Matthew Allwright was forced to intervene during Tuesday’s show.

Narinder Kaur argued that the government should spend more money on helping younger generations (Image: Jeremy Vine/ Channel 5)
Matthew Allwright was forced to intervene after guests Narinder Kaur and Marc Goldfinger clashed on the Jeremy Vine show. On hand to discuss Alan Milburn’s review of the UK’s youth unemployment crisis, Allwright began the debate by asking whether it was time for the government to reduce public spending on pensioners in order to help younger generations secure work. “I get really tired that every time we talk about spending and welfare spending, it’s seen as an immediate attack on pensioners. And of course, poorer pensioners do need protecting,” Kaur noted. “However, when you look at the welfare bill – 55% [is spent on pensioners] – and God knows billions of that is spent on the triple lock pension.
Scopri di più
Aiuto disoccupati
welfare
pension
“I’m actually really fed up of a generation of boomers, of rich pensioners getting welfare when they’re sat in mortgage-free homes, whether they’ve paid into the system or not.
Good Morning Britain panellist Kaur added, “It’s the current working-age people who are paying into the system. And we’ve got a younger generation who haven’t got work.
“They can’t get on the property ladder. They’ve got no future potential of doing anything of any good. And they’re getting depressed. And you’ve got these pensioners saying, ‘Well, we want this, and we want that.’ They had it all.
“They’ve still got it all. Yet, we’ve got younger people; what are their hopes, Matt? What’s the hope? I’ve got a 20-year-old and a 19-year-old. I am worried sick about how they’re going to get on the property, how they’re going to find work.”
Striking a nerve with Goldfinger, the Conservative Councillor promptly cut in. “You’re going to tell me you’re going to take money away from someone’s grandmother and you’re going to get a 19-year-old into work,” he fumed.
“I don’t think it works that way. It doesn’t. People have been paying in money their entire working lives. We are spending 25 times more money on giving welfare to these young people,” he pointed out.
“So are you saying that rich people should receive welfare?” Kaur fired back. “That is not the question here,” Goldfinger replied. “So how much do they get per year? They get £12,500 a year. That is not luxury,” he argued.
“It is for a rich pensioner,” Kaur fired back. With the conversation turning tense, Allwright intervened, asking the broadcaster why she felt it was fair to have pensioners save for retirement, to have their pension reduced or taken away to help younger people.

The panel discussed Alan Milburn’s review of the UK’s youth unemployment crisis (Image: Getty)
“Do you agree that you should be giving welfare to people who’ve got money and whose mortgages are paid off? And at the same time you’ve got a younger generation who’ve got nothing!” Kaur put back to him.
“I’m actually really sick and tired of not looking after the younger generation. Alan Milburn’s report is telling you we’ve got a lost generation. And we’ve got a country, a society, that the minute you mention pensions of old people, it’s ‘How dare you attack us’.”
Following Kaur and Goldfinger’s explosive clash, viewers responded to the debate on X. “So is she going to hand over her pension when she gets it? I guess no,” replied one.
“Narinder may be surprised to learn that many of the older generation she talks about were also young and had nothing once, often starting work at 15 and contributing until retirement, as welfare wasn’t an option then; pitting old against young isn’t helping anyone,” noted a second.
“They are in mortgage-free homes because they’ve f*****g paid for them for the last 25 years,” tweeted a third.
