Andy Burnham makes Channel migrant crisis ‘even more expensive’ in new Brexit betrayal . hyn

BELGIUM-EU-BRITAIN-DIPLOMACY

Andy Burnham admitted the UK is watching Europe’s Rwanda deal (Image: Getty)

Andy Burnham hinted Labour could join a “Rwanda-lite” scheme just two years after the UK’s deportation deal with Kigali was scrapped.

The Prime Minister said his Brexit betrayal deal with Brussels “opens up” the possibility of more cooperation on returns.

Mr Burnham admitted he is “interested” in “finding out where Europe is up to” after Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands confirmed a deal to send failed asylum seekers to the east African country.

Up until now, Labour has wanted to secure bilateral return hubs agreements. But the Home Office and the Foreign Office have failed to find a host country.

Andy Burnham to say Brexit 'has not worked' and he will sign new deal with EU | Brexit | The Guardian

And British taxpayers could be forced to pay into the EU’s Channel migrant action plan.

Mr Burnham said: “What we are announcing today is probably the limit of what we can achieve in this Parliament, given what needs to be done to implement it, but we want to inform the Parliament after this one so that decisions can be taken about that long-term relationship.

“And part of that is, as you say, collaboration on immigration.

“And, you know, we, as part of this, will want to get closer to those discussions that are happening in Europe around third-country returns.

“We will be interested in finding out where Europe is up to on that, the member states that are pursuing those options, and that is all part of the opportunity that opens up as a result of this agreement.”

The UK and the EU agreed on Friday to “establish a structured dialogue on migration”. These talks will include arrangements for “returns to third countries” and, officials believe, strengthen intelligence sharing on migrant smuggling gangs.

Fury as Burnham wants YOU to pay for new Channel migrant crackdown and EU projects under shameful Brexit 'reset' deal

Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp said: “Andy Burnham has clearly noticed European countries are planning to deport their illegal immigrants to Rwanda – and decided he wants to learn more.

“This all makes clear what a catastrophic mistake it was for Labour to cancel the previous Conservative Rwanda partnership just days before it was due to start in July 2024.

“If Labour had allowed this plan to commence, the small boat crossings could have been ended by now.

“That is why the Conservative BORDERS plan is needed – so illegal immigrants are all deported. The Europeans are now coming round to this idea and it’s about time our Government did too.”

The Rwanda deportation plan introduced under the Conservatives was axed by Sir Keir Starmer immediately after he became Prime Minister.

It cost Britain £700 million despite only four volunteers being sent to Kigali, then-home secretary Yvette Cooper said, as she branded the policy the “most shocking waste of taxpayer money I have ever seen”.

But the new EU pilot is said to differ from the Tory plan because it will only apply to failed asylum seekers who have exhausted all of their options.

Labour’s one-in-one-out migrant return deal with France collapsed because Paris refused to sign another agreement, insisting Downing Street should instead sign a pact with the EU.

Paris hid behind data protection diktats to avoid handing immigration officials their reasons for refusals.

And this led to the Home Office wasting time on cohorts who would eventually be rejected, according to the borders watchdog.

France refused to take back half of the migrants Britain wanted to boot out.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham just sealed a fresh package of deals with the EU that lets more British food and farm goods cross the border with far fewer checks, links the two

Britain and the EU agreed to a Channel Action Plan – which British taxpayers could have to pay towards.

The joint statement declared: “To this end, they will establish a Structured Dialogue on migration covering in particular the joint activities under the Channel Action Plan, action against irregular migration and migrant smuggling networks, strategic communication and border management, upstream cooperation and engagement with third countries, returns to third countries, pull factors for irregular migrants and legal pathways.

“The Dialogue will also provide a framework for developing new ways to prevent and counter irregular migration, including through the exchange of best practices and operational cooperation, in accordance with national, EU and international law.”

Mr Burnham, who has blamed Brexit for the small boats crisis, believes forging closer ties on migration could help curb the crossings.

A migration deal with Brussels could help Labour either join the EU five’s plan or create Britain’s own return hub.

And Downing Street said the Channel Action Plan will see UK specialists “joining forces to stop people smuggling and human trafficking, breaking up the criminal networks behind them, stopping people from abusing legal routes to come here, and working more closely with countries along the routes migrants take”.

The two parties said: “We today commit to working closely together on joint activities under the Action Plan.

Andy Burnham in talks to send UK cash to help poor EU countries | Politics | News | Express.co.uk

“This should include coordinated action to prevent and combat migrant smuggling and trafficking in human beings, including by disrupting the criminal supply chains underpinning them, addressing the drivers of irregular migration, preventing the misuse of legal migration channels and strengthening cooperation along key migratory routes.

“It should also enable work through relevant agencies, including Frontex, and more reciprocal information exchanges between interested EU Member States and the United Kingdom.

“Given the shared nature of these challenges, any new joint activities should be underpinned by a joint commitment, including, where appropriate, financial contributions, reflecting the shared roles and responsibilities for them.”

Mr Philp added: “Open-borders Burnham has found a way to make the small boats crisis even more expensive.

“Labour have signed a blank cheque with no returns target and no promise to take anyone back.

“As long as Labour keep Britain in the ECHR, removals will keep being dragged through the courts

Migrants are struggling to cross the English Channel

The English Channel migrant crisis has sparked concern (Image: Getty)

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood agreed in April to give Paris another £500 million to pay for an increase in police patrols, a new vessel to intercept migrant taxi boats, two helicopters, drones and a camera surveillance system.

And the Home Office will give the French another £160m to test new tactics to stop Channel migrant crossings.

But critics blasted the latest handouts as the three-year package will take the total given to Emmanuel Macron’s Government to a staggering £1.335 billion.

What is in Andy Burnham's much-disputed Brexit betrayal plan with the EU - and what is yet to be agreed? | Daily Mail Online

Andy Burnham Makes Channel Migrant Crisis ‘Even More Expensive’ in New Brexit Betrayal

Andy Burnham is facing fresh criticism over his approach to Britain’s growing Channel migrant crisis after agreeing to deepen cooperation with the European Union on immigration and border security. The latest agreement with Brussels has raised questions about whether British taxpayers could be expected to contribute even more money towards tackling illegal migration, despite the enormous sums already committed to controlling crossings from France.

The controversy comes as Burnham attempts to rebuild Britain’s relationship with the EU following years of strained relations after Brexit. While the Prime Minister insists that closer cooperation is necessary to stop criminal smuggling gangs and prevent dangerous Channel crossings, critics argue that the latest arrangements risk creating another expensive commitment without guaranteeing meaningful results.

At the centre of the disagreement is the new Channel Action Plan, which forms part of the wider agreement reached between Britain and the European Union at the November 20 summit in Brussels.

The plan is intended to strengthen cooperation against people-smuggling networks, improve intelligence sharing, coordinate border operations and work with countries along migration routes. It also includes discussions about returning people who have no legal right to remain in Britain.

However, the agreement contains provisions allowing new joint activities to be supported by financial contributions where appropriate. This has raised concerns about the potential cost to British taxpayers.

For critics of Burnham’s approach, the question is straightforward: how much more money will Britain have to spend before the government can demonstrate that its migration strategy is working?

Britain has already committed substantial financial resources to cooperation with France. Earlier agreements included hundreds of millions of pounds for additional policing, surveillance equipment, drones, helicopters and measures intended to intercept migrant boats before they reach British waters.

The latest three-year funding package announced for cooperation with France has brought the total amount committed to approximately £1.335 billion, according to figures reported during the current political debate.

That is a considerable sum, particularly at a time when public services face financial pressure and households continue to experience the effects of higher living costs.

Supporters of additional cooperation argue that stopping illegal crossings requires sustained international action. Smuggling gangs operate across national borders, making it difficult for any single government to dismantle their networks independently.

They argue that intelligence sharing, coordinated investigations and stronger action against criminal organisations could eventually reduce the number of dangerous crossings.

But opponents want to know whether the latest agreement will produce measurable results or simply create another financial obligation.

The Channel migrant crisis has become one of the most politically sensitive issues in Britain. Thousands of people have attempted the dangerous journey from northern France in small boats, often relying on criminal networks that charge large sums for passage.

The crossings present serious challenges for border authorities, emergency services and the asylum system. They also create dangerous conditions for migrants themselves, with overcrowded boats and unpredictable weather contributing to the risk of deaths at sea.

Successive governments have promised to tackle the problem, but the issue has remained unresolved.

For Burnham, the decision to pursue closer cooperation with Brussels represents an attempt to address a problem that has repeatedly exposed the limitations of Britain’s existing arrangements.

He has previously argued that Brexit weakened Britain’s ability to cooperate with European partners on returning migrants and managing cross-border migration.

His argument is that leaving the EU changed the mechanisms through which Britain could coordinate certain immigration and asylum procedures. Rebuilding relationships with European governments could therefore provide additional tools for tackling illegal migration.

However, this explanation has been strongly challenged by political opponents.

Brexit supporters argue that Britain left the European Union partly to regain control over its borders and immigration policy. They question why the government now believes closer integration with European institutions is necessary to address a problem that ministers promised would be easier to manage after leaving the bloc.

Nigel Farage has been particularly critical of Burnham’s European strategy, describing closer ties with Brussels as a potential betrayal of the referendum result.

The Reform UK leader has repeatedly warned that any return to freedom of movement could increase immigration and place additional pressure on housing, public services and the welfare system.

He has also challenged the government’s willingness to accept more European rules in exchange for improved access to EU markets.

The latest Channel Action Plan adds another dimension to that argument because it involves cooperation on migration alongside the broader economic agreements negotiated in Brussels.

For critics, the concern is that Britain could become increasingly dependent on European cooperation while continuing to shoulder significant financial responsibilities.

Yet the government maintains that the arrangement is not about restoring EU membership or surrendering control over British borders.

The official agreement focuses on practical cooperation against irregular migration, human trafficking and organised smuggling. It also provides a framework for discussions about returns to third countries and stronger coordination with European agencies.

One particularly important element concerns the possibility of working more closely with European countries exploring arrangements to transfer certain failed asylum seekers to countries outside Europe.

Burnham has indicated that he is interested in examining how these arrangements operate in other European countries.

Several EU member states have been exploring third-country return models, including proposals involving Rwanda. Britain previously abandoned its own Rwanda deportation partnership after the change of government in 2024.

The possibility of learning from European arrangements has therefore reopened another politically sensitive argument.

Conservative politicians have questioned why Labour cancelled the previous Rwanda scheme before considering similar approaches being discussed elsewhere in Europe.

They argue that Britain could have pursued a stronger deportation policy earlier rather than negotiating new international arrangements that may require further spending.

Labour’s position is that migration challenges must be addressed through measures that are operationally effective and consistent with domestic and international legal obligations.

The government believes that dismantling smuggling gangs is more sustainable than relying exclusively on expensive deportation announcements.

Nevertheless, the effectiveness of this strategy will ultimately be judged by the number of dangerous crossings prevented and the ability of authorities to bring criminal networks to justice.

Financial accountability will also be crucial.

The public will want to know whether the additional cooperation will reduce the overall cost of managing irregular migration or simply add another layer of spending.

There is a wider economic issue too. Britain is facing pressure on public finances, and every new international commitment must be considered alongside spending on hospitals, schools, housing and infrastructure.

The government has presented the wider EU agreement as an economic opportunity. Its estimated potential contribution of up to £17 billion annually to the UK economy by 2040 is based on the combined benefits of several agreements covering food trade, carbon markets and youth mobility.

However, that estimate should not be confused with an immediate financial saving or a guaranteed reduction in migration costs.

The Channel Action Plan is a separate part of the package, and its practical results will need to be assessed over time.

For communities affected by migration accommodation, the issue is particularly immediate. Local residents have raised concerns about pressure on public services, housing availability and the impact of large accommodation centres.

The government must therefore demonstrate that its policies are capable of producing results rather than simply shifting responsibilities between departments and international partners.

Another challenge concerns the relationship with France.

The success of any Channel strategy depends heavily on cooperation between British and French authorities. French police and border officials play an important role in preventing boats from reaching the coastline, while British agencies must manage arrivals, asylum applications and enforcement once migrants reach the United Kingdom.

The two countries have frequently disagreed over the best methods of tackling the crossings.

Financial agreements have helped maintain cooperation, but they have not eliminated the problem.

This creates a difficult political situation for Burnham. He must convince British taxpayers that additional cooperation is worth the cost while also demonstrating that the government is not becoming dependent on arrangements that fail to deliver lasting improvements.

The issue could also become a major point of disagreement within Labour itself.

Some Labour supporters favour a more cooperative approach towards European institutions, believing that Britain’s departure from the EU created unnecessary barriers to dealing with shared challenges.

Others may be concerned that the government is exposing itself to criticism by appearing too willing to make financial and regulatory concessions to Brussels.

For voters who supported Brexit, the concern is especially sensitive. They may accept international cooperation against criminal gangs but reject any suggestion that Britain should gradually restore the political arrangements associated with EU membership.

Burnham will therefore need to explain why the Channel Action Plan is compatible with an independent immigration system.

He will also need to clarify what financial contributions Britain might be expected to make and whether there will be measurable targets against which the agreement can be judged.

Without clear information, the political debate will inevitably focus on the possibility of higher costs and uncertain results.

The government has an opportunity to demonstrate that international cooperation can make a practical difference. If the plan helps prevent dangerous crossings, dismantle smuggling networks and improve the return of people without legal permission to remain, it could provide tangible benefits.

But if the crossings continue at significant levels while spending commitments increase, criticism will become more difficult for ministers to dismiss.

Ultimately, the Channel migrant crisis is not simply a question of Britain’s relationship with Brussels. It involves border enforcement, criminal justice, international diplomacy, asylum policy and the management of public finances.

No single agreement can resolve all these challenges.

The important test will be whether the government can translate its new commitments into measurable improvements while maintaining transparency about the costs.

For Burnham, the political stakes are considerable. His decision to pursue closer relations with the EU may be intended to strengthen Britain’s ability to tackle illegal migration, but it has also reopened the argument about whether Brexit is being gradually reversed.

Farage and other critics are likely to use every additional financial commitment as evidence that Labour’s European strategy is moving in the wrong direction.

Supporters will counter that cooperation is necessary because criminal smuggling networks do not respect national borders.

Both arguments will face scrutiny as the new arrangements are implemented.

British taxpayers will ultimately want more than diplomatic announcements and promises of future progress. They will want to see fewer dangerous journeys, stronger border enforcement and a reduction in the financial burden associated with the crisis.

The government must now demonstrate that its latest agreement represents a practical solution rather than another expensive political commitment.

As Britain enters a new phase of relations with Brussels, the question surrounding Burnham’s strategy is becoming increasingly difficult to avoid: can closer cooperation genuinely make the Channel safer and cheaper to manage, or will taxpayers be asked to pay even more while the underlying problem continues?

The answer will have major consequences for Labour’s immigration policy, Britain’s relationship with Europe and the future of the political debate over Brexit.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *