
Andy Burnham has been issued a warning over rejoining the EU (Image: Getty)
Andy Burnham has been warned rejoining the EU could force Britain to take in thousands of extra migrants a year or pay millions of pounds instead. Pro-Brexit campaigners fear the UK would have to sign up to the bloc’s asylum solitary scheme.
Britain would have to accept around 4,400 asylum seekers annually or cough up £76 million under the policy, according to analysis by the Stay Out group.
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage said: “More mass migration madness is the very last thing we need. This would be another catastrophic Brexit betrayal from the establishment.
“If Open Borders Burnham wants a battle over open-door immigration – I say bring it on. I will fight this tooth and nail.”

Nigel Farage has vowed to fight Andy Burnham’s bid to reverse Brexit (Image: Getty)
The EU’s asylum solidarity scheme states that members must take in asylum seekers from countries on the frontline of the crisis or pay a set amount for every place declined.
Tory Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp said: “It would be a betrayal of the British people if the Government signed up to take in any of Europe’s illegal immigrants or handed over any of our hard-earned money for no reason.
“The Government has created enough problems here without taking on Europe’s as well. There is a solution to illegal immigration in the UK’s hands without needing a deal with Europe – the Conservative BORDERS plan.
“This sees us leave the European Convention on Human Rights so illegal immigrants can be rapidly deported to their country of origin or a safe third country outside Europe, like Rwanda.
“We are putting these ideas to a vote in Parliament on Tuesday – but I bet Lib Dem and Labour MPs will vote against it.”
Britain’s share of migrants under the EU programme would be 4,444 people a year which would fill 47 asylum hotels, according to the analysis.
The alternative is a payment of £17,000 for every person rejected, which would amount to £75.6 million a year or almost £1.5 million a week, the research said.
If the UK refused it would risk fines from the European Court of Justice.
It comes as almost 25,000 small boat migrants have made the dangerous Channel crossing so far this year.
Stay Out, which has been launched by figures from the 2016 Vote Leave campaign, has also suggested that the UK’s annual payments to the EU’s budget could be an eye-watering £750 million a week if the country rejoins.
The campaign group’s chairman and former deputy chief Brexit negotiator for the
UK, Oliver Lewis, said: “Andy Burnham wants to rejoin the EU without telling the public it would mean thousands more asylum seekers sent here from Southern Europe every year, enough to fill dozens more hotels, on top of a £750 million a week membership fee.
“If we refuse to accept whatever number Brussels decides, Britain would face a bill of almost £1.5 million a week.
“There would be no veto, no opt-out and no end date, and the bill would rise whenever other European countries voted to raise it.”
The warning comes as Andy Burnham is heading to Brussels on Friday to meet EU leaders at a joint summit.
The Prime Minister is set to sign a series of agreements on food and farming, emissions trading and youth mobility which he insists will help ease the cost of living and boost the economy.
He is also looking at options for the long-term future relationship with the bloc and has not ruled out rejoining.
Arch-Brexiteer Mr Farage is also travelling to Brussels at the same time to rail against Mr Burnham’s plans.
The Prime Minister has reignited the EU debate despite pledging not to “re-run” Brexit arguments when standing in the crunch by-election in Leave-voting Makerfield earlier this year.
But any major changes will have to come after the next general election as Mr Burnham has committed to Labour’s manifesto “red lines” not to return to the single market, customs union or freedom of movement.
Mr Burnham, who campaigned for Remain at the 2016 referendum, has insisted voters will be “the boss” of any changes.
But the Prime Minister opening the door to Britain rejoining the EU has proved controversial.
Splits have emerged in his Cabinet, while there is also disquiet from some Labour MPs.
And in a bombshell intervention last week, former Tory premier David Cameron, who fronted the Remain campaign, warned that returning to the club would be “long and painful”.
He also insisted that the UK’s economic problems are down to “overspending, over-borrowing, over-taxing, over-regulated, and far too much being spent on working age welfare” rather than the departure from the EU.
Speaking over the weekend at the Welsh Labour conference, Mr Burnham claimed Britain has “lost more than we gained” in the decade since the referendum.
He said: “I think the Conservatives gave Britain a harsher and harder Brexit than people thought they were getting when they voted in 2016, because they burned all of our bridges in the aftermath, with the EU, and so I’m going to lead as Prime Minister on this issue.”
He added: “But at the same time respecting the red lines in our manifesto and respecting the referendum, the referendum result. So, that’s the spirit, everybody, that I will take forward.”
A Government spokesperson said: “The Brexit deal that was negotiated by the previous Government was not good enough for Britain. It has damaged our economy and weakened our control over immigration. That was not what was promised.
“The UK-EU summit is about working to improve a bad Brexit deal, negotiating to bring down prices for consumers and cut costs for businesses. The manifesto red lines will remain – no return to the Customs Union, the Single Market or freedom of movement in this Parliament.
“Under this Government, net migration is down by 82% since its peak in 2023. The Home Secretary is implementing the most sweeping reforms to our immigration system in modern times. More than 80,000 people with no right to be in the UK have been removed or returned since the election.”
Andy Burnham Warned Rejoining the EU Could Force the UK to Accept Thousands More Migrants Every Year
A fresh political storm is developing in Britain after Prime Minister Andy Burnham was warned that bringing the United Kingdom back into the European Union could mean accepting thousands of additional asylum seekers every year.
The warning has reignited the immigration debate and raised serious questions about what rejoining the EU could mean for Britain’s borders, public services and taxpayers.
According to analysis commissioned by the pro-Brexit campaign group Stay Out, Britain could be expected to accept approximately 4,444 asylum seekers annually under the EU’s asylum solidarity scheme. Alternatively, the country could be required to make a financial contribution estimated at £75.6 million per year.
The figures have attracted considerable political attention, particularly as Burnham has opened the door to discussing Britain’s long-term relationship with Brussels.
Thousands More Asylum Seekers?
The central concern involves the EU’s asylum solidarity mechanism, which is designed to share responsibility for migration pressures between member states.
Countries facing particularly high numbers of asylum applications can receive assistance from other EU members.
Under the system, participating countries may contribute by accepting asylum seekers, providing financial assistance or offering other forms of support.
Stay Out estimates that Britain’s potential annual share could amount to 4,444 asylum seekers.
The campaign group argues that this could create additional pressure on accommodation, immigration services and local authorities.
Its analysis also estimates that refusing relocation places could result in payments of approximately £17,000 per person, potentially reaching £75.6 million annually.
These figures are campaign-group estimates rather than an agreed financial obligation for the United Kingdom. The precise arrangements would depend on the terms of any future British membership and applicable EU rules.
Nigel Farage Launches Fresh Attack
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has strongly criticised the possibility of Britain participating in the EU’s migration arrangements.
He said:
“More mass migration madness is the very last thing we need. This would be another catastrophic Brexit betrayal from the establishment.”
Farage also challenged Burnham directly, saying:
“If Open Borders Burnham wants a battle over open-door immigration – I say bring it on. I will fight this tooth and nail.”
His comments demonstrate how immigration could become one of the central issues in any future debate about Britain’s relationship with Europe.
Reform UK argues that the country should maintain control over its immigration system rather than accepting arrangements negotiated at European level.
Conservative Party Also Raises Concerns
The proposals have also attracted criticism from Conservative politicians.
Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp warned that Britain should not be required to accept asylum seekers from other European countries or make additional payments under the EU solidarity mechanism.
He argued that the government should prioritise controlling immigration through domestic policies.
The Conservatives have also promoted their own proposals for changing Britain’s approach to illegal immigration and international human rights arrangements.
What Has Andy Burnham Actually Said?
Burnham has argued that Brexit has damaged Britain’s economic position and that the country needs a more effective relationship with the European Union.
He has described the current Brexit arrangements as inadequate and suggested that Britain should have an honest discussion about its long-term future.
However, he has not committed the government to immediately rejoining the EU.
He has also said that he does not intend to push ahead of public opinion.
The government maintains that its current manifesto commitments remain in place, including no return to the EU Single Market, Customs Union or freedom of movement during this parliamentary term.
This distinction is important because closer cooperation with Brussels does not automatically mean full EU membership.
Could Britain’s Immigration System Change Again?
The debate raises important questions about the future of British immigration policy.
Since Brexit, the UK has operated an independent immigration system, allowing the government to establish its own rules for work visas, settlement and border controls.
Returning to the EU would involve negotiating new membership terms and addressing questions surrounding free movement, asylum responsibilities and the country’s participation in European institutions.
It would not automatically mean that every existing EU migration arrangement would apply in exactly the same way to Britain.
Nevertheless, any decision to pursue full membership would require detailed negotiations over these issues.
For ordinary British citizens, the consequences could affect housing, public services, government spending and local communities.
The Cost to British Taxpayers
Another major concern is the financial impact.
The Stay Out analysis estimates that the alternative to accepting 4,444 asylum seekers could involve payments of approximately £75.6 million annually.
That figure has prompted questions about whether British taxpayers should contribute towards managing migration pressures elsewhere in Europe.
Supporters of closer European cooperation argue that shared responsibility can help countries manage migration more effectively and prevent disproportionate pressure on individual states.
Opponents argue that Britain should retain control over its own immigration decisions and spending priorities.
Both positions raise important questions about the balance between international cooperation and national sovereignty.
Britain Faces a Major Political Debate
The argument over rejoining the EU is no longer simply about trade agreements and economic growth.
Immigration, border security, asylum policy and financial contributions are becoming central parts of the discussion.
Burnham has indicated that Brexit deserves a fresh assessment after a decade outside the European Union.
However, any major change would require public support, political agreement and negotiations with Brussels.
For now, the government says its existing commitments remain unchanged.
The big question is whether Britain should consider returning to a European system that could involve shared responsibility for asylum seekers, or maintain an independent immigration policy outside the EU.
🇬🇧 What do you think? Should Britain accept thousands of additional asylum seekers under a potential EU membership agreement, or should the country maintain full control over its own immigration system?
Would rejoining the EU bring economic benefits that justify these possible obligations, or should Britain focus on strengthening its own borders and public services?
Share your opinion in the comments!
