Should Brits on benefits be able to earn more than people working full-time? Have your say

Recent finds how identified the gap between claimants and those working full-time, with the worklessness crisis being called a national emergency.

Personal Finance App

The Centre for Social Justice calculated a £2,500 gap between workers and welfare claimants (Image: Getty)

The UK’s unemployment rate has been deemed a crisis, with around 6.7 million people across England, Wales and Scotland recieving at least one out-of-work benefit. The A report by the Centre for Social Justice identified 3,369 areas across England and Wales where worklessness dominates. It revealed that the areas, which home an average of 250 residents, have a combined population of 860,000. The findings also noted that in more than 19,000 neighbourhoods, more than one in three-working age adults claim out-of-work benefits, with almost six million people living in these areas.

The main out-of-work benefits are Universal Credit and Jobseeker’s Allowance, and it is possible to be eligible for both at the same time. However, if so your New Style JSA payments count as income when claiming Universal Credit and will reduce the amount of Universal Credit you receive.

The Centre for Social Justice’s report, chaired by former Work and Pensions Secretary Sir Iain Duncan Smith, warned that the UK’s low unemployment rate disguises a much deeper crisis of hidden worklessness, increasingly driven by health-related benefit claims.

The UK has a range of health-related benefits including Personal Independence Payment (PIP) / Adult Disability Payment (ADP), Attendance Allowance / Pension Age Disability Payment (PADP), Disability Living Allowance (DLA) / Child Disability Payment (CDP), all of which are non-Means-Tested Benefits, meaning they are paid regardless of your income, savings, or assets.

Earlier this year, The CSJ also calculated that in 2026-27 an “economically inactive claimant on Universal Credit” who gets the “average housing benefit and Personal Independence Payment” (PIP) for ill-health would receive an income of around £25,000. It claimed the figure could rise to £27,500 for those who receive the highest PIP rate.

In contrast, a full-time worker on the National Living Wage is expected to earn £22,500 after paying income tax and National Insurance – leaving a “£2,500 gap between work and welfare for existing claimants”

What do YOU think? Should Brits who claim benefits be able to earn more than those who have full-time jobs? Have your say in the comments.

Sir Iain claims that the worklessness problem had become normalised despite it causing significant damage to the nation. He added: “Britain is now living with levels of worklessness that would once have been treated as a national emergency.

“Yet because much of that worklessness is recorded as incapacity rather than conventional unemployment, it has gradually become accepted as a fact of life since the pandemic. This is not good enough. Lives are being ruined and yet this issue hides in plain sight.”

The amount of Government spending on benefits is expected to increase to £136.1 billion in 2026/27. The CSJ is calling for an overhaul of health-related benefits to restore incentives to work and replace a system it says risks writing people off with personalised support towards employment.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *