
Andy Burnham faced Commonwealth leaders who want the legacy of slavery addressed (Image: Victoria Jones/Shutterstock)
The push for reparations for Britain’s role in the slave trade has been compared to a “cynical and mercenary shakedown” by the UK’s former ambassador to Saudi Arabia. Sir John Jenkins, who was also the Foreign Office’s director for the Middle East and North Africa, warns that Andy Burnham’s openness to giving an apology “will only encourage those who believe that Britain is now more likely to pay up”.
In a new report for the Policy Exchange think tank he condemns Britain’s “culture of capitulation” and warns that its readiness to back down has emboldened adversaries. Mr Burnham has said he is “open” to an apology for the slave trade but resisted calls for reparations. A major study suggested in 2023 that the UK should pay £18.8trillion for its involvement in slavery in 14 countries. The former top diplomat blasts calls for reparations in his report, stating: “Even the most casual observer might be forgiven for thinking all this simply represents a cynical and mercenary shakedown of a guilt-ridden West by professional grievance entrepreneurs.”

Andy Burnham has said he is open to the idea of an apology but critics are alarmed (Image: Chris Jackson/Press Association)
Sir John, who was also an ambassador to Iraq, said claims made in support of reparations “range from the ignorant to the bizarre”. He writes: “Equally bizarre to many observers is the claim that people alive today who have no personal connection to the slave trade should pay money to people who claim injury in the present as a result of descent from those enslaved several centuries ago.”
The former diplomat accuses the Prime Minister of “misplaced optimism” for thinking “an apology and a ‘structured dialogue’ will deter calls for slavery reparations”. Sir John warns that Britain risks doing modern equivalent of “paying the Danegeld” – the protection money paid to Vikings. He cites further examples of Britain caving-in to demands which go against its national interest, including the deal to hand control of the Chagos Islands to Mauritius and the agreement to release terrorists as part of the Northern Ireland peace process.
Professor John Bew, who advised four prime ministers on foreign policy, warns in the foreword to the report that Britain diplomacy is too often seen as the “soothing of tensions rather than than the art of getting your own way”.
Former Home Secretary and Reform UK Suella Braverman responded to the report, saying: “Britain played a leading role in abolishing slavery and spent huge sums of money stamping it out across the world… We will not apologise or make taxpayers pay for the actions of those before us centuries ago. Giving into these demands shows weakness, not leadership.”
Andy Burnham Warned Over Slavery Apology – ‘He’ll Be Asked for Money Next’
Andy Burnham has been drawn into an increasingly heated political debate over Britain’s historical responsibility for slavery, with critics warning that an apology could open the door to demands for financial reparations.
The controversy has raised difficult questions about Britain’s colonial past, the responsibilities of modern governments and whether taxpayers should be expected to pay compensation for historical injustices committed centuries ago.
Supporters of an official apology argue that acknowledging the suffering caused by slavery is an important step towards historical honesty and reconciliation. However, opponents fear that expressions of regret could eventually become the starting point for substantial financial claims against the British government.
The warning that Burnham could soon face demands for money has added another dimension to an already sensitive political issue.
For the Prime Minister, the challenge is to acknowledge historical suffering without making commitments that could have significant financial and legal consequences for future generations.
1. Why Andy Burnham Is Facing Pressure Over Slavery
The debate over Britain’s historical involvement in slavery has returned to the political spotlight following renewed calls for European governments to acknowledge their historical responsibilities.
Britain played a significant role in the transatlantic slave trade, with British merchants, shipping companies and plantation owners participating in a system that forcibly transported millions of Africans across the Atlantic.
Although Parliament abolished the British slave trade in 1807, slavery itself continued in most British colonies until the Slavery Abolition Act of 1833 began taking effect in 1834.
The historical consequences were enormous.
Enslaved people endured forced labour, family separation, violence and systematic denial of their basic freedoms.
The economic benefits of slavery also contributed to the development of British commercial interests and industries.
Supporters of an official apology argue that the government should recognise these historical realities and acknowledge the suffering experienced by enslaved people and their descendants.
However, critics question whether a modern government should accept responsibility for events that occurred under political and economic systems that no longer exist.
2. The Warning: An Apology Could Lead to Demands for Money
The most controversial aspect of the debate concerns the possibility of reparations.
Critics have warned that an official apology could strengthen demands for financial compensation from Britain.
They argue that once a government formally acknowledges responsibility, campaigners may use that statement to support calls for payments, development funding or other forms of compensation.
The phrase, ‘He’ll be asked for money next’, captures the central concern among opponents of reparations.
They fear that an apology could become the first stage of a much larger financial commitment.
However, an apology does not automatically create a legal obligation to pay compensation.
Any reparations proposal would involve separate political, legal and financial considerations.
The government would need to explain who might qualify, how payments would be calculated and which institutions would be responsible for funding them.
These questions remain highly contentious.
3. Why Reparations Have Become an International Issue
The reparations debate is not limited to Britain.
Caribbean governments and international campaigners have spent years demanding greater recognition of the long-term consequences of slavery and colonial exploitation.
The Caribbean Community, commonly known as CARICOM, established a reparations commission to coordinate its campaign.
Its reparatory justice programme includes calls for formal apologies, educational initiatives, healthcare investment, debt relief and economic development.
Campaigners argue that slavery did not simply end when abolition legislation was introduced.
They maintain that its economic and social consequences continued through generations of discrimination, unequal land ownership and restricted economic opportunities.
They also argue that European governments and institutions benefited from historical exploitation.
Opponents respond that establishing direct financial responsibility across generations is extremely complicated.
They question how modern taxpayers should be held accountable for actions committed by people who lived centuries ago.
4. Britain Has Already Faced a Difficult Historical Legacy
Britain’s involvement in slavery remains an important subject of historical debate.
The abolition of slavery in the British Empire was a major legal development, but the financial arrangements surrounding abolition remain controversial.
Under the 1833 legislation, the British government agreed to pay £20 million in compensation to slave owners.
The money was intended to compensate owners for the loss of their legally recognised property interests.
Enslaved people received no equivalent financial compensation for the years of forced labour and suffering they had endured.
The compensation scheme represented approximately 40 per cent of the government’s annual public expenditure at the time.
The debt associated with this compensation was not fully repaid until 2015.
This historical example is frequently cited by reparations campaigners, who argue that the British state financially compensated slave owners while leaving formerly enslaved people without comparable support.
For critics of modern reparations, however, the historical circumstances do not establish an automatic obligation for present-day taxpayers.
5. Supporters Say an Apology Is About Recognition, Not Compensation
Those calling for an official apology argue that acknowledging historical wrongdoing should not automatically be interpreted as accepting unlimited financial liability.
They believe a government can express regret for slavery while maintaining a separate discussion about the appropriate forms of historical reconciliation.
An apology, they argue, would demonstrate respect for the victims and their descendants.
It could also provide an opportunity to improve education about Britain’s colonial history.
Supporters believe that recognising the past is essential to understanding present-day inequalities.
They also argue that Britain should engage constructively with Caribbean countries rather than dismissing their concerns.
For these campaigners, the issue is not simply about money.
It concerns historical recognition, dignity and the responsibility of institutions to acknowledge the consequences of their actions.
6. Critics Warn Against Opening the Door to Unlimited Financial Claims
Opponents of reparations have raised concerns about the potential cost to British taxpayers.
They argue that the government already faces substantial financial pressures involving the NHS, social care, pensions, housing and national defence.
At a time when public services are struggling to meet demand, they question whether ministers should consider additional financial commitments relating to historical events.
There are also questions about fairness.
Who would receive compensation?
Would payments go to individuals, governments or charitable organisations?
How would eligibility be determined?
Would other countries and institutions also be expected to contribute?
These questions demonstrate the practical difficulties associated with reparations.
Critics argue that without clear answers, politicians risk creating expectations that cannot realistically be fulfilled.
They also warn that financial discussions could overshadow more constructive efforts to improve international relationships and address present-day inequalities.
7. What Could an Apology Actually Mean for Britain?
An official apology could take several different forms.
It might involve a parliamentary statement acknowledging Britain’s historical role in the slave trade.
Alternatively, the government could support educational projects, memorials and historical research.
There could also be discussions about development partnerships with Caribbean countries.
These options would have different financial and political consequences.
A formal apology would not necessarily involve compensation payments, and any financial programme would require separate decisions.
Burnham would therefore need to clarify precisely what an apology would mean and whether it would involve any commitment to financial reparations.
The public would also expect Parliament to examine the issue carefully before significant taxpayer money was committed.
8. Labour Must Balance Historical Responsibility With Economic Reality
The debate creates a difficult political challenge for Labour.
Burnham has attempted to position himself as a leader who believes in international cooperation, social justice and rebuilding Britain’s relationships with countries around the world.
However, his government must also consider the financial pressures facing British households.
An additional financial commitment, particularly one involving billions of pounds, would inevitably attract scrutiny.
Opposition politicians could argue that Labour was prioritising historical compensation over the immediate needs of people living in Britain.
Reform UK and Conservative politicians may also use the issue to question the government’s priorities.
For Burnham, the most important consideration will be ensuring that any decision is based on careful examination rather than political pressure.
He must distinguish between acknowledging historical injustice and agreeing to specific financial obligations.
9. The Public Deserves a Clear Answer
Ultimately, British voters deserve transparency about the government’s position.
If ministers support an apology, they should explain what form it would take.
If they oppose reparations, they should explain why.
If they are considering financial assistance or development programmes, they should publish the estimated costs and explain how the money would be spent.
This is particularly important because historical responsibility is an emotionally sensitive issue involving millions of people.
The debate should not be reduced to political slogans or accusations.
Britain can acknowledge its historical involvement in slavery while still having a serious discussion about the appropriate response in the modern world.
Equally, taxpayers have a legitimate interest in knowing whether political statements could lead to substantial public spending commitments.
Conclusion: An Apology Could Create a Much Bigger Political Battle
Andy Burnham’s position on Britain’s historical responsibility for slavery could become another difficult political issue for his government.
Supporters of an apology believe Britain should acknowledge the suffering caused by the transatlantic slave trade and engage constructively with countries still affected by its historical consequences.
Critics, however, warn that an apology could encourage demands for financial reparations and create additional pressure on already stretched public finances.
The distinction between acknowledging historical wrongdoing and accepting a financial obligation is crucial.
An apology does not automatically mean that compensation must follow.
Nevertheless, the government must be clear about its intentions and avoid making statements that could create confusion about future commitments.
Britain’s history deserves honest examination, and the suffering of enslaved people should never be dismissed.
At the same time, any proposal involving public money must be transparent, carefully considered and subject to democratic scrutiny.
The question facing Burnham is not simply whether Britain should apologise.
It is whether his government can address an important historical issue without creating another major financial and political controversy.
