
David Lammy wants a vote on rejoining the EU (Image: Getty)
There are remarkably few times in which anything David Lammy says, writes or does should be taken seriously. Yet he has just written the most honest case yet for heading back into the European Union – and here’s why that should worry you.
Taking to the pages of a national newspaper, the former Deputy Prime Minister has urged Andy Burnham to put a return to the bloc on the ballot at the next general election. It marks a staggering change in direction from a man once boldly committed to adhering to those infamous ‘red lines’.
But in doing so Mr Lammy has given the game away. He waxes lyrical in his piece, as a great many state-loving socialists are wont to do, about his love of the European Union. He admires that Brussels has championed a “total rethink of market orthodoxies”, he says, crowing that the EU has become “more strategic, more interventionist and more industrial”.
For those on the left it is clear that a heavier-handed state is a selling point – for those with access to a calculator and a working understanding of economics, it is a warning flag.
Britain’s problems have not been caused because we simply didn’t have enough government. The country faces a combination of worklessness, declining productivity, overspending and borrowing, and a stagnant economy bereft of real growth and opportunity. We have far too much government, and the fact our former Deputy Prime Minister cannot see that is damning in itself.
Taxes throttle growth and drive the creators of wealth overseas. Our planning system blocks the construction of the homes and infrastructure we desperately need. The ever-increasing cost of hiring a new worker has driven more young people onto the dole. Yet Mr Lammy’s answer to this is to sign us back onto a club that wants more intervention, not less.
Underpinning his argument is the claim from the Bank of England that the economy is some 6 to 8 per cent smaller in 2025 than it otherwise would have been. This of course ignores the war in Ukraine, the Covid pandemic, and the lack of cheap housing, energy, and our long-standing productivity challenges.
Political failure to make the most of Brexit and deregulate the economy to spur economic growth must surely not be answered by demanding we rejoin a bloc that would continue the same failed lessons of the past? Not to mention the price of entry would be extortionate – and Mr Lammy admits it.
Free movement “would return”, he says. Now, whilst free movement of workers and the economically productive is not a bad thing for an economy, border controls to safeguard the bounties of a welfare state are surely sensible. Additionally, the rebate Margaret Thatcher fought for, worth around £5billion a year, would go up in smoke.
He insists that “like Ireland” we could stay out of Schengen and “like Sweden” keep the pound. But he neglects to mention that Ireland won its opt-out as an existing member, not as one attempting to rejoin the club. Sweden is legally bound to join the euro and simply drags its feet, and all new members are expected to commit to both. Any exemption would be a favour from Brussels, not an automatic right.
At the end of his staggering tract of dishonesty and foolishness lies the most revealing line of all. Should Marine Le Pen win the French presidency, Mr Lammy fears she could veto our return. His solution? Win her round, because Britain rejoining “would reduce France’s EU budget contributions”.
I would urge you to read that again. Mr Lammy’s masterplan is to charm Paris by promising our money to pay them off. His defence is that membership would give us “a say” in Europe’s decisions. A say, yes, but a veto over most of them, no. We would be one voice among 28, bound by rules we can, and would, be outvoted on.
Mr Lammy dismisses free-trading Britain as “the Jacob Rees-Mogg fantasy”. The truth that he handily seeks to ignore is it was never tried. Successive governments, his own included, kept the EU rulebook and raised taxes on the very businesses that might have used the freedom.
The answer to a botched Brexit is not to hand back the keys, it is to finally use them.
David Lammy’s Plan to Win Over France Reveals the True Price of Rejoining the EU
David Lammy’s intervention in Britain’s increasingly heated debate over Europe has brought an important question back into the political spotlight: what would the United Kingdom actually have to accept if it wanted to rejoin the European Union?
The former deputy prime minister has called on Andy Burnham to make returning to the EU a clear political commitment at the next general election. Rather than relying on closer trading arrangements or a limited agreement with Brussels, Lammy argues that full membership would offer Britain greater economic influence, stronger international relationships and a more meaningful role in shaping European decisions.
However, his argument has also exposed some of the difficult questions that any serious attempt to rejoin would have to address. Among the most significant is the attitude of France, one of the EU’s most influential member states and a country whose support could become particularly important during negotiations.
Lammy has suggested that Britain could make the prospect of rejoining more attractive to Paris by demonstrating that its return would reduce France’s financial contribution to the European budget. The argument is straightforward: if Britain became a member again, its financial contributions could help change the overall balance of payments between member states.
Yet this approach raises a much larger issue. If Britain needs to persuade other European governments by offering financial advantages, what would the final cost of membership look like for British taxpayers?
The question deserves serious examination, particularly because the debate is no longer confined to theoretical discussions about Britain’s relationship with Europe.
Why France matters so much
France is not simply another country in the European Union. Alongside Germany, it has traditionally played a central role in determining the direction of European policy, from economic cooperation and defence to agriculture, migration and institutional reform.
Any British government seeking to return to the EU would therefore need to establish a constructive relationship with Paris.
French politicians would have their own priorities. They would want to understand what Britain intended to contribute, what influence it expected to exercise and whether its return would strengthen or complicate the existing European arrangements.
The financial argument raised by Lammy is particularly relevant because EU membership involves more than access to a large trading market. Member states contribute to a shared budget that finances agricultural support, regional development, research, infrastructure and other European programmes.
The precise financial settlement would be a matter for negotiation. Britain could not simply assume that the arrangements it enjoyed before Brexit would automatically be restored.
That distinction is crucial. The United Kingdom left the EU in 2020, and the political circumstances surrounding a possible return would be very different from those that existed when it was a member.
France and other member states would have their own interests to defend. They would not necessarily regard Britain’s return as an uncomplicated benefit.
The financial question behind the political promise
One of the most controversial elements of Britain’s previous EU membership was its financial contribution.
The UK negotiated a budget rebate in the 1980s, reducing the amount it ultimately paid into the European budget. That arrangement became an important feature of Britain’s relationship with Brussels for decades.
If the country sought to rejoin, however, it could not safely assume that the same rebate would be available.
Lammy has acknowledged that a different formula for financial contributions would need to be negotiated. That leaves a substantial question unanswered: how much would Britain be expected to contribute under a new membership agreement?
The answer would depend on the terms negotiated, the economic circumstances at the time and the arrangements agreed with existing member states.
Supporters of rejoining would argue that contributions should not be considered in isolation. They would point to the potential benefits of closer economic integration, reduced trade barriers, participation in European programmes and greater influence over regulations affecting British businesses.
Critics would respond that these benefits must be measured against the direct financial commitment and the possibility that Britain could lose some of the special arrangements it previously enjoyed.
Neither side can settle the argument simply by presenting a single headline figure.
A proper assessment would need to compare the costs of membership with the economic consequences of remaining outside, while also considering the value of political influence and international cooperation.
The free movement question cannot be ignored
Another major issue is freedom of movement.
Lammy’s case for rejoining involves accepting that the movement of people between Britain and EU countries would once again become a central part of the relationship.
For businesses, universities and workers, this could create opportunities. British employers could find it easier to recruit from European countries, while British citizens could benefit from broader opportunities to live, study and work across the continent.
Supporters would argue that mobility could help address labour shortages and strengthen cultural and professional connections.
However, freedom of movement also raises questions about public services, housing, employment policy and immigration management.
These concerns cannot simply be dismissed as political misunderstandings. Governments would need to explain how a return to free movement would operate alongside domestic policies on migration, public spending and the labour market.
The challenge would be to establish a credible settlement that recognises both the economic opportunities and the pressures that increased mobility could create.
France would also be interested in these questions. Any agreement involving Britain would have implications for the movement of citizens, workers and businesses across the Channel.
Could Britain keep the pound and stay outside Schengen?
Perhaps the most complicated part of the discussion concerns whether Britain could return to the EU while retaining the arrangements that make its position different from that of many other European countries.
Lammy has argued that Britain could remain outside the Schengen passport-free travel area and retain sterling rather than adopting the euro.
There are precedents for certain EU countries maintaining special arrangements. Ireland, for example, is outside Schengen and maintains a common travel area with the United Kingdom.
Sweden continues to use its own currency, although its EU membership includes a commitment to adopt the euro once the relevant conditions are met.
But the existence of these arrangements does not mean Britain would automatically receive identical treatment.
The circumstances surrounding the UK’s departure and possible return would be subject to negotiation. EU governments would have to consider whether granting Britain special exemptions would be compatible with the rules and principles governing membership.
The British government could request flexibility, but it would need to persuade the other member states that such arrangements were acceptable.
That is where the political challenge becomes particularly significant.
A government campaigning for rejoining might promise voters that Britain could retain important elements of its previous independence. Yet the final terms would depend on negotiations with countries that would have their own expectations.
The referendum question
Lammy’s proposal also raises an important democratic question.
He has called for Labour to make rejoining a political commitment at the next general election, with negotiations taking place afterwards and the final agreement being put to voters.
This approach would mean the public would not simply be asked whether they wanted Britain to return to the EU in principle. They would eventually have the opportunity to examine the actual terms of membership.
That distinction matters.
The 2016 referendum took place before the practical consequences of Brexit had become fully apparent. A future vote would take place in a different economic and political environment, with voters potentially able to assess a specific membership agreement rather than an abstract choice.
However, the process would need to be transparent. Voters would need clear information about financial contributions, immigration arrangements, trade rules, regulatory obligations and Britain’s future influence within European institutions.
Without those details, the debate could once again become dominated by competing political slogans.
France will have its own conditions
The suggestion that Britain could win French support through a more attractive budget arrangement should not be mistaken for a guarantee of French approval.
Paris would consider the broader consequences of British membership. French leaders would want to know whether Britain was prepared to participate consistently in European cooperation or whether it would seek another collection of exemptions.
They would also examine the implications for the balance of influence within the EU.
Britain was one of Europe’s largest economies when it left. Its return would have significant consequences for negotiations over trade, defence, foreign policy and the future direction of the bloc.
For France, the question would not simply be whether Britain could provide additional financial resources. It would also be whether the political advantages of British membership outweighed the complications of negotiating a new settlement.
The same calculations would apply in Germany, the Netherlands, Ireland and other member states.
Britain might be eager to return, but the decision would not be made in London alone.
A political debate with consequences beyond Westminster
The debate over rejoining is also creating new divisions within British politics.
Some Labour figures believe the country should move towards full membership rather than settle for limited agreements with Brussels. Others favour a more gradual approach, arguing that practical improvements in trade and cooperation should come before any discussion of membership.
Andy Burnham faces a particularly delicate political decision. He has indicated that Britain should examine its long-term relationship with Europe, but the precise options and timetable remain subjects of debate.
Conservative and Reform politicians are likely to challenge any proposal that they believe would weaken Britain’s ability to make independent decisions.
Their arguments will focus on sovereignty, immigration, financial contributions and the authority of European institutions.
Supporters of rejoining will counter that formal membership would give Britain a voice in decisions that already affect its economy and businesses.
The disagreement is therefore about more than whether Britain should have closer relations with Europe. It concerns the balance between national independence and shared decision-making.
The price must be explained before the promise is made
Lammy’s intervention has ensured that the question of EU membership will remain part of the political conversation.
His proposal to make rejoining an electoral commitment is significant because it moves the discussion beyond technical cooperation and towards a fundamental change in Britain’s international position.
But the suggestion that France could be persuaded through a more favourable financial arrangement illustrates the scale of the negotiations that would lie ahead.
Britain would need to discuss its budget contribution, freedom of movement, the euro, Schengen, regulatory obligations and the distribution of political influence. It would also need to persuade existing member states that its return would serve the interests of the European Union as a whole.
None of these questions has an automatic answer.
For British voters, the central issue should be transparency. If politicians believe rejoining would improve economic growth, strengthen security and restore international influence, they should explain how those benefits would be achieved and what commitments would be required in return.
Equally, those who oppose membership should demonstrate how Britain could secure comparable economic and diplomatic advantages from outside the bloc.
France will have an important role in any future negotiations, but it will not be the only country with a voice.
Ultimately, the true price of rejoining the EU cannot be reduced to a payment to Brussels or a promise made to Paris. It would involve a much broader political and economic settlement, one that could reshape Britain’s relationship with Europe for generations.
Before any government asks the public to support that destination, it will need to show them the actual terms of the journey.
