
Prime Minister Andy Burnham is considering the findings of a major study (Image: Getty)
Employers including the NHS must stop depending on immigrant workers and give British young people a chance instead, according to the Labour grandee who led an inquiry into the youth unemployment crisis. Local workers “have to come first”, said Alan Milburn.
He was speaking at the launch of his 267-page report looking into almost a million youngsters not in education, employment or training, known as NEETs. Mr Milburn, a former health secretary, called the figure a “national failure” which had “dire economic and fiscal consequences”.
But the price would grow even higher as numbers rose, he said. He insisted: “A lost generation is not inevitable. A work generation is possible. Young people need a working state and a new settlement to bring it about.”
Presenting the findings of his government-commissioned study, he called for radical changes to the education system so schools were judged on whether pupils went on to find employment, not just on exam results.
Health services should help young people with mental health conditions into work, rather than simply providing a diagnosis, he said. And he argued young people should be given a legal guarantee of a job or course placement, to give them a first step on the career ladder/
Mr Milburn also demanded radical changes to the benefits system, with many young people on health-related benefits receiving less than today – and potentially losing their entitlement unless they accept help finding work. The proposal was immediately condemned by trade unions, and could spark a huge battle with Labour MPs, who last year forced the Government to back down over plans to limit disability payments.
Mr Milburn called on the Government to provide funding of £500 million next year to begin making his plans a reality.
The changes would eventually cut the benefits bill by £3.6 billion and bring an extra £2.4 billion through taxes, a total saving of £6 billion. But Conservative critics pointed out that the cost to taxpayers would initially rise, and may not fall for a decade.
Launching the report, the former MP urged employers to recruit British youngsters. He said: “My message to the country, not just to the politicians but to employers, is that young people in those disadvantaged communities have to come first. They are the priority.
“In some ways what has happened in the youth labour market over the past 15 or 20 years is, there has become an over-dependence on migrant labour.
“Migration has fallen now, and that creates an opportunity for employers to reorientate back to employing young people from their communities, and that’s what they should do in my view.”
Turning to the NHS, he said: “The public sector has got to give a lead. It has a special responsibility to do that. Take something like the NHS – it’s a huge employer, the biggest in the country. We say in the report, look – you have a very diverse workforce, that’s great, and you recruit from all over the word, and that’s fantastic. But you need to do more to recruit from your local communities, particularly amongst the young.”
Get the latest politics news – straight from our team in Westminster and more
Invalid email
You agree you are 18 or over. We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you’ve consented to and to improve our understanding of you. This may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. You can unsubscribe at any time. More Info.
The study called for legislation to prevent future governments adopting policies likely to destroy jobs for young people. Mr Milburn insisted this was a long-running problem, but the report highlighted recent decisions taken by ex-Labour Chancellor Rachel Reeves, including increasing National Insurance rates for employers.
Workers under the age of 21 are largely exempt, but Mr Milburn pointed out that those aged 21 to 24 became more expensive to employ. Highlighting research by watchdog the Office for Responsibility (OBR), he said the change “increased the cost of a full-time worker on the National Living Wage by around £800 per year. The OBR estimated this package would raise £25.7 billion annually by 2029-30, directly from the bottom line of businesses.”
He also highlighted increases in the minimum wage, as well as Labour’s Employment Rights Act, which he said had “unintended consequences”. The report said: “The potential impact is already being felt with more than a third (37 per cent) of employers planning to reduce permanent hiring because of Employment Rights Act reforms.”
Trade unions hit out at the prospect of cuts to benefits such as Personal Independence Payments (PIP), which goes to people with disabilities. Maryam Eslamdoust, General Secretary of the Labour-affiliated transport and travel union, said: “Cuts to PIP payments for young people seem like a justification for needless cruelty and will not incentivise anyone into work. Not only that it is discriminatory, pushing people into poverty and homelessness.”
The PCS union, which represents civil servants in the Department for Work and Pensions, also condemned the plans. General Secretary Fran Heathcote said: “The mental health crisis among our young people is not the fault of public services but is a result of decades of under-funding by successive governments. Moving now to cut payments for under-25s will not fix their issues or provide them with a better future, they will need both financial and specialised work-coach support to help bring them into the working environment.”
The Government announced the creation of a new youth opportunities unit reporting directly to Prime Minister Andy Burnham, but Ministers did not immediately commit to implementing all Mr Milburn’s proposals. Mr Burnham said: “It is an economic and moral catastrophe and a moral failure that we now have a million 16 to 24-year-olds who are not in education, employment or training.”
He added: “Put simply, this will be our approach: jobs rather than crude cuts; investment and prevention rather than abandonment; opportunity matched by responsibility; a safety net for those who cannot work; and a welfare system that helps people fulfil their potential rather than writing them off.”
Andy Burnham’s Jobs Chief Issues NHS With Major Warning Over Migrants
The National Health Service is facing renewed questions about its long-term staffing strategy after a senior figure involved in Andy Burnham’s employment plans issued a warning about the growing dependence on migrant workers. The intervention has reignited debate over immigration, workforce shortages and the future of Britain’s public services. At a time when the NHS is struggling with long waiting lists, recruitment difficulties and increasing demand for healthcare, concerns about the availability of overseas workers have become an important political issue for the Labour government.
The NHS is one of Britain’s most important public institutions, employing hundreds of thousands of doctors, nurses, healthcare assistants and other professionals. However, maintaining sufficient staffing levels has become increasingly difficult. An ageing population, rising demand for medical treatment and pressure on hospital services have created a significant need for additional workers.
International recruitment has played an important role in filling vacancies across the health service. Thousands of doctors, nurses and other healthcare professionals from overseas have helped hospitals and medical practices maintain essential services. Without their contribution, many parts of the NHS would face even greater staffing difficulties.
Nevertheless, the growing reliance on overseas recruitment has raised questions about whether Britain has invested sufficiently in training its own healthcare workforce. Critics argue that successive governments have failed to develop a sustainable domestic recruitment strategy, leaving the NHS increasingly dependent on international labour.
The warning from Burnham’s jobs chief is particularly significant because it comes amid wider discussions about youth unemployment and the government’s plans to help more British people enter employment. Alan Milburn’s work on the growing number of young people who are not in education, employment or training has highlighted the importance of improving skills and creating opportunities for the next generation.
One of the central questions is whether Britain could do more to prepare domestic workers for careers in healthcare. Nursing, medicine, social care and other NHS professions offer opportunities for long-term employment, but entering these careers requires appropriate qualifications, practical experience and professional training.
The government must therefore consider whether existing education and training systems are providing enough opportunities for young people who want to work in healthcare. Increasing the number of training places, improving apprenticeships and supporting students financially could help develop a larger domestic workforce.
However, training additional healthcare professionals is not an immediate solution. Becoming a doctor or specialist nurse can take several years, while hospitals need qualified staff every day. International recruitment will therefore remain important while Britain develops its domestic workforce.
Another concern involves the financial implications of recruiting workers from overseas. International recruitment can help fill urgent vacancies, but it also involves recruitment expenses, relocation arrangements and immigration administration. Some countries may also lose experienced healthcare professionals when their workers move abroad to take up better-paid positions.
This raises ethical questions about the responsibility of wealthy countries to avoid excessive dependence on healthcare workers trained in nations experiencing their own staffing shortages. Britain should develop recruitment arrangements that respect international standards and avoid undermining healthcare systems in developing countries.
The NHS also faces challenges in retaining existing employees. Recruitment alone cannot solve staffing shortages if experienced doctors and nurses continue leaving because of excessive workloads, poor working conditions and limited opportunities for professional development.
Many healthcare professionals work under considerable pressure. Long shifts, staff shortages, administrative responsibilities and emotionally demanding situations can contribute to exhaustion and dissatisfaction. When experienced employees leave, hospitals lose valuable knowledge and must spend additional resources recruiting replacements.
Improving retention should therefore be a central part of the government’s healthcare strategy. Better working conditions, more flexible working arrangements, professional development and appropriate mental health support could help encourage experienced employees to remain in the NHS.
Immigration policy is another important part of the debate. The Labour government faces pressure to reduce overall migration while ensuring that essential sectors can recruit the workers they need. These objectives can sometimes conflict, particularly when the NHS continues to experience significant vacancies.
Reducing immigration without developing alternative sources of labour could make existing staffing problems worse. Hospitals and care providers cannot simply replace experienced doctors and nurses overnight. Any changes to visa arrangements must therefore take account of the practical requirements of healthcare services.
At the same time, relying too heavily on international recruitment could discourage long-term investment in domestic education and training. The government needs a balanced approach that provides immediate staffing support while gradually increasing the number of qualified British workers entering healthcare professions.
The situation also has consequences for patients. When hospitals do not have enough staff, appointments may be delayed, treatment schedules can be disrupted and pressure on existing employees can increase. Patients may experience longer waiting times and difficulties accessing routine medical services.
An effective workforce strategy is therefore essential to improving NHS performance. It must consider not only the number of employees but also their qualifications, experience, geographical distribution and ability to provide high-quality care.
There are also regional differences in recruitment. Hospitals in major cities may have access to larger labour markets and international recruitment networks, while healthcare providers in rural and less prosperous areas can struggle to attract qualified professionals. Government policies should recognise these differences and provide targeted support where shortages are most serious.
In my opinion, the warning about migrant recruitment should encourage a more honest discussion about Britain’s healthcare workforce. International employees make an essential contribution to the NHS and should not be unfairly blamed for problems created by years of insufficient planning and investment.
The government should instead focus on developing a sustainable workforce strategy. This should include more university and apprenticeship opportunities, improved support for healthcare students, better working conditions and a clear long-term plan for recruitment and retention.
There should also be greater cooperation between schools, colleges, universities and healthcare employers. Young people need accessible information about careers in medicine, nursing and social care, together with practical opportunities to gain experience before entering the workforce.
At the same time, the NHS must continue to recruit internationally where necessary. Overseas professionals should receive fair treatment, proper support and opportunities to develop their careers. A successful healthcare system should value the contributions of both domestic and international employees.
Ultimately, the government must recognise that immigration policy and NHS workforce planning cannot be considered separately. Decisions affecting visas and international recruitment have direct consequences for hospitals, healthcare professionals and patients.
In conclusion, the warning from Andy Burnham’s jobs chief has highlighted one of the most difficult challenges facing Britain’s healthcare system: how to balance the need for migrant workers with the long-term development of a sustainable domestic workforce. International doctors and nurses remain vital to the NHS, but Britain must also do more to train, recruit and retain its own healthcare professionals. Reducing immigration without addressing staffing shortages could place even greater pressure on hospitals and patients. The Labour government therefore needs a carefully planned strategy that protects essential services, creates opportunities for young British workers and recognises the invaluable contribution made by overseas staff. The future of the NHS depends not on choosing between migrant and domestic workers, but on ensuring that there are enough skilled professionals to provide safe and effective healthcare for everyone.
