Labour grandee Alan Milburn calls for laws to stop future governments making the same mistakes

Former Labour Chancellor Rachel Reeves (Image: Getty)
Future governments should be banned from imposing the type of job-killing tax hikes introduced by Rachel Reeves and Sir Keir Starmer, Labour grandee Alan Milburn said today. Mr Milburn, a former Health Secretary, called for laws to ensure future government policies helped young people get jobs, training or education – instead of destroying opportunities.
The call for a “statutory Youth Opportunity Test” is one of the recommendations in his 267-page report into the youth unemployment crisis. There are almost a million young people aged 16 to 24 not in employment, education or training, the so-called NEETS, and Mr Milburn warned: “Without a sharp change in direction, the country will pay an ever higher fiscal price through an increasingly unaffordable benefits bill as more young people become trapped in economic inactivity.”
He said the problem had been brewing for decades. But while he did not criticise any party or politician by name, he highlighted increases in employer National Insurance contributions introduced by former Chancellor Rachel Reeves, which came into effect in April 2025.
Workers under the age of 21 are largely exempt, but Mr Milburn pointed out that those aged 21 to 24 became more expensive to employ. He said:“The 2025 changes increased the cost of hiring workers outside these exemptions. The employer National Insurance rate increased from 13.8 to 15 per cent, and the standard Secondary Threshold, above which employers begin paying employer National Insurance, was reduced from £9,100 to £5,000.”
Highlighting research by watchdog the Office for Responsibility (OBR), he said these changes “increased the cost of a full-time worker on the National Living Wage by around £800 per year. The OBR estimated this package would raise £25.7 billion annually by2029-30, directly from the bottom line of businesses. 160 The threshold changes have hit particularly hard and have had a profoundly negative impact on business sentiment.”
He also highlighted increases in the minimum wage. “The starting point is employment costs. Over recent years, they have risen. Wage costs for young people aged 18 to 20 on the minimum wage have increased by 65 per cent over the last 5 years. 156 The employer National Insurance rate has
increased and the threshold at which employers start paying it has fallen.
“Employment regulation is becoming more challenging for employers. At the same time, businesses are increasingly being asked to provide pastoral and workplace support for young people with more complex needs.”
He said the Government “should introduce a new statutory Youth Opportunity Test to assess the potential impact on youth participation of public policy changes. The explicit aim should be to prevent the youth labour market being flooded with more new regulation and to reduce existing regulatory burdens.”
Mr Milburn set out measures to lower the Neet rate by more than half from 13.4% to around 6.8% by 2036, bringing the UK into line with other comparable European countries.
The UK rate has never been lower than 9.7% since data began in 2001.
But in a challenge to ministers, he said Britain should aim to go further and set a new national ambition for a 5% Neet rate, which he dubbed “Neet Zero”.
Mr Milburn said: “I believe we should set ourselves a new national ambition: every young person should be learning, earning or actively participating.
“By 2036, the United Kingdom should aim to reduce the Neet rate to around 5% and become one of Europe’s best-performing countries for youth participation. That will be an effective rate of Neet Zero. Full youth participation. Full employment and full education for the young. The end of long-term youth unemployment.”
This would mean approximately 600,000 more young people engaging in work, education, or training each year.
The ambition would be buoyed along by “a combination of potentially higher levels of economic growth, partially as a consequence of more people being in work, and new momentum in the youth labour market”, Mr Milburn said.
The Government should commit to the national ambition within the first 100 days of the report being published on Tuesday, he added.
A variety of reforms to the welfare system and new support for young people feature among Mr Milburn’s recommendations for how to help get more Neets earning or learning.
They include giving up to £7,000 to employers for hiring under-25s who have been a Neet for six months, while also expecting them to create more youth jobs.
To incentivise employers to hire more young people, Mr Milburn said the Government should lower employer national insurance contributions (NICs) over a five-year period for workers aged 21 to 24, initially targeting hospitality and retail businesses.
If the Government were to endorse the move, it would partially reverse a NICs employers increase introduced by Rachel Reeves when she was chancellor.
Mr Milburn also recommended a greater focus on technical and vocational education, including by doubling the number of apprenticeships by 2036.
A new youth opportunity service – which Mr Milburn said should be rolled out across all of England by 2029 – would aim to be young people’s single point of contact on employment, careers, health and practical support.
But the report’s recommendation that young people’s entitlement to the main sickness and disability benefits be replaced with a new “youth allowance” has drawn criticism from charities.
Katie Schmuecker, principal policy adviser at the Joseph Roundtree Foundation, said “cutting sick and disabled young people’s benefits should not be part of this package”.
She added: “Financial support is part of what helps young people take up earning or learning. The wider support offer won’t succeed if the young people it is meant to help are also struggling to afford food or the bus to college.
“Our social security system plays a vital role in preventing poverty and supporting young people to move forward with their lives. An adequate safety net, that at the very least covers the cost of essentials, would give young people the space to take the next steps they need to get earning or learning.”
Mr Milburn has framed the change as moving from writing “a cheque” to creating an opportunity for young people to work, and has suggested new investment in support, training and jobs will come before any benefit changes.
Without action, the UK will “pay an ever higher fiscal price through an increasingly unaffordable benefits bill as more young people become trapped in economic inactivity”, the former minister said in his report.
He warned that his proposals were not a short-term fix, but a “10-year programme” which would take time to produce results.
Welfare savings would begin in 2029, Mr Milburn said, and could result in an accumulated £13.7 billion welfare savings in a decade’s time, as well as adding 0.4% GDP to economic growth per year by 2036.
