Andy Burnham’s Brexit Betrayal is just the start – he is completely out of his depth . HYN

Andy Burnham's Brexit Betrayal is bonkers | Politics | News | Express.co.uk

Andy Burnham will hand a raft of powers back to Brussels at the surrender summit but it is just the start of the Great Brexit Betrayal. In just six months the Prime Minister has gone from promising the voters of Makerfield he would not re-run the debate, to giving speeches at white tie dinners in the City trashing Britain’s independence from the bloc. Express readers will not be surprised that Burnham is already failing to keep his promises.

His history of shape-shifting has been well documented in these pages and the issue of Brexit was always the one he was most likely to betray the public on. The question is why and there is one clear answer – because he is completely out of his depth. Burnham’s coup saw him installed much quicker than expected, catapulting him into No 10 before he had a proper plan for government.

How significant are Burnham's remarks on Kremlin interference in Brexit vote? | Andy Burnham | The Guardian

Four months on and the evidence is clear. A damp squib budget and lots of promises about what happens after the next election are all there is to show for this new premiership. A country driven to distraction by political turmoil has been willing to give Burnham a chance, hopeful that he will be the one to bring stability.

But his casual disregard for the 17.4 million voters who chose to free Britain from the suffocating grip of Brussels bureaucrats reveals so much. Burnham managed to bypass the national electorate when he quit as Manchester’s mayor and then stitched up the Labour party to avoid a vote there too. It’s little surprise then that what voters want is not his top priority. But by blundering into the Brexit debate without a plan he has reignited a fire that he will be unable to control.

UK has lost more than it gained from Brexit, Andy Burnham says

Kemi Badenoch nailed it when she said the Prime Minister must “stop obsessing about Europe” and get on with fixing Britain. The Tory leader pointed out that the UK doesn’t need Europe to sort out the economy, fund defence, boost employment and back business. But Burnham is a political mirage. From afar he seemed like the answer for a desperate Labour Party grasping around for a solution.

Up close, it turns out there is nothing there, other than a Metropolitan mayor who built his popularity on giving out taxpayers’ money while blaming the government for everything else. Now he is the government, the decisions are ducked and delayed and he has had to find a new enemy to blame and Brexit fits the bill perfectly. On Friday, Mr Burnham will sign the so-called reset deal with Brussels that was originally negotiated by Keir Starmer.

Andy Burnham to say Brexit 'has not worked' and he will sign new deal with EU | Brexit | The Guardian

Brussels will lift some of its red tape on some British producers but in return has demanded the UK permanently aligns with all EU regulations on food and farming. Then he will set out options for what happens next, including rejoining the single market or going all the way back in. Burnham could try to seize the opportunities freedom from the bloc has offered instead of trying to overturn it.

In fact he already has. The government announced a VAT on household electricity bills to help with the cost of living that is only allowed now the UK has left the bloc. Trade deals, animal welfare, subsidies, state aid, AI regulation are all now under Britain’s control.

Andy Burnham: Time for honest discussion about freedom of movement between UK and EU | The Independent

It’s up to the government to use those powers to make the country a success. Doomsters predicted a mass exodus from the City after Brexit but it has enjoyed major successes since leaving the EU stranglehold. Latest polls show support for rejoining dramatically melts away if Britain was forced to take the euro and no longer enjoyed a rebate.

Few want to be caught up in another decade of debates and negotiations about going back in. Even half the Cabinet knows it would be a bad idea, burning any trust Labour has regained in the Red Wall. But EU leaders are already rubbing their hands with glee at the thought of an extra £30bn being paid into their coffers. Czech Prime Minister Andrej Babis was asked if he would support the UK’s return. “Yes, of course,” he replied. “We need more money.”

Burnham is already trampling over the wishes of the Makerfield voters that he looked in the eye and pledged not to betray Brexit. We should not be surprised that his promises to the rest of us count for nothing either.Andy Burnham to announce bombshell Brexit betrayal over 'new EU deal' - AOL

Andy Burnham’s Brexit Betrayal Is Just the Start – He Is Completely Out of His Depth

Andy Burnham is facing an increasingly difficult political battle after reopening Britain’s Brexit debate and pursuing a closer relationship with the European Union. What was initially presented as a practical attempt to improve trade and economic cooperation has developed into a much wider argument about national sovereignty, political promises and the future direction of the country.

The Prime Minister’s decision to criticise Brexit so openly has angered supporters of Britain’s departure from the EU. Critics accuse him of abandoning promises made to voters and attempting to reverse the referendum result through a series of agreements negotiated with Brussels.

The controversy has also raised questions about whether Burnham fully understood the political consequences of reopening such a divisive issue. While he insists that Britain needs a more constructive relationship with Europe, opposition politicians argue that his approach risks creating uncertainty without delivering the economic benefits promised.

Following the latest UK-EU summit on November 20, 2026, the debate has become even more complicated. Agreements covering food and agricultural trade, emissions trading and youth mobility have encountered difficulties, including a dispute over university tuition fees for European students.

For Burnham, the challenge is no longer simply negotiating with Brussels. He must also convince British voters that his European strategy is consistent with their democratic wishes.

1. Burnham’s Brexit reversal has reignited political divisions

One of the biggest controversies concerns the Prime Minister’s increasingly critical assessment of Brexit.

Burnham has argued that Britain’s departure from the European Union failed to deliver the promises made during the 2016 referendum campaign.

He believes the country ended up with a harder Brexit than voters were originally led to expect, creating additional barriers for businesses and weakening Britain’s economic position.

In October 2026, he described the existing relationship with Europe as inadequate and said that Britain needed to examine its long-term options.

His comments went further than simply supporting improved trade arrangements.

Burnham indicated that he would personally like to see Britain rejoin the European Union during his lifetime, although he insisted that any decision must ultimately belong to the public.

This distinction has not satisfied Brexit supporters.

They argue that the Prime Minister is gradually preparing the country for a reversal of the referendum result without providing a sufficiently clear explanation of what such a change would involve.

According to political commentator Sam Lister in the Daily Express, Burnham’s handling of Brexit demonstrates a failure to appreciate the political consequences of reopening the issue.

That is an opinion rather than an established assessment of his abilities, but it reflects the strength of opposition to his approach.

2. The Brussels summit has exposed the difficulties of negotiating with Europe

Burnham’s European strategy was supposed to demonstrate that Britain could secure practical economic benefits without returning to EU membership.

However, the November summit has highlighted the difficulties involved in achieving that objective.

The proposed agreements cover three important areas:

  • Food and agricultural trade: Reducing paperwork, border checks and regulatory barriers affecting British exporters.
  • Emissions trading: Linking Britain’s carbon market with the European system.
  • Youth mobility: Creating opportunities for young British and European citizens to live, study and work in each other’s countries for limited periods.

The Government estimates that the wider package could increase British GDP by approximately 0.5 per cent by 2040.

However, the negotiations have encountered a significant obstacle over university tuition fees.

The European Union wants British universities to allow eligible European students to pay domestic tuition fees rather than higher international rates.

Brussels has linked progress on the wider package to resolving this issue within six months.

The potential financial implications have generated further criticism, with opponents questioning whether British taxpayers and universities should accept additional costs to secure the agreement.

For Burnham, the dispute illustrates how difficult it can be to negotiate a closer relationship with Brussels while maintaining the Government’s existing political commitments.

3. Nigel Farage accuses Labour of betraying Brexit

Nigel Farage has emerged as one of the most outspoken opponents of Burnham’s European strategy.

The Reform UK leader believes Labour is gradually reversing Brexit through individual agreements rather than presenting voters with a clear decision about Britain’s future.

He has criticised the Government’s willingness to accept closer regulatory alignment and warned that Britain could become increasingly dependent on decisions made by European institutions.

Following the Brussels summit, Farage described the agreement as a costly mistake and a betrayal of Brexit supporters.

His criticism focuses on the principle that Britain should retain control over its laws, borders and economic policies.

Farage argues that the country should not accept European regulations simply to obtain easier access to the single market.

However, Burnham’s supporters point out that Britain can cooperate with European countries without automatically restoring EU membership or freedom of movement.

The disagreement therefore concerns the extent of cooperation Britain should accept in exchange for improved economic relations.

For Reform UK, the controversy provides an opportunity to challenge Labour’s interpretation of the referendum result and demand greater clarity about its long-term intentions.

4. Labour’s own Brexit promises are creating difficulties

Perhaps the most complicated aspect of Burnham’s position is that Labour entered government with clear commitments concerning Britain’s relationship with Europe.

The party promised not to rejoin the single market or customs union and ruled out restoring freedom of movement during the current parliamentary term.

Burnham has repeatedly insisted that he will respect those commitments.

However, his comments about potentially rejoining the EU in the future have created uncertainty about the direction of Labour policy.

Some Labour MPs support closer European integration because they believe it could improve economic growth and reduce trade barriers.

Others represent constituencies that voted heavily for Brexit and are concerned that reopening the debate could alienate traditional supporters.

Burnham’s own constituency of Makerfield voted approximately 65 per cent in favour of leaving the EU in 2016.

This makes his position particularly sensitive.

He must explain why closer European cooperation is in the interests of voters who previously supported independence from Brussels.

The Prime Minister has said that he will not rerun the referendum and that the public will ultimately decide Britain’s future relationship with Europe.

Nevertheless, critics argue that his Government needs a clearer explanation of how far it intends to go.

5. Economic promises are facing questions

Burnham has defended his European reset by pointing towards the potential economic benefits.

His Government believes reduced agricultural trade barriers could help British exporters, while closer cooperation over carbon markets could support industrial businesses.

The proposed youth mobility arrangements could also create opportunities for young people and employers.

However, the projected economic gains are not guaranteed.

The Government’s estimate of a 0.5 per cent increase in GDP by 2040 represents a long-term forecast rather than immediate additional money for households.

Critics argue that ministers must explain the financial commitments associated with the agreements before presenting the projected benefits as a success.

There are also questions about whether the arrangements will deliver lower prices for consumers.

Reducing administrative costs for exporters could improve efficiency, but there is no automatic guarantee that businesses will pass every saving on to customers.

The Institute for Government has also highlighted the limitations of pursuing multiple smaller agreements without settling the broader question of Britain’s long-term relationship with Europe.

This creates a difficult political challenge for Burnham.

He must demonstrate that the agreements provide measurable economic improvements rather than simply creating another period of uncertainty.

6. European leaders are not prepared to give Britain everything it wants

Another difficulty concerns the expectations of European governments.

Britain may want greater access to European markets while maintaining control over its domestic regulations and immigration policies.

However, the EU has its own interests and is unlikely to offer every advantage of membership without corresponding responsibilities.

French President Emmanuel Macron has previously indicated that Britain could not simply select the benefits of membership while rejecting the obligations.

This is an important consideration for Burnham.

Closer access to the single market could involve accepting common rules, financial contributions and other commitments.

Rejoining the European Union would involve an even more extensive negotiation.

Britain might also have to accept membership conditions different from those it enjoyed before Brexit.

The Prime Minister therefore faces a difficult choice between maintaining the current arrangements and pursuing deeper integration.

Either direction involves political and economic trade-offs.

7. The Conservative Party is questioning Burnham’s judgment

Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has also criticised the Prime Minister’s approach.

She argues that Brexit created opportunities for Britain to develop independent policies and that Labour should concentrate on using those freedoms rather than gradually moving closer to Brussels.

The Conservatives have highlighted areas where Britain can establish different regulations and pursue its own trade priorities.

Their argument is that the Government should focus on domestic productivity, investment and public services instead of reopening a divisive constitutional debate.

However, supporters of Burnham’s strategy argue that formal independence does not eliminate the economic importance of Britain’s relationship with Europe.

The EU remains a major trading partner, and British businesses continue to depend on access to European customers and supply chains.

The political disagreement is therefore not simply about whether Brexit was right or wrong.

It concerns which economic and regulatory arrangements are most beneficial for Britain today.

8. Immigration remains a major obstacle

Burnham has also argued that Brexit failed to deliver the promised improvements in immigration control.

His position is that leaving the EU did not solve the small-boats crisis or eliminate the wider challenges associated with managing migration.

However, his willingness to consider closer European cooperation has generated concerns among immigration-focused voters.

The proposed youth mobility arrangement is one example.

Although it is not a restoration of unrestricted freedom of movement, critics fear that such programmes could eventually expand.

Farage has warned that closer European integration could make it more difficult for Britain to maintain an independent immigration policy.

Burnham must therefore explain precisely how his proposed arrangements would operate and what safeguards would remain in place.

Without clear answers, the immigration debate could become another major source of political opposition.

9. Burnham needs to explain what happens next

The biggest unanswered question concerns the Government’s long-term ambitions.

Burnham has promised a national conversation about Britain’s future relationship with the EU.

The options could include maintaining the current arrangements, joining a customs union, seeking closer single-market access or eventually reconsidering full EU membership.

Each option would involve different economic and political consequences.

A customs union could reduce certain trade barriers but would limit Britain’s ability to negotiate independent goods-trade agreements.

Single-market participation could provide wider access to European markets but would involve significant regulatory commitments.

Full EU membership would require a much broader political and legal process.

Burnham has said that major changes would require a public mandate and would not be introduced during the current parliamentary term.

However, the Government will need to provide greater clarity about what it hopes to achieve before the next general election.

Otherwise, businesses and voters could be left uncertain about the country’s long-term direction.

The political consequences of Burnham’s Brexit strategy

Andy Burnham’s decision to reopen the Brexit debate has created a complicated political situation.

His supporters believe Britain needs a more practical relationship with Europe after years of trade disruption and economic uncertainty.

Opponents argue that the Prime Minister is undermining the referendum result and making commitments that could restrict future governments.

The Brussels summit has demonstrated that negotiating closer cooperation is not straightforward. The dispute over tuition fees, regulatory alignment and financial commitments shows that Britain cannot necessarily secure every benefit it wants without making compromises.

Burnham must now answer three important questions.

First, what economic benefits will ordinary British households receive from the agreements?

Second, how much regulatory independence is Britain prepared to exchange for easier access to European markets?

Third, will voters be given a meaningful opportunity to decide the country’s long-term relationship with the EU?

These questions deserve clear answers rather than political slogans.

Whether critics are justified in describing Burnham as being out of his depth is a matter of political opinion. What is clear is that his European strategy has opened a difficult debate that reaches far beyond the agreements signed in Brussels.

The success of his approach will ultimately depend on whether it delivers tangible economic improvements while respecting democratic accountability.

For Britain, the challenge is to learn from the consequences of Brexit without creating another period of uncertainty over the country’s future.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *