Andy Burnham Suffers Major Setback as Makerfield Voters Reject Brexit Betrayal Plan . HYN

Andy Burnham shortly after his Makerfield by-election win

Andy Burnham shortly after his Makerfield by-election win (Image: Getty)

Andy Burnham’s Makerfield voters are firmly opposed to handing new powers to the EU, new polling shows. With less than two weeks before the Prime Minister attends a major Brussels summit, his plans to bring the UK back under EU rule have been roundly rejected by his own constituents. Eight in ten say the UK should make its own decisions on state aid to grow regional economies, and 78% say the UK government alone should make its own decisions about VAT rates.

Burnham says it is 'clear' Russia interfered with Brexit referendum

The survey found 75% believe the UK should set its own employment laws and 74% believe only the British government should make decisions about food standards. These are all policy areas where Labour is expected to hand some control back to the EU, either as part of the forthcoming reset, which is expected to include UK firms obeying EU food regulations, or as part of Mr Burnham’s long-term plan to develop a new relationship with the EU, such as re-joining the single market.

Breakingviews - A roadmap for Andy Burnham to reverse Brexit | Reuters

The poll deliberately did not mention the EU, in order to break voters out of so-called Brexit “tribes” Instead, it asked voters where they believed decisions should be made. In every case, a clear majority of the voters polled in Makerfield said policy should be decided by UK governments alone.

Mr Burnham returned to Parliament in June after winning a by-election in the North West constituency. He said at the time that every policy of his government would need to pass a “Makerfield test” to ensure it was considered acceptable to the people of Makerfield and similar parts of the country.

Burnham's Makerfield constituents reject EU surrender

The polling was conducted by Britain Unbound, which is calling for the UK to make the most of Brexit freedoms rather then rejoining the Single Market or the EU.

Jonathan Hinder, Labour MP for Pendle and Clitheroe, said: “Voters in Labour’s heartlands are clear that they do not support signing up to rules we have no say over and enforced by courts we do not control. They want UK governments to be free to decide these policies for ourselves.”

Conservative peer Lord Redwood, co-chair of Britain Unbound, said: “Makerfield voters reject giving away our hard won right to self-government to the EU and ignoring the results of the 2016 Referendum.

“They were promised the Makerfield test for any policy change. Yet a few months on, the Burnham Government is proposing the opposite of what they voted for.”

Makerfield: Labour's Andy Burnham wins important by-election in north-west England - BBC Newsround

“Giving away our powers of self-government, and offering to pay the EU a load of money as well, fails Mr Burnham’s Makerfield test. A decisive poll shows more than two-thirds of Makerfield voters oppose giving away any lawmaking and taxraising over us to the EU. The proposed reset is a surrender to the EU that voters do not want.”

Other issues which voters believed should be decided in the UK included “buy British” rules, energy policy, animal welfare and medicine approval for the NHS.

Andy Burnham backtracks on Brexit as he makes leadership pitch

Andy Burnham Suffers Major Setback as Makerfield Voters Reject Brexit Betrayal Plan

Prime Minister Andy Burnham is facing renewed political pressure after a new poll revealed strong opposition among voters in his own Makerfield constituency to transferring important policy-making powers to European Union institutions. The findings have reignited Britain’s Brexit debate and raised questions about whether the Prime Minister’s plans for closer relations with Brussels are consistent with the promises he made to the people who elected him.

The controversy is particularly sensitive because Burnham previously promised that his government’s policies would have to pass what he described as the “Makerfield test”. His argument was that national decisions should improve the lives of ordinary people, particularly those living in communities that have often felt overlooked by Westminster.

However, new research suggests that many voters in his constituency want Britain to retain independent control over important domestic decisions. The results have provided ammunition for opponents of closer European integration, who argue that Labour risks ignoring the views of communities that strongly supported Brexit in 2016.

For Burnham, the political challenge is considerable. He must balance his ambition to rebuild economic relations with Europe against the expectations of voters who want greater national control over British laws and policies.

A major warning from Burnham’s own constituency

The latest controversy follows polling commissioned by Britain Unbound and conducted by Survation among residents of Makerfield.

The research examined who voters believed should make decisions about important areas of British policy. Rather than directly asking whether respondents supported Brexit or closer relations with the European Union, the survey focused on the principle of where political authority should rest.

The results showed that substantial majorities preferred decisions to be made independently by the UK Government.

Among the findings:

  • 80 per cent believed decisions about state aid for regional development should be made by the UK Government alone.
  • 78 per cent wanted Britain to retain control over VAT rates.
  • 75 per cent believed employment laws should be determined domestically.
  • 75 per cent supported domestic control over decisions concerning the refusal of entry to criminals.
  • 74 per cent wanted British authorities to determine food standards.
  • 69 per cent favoured domestic control over animal welfare standards.
  • 67 per cent believed decisions about medicine approvals for the NHS should remain with British authorities.

Across all ten policy areas examined, between 67 and 80 per cent supported domestic decision-making.

Only small minorities, ranging from approximately 2 to 12 per cent depending on the issue, preferred following decisions made by international institutions.

These findings have been presented by Britain Unbound as evidence that Burnham’s proposed European reset could conflict with the political preferences of his own constituents.

However, the research should be interpreted carefully. It measured attitudes towards where decisions should be made, rather than asking whether respondents supported every individual aspect of the government’s proposed relationship with the EU.

It therefore does not establish that all Makerfield voters oppose closer cooperation with European countries.

The Makerfield test comes back to haunt Labour

The phrase “Makerfield test” has become an important part of Burnham’s political identity.

When he returned to Parliament through the Makerfield by-election in June 2026, he emphasised the importance of ensuring that government decisions worked for ordinary communities.

He suggested that policies should be judged according to whether they improved people’s lives and opportunities.

This message was particularly important in a constituency that had strongly supported leaving the European Union in the 2016 referendum.

Makerfield voted approximately 65 per cent in favour of Brexit, demonstrating the strength of support for national sovereignty and political independence in the area.

Burnham therefore faces an uncomfortable political question: can his plans for closer European relations genuinely pass the test he promised his constituents?

Opponents argue that transferring authority over taxation, employment legislation and food regulations to European institutions would contradict the principle of domestic accountability.

They believe voters should not be expected to accept rules made by institutions over which they have limited direct control.

Labour supporters, however, may argue that cooperation with European countries does not necessarily mean abandoning British sovereignty.

The distinction between negotiating common standards and surrendering domestic decision-making powers is likely to become a central part of the political debate.

Opposition politicians seize the opportunity

The latest findings have provided Conservative politicians and Brexit campaigners with an opportunity to challenge Burnham’s European strategy.

Jonathan Hinder, Labour MP for Pendle and Clitheroe, has also expressed concerns about accepting rules that Britain would have limited ability to influence.

He argued that voters in traditional Labour communities do not necessarily support signing up to regulations imposed by institutions outside the United Kingdom.

Conservative peer Lord Redwood, co-chairman of Britain Unbound, criticised the government’s approach and argued that the results demonstrated strong support for national decision-making.

He maintained that British voters had been promised greater control over their country’s future during the Brexit referendum and should not see those responsibilities transferred elsewhere.

For opposition parties, the issue is not simply about European trade or economic cooperation. It concerns the meaning of Brexit and whether the government intends to preserve the political independence promised to voters.

Nevertheless, the opposition must also explain how Britain can cooperate effectively with its largest nearby trading partner while maintaining control over domestic policy.

Burnham’s European strategy faces difficult questions

Burnham has argued that Britain’s relationship with the European Union needs to improve.

His government believes that closer cooperation could reduce unnecessary trade barriers, improve economic opportunities and strengthen relationships with European partners.

Areas under discussion include food standards, agricultural trade, energy cooperation, emissions arrangements and opportunities for younger people to work and travel across Europe.

Supporters argue that these agreements could benefit British businesses without requiring the country to rejoin the European Union.

The Prime Minister has also indicated that Britain will not immediately return to the EU single market or customs union and will not restore unrestricted freedom of movement during the current parliamentary term.

However, critics remain concerned that regulatory alignment could gradually increase European influence over British domestic policy.

The controversy surrounding Makerfield demonstrates why the government needs to explain precisely what closer cooperation would involve.

Voters may support improved trade relations while opposing arrangements that require Britain to follow European regulations without sufficient influence over their development.

These are not necessarily contradictory positions.

Brexit still divides Makerfield

The political situation is more complicated than a simple division between Leave and Remain voters.

Makerfield’s support for Brexit in 2016 remains an important part of its political history. However, attitudes towards the economic consequences of leaving the European Union have evolved.

Earlier research conducted by UCL Policy Lab and More in Common in June 2026 found that 55 per cent of surveyed Makerfield residents said they would vote to rejoin the European Union in a hypothetical referendum, compared with 45 per cent who would vote to remain outside among respondents choosing between those two options.

That research also recorded positive personal favourability towards Burnham among 44 per cent of respondents, compared with 36 per cent who viewed him unfavourably.

These findings illustrate an important distinction: voters can support closer economic relations with Europe while still wanting Britain to retain control over its domestic laws.

The two surveys asked different questions and were conducted for different purposes. They should not be treated as directly contradictory measurements of the same political preference.

Indeed, the results suggest that public attitudes towards Brexit are more complicated than the traditional Leave and Remain labels.

Economic cooperation versus national sovereignty

One of the biggest challenges facing the government is explaining how Britain can benefit from European cooperation without undermining domestic decision-making.

Businesses operating across European markets often favour common standards because they reduce administrative costs and make international trade easier.

For example, closer alignment on food safety regulations could help British agricultural producers and food exporters avoid unnecessary border checks.

Similarly, cooperation on energy and environmental policy could create opportunities for investment and improve coordination between neighbouring countries.

However, there are concerns about the consequences of automatically adopting regulations developed by European institutions.

Critics argue that Britain should retain the flexibility to establish policies that reflect its own economic circumstances and regional priorities.

This debate also extends to state aid, employment legislation and taxation.

For many Brexit supporters, the ability to determine these policies independently was one of the central reasons for leaving the European Union.

The government therefore faces the difficult task of demonstrating that cooperation can deliver economic benefits without undermining the political independence that voters value.

Labour faces a growing political balancing act

The latest polling places Burnham in a difficult position.

He must reassure voters in traditional Labour communities that closer relations with Europe will not mean ignoring their concerns about sovereignty.

At the same time, he must explain why improved cooperation with the EU could help businesses, workers and households across Britain.

The political consequences could extend beyond Makerfield.

Other constituencies that voted strongly for Brexit may also be concerned about proposals involving European regulatory alignment.

Reform UK is likely to use these disagreements to strengthen its criticism of Labour, arguing that the government is moving away from the referendum result.

The Conservatives may also seek to attract voters who believe that Britain should retain greater independence over domestic legislation.

For Labour, the challenge is to prevent the European debate from overshadowing its wider economic and public-service priorities.

Conclusion: The Makerfield test creates a serious challenge for Burnham

The latest Survation polling has created a significant political challenge for Andy Burnham by highlighting strong support for domestic decision-making among residents of his constituency.

The findings suggest that many Makerfield voters remain attached to the principle of British sovereignty, particularly in areas such as taxation, employment law, food standards and regional economic policy.

For opponents of Labour’s European strategy, the results represent evidence that closer regulatory alignment could encounter resistance in traditional Leave-voting communities.

For the government, however, the findings should also serve as an opportunity to explain the practical differences between international cooperation and transferring political authority.

Burnham must demonstrate that his European policy can deliver tangible economic improvements while respecting the democratic expectations of the people he represents.

The central issue is not simply whether Britain should work more closely with Europe. It is how far that cooperation should extend and which decisions should remain under the control of British institutions.

The Prime Minister’s promise that government policies must pass the Makerfield test now carries particular significance.

His ability to reconcile economic cooperation with national sovereignty will be closely examined by voters, political opponents and members of his own party.

Ultimately, the future of Britain’s relationship with Europe will require honest debate, clear explanations and respect for different public priorities.

For Burnham, the message from Makerfield is that closer European relations cannot be presented as an automatic political victory. The government must explain exactly what it proposes, what Britain would gain and what responsibilities it would accept.

Whether his plans can satisfy both the demands of economic cooperation and the expectations of Brexit-supporting communities remains one of the most important political questions facing his administration.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *