UK citizen who encouraged others to ‘celebrate’ October 7 detained in US for ‘supporting terrorism . hyn

Why is the U.K. arresting peaceful protesters on terrorism charges?

A UK citizen who encouraged others to “celebrate” the October 7 massacre has been detained in the US for “supporting terrorism”.

Sami Hamdi, who describes himself as a commentator on the Middle East and North Africa, was arrested by immigration officers on Sunday morning.


The journalist had spoken at the annual gala of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) Sacramento brunch in California on Saturday, and was scheduled to give another speech on Sunday in Florida.

However, he was detained at San Francisco airport.

Sami Hamdi: UK citizen who encouraged others to 'celebrate' October 7 detained in US for 'supporting terrorism'

Tricia McLaughlin, spokeswoman for the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said: “This individual’s visa was revoked and he is in Ice [immigration and customs enforcement] custody pending removal.

“Under President Trump, those who support terrorism and undermine American national security will not be allowed to work or visit this country. It’s common sense.”

Following Hamas’s attack on Israel on October 7 2023, which saw around 1,200 killed, Mr Hamdi encouraged others to “celebrate”.

He told a mosque in London: “We are pitying people who brought a huge victory since 1948.

Anger, defiance in the UK as October 7 anniversary colored by Manchester attack | The Times of Israel

 

“Don’t pity them, they don’t want your pity. Celebrate the victory.

“How many of you felt it in your hearts when you got the news that it happened? How many of you felt the Euphoria? Allah Akbar!”

At the same event, Mr Hamdi denied widespread reports of sexual violence committed by Hamas, claiming instead that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu “had to lie about rape”, according to the National Post.

Last year, two of the commentator’s speeches were cancelled by the Canadian universities which were set to host them.

Anger, defiance in the UK as October 7 anniversary colored by Manchester attack | The Times of Israel

Mr Hamdi denied widespread reports of sexual violence committed by Hamas

 

 

A spokesman for Concordio, which banned Mr Hamdi, said that his speech would produce a “culture of intimidation”.

Laura Loomer, an American conservative activist, called on British Home Secretary Shabana Mahmoud to get involved, saying: “Will she arrest him? Or while she allow this jihadi to roam the streets of the UK?”

However, CAIR rejected the reasoning for Mr Hamdi’s detainment.

It said: “Abducting a prominent British Muslim journalist and political commentator on a speaking tour in the United Stated because he dared to criticise the Israeli Government’s genocide is a blatant affront to free speech.

 

Laura Loomer called on Shabana Mahmood to arrest Sami Hamdi when he returns to the UK

 

UK authorities threaten extradition, jail to US citizens for online posts stoking riots

“Our nation must stop abducting critics of the Israeli Government at the behest of unhinged Israel First bigots.

Mr Hamdi has previously denied accusations that he celebrated October 7, instead claiming he was “illustrating the international recognition that efforts to normalise relations in the Middle East must include Palestinian people.”

He told the National Post: “The October 7 events underscore the failure of any approach that seeks normalisation at the expense of the Palestinian people.”

American authorities said: “Mr Hamdi entered the United Stated on a visitor visa October 19, through John Wayne Airport in Orange Country, California.

“The state department’s bureau of consular affairs revoked Mr Hamdi’s visa October 24, 2025, effective immediately.

“The Ice detained Mr Hamdi and he was illegally in the country, and he will be placed in immigration proceedings.”

UK Citizen Who Encouraged Others to ‘Celebrate’ October 7 Detained in the US for Alleged Support of Terrorism

The detention of British political commentator Sami Hamdi in the United States has sparked widespread controversy and raised important questions about terrorism, freedom of speech, immigration laws and international relations. Hamdi was detained by US immigration authorities at San Francisco International Airport in October 2025 while travelling on a speaking tour. The incident attracted considerable attention after the US Department of Homeland Security referred to allegations that he had expressed support for terrorism following Hamas’s October 7, 2023 attack on Israel. His previous remarks encouraging an audience to celebrate what he described as a victory became a central part of the controversy. While American officials defended their actions on national security grounds, supporters of Hamdi argued that his detention was politically motivated and threatened freedom of expression. The case has therefore become part of a wider debate about the boundaries between political speech, support for terrorism and individual rights.

First of all, it is important to understand the background of the October 7 attacks. On that day in 2023, Hamas-led militants launched a large-scale attack on southern Israel, killing approximately 1,200 people and taking around 250 hostages. The attacks included shootings, killings of civilians and assaults on communities and a music festival. The incident shocked the international community and triggered a major military conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza. The subsequent war resulted in extensive destruction, displacement and a severe humanitarian crisis among Palestinians. These events created deep political divisions internationally, particularly regarding Israel’s military response, Palestinian rights and the future of the Middle East.

Sami Hamdi, a British political commentator specialising in Middle Eastern affairs, became involved in the controversy because of comments he reportedly made shortly after the October 7 attacks. According to media reports, he addressed an audience at a London mosque and encouraged people to celebrate what he described as a victory. His remarks included references to the emotions people experienced when they heard about the events. These statements attracted criticism because many people interpreted them as expressing approval of an attack that had resulted in the deaths of numerous civilians and the taking of hostages. Critics argued that celebrating such violence was deeply offensive and could contribute to the normalisation of terrorism.

In October 2025, Hamdi travelled to the United States to participate in a speaking tour organised in connection with the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR). However, on October 26, he was detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials at San Francisco International Airport. The Department of Homeland Security subsequently confirmed that his visa had been revoked and that he was being held pending removal from the country. US officials stated that individuals considered to support terrorism or undermine American national security would not be permitted to remain in the United States. The detention immediately attracted international media attention and generated strong reactions from political organisations, journalists and civil rights advocates.

The American government’s position focused on national security and the alleged consequences of Hamdi’s public statements. Officials argued that foreign visitors must comply with American immigration requirements and that the government has the authority to revoke visas when security concerns arise. From this perspective, the case was not simply about political disagreement but also about the responsibility of the United States to prevent individuals considered security risks from entering or remaining in the country. Supporters of this approach argued that freedom of speech should not automatically provide protection against immigration consequences, particularly when authorities believe that a person’s public statements demonstrate support for extremist organisations.

However, the detention also generated considerable criticism. The Council on American-Islamic Relations strongly condemned the decision and called for Hamdi’s release. The organisation argued that he had been targeted because of his criticism of the Israeli government’s policies towards Palestinians. Its representatives described the detention as an attack on freedom of expression and raised concerns about the treatment of individuals who publicly support Palestinian rights. Hamdi’s supporters also argued that political commentary about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict should not automatically be interpreted as support for terrorism. They maintained that governments must distinguish between criticism of a state, support for Palestinian political rights and approval of attacks against civilians.

Another important issue concerns the relationship between freedom of speech and national security. Freedom of expression is a fundamental principle in democratic societies because it allows individuals to discuss political issues, challenge government decisions and express unpopular opinions. Journalists, academics and political commentators must be able to examine controversial international events without automatically facing punishment for their viewpoints. Nevertheless, freedom of expression does not mean that every statement is without legal consequences. Direct encouragement of terrorist activity, threats and certain forms of support for prohibited organisations may fall within legal restrictions, depending on the relevant legislation and circumstances. The challenge for governments is to enforce these restrictions without unnecessarily limiting legitimate political debate.

Furthermore, the case highlights the importance of distinguishing between support for the Palestinian people and support for Hamas. These are not interchangeable positions. Millions of people around the world support Palestinian rights, oppose the occupation of Palestinian territories or criticise Israeli military operations without supporting Hamas or its attacks on civilians. Similarly, condemning Hamas’s violence does not mean that people must support every action taken by the Israeli government. A balanced discussion requires recognising these distinctions and avoiding the assumption that everyone expressing criticism of one side automatically supports the other.

The controversy also raises questions about the responsibilities of journalists and political commentators. Public figures who discuss armed conflicts have considerable influence over public understanding and attitudes. Their language can shape how audiences interpret violence, political resistance and humanitarian suffering. Commentators therefore have a responsibility to communicate carefully, particularly when discussing events involving civilian deaths. Celebrating or appearing to celebrate attacks that kill innocent people can cause serious distress to victims and their families. At the same time, journalists must retain the ability to investigate political developments, criticise governments and discuss the historical causes of conflicts without being subjected to arbitrary restrictions.

The case took another significant turn in November 2025, when Hamdi returned to the United Kingdom after spending more than two weeks in US immigration detention. According to reports, he agreed to leave the United States voluntarily following the cancellation of his visa. Hamdi subsequently claimed that his detention was connected to his political advocacy and criticism of Israel. He also stated that legal proceedings had raised serious concerns about freedom of speech. US authorities, meanwhile, maintained their position regarding immigration and national security. His return to Britain did not eliminate the wider debate about the circumstances of his detention or the limits of government authority over foreign visitors.

There are several important lessons that can be drawn from this incident. Firstly, governments must ensure that national security decisions are supported by clear legal grounds and appropriate procedures. Secondly, immigration authorities should communicate their decisions transparently, particularly when individuals are detained because of alleged political or security concerns. Thirdly, media organisations should provide balanced reporting that distinguishes verified facts from allegations and political interpretations. Finally, public figures should recognise the importance of responsible language when discussing violence and conflict, especially when civilian lives are involved.

In conclusion, the detention of British commentator Sami Hamdi in the United States demonstrates the complex relationship between national security, political expression and international human rights. His reported remarks about the October 7 attacks generated serious criticism, while his detention raised concerns among supporters who believed that his political views were being targeted. The case illustrates the importance of distinguishing between legitimate political criticism and expressions that may encourage or support terrorism. Governments have a responsibility to protect national security, but they must also respect fundamental freedoms and ensure that legal powers are exercised fairly. Ultimately, a democratic society must be able to condemn violence, protect innocent civilians and allow open political debate at the same time. Achieving this balance is essential not only for individual rights but also for maintaining public trust in democratic institutions.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *