Andy Burnham’s Brexit Betrayal is just the start – he is completely out of his depth . hyn

Burnham

Andy Burnham is betraying Brexit just months after promising not to reopen the debate (Image: James Veysey/Shutterstock)

Andy Burnham will hand a raft of powers back to Brussels at the surrender summit but it is just the start of the Great Brexit Betrayal. In just six months the Prime Minister has gone from promising the voters of Makerfield he would not re-run the debate, to giving speeches at white tie dinners in the City trashing Britain’s independence from the bloc. Express readers will not be surprised that Burnham is already failing to keep his promises.

His history of shape-shifting has been well documented in these pages and the issue of Brexit was always the one he was most likely to betray the public on. The question is why and there is one clear answer – because he is completely out of his depth. Burnham’s coup saw him installed much quicker than expected, catapulting him into No 10 before he had a proper plan for government.

Andy Burnham to say Brexit 'has not worked' and he will sign new deal with EU | Brexit | The Guardian

Four months on and the evidence is clear. A damp squib budget and lots of promises about what happens after the next election are all there is to show for this new premiership. A country driven to distraction by political turmoil has been willing to give Burnham a chance, hopeful that he will be the one to bring stability.

But his casual disregard for the 17.4 million voters who chose to free Britain from the suffocating grip of Brussels bureaucrats reveals so much. Burnham managed to bypass the national electorate when he quit as Manchester’s mayor and then stitched up the Labour party to avoid a vote there too. It’s little surprise then that what voters want is not his top priority. But by blundering into the Brexit debate without a plan he has reignited a fire that he will be unable to control.

Andy Burnham discusses Brexit and closer ties to EU

How significant are Burnham's remarks on Kremlin interference in Brexit vote? | Andy Burnham | The Guardian

Kemi Badenoch nailed it when she said the Prime Minister must “stop obsessing about Europe” and get on with fixing Britain. The Tory leader pointed out that the UK doesn’t need Europe to sort out the economy, fund defence, boost employment and back business. But Burnham is a political mirage. From afar he seemed like the answer for a desperate Labour Party grasping around for a solution.

Up close, it turns out there is nothing there, other than a Metropolitan mayor who built his popularity on giving out taxpayers’ money while blaming the government for everything else. Now he is the government, the decisions are ducked and delayed and he has had to find a new enemy to blame and Brexit fits the bill perfectly. On Friday, Mr Burnham will sign the so-called reset deal with Brussels that was originally negotiated by Keir Starmer.

Brussels will lift some of its red tape on some British producers but in return has demanded the UK permanently aligns with all EU regulations on food and farming. Then he will set out options for what happens next, including rejoining the single market or going all the way back in. Burnham could try to seize the opportunities freedom from the bloc has offered instead of trying to overturn it.

In fact he already has. The government announced a VAT on household electricity bills to help with the cost of living that is only allowed now the UK has left the bloc. Trade deals, animal welfare, subsidies, state aid, AI regulation are all now under Britain’s control.

It’s up to the government to use those powers to make the country a success. Doomsters predicted a mass exodus from the City after Brexit but it has enjoyed major successes since leaving the EU stranglehold. Latest polls show support for rejoining dramatically melts away if Britain was forced to take the euro and no longer enjoyed a rebate.

Few want to be caught up in another decade of debates and negotiations about going back in. Even half the Cabinet knows it would be a bad idea, burning any trust Labour has regained in the Red Wall. But EU leaders are already rubbing their hands with glee at the thought of an extra £30bn being paid into their coffers. Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babis was asked if he would support the UK’s return. “Yes, of course,” he replied. “We need more money.”

Burnham is already trampling over the wishes of the Makerfield voters that he looked in the eye and pledged not to betray Brexit. We should not be surprised that his promises to the rest of us count for nothing either.

Andy Burnham backtracks on idea of referendum if UK accepts EU free movement

Andy Burnham’s Brexit Betrayal Is Just the Start – Questions Grow Over His Political Direction

Andy Burnham is facing renewed political criticism over his position on Brexit, with opponents questioning whether his approach to Britain’s relationship with the European Union reflects the priorities of voters who supported leaving in 2016. His comments and proposals on closer European cooperation have reopened an argument that continues to divide British politics, creating another challenge for Labour at a time when the party is already facing pressure over its economic and domestic policies.

For Burnham, the controversy is particularly significant because he has increasingly been discussed as a potential figure in Labour’s future national leadership. His experience as Mayor of Greater Manchester has given him a prominent platform, but any ambitions beyond regional government would expose him to much closer scrutiny over his views on the biggest political questions facing the country.

Brexit is one of those questions.

The referendum was not simply a disagreement about trade arrangements or European regulations. For millions of voters, it represented a decision about national sovereignty, democratic accountability and the direction in which Britain should develop.

Consequently, suggestions that the country should move towards closer integration with Brussels can quickly generate strong reactions.

Brexit Remains a Sensitive Political Issue

When Britain voted to leave the European Union in June 2016, the result was 51.9 per cent for Leave and 48.1 per cent for Remain.

The outcome triggered years of political negotiations and eventually resulted in the United Kingdom formally leaving the EU on 31 January 2020.

However, leaving the European Union did not bring an end to disagreements about Britain’s future relationship with Europe.

Supporters of Brexit argued that the country needed greater control over immigration, legislation, trade policy and its international relationships.

Those who supported remaining in the EU warned that departure could create additional economic barriers and weaken Britain’s influence in European decision-making.

Nearly a decade after the referendum, both sides continue to debate whether the decision has delivered the results they expected.

Burnham’s position has brought these disagreements back into the spotlight.

He has argued for a more constructive relationship with the European Union, suggesting that Britain should explore opportunities for cooperation where they could produce economic benefits.

However, critics worry that closer cooperation could gradually undermine some of the independence that Brexit was intended to secure.

The distinction between improving relations and reversing the referendum result is therefore central to the argument.

What Does Burnham Actually Want From Europe?

The debate surrounding Burnham is partly driven by questions about how far he believes Britain should move towards the European Union.

Closer cooperation does not necessarily mean rejoining the single market or becoming an EU member again.

There are several possible areas in which Britain and the EU could develop stronger arrangements without restoring full membership.

These include food standards, energy cooperation, scientific research, security arrangements and trade facilitation.

Supporters argue that practical agreements could reduce unnecessary costs for businesses and improve Britain’s economic relationship with its largest nearby trading bloc.

For businesses involved in importing and exporting goods, regulatory differences and additional paperwork can create difficulties.

A more cooperative framework could potentially reduce some of those obstacles.

However, opponents want clear assurances that such arrangements would not involve surrendering significant decision-making powers.

They also question whether closer cooperation could eventually create pressure for Britain to accept rules over which it has limited influence.

These concerns deserve serious consideration because the question is not simply whether cooperation is beneficial.

It is also about the conditions under which that cooperation takes place and the responsibilities Britain would accept in return.

The Democratic Question Burnham Cannot Ignore

One of the strongest arguments made by Brexit supporters concerns democratic accountability.

They believe the 2016 referendum established a clear instruction that politicians should respect.

From this perspective, changing Britain’s relationship with Europe without another clear public mandate could create a serious problem of political trust.

However, the referendum did not prohibit future governments from negotiating different international agreements or changing domestic policies.

Britain remains a sovereign country with the ability to make decisions through its Parliament and democratic institutions.

The question is therefore not whether Britain’s relationship with Europe can ever change.

It is whether significant changes should be presented honestly, debated openly and supported through appropriate democratic procedures.

Any politician advocating closer integration with the EU would need to explain precisely what was being proposed.

Voters should be able to distinguish between limited cooperation, participation in specific European programmes, closer trade arrangements and full membership.

Treating all these possibilities as identical risks creating confusion.

Burnham would need to provide clarity if he wants his arguments to be taken seriously by voters on both sides of the Brexit debate.

Greater Manchester’s Economic Concerns

Burnham’s position also needs to be understood in the context of his responsibilities as Mayor of Greater Manchester.

The region has a diverse economy involving manufacturing, financial services, technology, education, healthcare and international trade.

Businesses across Greater Manchester depend on access to international markets and effective transport connections.

Universities also maintain important relationships with European institutions, researchers and students.

Consequently, changes in Britain’s relationship with the EU can have practical consequences for the region.

Supporters of Burnham’s approach argue that closer cooperation could create opportunities for businesses, universities and workers.

They believe that Greater Manchester should be able to benefit from international investment and partnerships rather than being restricted by unnecessary political barriers.

Critics, however, argue that economic cooperation should not become an excuse for gradually reversing Brexit.

They point out that Britain can negotiate international partnerships while remaining outside the European Union.

The challenge for Burnham is to demonstrate that his proposals would produce measurable benefits rather than simply generate another round of political arguments.

Labour’s Growing Political Difficulties

The Brexit controversy comes at a time when Labour faces pressure on several domestic issues.

The Government entered office in 2024 promising economic stability, improved public services and a different approach to national leadership.

However, voters continue to face concerns about the cost of living, housing affordability, taxation and access to healthcare.

Immigration has also remained a major political issue, particularly as the Government attempts to demonstrate that it can manage the asylum system effectively.

These challenges have created opportunities for opposition parties to question Labour’s performance.

Reform UK has made immigration, national sovereignty and dissatisfaction with established political institutions central to its political message.

The Conservatives have also sought to challenge Labour over taxation, economic management and its approach to public spending.

For Burnham, the danger is that his position on Europe becomes another source of division within an already difficult political environment.

If he wants to play a larger role in national politics, he will need to explain how his priorities address the concerns of voters who feel disconnected from Westminster.

Could Brexit Become a Leadership Problem?

Burnham’s political ambitions have repeatedly attracted attention, particularly because he has previously contested the Labour leadership.

His experience as Mayor of Greater Manchester has helped him develop a profile that differs from that of many Westminster politicians.

He has often presented himself as a supporter of regional empowerment and greater investment outside London.

These themes could become important elements of any future national political campaign.

However, a return to Westminster would bring additional scrutiny.

Burnham would have to explain his positions on taxation, immigration, defence, public services, economic growth and Britain’s international relationships.

Brexit would almost certainly feature prominently.

Some Labour voters remain strongly opposed to European integration, while others believe the country should reconsider its departure.

A politician seeking to unite these different groups would face a difficult balancing act.

Burnham would need to demonstrate that he can advocate closer cooperation without dismissing the concerns of people who supported leaving the EU.

He would also need to explain why his proposals would improve living standards.

The Economic Argument Is More Complicated Than Political Slogans

Both sides of the Brexit debate frequently present economic arguments.

Supporters of closer European relations point to the importance of trade, investment and regulatory cooperation.

They argue that reducing barriers could help British businesses compete more effectively.

Brexit supporters, meanwhile, emphasise the opportunities created by independent trade policy and the ability to develop regulations suited to Britain’s own economic priorities.

They also argue that the benefits of leaving the EU should be judged over a longer period rather than through short-term economic comparisons.

The reality is that Britain’s economic performance depends on many factors, including productivity, investment, skills, infrastructure, taxation and global economic conditions.

Brexit is one part of that picture, but it cannot explain every economic difficulty facing the country.

Any serious proposal from Burnham should therefore be supported by detailed evidence.

Voters need to understand what changes are being suggested, what benefits are expected and what potential costs could arise.

Political claims without clear explanations are unlikely to settle the argument.

Voters Want Practical Answers

Perhaps the most important issue is that many people are tired of seeing Brexit dominate political discussions while their everyday problems remain unresolved.

Households want affordable housing, reliable public transport and access to functioning public services.

Workers want wages that keep pace with living costs.

Small businesses want a stable economic environment in which they can plan, invest and employ people.

These priorities are shared by many people regardless of whether they voted Leave or Remain.

Burnham’s supporters may argue that closer European cooperation could contribute to economic improvements.

His critics may respond that Britain should focus on making the most of its independence rather than revisiting old political arguments.

Both positions require evidence.

The Government and its political opponents should be judged on the practical consequences of their proposals rather than the strength of their rhetoric.

A Defining Moment for Burnham’s Political Future

The latest Brexit controversy demonstrates why Burnham’s national ambitions could become increasingly complicated.

His experience in Greater Manchester gives him a platform to discuss regional inequality, transport, economic development and public services.

However, national leadership requires a much broader political programme.

He would need to establish how his approach to Europe fits into a wider strategy for economic growth and national renewal.

He would also need to convince voters that he understands the concerns of communities that supported Brexit and do not want their decision casually dismissed.

At the same time, he would have to explain why closer cooperation could be beneficial to those who believe Britain’s departure has created unnecessary economic difficulties.

These are not easy questions, and they cannot be resolved through personal criticism or political slogans.

Ultimately, the controversy is about more than Andy Burnham’s individual position.

It reflects a continuing national disagreement over sovereignty, economic opportunity and democratic accountability.

Britain has left the European Union, but the debate about what that decision should mean for the country’s future is far from finished.

If Burnham wants to become a more influential national political figure, he will need to offer voters a clear and convincing explanation of where he believes Britain should go next.

His challenge is not simply to defend closer relations with Europe.

It is to demonstrate that any proposed changes would respect democratic accountability, protect Britain’s interests and deliver practical improvements to people’s lives.

Until those questions receive clear answers, Brexit is likely to remain a major political obstacle for anyone seeking to define Labour’s future direction.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *