OPINION: Our new PM remains popular. Labour is ahead in the polls. Everything looks just dandy for Andy. But there’s a problem, writes Harvey Jones.

Andy Burnham’s honeymoon is fizzling out and reality is sinking in (Image: Getty)
For weeks, political commentators have been predicting the end of Andy Burnham’s honeymoon with the electorate. It hasn’t happened. When political honeymoons end, it’s usually in a sudden cloudburst. Remember when Rachel Reeves axed the Winter Fuel Payment? That’s when the heavens opened on Keir Starmer. The sun has largely shone on Burnham. He hasn’t made a disastrous decision, committed an unforgivable gaffe or done something to split his party or the country in two.
Instead, the honeymoon has simply petered out. We were promised the Caribbean, we got three long months in Rhyl. And now the nation, along with much of the Labour Party, has the creeping feeling that Burnham wasn’t the one after all. Could be worse, people think. Could be Keir Starmer. But we hoped for better, and we haven’t got it.
The nation warmed to the cheery northerner when he made self-deprecating jokes about his navy blue T-shirt and munched through bags of crisps while looking and sounding like a human being. Starmer couldn’t do TikTok, people said. And they were right. He couldn’t. But there’s something Burnham isn’t doing any better than Starmer. Being an effective PM.
Honeymoons throw people together and it hasn’t taken long to figure out Andy Burnham. He’s a jolly chap, but you wouldn’t want him running the country. Except he is.
Labour was desperate to hitch itself to anyone, and grabbed Burnham. Given the dearth of talent in the cabinet, it’s easy to see how this jovial blank space floated to the top.
Burnham is a people pleaser, and the people are still broadly pleased. He wants to keep it that way. So he’s thrown us small treats such as lower bus fares, money off energy bills and a Budget designed to ‘do no harm’, rather than actually do some good. Nothing to get the juices flowing though. It’s been a long honeymoon, but at least he remembered the flip-flops. We’ve witnessed plenty of those.
Reality is sinking in – we’re just not really into him. Yesterday, the House of Commons emptied during PMQs, as Burnham mumbled tediously away. Even the combative Kemi Badenoch struggled to spice things up. She must feel like she’s thumping a wet sponge, soaking everything up and giving nothing back.
A British PM is supposed to dominate the Commons. This one slips in and out unnoticed, as if he’s only there to clear up and collect the lanyards.
Like a lot of marriages, Labour came to this one with unrealistic expectations. Now they’ve seen Burnham at close quarters, their ardour has cooled. Soon it will be the turn of voters. This honeymoon will end in the worst possible way. Apathy. By then it’ll too late. We’re stuck with him.
Nigel Farage Rages Over ‘Outrageous Cover-Up’ on Migrant Crime – ‘What Are They Hiding?’
A growing political storm has erupted in Britain after Reform UK leader Nigel Farage accused the Labour government of concealing important information about crimes committed by foreign nationals. His angry reaction followed the Ministry of Justice’s refusal to release figures showing the number of criminal convictions involving foreign nationals in 2025, broken down by nationality and type of offence. The decision has reignited the debate over immigration, public safety, government transparency and the public’s right to know what is happening in the country.
Farage did not hide his frustration. Describing the government’s decision as an “outrageous cover-up”, he questioned why ministers appeared unwilling to publish information that could help the public understand the relationship between immigration and crime. He also pointed to the government’s continuing dispute over figures covering the period from 2018 to 2024. In a strongly worded statement, he asked: “What are they hiding?” His comments quickly attracted attention and added further pressure on Labour to explain its position.
The controversy began when the Centre for Migration Control requested detailed information from the Ministry of Justice about criminal convictions involving foreign nationals. The organisation wanted figures for 2025, separated according to nationality and offence. Such information, supporters argue, would allow researchers, policymakers and members of the public to examine patterns in criminal convictions and assess whether immigration policies are having consequences for public safety.
However, the Ministry of Justice rejected the request, arguing that releasing the information could potentially lead to the identification of individuals concerned. An official from the department’s Analysis Directorate explained that the protection of personal information outweighed the legitimate public interest in publishing the requested data. The government therefore defended its decision on privacy grounds rather than accepting the argument that all the information should automatically be made public.
Nevertheless, this explanation has failed to satisfy Farage and other critics. They argue that the government should be able to publish statistics in an anonymised form without revealing the identities of individual offenders. In their view, protecting personal privacy and providing meaningful public information are not necessarily incompatible. Properly prepared statistical reports could potentially reveal important trends while ensuring that individual people cannot be identified.
The dispute is particularly sensitive because it is not limited to the figures for 2025. There is also an ongoing disagreement concerning data covering the years 2018 to 2024. The Information Commissioner’s Office previously ruled that the Ministry of Justice should disclose the relevant information. However, the department has continued to challenge the decision through legal proceedings, raising questions about the financial cost and wider implications of the dispute.
For Farage, the government’s repeated refusal to release the statistics creates the impression that ministers are avoiding uncomfortable questions. He believes the public deserves greater transparency, particularly when immigration and crime are such important issues in national political debate. His argument is that people should not have to rely on political statements, speculation or incomplete information when assessing the effectiveness of government policies.
The issue also raises a broader question about trust in public institutions. In a democratic society, citizens expect governments to explain important decisions and provide reliable information about matters affecting their communities. When official statistics are withheld, even for legitimate reasons, suspicion can grow. People may begin to wonder whether the government is protecting sensitive information appropriately or simply avoiding political embarrassment.
However, it is important to distinguish between the refusal to publish statistics and proof of a deliberate cover-up. Farage’s accusation represents his political interpretation of the situation, not an established finding that ministers are concealing evidence of widespread criminal activity. The Ministry of Justice has presented privacy concerns as its justification, and the disagreement over the earlier data remains subject to legal scrutiny. Without access to the complete figures, it would be premature to draw conclusions about the scale or nature of migrant crime.
There is also a danger in treating foreign nationals as a single group. People who move to Britain do so for many different reasons. Some arrive to study, work or join family members, while others seek protection from conflict and persecution. Many contribute positively to British society, support local businesses, pay taxes and work in essential industries. It would be unfair and misleading to associate an entire population with the criminal actions of particular individuals.
At the same time, acknowledging the positive contributions of migrants does not mean ignoring crimes committed by foreign nationals. Serious offences must be investigated properly, and those responsible must face the consequences under British law. Public safety should remain a priority regardless of an offender’s nationality, background or immigration status. A fair immigration system must also ensure that appropriate legal action is taken against foreign nationals who commit serious crimes and are eligible for deportation.
The debate becomes even more complicated when the government discusses the deportation of foreign national offenders. Home Office figures cited in the political dispute indicate that 21,294 convicted foreign nationals were living in the community without having been deported. This figure has attracted considerable attention, although understanding it requires examining individual legal circumstances, deportation restrictions and the reasons why removal has not taken place.
The government, for its part, has defended its record by pointing to enforcement measures and changes intended to speed up deportations. It has stated that nearly 12,000 foreign national offenders have been removed since July 2024, representing an increase of 41 per cent. Ministers argue that these measures demonstrate their commitment to public safety and show that they are taking the issue seriously.
Nevertheless, figures about deportations and criminal convictions should be examined carefully. The number of people removed from the country does not, by itself, explain how many foreign nationals commit crimes, how serious those offences are or how immigration enforcement affects local communities. Reliable comparisons require consistent definitions, accurate records and sufficient context.
This is why the publication of comprehensive statistics matters. Without transparent information, politicians from different parties can present selective figures to support their arguments. One side may emphasise individual cases to suggest that immigration creates unacceptable risks, while another may focus on the positive economic and social contributions of migrants. Neither approach can replace a complete examination of the available evidence.
The government should therefore consider whether it can release the requested information in a form that protects personal identities while providing meaningful statistical detail. Data could be grouped into sufficiently large categories, with appropriate safeguards against identifying individual offenders. Independent experts could also assess whether the proposed publication creates genuine privacy risks or whether those concerns can be addressed through anonymisation.
Such an approach would benefit both the public and the government. If the statistics show that particular problems exist, officials would have stronger evidence to develop targeted policies. If the figures challenge claims made by political opponents, ministers would have an opportunity to demonstrate that through verifiable information. Transparency should not be viewed simply as a political concession; it should be an essential part of responsible government.
For Nigel Farage, however, the controversy represents a much wider failure of confidence in Britain’s immigration system. He has repeatedly argued that successive governments have failed to maintain effective border controls and have not been sufficiently honest about the consequences of their policies. By challenging Labour over the withheld crime statistics, he is attempting to place immigration and public safety at the centre of the national political conversation.
Whether his accusations will persuade voters depends partly on what happens next. If the government continues to withhold the information, pressure for greater transparency is likely to increase. If it eventually publishes the figures, the debate will move towards interpreting the evidence and deciding what policy changes, if any, are justified.
Ultimately, the British public deserves an immigration system that is fair, effective and accountable. People should be able to discuss crime and immigration without being accused automatically of prejudice, but they must also avoid blaming entire communities for the actions of individuals. Evidence, rather than fear or political slogans, should guide the discussion.
Farage’s question, “What are they hiding?”, captures the frustration felt by critics who believe the government has not provided satisfactory answers. Yet the most important question is not simply whether Labour has something to conceal. It is whether the government can demonstrate that its decisions are justified, proportionate and consistent with the public interest.
Britain needs accurate statistics, effective policing, sensible immigration controls and a justice system that treats everyone equally. Publishing reliable information would be an important step towards rebuilding public confidence. Whatever the political consequences, transparency should be the starting point of an honest national conversation about immigration and crime.
