Labour’s EU reset won’t make your food shop cheaper, it could make it more expensive . HYN

Labour's EU reset won't make your food shop cheaper, it could make it more expensive, writes Julian Jessop

The government is trying to sell its toxic ‘reset’ of relations with the EU by claiming that it will lower the cost of living, starting with food prices.

Cabinet Office Minister Hamish Falconer has even fronted a rather naff video where he waves items from supermarket shelves and implies they will now be cheaper.

Unfortunately, this does not stack up.

Labour's EU reset won't make your food shop cheaper, it could make it more expensive, writes Julian Jessop

The UK-EU summit is expected to include an agri-food deal where Britain agrees to copy EU rules.

The government says that this will cut paperwork, reduce costs, and create more export opportunities.

However, these benefits are greatly exaggerated.

The pro-Brussels lobby still relies heavily on an old academic study which claimed that a large part of the 25% rise in UK food prices between December 2019 and March 2023 was due to the increase in non-tariff barriers with the EU.

But food prices rose only slightly more in the UK than in Italy and France, and by much less than in Spain and especially Germany (also a major food importer).

The average increase in EU food prices over this period was 30%.\Andy Burnham announces major Brexit plan that could make weekly food shop cheaper amid cost of living fears

 

The reality is that main drivers of higher food prices are global or otherwise unrelated to Brexit, such as UK government policies on labour costs, energy, and tax.

This particularly applies to the items waved by the Minister in the video, which included home-produced eggs, milk, and meat.

On the export side, the UK has never been a major food exporter and never will be.

We therefore do not have a large food surplus to sell. In any event, exporting more food to the EU will not reduce prices at home.

But it is worse than that.

The proposed UK-EU reset will actually increase the cost of living, including the price of food.

The agri-food deal will impose additional costs on all businesses in the sector, not just those trading with the EU.

It will reduce the freedom of UK farmers to exploit the most up to date technologies, including gene editing and the best pesticides.

Other aspects of the ‘reset’ will raise costs across the whole economy, notably by increasing the cost of energy and requiring us to impose the EU’s higher tariffs on a range of other goods and commodities.

In the meantime, the UK can already reduce barriers to allow cheaper imports both from the EU and, thanks to Brexit, from the rest of the world.

That freedom will be lost if we have to realign with EU rules and tariffs.

Politics is toxic as well.

The items in your 'big shop' set to cost more under Brexit reset

The cross-party campaign group Britain Unbound (on whose Advisory Council I sit) recently published new polling of voters in the Prime Minister’s own Makerfield constituency.

The survey asked who should decide UK economic policy on 10 different issues, ranging from medicine approval to state aid.

In every case, a clear majority said policy should be decided by UK governments alone – including animal welfare and food standards.

The proposed reset will drive a coach and horses through all that.

It is a bad deal, and the UK should walk away

UK set for cheaper food and trade boost, but will follow EU rules in Brexit reset

Labour’s EU Reset Won’t Make Your Food Shop Cheaper – It Could Make It More Expensive

Labour’s plans to rebuild Britain’s relationship with the European Union have sparked a fresh political controversy, with critics warning that promises of cheaper supermarket shopping may be far less convincing than ministers suggest.

The government has presented its proposed EU reset as an opportunity to reduce trade barriers, cut administrative costs, and make food imports and exports easier. Ministers argue that closer cooperation with Brussels could help British businesses and eventually ease pressure on household budgets.

However, opponents believe the economic benefits are being exaggerated. They warn that closer alignment with European regulations could introduce new costs for British farmers, food producers, importers, and ultimately consumers.

With millions of households continuing to struggle with the cost of living, the question is particularly important: will Labour’s European strategy genuinely make everyday shopping more affordable, or could it create another set of financial pressures?

The debate is no longer simply about Brexit. It is about whether government decisions will make a measurable difference to the amount families pay at the supermarket checkout.

Labour’s Promise of Cheaper Food Comes Under Scrutiny

Labour has been attempting to convince the public that closer economic cooperation with the European Union could help reduce food prices.

The government’s argument centres on removing unnecessary paperwork, reducing border checks, and simplifying the movement of agricultural products between Britain and European markets.

Since Brexit, businesses trading certain food products with the EU have faced additional sanitary and phytosanitary requirements.

These include documentation, certification, and border procedures designed to protect animal and plant health.

Ministers believe that reducing these obstacles could make international food trading more efficient.

However, critics argue that removing some administrative barriers does not automatically translate into cheaper supermarket prices.

Food prices are influenced by numerous factors, including energy bills, wages, transportation, packaging, agricultural production costs, exchange rates, and international commodity markets.

Even if businesses save money through simplified trading arrangements, supermarkets are not automatically required to pass every saving directly to consumers.

That is why promises of cheaper shopping deserve careful examination rather than automatic acceptance.

The Hidden Costs of Closer European Alignment

One of the biggest concerns involves the possibility that British businesses could become increasingly dependent on European regulatory standards.

A closer agricultural agreement could require Britain to align with EU rules covering food safety, animal health, plant protection, and agricultural production.

Supporters argue that this would make trade easier by reducing the need for separate regulatory systems.

However, critics believe regulatory alignment could limit Britain’s ability to establish different agricultural policies.

British farmers may have fewer opportunities to adopt certain technologies or use agricultural products that are not permitted under European regulations.

This could affect productivity and operating costs.

If farmers face higher production expenses, some of those costs could eventually be reflected in the prices paid by consumers.

The government must therefore demonstrate that the savings generated by reduced border administration would outweigh any additional costs associated with regulatory alignment.

Without a transparent assessment, households are being asked to trust political promises rather than measurable economic evidence.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *