from pensioners whose individual income exceeds the government’s threshold.
The development has reignited the political debate about the treatment of older people and whether Britain’s pension system is providing sufficient financial protection.
Why are pensioners being forced to repay £300?
The Winter Fuel Payment is designed to help older people cover the cost of heating their homes during colder months.
Under the arrangements for winter 2026/27, eligible pensioners in England, Wales and Northern Ireland can receive between £100 and £300.
However, the government has introduced an income threshold of £35,000.
Anyone whose individual annual income exceeds this amount will have their Winter Fuel Payment recovered by HMRC.
Importantly, the threshold applies to individual income rather than combined household income.
This means that two pensioners living together could be treated differently depending on their individual financial circumstances.
One partner might keep their payment while the other is required to repay theirs.
The government argues that this approach ensures assistance reaches pensioners who need it most while allowing higher-income retirees to contribute towards the cost of the scheme.
However, critics believe that the policy creates unnecessary confusion and disappointment for older people who initially believe they are receiving additional financial support.
Who can receive the £300 Winter Fuel Payment?
For winter 2026/27, eligibility generally applies to people born on or before June 27, 1960, who meet the residency and other qualifying conditions.
The amount received depends on age and household circumstances.
For pensioners living alone, the standard arrangements include:
-
- £200 for eligible people aged between 66 and 79.
-
- £300 for eligible people aged 80 or over.
Different amounts apply when eligible pensioners live together.
Those living in qualifying care-home circumstances may also receive reduced payments.
Most eligible people receive their money automatically, with payment letters issued during October and November.
The majority of payments are expected to arrive in November or December.
However, pensioners should remember that the amount initially deposited into their bank account may subsequently be reclaimed if their income exceeds £35,000.
How will HMRC take the money back?
One of the most important details is that pensioners generally do not need to make a separate repayment themselves.
HMRC will recover the money automatically through the tax system.
For people who pay tax through PAYE, the department will normally adjust their tax code.
This means a pensioner may notice that their monthly income after tax has decreased.
For people completing Self Assessment tax returns, the Winter Fuel Payment must be included in the relevant return.
Online tax returns may contain the information automatically, but taxpayers should check that the payment has been correctly included.
Paper tax returns require pensioners to enter the relevant information themselves.
The government says the system is designed to make recovery straightforward and avoid requiring older people to arrange individual repayments.
Nevertheless, pensioners who do not regularly check their tax codes could be surprised when deductions appear.
Why the £35,000 threshold is causing controversy
The £35,000 threshold has become one of the most contentious aspects of the policy.
Critics argue that pensioners earning slightly more than £35,000 should not automatically be treated as wealthy.
Many retired people have worked throughout their lives, saved into private pension schemes and accumulated modest additional income.
Some may have spent decades paying into workplace pensions specifically to improve their financial security during retirement.
The policy means that someone with an income just above the threshold can lose the entire Winter Fuel Payment rather than only a proportion of it.
There is no gradual reduction in the amount recovered.
If an individual’s qualifying income exceeds £35,000, HMRC reclaims the full payment.
Supporters of the policy argue that public money should be targeted towards lower-income pensioners.
However, opponents believe the absence of a gradual withdrawal system creates an unfair financial cliff edge.
Pensioners with private pensions could be affected
Another important issue concerns the types of income included in the £35,000 calculation.
The threshold is not based solely on employment earnings.
It can include:
-
- State Pension income.
-
- Private and workplace pension income.
-
- Employment income.
-
- Taxable savings interest.
-
- Certain other taxable income.
This means pensioners who receive both the State Pension and a private pension may find themselves above the threshold.
For example, someone receiving £12,500 from their State Pension and £23,000 from a private pension would have total income of £35,500.
Under the rules, that person would have to repay the full Winter Fuel Payment.
By contrast, certain non-taxable benefits and interest earned within an ISA are not included in the calculation.
This distinction is important because two pensioners with similar overall financial circumstances could face different outcomes depending on the composition of their income.
When will HMRC recover the payment?
The recovery arrangements depend on the tax year and the way an individual pays tax.
For the 2026/27 payment, HMRC will generally recover the amount through PAYE adjustments or Self Assessment.
HMRC has also announced changes to the timing of recovery for future payments.
From April 2027, the department intends to collect Winter Fuel Payment charges in advance during the same year that payments are made.
As a result, some pensioners could temporarily see two Winter Fuel Payment amounts reflected in their tax codes during the transition.
For example, someone receiving two typical £200 payments across the relevant years could face deductions of approximately £30 to £33 per month over a period of 12 to 15 months.
HMRC has confirmed that pensioners will not be required to repay more than the total value of the payments they received.
This change is intended to make recovery more closely aligned with the tax year in which the payments are issued.
Pensioners receiving Pension Credit have additional protection
There is some important reassurance for older people receiving means-tested benefits.
The government’s policy includes protections for pensioners receiving qualifying benefits such as Pension Credit.
These individuals will not have their Winter Fuel Payment reclaimed under the income threshold arrangements.
Pension Credit is particularly important because it provides additional financial assistance to older people on lower incomes.
It can also unlock access to other forms of support, including certain housing-related assistance and help with heating costs.
However, many eligible pensioners do not claim Pension Credit because they mistakenly believe they earn too much or have too much savings.
Older people who are unsure about their eligibility should check the official government guidance.
Even a relatively small Pension Credit entitlement can make a significant difference to an older household’s finances.
Winter Fuel Payment controversy puts the government under pressure
The decision to reclaim payments from pensioners earning more than £35,000 has attracted criticism from opposition politicians and campaigners.
Some argue that the government should have introduced a more gradual repayment arrangement.
Others believe the threshold should increase over time to reflect inflation and changes in pension income.
The controversy also comes after previous disputes over Winter Fuel Payment eligibility.
In 2024, the government restricted payments largely to pensioners receiving Pension Credit or certain other means-tested benefits.
That decision generated significant criticism.
In June 2025, the government announced that payments would return to a broader group of pensioners from winter 2025/26, while introducing the £35,000 recovery threshold.
The latest arrangements therefore represent an attempt to combine wider eligibility with income-based recovery.
However, the policy continues to divide opinion.
What should pensioners do now?
Older people should take several practical steps to avoid unexpected financial problems.
First, check total individual taxable income rather than looking only at the State Pension.
Second, read any correspondence from HMRC and examine changes to PAYE tax codes.
Third, pensioners completing Self Assessment should ensure that the Winter Fuel Payment is correctly included.
It is also important to remain alert to scams.
HMRC has warned that criminals may use the repayment controversy to send fake messages claiming that pensioners must immediately transfer money or provide banking information.
HMRC will not ask people to provide bank details through suspicious text messages or emails to recover Winter Fuel Payments.
Anyone uncertain about their circumstances should use the official GOV.UK website rather than following links in unexpected messages.
Official guidance is available here:
https://www.gov.uk/winter-fuel-payment
Conclusion: Another financial worry for Britain’s pensioners
The decision to reclaim Winter Fuel Payments from pensioners with individual incomes above £35,000 has created another difficult debate about retirement security in Britain.
Although eligible older people can receive payments of up to £300, those above the income threshold must ultimately return the full amount through the tax system.
For some households, the deductions may be manageable.
For others, particularly pensioners facing high heating costs and limited disposable income, the additional financial pressure could be unwelcome.
The government’s argument is that public assistance should be concentrated on people who need it most.
Critics counter that pensioners who have spent decades saving for retirement should not automatically be treated as wealthy simply because their income exceeds an arbitrary threshold.
As winter approaches, millions of older people will be watching their bank accounts, tax codes and heating bills carefully.
The bigger question remains whether the government can create a system that provides meaningful support without leaving pensioners confused about money they initially believed was theirs to keep.
