Miliband-slavery-clown

Until Ed Miliband comes up with the cash, his fine words mean nothing. (Image: Getty)

This is actually a serious subject, so I’ll start with the serious bit. Slavery is an abomination. Snatching fellow human beings from their families and working them to death for your own financial gain is as low as it gets. In ancient times, it was endemic. The Romans did it. The Greeks did it. The Vikings did it. The Egyptians, Persians, Arabs and Africans did it, and in parts of the world some people still do. The Americans did an awful lot of it until relatively recently. So did the Europeans, and yes, so did we.

Ed Miliband piles into slavery row - virtue-signalling fool made worse | Personal Finance | Finance | Express.co.uk

We traded slaves for almost 250 years, and we can’t claim that was okay just because it was the done thing. Plenty of our fellow countrymen thought it was an abomination, including William Wilberforce, who fought for two decades to get it banned. After 1807, we sent the Royal Navy after the slavers of the world and helped stamp out the trade. Nobody did that before. We should be proud. But for a while, we were up to our necks in it. And it wasn’t good.

This has fuelled growing demands for reparations, with campaigners putting the bill at anything up to £20trillion. Our economy is just £3trillion a year, so I’m not sure how they expect us to find the money. Perhaps we can pay in instalments over the next few centuries. They’ll no doubt try to take us to court. Which is madness. We can’t relitigate history, or we’d end up in an excruciating debate over whether descendants of the Romans should compensate us for invading ancient Britain, or whether we should pay them for the roads.

It was always going to cast a shadow over King Charles’s Royal tour. Former PM Tony Blair tried to put the whole thing to bed in 2006, expressing “deep sorrow and regret” over Britain’s involvement, while stopping short of a full apology. It wasn’t enough.

Now Andy Burnham stepped up, burbling on about offering a formal apology. But what use is that? He’s never owned slaves. No Briton alive has held slaves. The guilty parties are long dead. Which makes a formal apology completely insincere and in practical terms, totally useless. Like Blair’s non-apology, Burnham’s won’t be enough either.

Campaigners at Caricom want debt relief, investment in health and education, cultural restoration and other measures. We have close historical links to the Caribbean and could do more to help. But they also want financial compensation and we can’t do that. Chancellor John Healey cut his fiscal headroom to just £15billion last week. We’re a few trillion short.

Even if we did, any payment would disappoint and simply invite further demands. Once you establish the principle that people should pay for misdemeanours committed hundreds of years ago, there will be no end to it.

Ed Miliband - Latest News, Pictures, Comment and Updates | Express.co.uk

Which makes Burnham’s suggestion of a formal apology empty virtue signalling. Naturally, foreign secretary Ed Miliband liked the sound of that. As energy secretary, he based our policy on that exact principle and left us with some of the highest bills in the world. Today, he’s been publicly beating himself up about “difficult chapters in our past” and the need to discuss whether an apology might help “heal the division”.

To be fair, he also said financial reparations are not the “right or feasible answer to transatlantic slavery”. That may be the first sensible thing he’s said since entering politics. But in that case, an apology, formal or otherwise, amounts to the same thing: nothing.

Here’s the reality. If we’re not going to pay compensation – and we’re not – no amount of word salad will do the job. We can’t undo historical slavery, but we can avoid looking like blustering hypocrites in the here and now.

Britain has enough problems. If we’re going to wring our hands over historical events we can’t change, we’ll never get anything done. But that won’t stop this clownish government trying.

puntura nel sedere

Now Ed Miliband Piles Into Slavery Row – This Virtue-Signalling Fool Just Made It Worse

Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband has become embroiled in the growing controversy over Britain’s historical involvement in the transatlantic slave trade after publicly supporting Andy Burnham’s new approach to the issue. His intervention has intensified political divisions, with critics accusing Labour of prioritising symbolic gestures and historical apologies over the economic concerns facing ordinary British families. The dispute has also raised questions about whether the Government can acknowledge Britain’s past without exposing taxpayers to further financial demands. While Miliband insists that Britain should stop avoiding difficult conversations about slavery, he has firmly rejected financial reparations, declaring that such payments are neither practical nor feasible. His position has therefore created an unusual political situation: Labour is becoming more open to a formal national apology while simultaneously promising that British taxpayers will not face additional financial liabilities.

Đang viết

The latest development came during the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting in Antigua and Barbuda, where Miliband defended Burnham’s decision to open structured discussions with countries affected by the slave trade. He argued that previous British governments had repeatedly attempted to avoid the subject rather than confronting its historical consequences.

Speaking to the BBC’s Newscast programme on 4 November 2026, Miliband criticised former Prime Minister Tony Blair’s response to the issue in 2006. Blair had expressed deep sorrow and regret for Britain’s involvement in slavery but stopped short of issuing a formal national apology.

Miliband described the previous approach as a form of “sorry, not sorry”, suggesting that Britain had expressed regret without demonstrating a genuine willingness to address the concerns of affected communities.

He argued that the country should be confident enough to discuss its history openly and that avoiding difficult conversations had damaged relationships with Commonwealth partners.

However, his comments immediately attracted criticism from opponents who believe the Government is unnecessarily reopening a historical controversy at a time when Britain faces serious domestic economic challenges.

One of the most controversial aspects of the debate concerns the possibility of financial reparations.

Caribbean governments and campaigners have argued that Britain should recognise the long-term economic consequences of slavery through financial compensation, debt cancellation and investment in affected communities.

The Caribbean Community, known as CARICOM, has developed a ten-point reparations plan covering formal apologies, education, healthcare, economic development and other measures.

Its supporters argue that the economic inequalities created by centuries of exploitation did not disappear when slavery was abolished.

However, Miliband was determined to draw a clear line between historical recognition and financial compensation.

He insisted that British taxpayers would not pay a penny more as a result of the Government’s new approach to the Commonwealth.

He also explicitly ruled out reparations, describing them as impractical and financially unfeasible for Britain.

His statement was intended to reassure voters that Labour was not preparing to accept enormous compensation demands.

Nevertheless, the Government has proposed other forms of financial cooperation.

Burnham has introduced a debt restructuring initiative designed to help poorer Commonwealth countries facing high borrowing costs. The proposal could allow developing nations to manage repayments more effectively and redirect resources towards essential public services.

Miliband has defended this approach as a practical alternative to direct compensation.

The Government has also announced £40 million over three years for infrastructure investment in the Caribbean, including green energy projects.

Importantly, this funding will come from existing budgets rather than an additional financial contribution.

Despite these assurances, critics have questioned why British taxpayers should fund international initiatives when public services at home are experiencing considerable pressure.

The NHS continues to face financial difficulties, local councils are struggling with budgets, and millions of households remain concerned about housing costs, taxation and everyday living expenses.

For Reform UK leader Nigel Farage, the controversy provides another opportunity to challenge Labour’s priorities.

Farage has accused Burnham of promoting grievance politics and argued that Britain should recognise its contribution to ending the slave trade rather than encouraging further demands for compensation.

He has repeatedly highlighted the abolition of the slave trade in 1807 and the subsequent efforts of the Royal Navy to suppress international slave trafficking.

The British West Africa Squadron intercepted slave ships and helped liberate thousands of enslaved Africans during the nineteenth century.

However, this historical achievement must be considered alongside Britain’s earlier participation in the slave trade.

British merchants, plantation owners, shipping companies and financial institutions benefited from the forced transportation and exploitation of millions of Africans.

The British Government also compensated slave owners following abolition in 1833, borrowing £20 million to finance the payments. The formerly enslaved people themselves received no equivalent compensation.

This historical contradiction remains central to the current debate.

Supporters of reparations argue that Britain cannot celebrate abolition while ignoring the economic benefits accumulated through slavery.

Opponents respond that present-day taxpayers should not be held financially responsible for decisions made by governments and private individuals centuries ago.

Miliband appears to be attempting to navigate between these competing arguments.

His position is that Britain should acknowledge historical suffering, consider a formal apology and cooperate with Commonwealth countries while refusing direct financial reparations.

The Foreign Secretary has also suggested that discussions about an apology could reach an important conclusion within approximately a year.

He indicated that a formal apology could potentially be considered ahead of the G20 leaders’ summit, which Britain is scheduled to host in Manchester in November 2027.

This would represent a significant diplomatic development.

However, the Government has not yet finalised the wording or timing of any formal apology. Burnham has said that affected countries and communities should help shape the process rather than Britain deciding unilaterally what the apology should contain.

This approach has received a cautiously positive response from several Caribbean leaders.

Ghanaian President John Dramani Mahama welcomed the change in Britain’s willingness to discuss the historical issue, describing it as an opportunity to make progress on the relationship between Britain and former colonies.

Leaders within CARICOM have also indicated their willingness to participate in structured discussions.

Nevertheless, they have made clear that an apology alone will not necessarily satisfy their wider demands for reparatory justice.

The controversy has also attracted attention because of King Charles III’s visit to the Caribbean.

During his engagements, the King acknowledged the suffering caused by slavery and described it as a monstrous injustice that continues to cast a shadow over affected communities.

His remarks demonstrated a willingness to recognise the painful aspects of Britain’s history while maintaining the constitutional neutrality expected of the monarchy.

However, the King did not independently promise financial reparations or issue a formal national apology.

This distinction is important because decisions about government policy and public expenditure remain the responsibility of elected ministers.

For Miliband, the challenge is to demonstrate that his diplomatic approach can deliver practical results without creating additional financial burdens.

The Foreign Secretary believes that stronger Commonwealth relationships could help Britain cooperate with developing countries on trade, climate change, investment and international security.

Supporters of his approach argue that acknowledging historical grievances may actually improve Britain’s diplomatic position.

They believe that refusing to discuss the past could damage trust and make cooperation on future challenges more difficult.

However, critics question whether the Government is spending too much political energy on historical symbolism.

They argue that Labour should concentrate on improving economic growth, reducing the cost of living and addressing problems within public services.

There is also a wider concern about the consistency of Labour’s political message.

Burnham has been discussing a formal apology, Miliband has criticised previous governments for avoiding the issue, and the Government is simultaneously insisting that no financial reparations will be paid.

For voters, the important question is what the new policy will actually achieve.

A formal apology may have diplomatic and symbolic significance, but it will not automatically improve healthcare, education or living standards in Caribbean countries.

Similarly, debt restructuring could provide economic assistance, but its effectiveness will depend on the terms negotiated and the countries benefiting from the arrangements.

In my opinion, the Government needs to explain its objectives more clearly.

Britain should be able to recognise the suffering caused by slavery without accepting unrealistic financial demands. At the same time, historical discussion should not become an excuse for avoiding practical cooperation with countries that continue to experience economic difficulties.

Miliband should publish clear details of the proposed debt initiative, explain how the £40 million infrastructure allocation will be used and establish firm financial safeguards.

He must also ensure that any formal apology is carefully worded and does not create confusion about the Government’s position on compensation.

The debate should be based on historical evidence, financial transparency and constructive international cooperation rather than political insults.

Ultimately, the success of Labour’s approach will depend on whether it can improve Britain’s relationships with Commonwealth countries while maintaining public confidence at home.

In conclusion, Ed Miliband’s intervention has intensified the political controversy surrounding Britain’s historical involvement in the slave trade. By criticising Tony Blair’s previous response and supporting Andy Burnham’s proposed structured dialogue, the Foreign Secretary has signalled a more open approach towards historical apologies. However, he has firmly ruled out financial reparations and promised that British taxpayers will not pay additional money as a result of the new Commonwealth strategy. The Government has instead proposed debt restructuring and £40 million in Caribbean infrastructure investment from existing budgets. While supporters believe this approach could strengthen international relationships, critics argue that Labour risks creating unnecessary political divisions and distracting attention from domestic problems. The coming year will reveal whether Miliband and Burnham can turn their diplomatic commitments into practical results without creating the financial obligations that opponents fear.