The state pension triple lock “favours better off” retirees and should be reformed, a leading think tank has claimed ahead of Chancellor Rachel Reeves’s Autumn Budget on November 26.
Economists from the Institute of Fiscal Studies (IFS) are sounding the alarm that the mechanism used to raise the annual payment rate for the retirement benefit skews towards wealthier individuals
Under the triple lock, state pension payment rates are increased ever year by either the rate of consumer price index (CPI) rate of inflation, average wage growth or 2.5 per cent; whichever is highest.
Heidi Karjalainen, senior research economist at the IFS, claims keeping the triple lock while raising the state pension age “will tend to favour groups that are better off” as longer-lived and richer Britons benefit the most from its generosity, while poorer people with lower life expectancy lose out.
“Raising the state pension age delays the point at which people can receive their state pension,” she said. “This delay affects poorer people, who on average have a lower life expectancy, more because the loss of a year of state pension income is more important for those with lower life expectancy.
“On the other hand, those with a higher life expectancy benefit relatively more from the triple lock, as they are more likely to be receiving a generously indexed state pension into their 90s.”
The warning comes ahead of new CPI inflation for the 12 months to September 2025 data being published tomorrow (October 22), which will determine how much the state pension rises next April.
This figure is expected to come in below the 4.8 per cent average earnings growth recorded between May and July, meaning the triple lock will once again be triggered by wages.
It will lift the full new state pension by around £11 a week to roughly £241 per week from April 2026. Although not every pensioner receives the full amount, the majority of newly retired Britons get the new state pension rate or one close to it.
Since the triple lock was introduced in 2011, the value of the state pension has risen much faster than both earnings and prices. At £241 per week, the full new state pension is now £30 per week , or 14 per cent, higher than it would have been if it had simply tracked average earnings.
According to the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), the triple lock now costs the Government around £12billion more each year than an earnings-linked system would.
Ms Karjalainen asserts that while the controversial policy had boosted pensioner living standards, its long-term impact on public finances was becoming unsustainable.
She added: “The generosity of the triple lock has a substantial and growing impact on public finances. Spending on the state pension will continue to increase due to the ageing population, but the triple lock also plays a part.
“And because the triple lock increases the value of the state pension based on the maximum of three figures, two of which are potentially volatile over time, forecasting state pension spending in the future also becomes more difficult under this indexation policy.”
The fiscal watchdog estimates that state pension spending will rise by around £80billion in today’s terms by the 2070s, with over half of this increase driven by the triple lock.
In a more volatile economy, the policy could cost an extra 1.5 per cent of national income, or £44,billion in today’s terms,while in a more stable scenario it could cost £40 billion less.
In light of these projections, the IFS is now calling for the Labour Government to consider moving to a new “smoothed earnings link” system, similar to that used in Australia.
This would see ministers set a target value for the state pension as a share of median full-time earnings. In normal years, it would rise with earnings, but if inflation outpaced wage growth, payments would instead increase with prices until earnings caught up again.
Ms Karjalainen said this would make the system “more sustainable and predictable” for both pensioners and policymakers.
She said: “While the triple lock has helped increase pensioner living standards over the last 15 years, a better approach is needed for the future. While the Government has committed to keeping the triple lock this parliament, a sensible approach would be to move away from it after the next election.”
State Pension Future in Doubt as Triple Lock ‘Tends to Favour Better-Off’ Retirees
Britain’s State Pension system is facing renewed scrutiny after leading economic researchers warned that the controversial triple lock mechanism tends to benefit wealthier retirees more than poorer pensioners. The warning has reignited debate about the future of retirement incomes, government spending and whether the current system can remain financially sustainable as Britain’s population continues to age. With millions of older people depending on the State Pension to support themselves, any changes to the triple lock could have significant consequences for households across the country.
First of all, the triple lock has been one of the most important pension policies in Britain since its introduction in 2011. It was designed to protect pensioners against rising living costs and ensure that the value of the State Pension would not fall behind inflation or average earnings.
Under the system, the State Pension increases every April by whichever is highest among three measures: inflation, average earnings growth or 2.5 per cent.
This arrangement has helped millions of pensioners maintain their purchasing power during periods of economic uncertainty. However, it has also become increasingly expensive for the government, particularly as the number of people reaching retirement age continues to grow.
A report published by the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) in October 2025 raised important questions about the fairness and long-term sustainability of the policy. Researchers argued that the triple lock disproportionately benefits wealthier pensioners because people with higher life expectancy are more likely to receive its generous increases over a longer period.
The researchers also warned that using increases in the State Pension age to control government expenditure while retaining the triple lock could further favour people who are already financially better off. <Cite refs={[“turn762790search0″,”turn762790search1”]}/>
One of the central concerns involves differences in life expectancy between income groups. People with higher incomes and greater financial resources generally have longer life expectancies than those experiencing poverty or poor health.
Consequently, wealthier pensioners may receive the benefit of repeated annual increases for more years than people who die at younger ages.
This creates an important question about whether a policy originally designed to protect all pensioners equally is producing unequal financial benefits over time.
However, the debate is more complicated than simply describing the triple lock as a benefit for wealthy retirees. Many poorer pensioners also depend heavily on the State Pension to pay for food, heating, housing and other essential expenses.
For some older people, it represents their main source of income. Removing or weakening the triple lock could therefore create additional financial difficulties for those who have limited private pension savings.
The issue has become particularly important amid continuing concerns about the cost of living. Older households often face higher energy expenses because they spend more time at home and may have additional heating requirements during the winter months.
Rising food prices, housing costs and household bills can also place considerable pressure on pensioners who have little opportunity to increase their earnings.
Another major concern involves the financial position of the British government. State Pension expenditure represents a substantial part of public spending, and demographic changes are expected to increase the number of people receiving retirement benefits over the coming decades.
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has also warned that the combination of population ageing and the triple lock creates long-term financial risks.
Its 2026 assessment recommended preparing reforms to make pension spending more predictable and sustainable. It highlighted the fact that the UK State Pension has increased faster than average earnings over much of the period since 2011. <Cite refs={[“turn762790search1″,”turn762790search4”]}/>
For Chancellor Rachel Reeves, this presents a difficult financial challenge. The government must find ways to manage public expenditure while ensuring that older citizens receive sufficient support during retirement.
Changing the triple lock could generate savings over time, but any reform would carry considerable political and social risks. Millions of pensioners have organised their retirement finances around the expectation that their State Pension will continue to receive annual protection.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s government has committed to maintaining the existing triple lock throughout the current Parliament. This commitment provides some reassurance to pensioners in the short term, although questions about what happens afterwards remain.
The government has also published analysis of an adjusted triple lock intended to apply from April 2030. Under this approach, pensions would continue to receive protection against inflation and retain their value relative to earnings over time, while reducing the permanent spending increases associated with the existing mechanism. <Cite refs={[“turn762790search3″,”turn762790search4”]}/>
Nevertheless, campaigners argue that pension reform must not leave poorer retirees behind.
One possible alternative would be to introduce a more targeted system that provides additional financial assistance to pensioners on lower incomes. Such an approach could help ensure that people who genuinely struggle to afford essential expenses receive sufficient support.
Another proposal involves replacing the triple lock with a system linked more consistently to average earnings. Researchers at the IFS have suggested that a smoothed earnings link could provide greater predictability while allowing pensioners to share in improvements in national living standards.
However, any replacement system would need strong safeguards to ensure that inflation does not significantly reduce the real value of retirement incomes.
Pension Credit is another important part of this discussion. It provides additional financial support to eligible pensioners on lower incomes and can unlock access to other benefits. However, some eligible people do not claim it, meaning that improving awareness and access could be an important part of any future reform.
There is also a wider generational question. Younger workers are increasingly concerned about whether they will receive comparable pension support when they eventually retire. They face rising housing costs, changing employment conditions and difficulties building private pension savings.
The government must therefore consider how to create a retirement system that is fair to both current pensioners and future generations.
In conclusion, the warning that Britain’s triple lock tends to favour better-off retirees has reopened an important debate about the future of the State Pension. Although the policy has helped protect millions of older people against inflation and rising living costs, researchers have identified concerns about inequality, life expectancy and long-term public expenditure. Keir Starmer’s government faces the difficult task of balancing financial sustainability with the need to protect pensioners from poverty. Any future changes must be carefully considered, transparent and accompanied by appropriate support for vulnerable households. Ultimately, Britain’s pension system should provide security and dignity in retirement without placing an unsustainable burden on future generations.
