Andy Burnham wants to rejoin in his lifetime (Image: Getty)
In the past few weeks there has been an extraordinary cacophony of voices advising our hapless PM against pursuing an EU reset let alone an attempt to join the EU.
The very PM who fired the starting pistol on Brexit and who campaigned to remain in the EU and lost, David Cameron, has said that joining would lead to major problems for a long period and is not in Britain’s interests.
The Financial Services sector have warned against dynamic alignment (accepting EU regulation) as this would destroy the Brexit benefits accrued so far. The Food and Drink federation have highlighted that linking with the self serving and protectionist EU would damage British producers. Even the CBI have warned against the disruption of joining the EU.
This week the most recent report of the Independent Business Network (IBN) reflects why family businesses, including sole traders and Entrepreneurs (85% off all businesses) do not want a reset less still to join the EU , a very different EU to that of 2016.
The campaign group , “Stay Out” have estimated the cost to the U.K. would be £750 million per week , over £39 billion per annum and these figures tally with other groups.
Brexit Britain is well placed to be leaders in AI, Financial and related services, Biotech and extraction industries, all of which would be quashed by an over regulated and protectionist EU. The EU would require all businesses to comply whether or not they export to the EU. As for the reset only 1.3% of all exports are food and agriculture going to the EU.
We now have trade deals with fast growing economies and some old friends like NZ whose trade with the U.K. has grown by around 16%. The application of tariffs to protect EU producers would not only kill these deals but also increase the cost of living for consumers.
On the other side the only arguments repeatedly deployed are two fold. That we can have a seat at the top table in the EU, a useless figment given the EU is in sharp relative decline and we have no veto. We become a slave of the EU machine. Secondly that a bunch of random, out of date financial figures have been floated suggesting, theoretically, that the economy could have been 4 or 8 % larger had we not had Brexit.
These forecast figures do not pass the “smell test” as they would have required unbelievable , super growth. The famous economist, Galbraith once said that “The only function of economic forecasting is to make astrology look respectable.”. By contrast the real world figures show the U.K. economy to have grown faster post Brexit, than the Eurozone, than Germany and than France who are “basket cases” riven with major political unrest.
| Resource | 2016 (£bn) | 2028 Projection (£bn) |
|---|---|---|
| Customs duties | 3.32 | 5.50 |
| VAT-based resource | 2.67 | 4.75 |
| Unrecycled plastic packaging | n/a | 0.85 |
| Emissions trading (ETS1) | n/a | 0.58 |
| Carbon border adjustment | n/a | 0.14 |
| Uncollected electrical waste | n/a | 2.31 |
| Tobacco excise (TEDOR) | n/a | 0.35 |
| Corporate resource (CORE) | n/a | 1.17 |
| GNI-based resource | 13.12 | 23.65 |
| Total gross contribution | 19.11 | 39.30 |
| Gross contribution per week | 0.36 (~£350m) | 0.76 (~£750m) |
Source: StayOut (figures in £ billions).
And then there is the most important thing of all, our democracy, the rule of law and the ability to determine our own future, making our own decisions. Something the dictatorial Mr Burnham would have us give up.
PM Burnham has said he wishes to take us back to a fictitious golden age of the 1970’s. The horrendous decade of IMF bailouts, Union power, strikes, the three day week with power cuts, Britain in decline and joining the EU based on a lie. “Eyelash Andy” had better be careful what wishes for.
Since joining the EU now would be insanity, it is most puzzling as to why “Bambi Burnham” wants to join the EU, starting with the sneaky and damaging reset?
Is it a personal characteristic? Like “Bambi” he seems to want to be loved , even if the price of this is payed for by the rest of us.
Or is he playing to the gallery, fearful of his own backbench, Marxist MPs? Why does he want to give away self determination and control and impoverish people?
Whatever his reasoning it all points to a very weak and narcissistic individual. The entire future of our country is to be decided by an unelected PM, with no mandate. If it were France we would call it a Coup.
John Longworth is an entrepreneur and Businessman, Chairman of the Independent Business Network of family businesses and a former MEP
Andy Burnham’s Blind EU Giveaway Will Cost Us Our Money and Our Democracy
Andy Burnham’s plans to rebuild Britain’s relationship with the European Union have triggered a growing political debate about money, national sovereignty and democratic accountability. The Prime Minister insists that closer cooperation with Brussels could improve economic growth, reduce trade barriers and help British businesses. However, critics are questioning whether the potential benefits justify the financial commitments and regulatory obligations that could accompany a closer relationship with the EU.
The controversy comes as Burnham prepares for another important round of discussions with European leaders. His ambition to move Britain closer to Brussels has raised concerns among Brexit supporters, who fear that the Government could gradually reverse the country’s decision to leave the European Union without giving voters a direct say.
For many people, Brexit was about more than trade agreements. It was about restoring democratic control, protecting national sovereignty and ensuring that important decisions affecting Britain were made by British institutions. Any proposal that could change this relationship deserves serious examination.
Billions of pounds and questions about public money
One of the biggest concerns surrounding closer EU cooperation is the potential financial cost.
The Government has promoted several proposed agreements covering food and agricultural trade, energy cooperation, emissions trading and opportunities for young people to live and work in Europe.
Ministers argue that these arrangements could deliver substantial economic benefits. Government estimates suggest that a proposed food and agricultural agreement could add up to £5.1 billion annually to the economy, while cooperation on carbon markets could generate benefits worth up to £3.8 billion a year.
However, these are projected economic benefits rather than guaranteed savings or additional money immediately available to taxpayers.
There are also questions about the financial obligations associated with individual agreements. Participation in certain European programmes can involve contributions from the British Government, while other arrangements may require administrative payments or regulatory adjustments.
The Government says the current package would not involve contributions to the EU budget beyond administrative costs. Nevertheless, any future financial commitments must be clearly explained before agreements are finalised.
British taxpayers deserve to know exactly how much public money is involved, where it will go and what the country will receive in return.
Is Burnham quietly changing the meaning of Brexit?
Another major concern involves the political direction of Burnham’s European strategy.
The Prime Minister has repeatedly criticised the existing Brexit arrangements, arguing that Britain ended up with a harder departure than many voters expected in 2016.
He has also suggested that the country should have an honest national discussion about its long-term relationship with the European Union.
Burnham has indicated that he would personally welcome Britain rejoining the EU during his lifetime, although he has said that the public must decide the country’s future direction.
These comments have inevitably attracted attention.
For Brexit supporters, the concern is that a series of individual agreements could gradually bring Britain closer to European institutions without a clear national debate about the overall destination.
Supporters of Burnham’s approach reject this interpretation. They argue that closer cooperation does not automatically mean rejoining the EU and that Britain can improve trade and diplomatic relations while remaining independent.
The distinction is important. Cooperation with European countries is not the same as EU membership.
Nevertheless, ministers should be transparent about their long-term ambitions rather than leaving voters to interpret their intentions through political speeches.
What happens to Britain’s democratic control?
National sovereignty is one of the most important issues in the debate.
When Britain was a member of the European Union, certain decisions were made through shared European institutions. Following Brexit, the UK regained the ability to establish independent policies in several areas.
However, closer economic cooperation can involve accepting common standards and regulatory obligations.
For example, agreements designed to simplify food and agricultural trade may require Britain to maintain particular standards and procedures. This could make exporting easier, but it could also limit the Government’s freedom to change certain rules independently.
The important question is whether the economic benefits justify those commitments.
Parliament must have meaningful opportunities to examine agreements and understand their long-term consequences.
Democratic accountability should not disappear simply because ministers believe an international agreement would be economically beneficial.
The danger of regulatory alignment
Regulatory alignment has become one of the most contentious parts of Britain’s relationship with Brussels.
Supporters argue that following compatible standards can reduce paperwork, simplify trade and make it easier for British businesses to access European markets.
This is particularly relevant for farmers, food manufacturers and smaller exporters that have struggled with additional procedures since Brexit.
However, critics worry that accepting European regulations without having an equivalent role in shaping them could leave Britain following decisions made elsewhere.
This is sometimes described as a democratic deficit.
The Government must explain how future agreements would operate, whether Britain would have opportunities to influence relevant standards and what would happen if Parliament wanted to change domestic regulations.
Without clear answers, concerns about regulatory independence are unlikely to disappear.
British businesses need answers too
Burnham’s strongest argument for closer European relations is economic growth.
The European Union remains one of Britain’s most important trading partners, and thousands of businesses depend on customers and suppliers across Europe.
Since Brexit, additional customs procedures and administrative requirements have created difficulties for some exporters.
Smaller companies can be particularly affected because they often lack the financial resources and specialist staff needed to manage complicated international regulations.
Reducing unnecessary trade barriers could therefore offer genuine advantages.
However, businesses also need certainty.
If companies are expected to adapt to new regulations, pay additional fees or change their operating procedures, they need sufficient time and clear information.
The Government should publish detailed assessments explaining how the proposed agreements would affect different industries.
Economic growth should be measured through actual investment, employment, productivity and export performance rather than optimistic political forecasts.
Immigration remains part of the wider debate
Closer relations with the EU have also raised questions about immigration.
The Government has ruled out restoring general freedom of movement under its immediate policy commitments. However, discussions about a youth mobility arrangement have attracted attention because they could create additional opportunities for eligible young people to live, study and work across borders.
Supporters believe such arrangements could benefit education, tourism and employment opportunities.
Critics argue that ministers must explain the eligibility requirements, duration and potential impact on migration figures.
Britain needs an immigration system that supports economic growth while ensuring that housing, healthcare and public services have sufficient capacity.
Any future agreement must therefore be examined carefully rather than presented as an automatic benefit.
Opposition parties demand greater transparency
Burnham’s European ambitions have created opportunities for opposition parties to challenge the Government.
Nigel Farage and Reform UK have consistently argued that Britain should protect its independence and resist attempts to restore European political influence.
The Conservatives have also questioned the financial and regulatory consequences of closer cooperation.
Their criticism reflects wider concerns among voters who believe that the Government should prioritise domestic spending, public services and national economic development.
However, supporters of the EU reset argue that refusing to cooperate more closely could leave British businesses facing unnecessary costs and administrative barriers.
Both arguments raise important questions about Britain’s future.
The Government should respond by publishing evidence, explaining the financial commitments and allowing Parliament to scrutinise the agreements.
What should Burnham do before signing anything?
In my opinion, any major agreement with the European Union should meet several basic requirements.
First, the Government should publish a complete financial assessment, including direct payments, administrative costs and potential long-term obligations.
Second, ministers should explain precisely which European rules Britain would be expected to follow and whether Parliament would retain the ability to amend domestic legislation.
Third, independent economic assessments should examine whether projected benefits are realistic and which industries are most likely to gain.
Fourth, any agreement involving immigration or employment opportunities should include clear eligibility rules and transparent reporting.
Finally, Parliament and the public should have sufficient opportunities to examine significant changes before they become permanent commitments.
These safeguards would help ensure that closer cooperation is based on Britain’s national interests rather than political convenience.
Conclusion
Andy Burnham’s plans to rebuild Britain’s relationship with the European Union have opened another major debate about public money, national sovereignty and democratic accountability.
Closer cooperation could offer important economic opportunities, particularly for exporters, farmers and businesses struggling with additional trading barriers. However, these potential benefits must be weighed against financial commitments, regulatory obligations and the implications for Britain’s ability to make independent decisions.
The Government must not assume that voters will automatically support every agreement simply because ministers describe it as an economic improvement.
British taxpayers deserve transparency about financial contributions, while Parliament must retain meaningful oversight of international commitments.
Ultimately, Britain does not have to choose between complete isolation and surrendering its independence. It can maintain constructive relationships with European neighbours while protecting democratic accountability and national interests.
Burnham’s responsibility is to demonstrate that every proposed agreement delivers genuine benefits and represents a fair deal for the British public. Before taking Britain further towards Brussels, he must provide clear answers about the money involved, the rules Britain may have to follow and the powers that Parliament will retain. These are questions that cannot simply be dismissed as political opposition. They go to the heart of how Britain should be governed and who should have the final say over its future.
