Andy Burnham’s Labour will say anything to reverse Brexit – but this is truly pathetic. HYN

Burnham-Brexit-honest

Andy Burnham’s (Image: Getty)

And right now, there’s not much of a discussion either. Just hints, leaks and suggestions, and a surprisingly quiet response from Brexiteers. The result? We’re being slowly nudged back towards Brussels, like it or not. Burnham keeps testing the waters. He’s floated everything from restoring freedom of movement to going “all the way” and rejoining the European Union. He’s gaslighting us, playing party politics to unite the anti-Brexit left and trying to reverse the referendum by stealth. And the arguments are getting more ridiculous by the day.

Breakingviews - A roadmap for Andy Burnham to reverse Brexit | Reuters

Labour won the general election promising not to bring back free movement during this Parliament. Burnham’s own election victory came in Leave-voting Makerfield, where he promised voters he wouldn’t reopen the Brexit debate. His exact words were: “The last thing we should do right now is re-run those arguments.” Yet he seems to restart the debate almost every single day.

Burnham also blames almost every ill afflicting Britain on the 2016 vote, even many of our EU neighbours are in a far worse state. Last week, Labour MP Stella Creasy, chair of the Labour Movement for Europe, once again claimed that leaving the EU has cost the UK between 6% and 8% of GDP. It’s a familiar Remainer claim, based on research by the pro-EU Centre for Economic Policy Research. But it relies on questionable assumptions and reaches an extraordinary conclusion.

Andy Burnham does not rule out Brexit reversal being in next Labour manifesto | Labour | The Guardian

Since Brexit, the UK economy has grown 13.2%. That’s disappointing but it’s better than France, up 12.8%, Italy, up 10.7%, and Germany, up a mere 7.2%. If Creasy’s figures were correct, the UK might have grown by as much as 21.2%. Does anyone seriously believe we would have grown at three times Germany’s rate if we’d stayed in the EU?

Burnham also refuses to confront the potential cost of rejoining. We’re unlikely to get the £5billion rebate negotiated by Margaret Thatcher. And may have to rejoin Schengen, accept freedom of movement and eventually adopt the euro. EU negotiators will treat us as supplicants, and laugh in our faces.

Brexit deal is not good enough for British public, says Andy Burnham | Brexit | The Guardian

But why would we want to rejoin a trading bloc whose economic and political power is dwindling, while its bureaucrats accelerate the process by regulating it to death?

Burnham completely ignores the fact that Europe is in turmoil right now. France has been rocked by weeks of protests and rioting, with the unrest spreading to Italy, Germany, Albania and Belgium. German taxpayers fear they’ll be left on the hook for debts run up by the French, whose profligacy risks crashing the euro. Is this the dysfunctional club Burnham wants to beg his way back into? We’d soon be begging to leave again. But Labour’s latest argument for closer EU ties is peak madness.

In a statement marking Remembrance Sunday, Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy said her department wanted to “repair” damage to “the strong links with Europe that veterans’ service helped to secure and endure after the Second World War”.

So apparently the Spitfire pilots defending our skies in the Battle of Britain, the Desert Rats defeating Rommel in North Africa and British troops storming the beaches on D-Day did so because they wanted us to rejoin the EU’s Erasmus+ programme, as Nandy suggested. It’s beyond madness.

Labour is coming up with all sorts of ridiculous arguments to justify reversing Brexit. There’s nothing honest about this process at all. We simply can’t believe a word they say.

Burnham insists he won't seek to reverse Brexit as he lays out by-election pitch - YouTube

Andy Burnham’s Labour Will Say Anything to Reverse Brexit – But This Is Truly Pathetic

Andy Burnham has reignited Britain’s bitter Brexit debate after launching another attack on the decision to leave the European Union, accusing previous Conservative governments of damaging Britain’s economic prospects and weakening the country’s international relationships. His latest intervention has prompted criticism from Brexit supporters, who accuse Labour of attempting to gradually reverse the referendum result without giving voters a clear opportunity to decide the country’s future.

The Prime Minister’s increasingly outspoken comments have created an uncomfortable political situation for Labour. Having previously promised to respect the referendum result and avoid reopening old arguments, Burnham now appears determined to make Britain’s long-term relationship with Europe a major subject of national debate.

His critics argue that the government should concentrate on more immediate priorities, including economic growth, the cost of living, immigration and pressure on public services, rather than revisiting a constitutional argument that dominated British politics for years.

However, Burnham insists that the country cannot ignore the economic consequences of Brexit and that a better relationship with European partners could deliver practical benefits for British households and businesses.

The disagreement raises an important question: is Labour simply trying to improve Britain’s post-Brexit arrangements, or is the government preparing the political ground for a much more fundamental reversal?

Burnham declares that Brexit has failed

On November 16, 2026, Burnham is expected to deliver one of his clearest assessments yet of Britain’s departure from the European Union.

Speaking ahead of a major UK-EU summit, he is expected to argue that the Brexit settlement negotiated under Boris Johnson failed to deliver the promises made to voters.

His proposed speech includes the striking statement: “The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained.”

The Prime Minister believes that Britain’s departure created unnecessary barriers for businesses, weakened economic opportunities and complicated cooperation with European partners.

He is also expected to argue that the Conservative government damaged relationships with Brussels instead of pursuing a more constructive arrangement.

For supporters of Brexit, however, such comments represent a deeply contentious interpretation of the referendum result.

They argue that leaving the EU was about restoring democratic accountability and allowing British governments to make independent decisions about taxation, employment, immigration and regulation.

From this perspective, economic difficulties following Brexit cannot automatically justify returning powers to European institutions.

The debate therefore goes beyond whether Brexit has delivered its original promises. It concerns what voters expected when they chose to leave and whether those expectations should determine future government policy.

A closer relationship with Brussels

Burnham’s immediate objective is to negotiate a new agreement with the European Union.

The proposed arrangements are expected to focus on several practical areas, including food and agricultural trade, emissions trading and youth mobility.

The government believes that reducing unnecessary barriers could improve trade, support exporters and encourage investment.

One particularly important proposal involves closer cooperation over food standards and agricultural products.

Since Brexit, businesses trading between Britain and the EU have faced additional regulatory and administrative requirements. Ministers believe that greater alignment could simplify some of these processes and reduce costs.

Another area under consideration is linking emissions trading systems, potentially helping businesses operating across European markets.

A youth mobility arrangement could also provide opportunities for younger British and European citizens to work and gain experience abroad under agreed conditions.

According to the government, the proposed package could increase British GDP by approximately 0.4 per cent, equivalent to around £17 billion.

However, these figures represent projected economic benefits rather than guaranteed savings or immediate increases in household income.

The government will need to demonstrate how the arrangements would work and how their benefits would be distributed across different industries and communities.

Is Labour breaking its promises?

One of the most controversial aspects of Burnham’s approach concerns Labour’s previous commitments on Europe.

During the 2024 general election campaign, Labour ruled out returning to the EU single market, customs union and freedom of movement.

These commitments were intended to reassure voters that a Labour government would not attempt to reverse Brexit.

However, Burnham has subsequently opened a wider discussion about Britain’s long-term relationship with the European Union.

In September 2026, he suggested that a future Labour manifesto could potentially include a commitment to reconsider EU membership.

He also argued that Britain should examine the advantages and disadvantages of different arrangements rather than treating the current settlement as permanent.

This has created concerns among Conservative politicians and Brexit supporters that Labour’s position could gradually change.

Nevertheless, Burnham has repeatedly stated that he will respect Labour’s existing manifesto commitments during the current parliamentary term.

He has also said that he does not intend to impose a return to European membership without public support.

The distinction between immediate policy and long-term political ambition is therefore central to understanding Labour’s current position.

The Makerfield problem

The controversy becomes particularly sensitive when considering Burnham’s own constituency.

Makerfield voted approximately 65 per cent in favour of leaving the European Union in the 2016 referendum.

This result reflects the strong support for Brexit that existed across many traditional Labour communities in northern England.

During his campaign to return to Parliament through the Makerfield by-election in June 2026, Burnham promised not to reopen the divisive Brexit referendum argument.

He also introduced the idea of the “Makerfield test”, arguing that government decisions should deliver tangible improvements to ordinary people’s lives.

Now, however, his comments about Brexit have raised questions about how his European strategy will be received by constituents.

Critics argue that voters in communities such as Makerfield should not have their previous democratic decision gradually undermined through a series of agreements negotiated by politicians.

They believe that any fundamental change to Britain’s constitutional relationship with Europe should require a clear public mandate.

Supporters of Burnham’s approach counter that improving trade arrangements does not automatically mean reversing Brexit.

A country can maintain its independence while negotiating agreements with neighbouring states.

Nevertheless, the Prime Minister will need to explain how his proposals meet the expectations of people who supported leaving the EU.

Boris Johnson and Brexit supporters respond

Burnham’s increasingly critical language has also attracted opposition from prominent Brexit supporters.

Former Prime Minister Boris Johnson has warned against making Brexit the central political priority of the government.

Johnson has argued that reopening the debate risks reviving divisions that have already dominated British politics for a decade.

He has also defended the referendum result and suggested that voters would not necessarily support another attempt to reverse the country’s decision.

Other Brexit supporters argue that Britain should focus on using its independent position to develop new trade relationships and establish policies suited to domestic economic conditions.

They question whether closer regulatory alignment with Brussels could limit Britain’s ability to develop different approaches in areas such as agriculture, industry and taxation.

For these critics, the government’s proposals require much greater scrutiny.

They want ministers to explain precisely which regulations Britain would adopt, what influence British representatives would have over future decisions and whether the economic benefits would justify the commitments involved.

Labour faces divisions over Europe

Burnham’s approach has also created difficult questions within the Labour Party.

Some Labour politicians believe the party should move towards a much closer relationship with the European Union.

They argue that Brexit has created unnecessary economic barriers and that Britain needs stronger partnerships with European countries to compete internationally.

Former Chancellor Rachel Reeves has also expressed support for considering whether Britain could eventually rejoin the EU.

Other Labour figures remain concerned that reopening the Brexit debate could alienate voters in traditional Leave-supporting constituencies.

They fear that the party could lose support among working-class communities that previously rejected closer European integration.

This disagreement creates a difficult balancing act for the Prime Minister.

He must satisfy Labour politicians who want a more ambitious European strategy while convincing voters that the government respects the referendum result.

The political challenge is particularly important because Reform UK continues to make national sovereignty and immigration central elements of its political message.

What could Britain actually gain?

Supporters of Burnham’s strategy argue that closer cooperation could produce measurable economic advantages.

Reducing paperwork and border checks could help British food producers, agricultural exporters and manufacturers.

Improved cooperation on energy and emissions trading could also provide opportunities for businesses operating across European markets.

A youth mobility agreement could give younger people additional opportunities to study, work and travel.

However, these potential benefits must be assessed alongside the costs and obligations associated with closer alignment.

Businesses may benefit from common standards, but some industries could face additional regulatory requirements.

There are also important questions about immigration, parliamentary accountability and the extent to which Britain would retain freedom to change its domestic policies.

The government must provide transparent assessments rather than relying exclusively on headline economic projections.

British taxpayers and businesses deserve to understand both the advantages and the possible disadvantages of any agreement.

The November 20 summit could become a turning point

Burnham is preparing to meet European leaders at the UK-EU summit scheduled for November 20, 2026.

The meeting is expected to provide an opportunity to discuss practical agreements covering trade, agriculture, climate policy and cooperation between the two sides.

European leaders have welcomed the warmer tone from London but have also made clear that Britain cannot necessarily enjoy the benefits of EU membership while rejecting the obligations attached to it.

This is likely to be one of the most difficult aspects of the negotiations.

Britain wants improved access to European markets while retaining its independent political institutions and avoiding a full return to the single market or customs union.

The European Union, meanwhile, will want guarantees that any agreement provides a stable and predictable framework.

The outcome could therefore reveal how much progress Burnham can achieve without abandoning Labour’s existing commitments.

Conclusion: Britain deserves clarity about its future

Andy Burnham’s latest intervention has reopened one of the most divisive political arguments in modern British history.

His declaration that Brexit has failed represents a significant change in the tone of the government’s discussion about Europe.

For supporters of closer European integration, the proposed agreements offer an opportunity to reduce trade barriers and improve economic cooperation.

For Brexit supporters, however, the government’s approach raises legitimate questions about national sovereignty, democratic accountability and whether Labour is gradually moving towards reversing the referendum result.

Neither economic cooperation nor political independence should be treated as an automatic guarantee of success. Both require careful consideration of the practical consequences.

Burnham must now explain exactly what his government wants from Brussels, what Britain would have to accept in return and how the proposed arrangements would benefit ordinary households.

Most importantly, the Prime Minister must respect the fact that the 2016 referendum was a democratic decision involving millions of British voters.

If Labour intends to pursue a fundamental change in Britain’s relationship with Europe, voters deserve a clear explanation and an opportunity to express their views.

Britain has already spent years divided over Brexit. The country now needs honest information, transparent negotiations and a serious examination of the economic evidence.

The future relationship with Europe should not be decided through political slogans or assumptions about what the public wants.

Ultimately, the responsibility rests with Burnham to demonstrate that his strategy delivers real benefits while respecting the democratic principles that underpin Britain’s political system.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *