
Robert Jenrick (Image: Getty)
Tory and Labour governments have allowed a million young people to be out of work, education or training. Instead they’re unemployed – languishing on benefits. It’s a scandalous waste of our country’s potential.
After waiting a year on a Review to turn things around, it emerged yesterday that Burnham’s plan will take 10 years to produce any savings.
By the time Labour are forecast to reduce the youth benefits bill we’re forecast to spend £1.7 trillion on working age welfare. We will have gone bust before reforms make any impact.
A lot of the changes recommended were simply undoing the mistakes Labour have already made. Rachel Reeves’s jobs tax has proven to be a disaster.
Burnham’s going an inch when we need a mile.
Each day Andy Burnham is in No10 he resembles Keir Starmer more closely. Aimless, drifting, and with no answers to the big problems facing our country.
We’ve had a nothingburger Budget that did nothing to help people with the cost of living.
A much-needed defence spending increase has been postponed.
Immigration restrictions have been watered down to stop rebellion from Labour MPs.
Burnham’s the procrastinating Prime Minister who boots anything difficult into the long grass.
He simply can’t face doing the job he spent so long scheming to get. Today was another case in point. His much-hyped plan to fix the youth jobs crisis flopped as the facts emerged.

Annual costs and savings (Image: Welfare State to a Working State report)
Reform would reverse Rachel Reeves’s jobs tax for British workers, paid for by a levy on migrant workers, to put them first.
We’d cut worthless Mickey Mouse degrees that laden students with debt.
We’d back apprentices with an Apprenticeship Retention Bonus and end reliance on foreign doctors and nurses by lifting the arbitrary cap on medical school places and training British applicants.
We won’t stand by while another generation of youngsters are lost.
Andy Burnham’s New Wheeze to Tackle the Welfare Crisis Has Already ‘Flopped’
The welfare crisis has become one of the most serious social and economic challenges facing the United Kingdom. Rising unemployment, increasing government expenditure on benefits and the growing number of young people who are not in education, employment or training have placed considerable pressure on the British economy. In this context, Andy Burnham’s proposed approach to tackling the welfare crisis has attracted considerable political attention and criticism. A recent article entitled “Andy Burnham’s New Wheeze to Tackle Welfare Crisis Has Already ‘Flopped’”, published by the Daily Express on 17 November 2026 and written by Robert Jenrick, argues that the government’s proposed reforms are too slow and insufficient to address the scale of the problem. Although the article presents a strongly critical political perspective, it raises important questions about unemployment, public spending, economic growth and the future of Britain’s welfare system.
One of the main concerns raised by Jenrick is the growing number of young people who are neither working nor studying. According to the article, approximately one million young people in Britain are currently outside education, employment or training. This situation represents a serious failure of the education system, labour market and welfare policies. Young people who remain unemployed for long periods may lose confidence, professional skills and motivation. More importantly, they may become increasingly dependent on government financial support. This creates a vicious cycle in which unemployment leads to welfare dependency, while welfare dependency may make it more difficult for some individuals to return to employment. Therefore, tackling youth unemployment should be considered a national priority rather than simply an economic policy issue.
The central issue discussed in the article is a government review led by Alan Milburn, which proposes transforming the traditional welfare system into what he describes as a working state. The purpose is to encourage young people to earn or learn instead of remaining dependent on benefits. The report suggests introducing a comprehensive ten-year programme involving education, employment, healthcare and welfare reform. It also recommends improving apprenticeships, creating more employment opportunities and providing better mental health support for young people. These proposals recognise that unemployment is not always caused by a lack of willingness to work. In many cases, young people face complicated barriers, including poor qualifications, physical or mental health difficulties and insufficient employment opportunities.
However, Robert Jenrick argues that the proposed reforms are too slow to address Britain’s immediate economic difficulties. According to his criticism, the government may have to wait until 2036 before the programme produces significant annual financial savings. Meanwhile, public expenditure on welfare is expected to continue increasing. He warns that Britain could face serious financial difficulties before the reforms have any meaningful impact. His argument highlights an important weakness in long-term government planning: policies may appear attractive in theory, but they cannot solve an urgent crisis if their benefits take many years to materialise.
Furthermore, Jenrick believes that some of the proposed measures simply attempt to reverse the negative consequences of previous Labour government decisions. He particularly criticises Rachel Reeves’s changes to employers’ National Insurance contributions, arguing that higher employment costs have discouraged businesses from recruiting workers. From his perspective, the government cannot effectively solve unemployment while introducing policies that make hiring more expensive. He therefore calls for a more ambitious approach, including reversing the employment tax changes and encouraging businesses to recruit British workers. Nevertheless, this is a political argument rather than an established conclusion, and the actual effects of employment taxes should be assessed using broader economic evidence.
Another important aspect of the welfare crisis is the relationship between education and employment. Many young people graduate from universities with substantial student debt but struggle to find suitable jobs. In some cases, their qualifications do not match the skills required by employers. This suggests that the education system needs to become more closely connected to the labour market. Instead of concentrating exclusively on academic achievements, schools and universities should provide students with practical knowledge, professional experience and transferable skills. Vocational education, technical training and apprenticeships could offer valuable alternatives for individuals who prefer practical careers.
Jenrick also proposes reducing the number of university courses that he considers to have limited employment value and investing more heavily in apprenticeships. He argues that young people should have better opportunities to develop practical skills and enter professions that contribute directly to the economy. His suggestions deserve consideration because not every student needs to follow the traditional university route. However, it would be unfair to assume that humanities and other academic subjects are worthless simply because they do not lead directly to particular occupations. Universities play an important role in developing critical thinking, creativity, research and cultural understanding. The real objective should be to improve the quality and relevance of higher education rather than undermine its value.
In addition, the government must recognise the responsibility of employers in addressing youth unemployment. Businesses often prefer experienced workers because recruiting and training inexperienced employees can involve additional costs. Consequently, young people may find themselves trapped in a difficult situation: they cannot obtain employment without experience, but they cannot gain experience without being employed. To overcome this problem, the government could introduce financial incentives for companies that recruit young people, expand paid internships and encourage employers to provide structured training programmes. The Milburn review also recommends stronger hiring incentives and earlier intervention for young people who have been unemployed for extended periods. Such policies could help businesses recognise young workers as an investment rather than an unnecessary expense.
Mental health is another issue that should not be overlooked. Unemployment can have serious psychological consequences, including anxiety, depression, social isolation and declining self-esteem. Young people who experience these difficulties may find it increasingly challenging to participate in education or enter the workforce. Therefore, simply reducing welfare payments or imposing stricter conditions on benefit recipients will not necessarily solve the problem. Instead, the government should ensure that individuals receive appropriate healthcare, career guidance and psychological support. A successful welfare system should help people overcome their difficulties and become financially independent, rather than punish those who are struggling.
Nevertheless, the government’s proposals also raise legitimate concerns about public spending. Although investing in education, healthcare and employment programmes may eventually reduce welfare expenditure, these measures require substantial financial resources at the beginning. The government must therefore explain how the programme will be funded and demonstrate that taxpayers’ money is being used effectively. According to Milburn’s report, the proposed reforms could require annual investment of approximately £5.8 billion by 2036–2037, with projected welfare savings and additional tax revenues eventually offsetting these costs. However, these figures are estimates rather than guaranteed outcomes. Economic conditions may change, businesses may respond differently to incentives, and some young people may require more intensive support than initially expected.
From a wider political perspective, the disagreement between Jenrick and Burnham illustrates the difficulty of balancing immediate economic pressures with long-term social improvements. Opposition politicians naturally have an incentive to expose weaknesses in government policies, particularly when public spending and unemployment are major concerns. Jenrick’s criticism draws attention to the need for faster results, greater accountability and more effective economic management. However, describing a long-term programme as a complete failure before it has been implemented may also be politically motivated. A policy should ultimately be judged according to its measurable results rather than political accusations or promises.
In my opinion, the most effective solution would combine the government’s long-term strategy with more immediate employment measures. Britain needs to create opportunities for young people today while building a stronger education and welfare system for the future. The government should work closely with businesses, educational institutions and local authorities to identify the specific barriers preventing young people from entering employment. It should also regularly evaluate its policies, publish transparent financial information and make adjustments whenever programmes fail to achieve their objectives. Most importantly, welfare reform should protect vulnerable individuals while encouraging those who are capable of working to develop their skills and become independent.
In conclusion, Andy Burnham’s proposed approach to tackling Britain’s welfare crisis has generated considerable criticism, particularly because its financial benefits may take a decade to emerge. Robert Jenrick’s article raises important questions about the effectiveness, affordability and speed of the government’s reforms. Although some of his criticisms are politically influenced, his concerns about youth unemployment, rising welfare expenditure and insufficient employment opportunities deserve serious consideration. Nevertheless, the welfare crisis cannot be solved through financial cuts or political promises alone. It requires a comprehensive strategy that combines education, vocational training, business incentives, healthcare and responsible public spending. Ultimately, the success of welfare reform should not be measured simply by how much money the government saves, but by how many people are given a genuine opportunity to build independent, productive and fulfilling lives.
