The Yanks Tried For Six Years. The SBS Did It In One Night. How SBS Finished What America Couldn’t.H

The Yanks Tried For Six Years. The SBS Did It In One Night. How SBS Finished What America Couldn’t.

That’s how it’s done, mate, said one of the SPS operators to the Yanks. This is how the SPS finished what the Yanks couldn’t start. Operation Tetris. 6 years of American failure. One night of British excellence. The Americans have been hunting Mulladatala for 6 years. Six years of drones, satellites, Delta Force, and CIA files that run to hundreds of pages.

Six years of the most expensive manhunt in the history of modern warfare. and he is still alive, still giving interviews to Al Jazzer, still grinning at the camera because he knows the Americans are watching and cannot reach him. And somewhere in the south of England, the Special Boat Service is watching the Americans fail and waiting for the call.

They are the unit most people have never heard of. They are quieter than the Yanks, deadlier than the headlines suggest, and they have been in Afghanistan since day one. They have a plan the Americans never thought of. The call is coming. Chapter 1. The wrong tool for the job. To understand why the Americans failed, you have to understand what failing at this actually looked like.

It did not look like incompetence. The men hunting Mulla Dadulla were among the finest military and intelligence professionals in the world. Task Force Orange, the classified American signals intelligence unit that specialized in tracking high-V value targets, had been working his network for years.

The CIA had stations across southern Afghanistan and Pakistan dedicated to building human intelligence around his movements. Predator drones flew thousands of hours over Helman province. The National Security Agency intercepted  communications from every node in the Taliban’s electronic network. The problem was simple. Ddoula had stopped using the electronic network.

Communications & Media Studies

He understood with the strategic clarity of a man who had been hunted for years exactly how the Americans found people. They followed the signals. They monitored the phones, the radios, the satellite communications. Every time a Taliban commander made a call, the Americans had a chance to locate him. Dadullah had looked at the list of Taliban leaders killed or captured since the invasion and noticed something they all had in common.

They had been talking. He stopped talking. No phones, no satellite communications, no email, no electronic signatures of any kind. He communicated through couriers, physical human beings carrying messages on foot or by motorcycle through mountain passes that no drone could follow into.

He moved constantly, never sleeping two nights in the same place, rotating through a network of safe houses built over years of patient preparation. He met in person in compounds surrounded by civilian habitation in locations where the Americ’s most efficient tool, the air strike, the Hellfire missile, the JAMAM from altitude, could not be used without killing the people coalition forces were supposed to be protecting.

The Americans targeted him repeatedly. In 2006, they believed they had him pinpointed in Kandahar province and launched a strike that killed a significant number of fighters. Dadullah was not among them. In April of 2007, just weeks before the events of this story, American and NATO forces thought they had him surrounded in the Chorah district of Urusan province with 200 of his fighters.

They moved to close the net. Dadullah was not in Kora. 3 days later, he appeared on Al Jazzer alive, comfortable, apparently amused, claiming that Osama bin Laden was alive and leading the jihad. He was broadcasting from somewhere in southern Afghanistan. The Americans did not know where.

And here is the thing that makes this failure particularly painful. This is not a man who is hiding. He is commanding. He is planning. He is moving across the battlefield openly enough to meet with his senior commanders and conduct interviews with international media. He is not in a cave. He is in Helmond in the area the Americans are supposed to control running an insurgency that is killing coalition soldiers at a rate that has made the southern provinces the most dangerous territory in Afghanistan.

The problem is not capability. The problem is approach. The American method of hunting high value targets is built on a foundation that assumes the target will use the electronic infrastructure of the modern world. phones and computers and communications devices that allows signals intelligence to locate him. When the target removes himself from that infrastructure, the approach fails and the backup of direct action raids, drone strikes, and overwhelming force fails against a man who has spent 30 years learning how to make himself impossible

to strike cleanly. This is not a problem that more drones will fix. It is not a problem that more Delta Force rehearsals will fix. It is a structural failure. The American toolkit was built for a world where the enemy makes noise. Dadulla makes no noise. What is needed is something different.

Something that does not require the target to make a mistake with his phone. Something patient enough to wait, creative enough to deceive, and quiet enough to operate in the environment DDulla has built around himself. The Americans built a hammer. Ddoula is not a nail. What he is is a problem that requires an entirely different kind of soldier.

A soldier who does not lead with firepower. A soldier who can disappear into a human network and build a trap from the inside. A soldier whose institution has been perfecting exactly this kind of work since the jungles of Malaya in the 1950s. That soldier is not American. He is British. And he has been waiting for this problem his entire career.

Chapter 2. The regiment the Americans had never heard of. While the American military has been throwing everything it has at Mulla Dadullah and coming up empty, a British unit has been running the southern Afghan campaign from the shadows. Most people, if you ask them about British special forces, will tell you about the SAS.

They know the Iranian embassy siege. They know Bravo 20. They know the mythology. 16 minutes in Prince’s Gate. Men in Black AB sailing from the roof. the regiment that turned counterterrorism into something that looked like choreography. The SAS has a public profile, a cultural presence, a name that carries weight in every special forces conversation anywhere in the world.

The special boat service has none of this. The SPS does not brief journalists. Its operations do not become  books, not while they are still relevant, and not while the men involved are still operational. Its selection process is arguably the most demanding in the world and almost nobody outside the military community knows it exists. In 2007, while the SAS is running Task Force Black in Iraq, hunting insurgent networks across Baghdad and the Sunni Triangle in the most intensive special forces counterterrorism campaign since the Second World War, the SPS has been

Books & Literature

given something even harder. Afghanistan, the whole country, just them. This is not an accident. In 2005, the director of special forces drew a clean geographic line. Iraq was SAS territory. Afghanistan was SBS. The decision reflected operational reality. The SBS had been in Afghanistan since the first weeks after September 11th, 2001.

They had been on the ground while the Americans were still planning their invasion. They had built networks, developed sources, accumulated the kind of deep institutional knowledge of Helman province that cannot be generated by satellite imagery or drone footage. It is the knowledge that comes from being there in the dark for years. By the spring of 2007, C squadron of the Special Boat Service has been running targeted operations against Taliban leadership for years.

They are operating as part of task force 42, the British contribution to the joint special forces structure. They have conducted hundreds of operations. They have killed or captured dozens of Taliban commanders. They have in the specific business of hunting men who do not want to be found in southern Afghanistan more operational experience than any other unit on the planet.

They are also, unlike the Americans, not looking for Doula with technology. They are looking for him with people. The SPS approach to intelligence in Afghanistan is built on the same foundation that the regiment’s predecessors built in Malaya in the 1950s, in Borneo in the 60s, in Oman in the 70s. The understanding runs deep. In environments where technology fails, the human network is everything.

Not the human network of official informants and registered sources, but the deeper, slower, more patient work of understanding a society well enough to know who knows what, who trusts whom, and where the pressure points are that will make information move. They have been building this network in Helmond for years.

And in the spring of 2007, that network is about to pay off in a way that will change the course of the Afghan war. The SPS have a plan. Chapter 3, the trap. The plan does not begin with a weapon. It does not begin with a target package or an assault rehearsal or a drone tasked to a new orbit. It begins with a prisoner exchange.

And it is one of the most elegant pieces of operational deception conducted by any intelligence service in the 21st century. In March of 2007, the Taliban are holding an Italian journalist named Danielle Mastroako along with two Afghan assistants. One of the assistants, a driver named Azal Nakbandi, had already been beheaded on video.

A message from Dadullah himself about what happens when demands are not met with sufficient urgency. The demand is simple. Release five senior Taliban prisoners or the journalist dies the same way. The Afghan government faces a choice that has no good answer. Release five experienced Taliban commanders back into the battlefield.

or watch a western journalist die on camera with the full weight of international media attention already focused on the case. The Italian government is applying every diplomatic lever available. The optics of inaction are catastrophic. The Afghan government agrees to the exchange. Five prisoners are released. Master Gako goes free.

Nakshandi whose release had not been explicitly guaranteed in the terms is beheaded anyway. Doula has decided that five prisoners is not enough and casual brutality is how he communicates his indifference to international opinion. To the world watching, this looks like capitulation. A government paying the Taliban’s price, releasing dangerous men back into the war, getting less than it paid for.

It is not capitulation. The five released Taliban commanders are given gifts before they walk out of custody. mobile phones, laptops, the kind of equipment that a returning prisoner might reasonably be given to help him reestablish his life. They accept with gratitude. They walk back into the world they came from, back into the Taliban’s southern network, back toward the commanders and compounds and meeting points that constitute the insurgency’s operational structure in Helmond Province. They do not know what British

intelligence has done to those gifts. The tracking equipment embedded in the phones and laptops is described in public accounts only as sophisticated, which is the language intelligence services use when they do not wish to explain the specific technology. What it means in practice is that every movement these men make, every location they visit, every call made on those devices is being tracked and transmitted to Task Force Orange.

The American Signals Intelligence Unit that has been hunting DDoula’s network for years. The British deception, the American surveillance infrastructure. Two Allied services working the same problem from different angles. Task Force Orange begins to watch. The weeks pass. The released commanders do what released commanders do.

They return to the network, reestablish contacts, travel to meetings, make calls. Each movement is logged. Each new contact adds another thread to the web that British and American intelligence are weaving around the most wanted man in southern Afghanistan. The patience required for this is the patience of the spider. Weeks of watching, weeks of waiting, the certainty that if you hold still long enough, what you are hunting will eventually come to you.

Doula does not know that the men sitting across from him in his meetings are carrying devices that are telling his enemies exactly where he is. By the second week of May 2007, the picture is clear enough to act. Mala Doula is in a compound in Baharam Cha in the deep south of Helman province close to the Pakistani border. He is meeting with commanders.

He is planning the spring offensive. He has fighters around him. He believes he is safe, deep in friendly territory, far from the main coalition operating areas, surrounded by the civilian population that makes him untouchable from the air. The location is confirmed. The window is open.

Now the Americans look at their options. A drone strike is impossible. The compound sits in the middle of a residential area, and the civilian casualties would be catastrophic. An air strike is impossible for the same reason. A large-scale ground assault would take days to plan, would require moving forces that would alert his network, and would almost certainly give him time to disappear before they arrived.

The American toolkit, built for speed and firepower and scale, does not have a clean answer to a defended compound in a civilian area against a target who will vanish the moment he senses movement. The Americans look at the problem, then they look at the British. The SPS are called. Chapter 4. One night, the 12th of May 2007, Baham Cha, Helmond Province, Sea Squadron, Special Boat Service, lifts off by Raf Chinuk into the Afghan dark.

The landing zone is set back from the target, far enough that the sound of rotors does not carry to the compound, close enough that the approach on foot is manageable. The men who step off that helicopter carry what they need and nothing more. This is not a principle, the SPS articulates. It is something bred into the regiment by decades of operational experience in environments where weight is the enemy of effectiveness.

Every kilogram not carried is a kilogram of speed and endurance retained. The men moving through the helman knight have spent years in this country in this terrain and they carry the specific load of men who know exactly what they are walking into. Baham Cha is Taliban country. It sits close to the Pakistani border, a transit point for fighters and weapons moving between the two countries.

A place where the Pakistani authorities either cannot or will not intervene, where the Taliban move with a freedom they do not have anywhere near the coalition’s main operating areas. Ddoula has chosen it deliberately. He is on ground he controls in a compound surrounded by civilians, confident that geography and civilian presence make him untouchable.

He is not accounted for men who operate precisely because they cannot use the weapons that require clearance. The approach is conducted in silence through the dark. Navigation without lights, movement without sound, the kind of infantry craft that takes years to develop and that no amount of technological substitution can replace. The SPS have been moving through southern Afghanistan at night for years.

They know which sounds belong to the environment and which ones do not. Which shadows are static and which ones move, how to cover ground quickly while maintaining the tactical awareness that transforms a patrol into an assault force. The moment it reaches its objective, they reach the compound. There is no air support, no gunship circling overhead, no hellfire missile on standby.

The American preference for layered fire support for the overwhelming coverage of an AC30 or an Apache station ready to engage is not available here. The civilian density makes it impossible. What the SPS have is what they have always had. Trained men in the dark moving through a defended position with the controlled aggression of a unit that has rehearsed this scenario hundreds of times.

Inside the compound, there is fighting. Close quarter battle is the most intimate and the most dangerous form of warfare. It happens in rooms and corridors where the distances between contact and outcome are measured in meters, where the margin for error is zero, where the training that produces effective operators under these conditions requires years of repetition until the responses are below the level of conscious thought.

The SPS trained for this constantly, not just on ranges and in training facilities, but through the accumulated operational experience of hundreds of knights in Afghan compounds, building an institutional knowledge of how these situations unfold and how to resolve them in your favor. The men in that compound are not running through a scenario they have rehearsed.

They are executing training refined by years of operational reality. The knowledge of what happens when rooms are cleared in the wrong order. What happens when a target has an exit route the assault team has not covered? What happens when the noise of the initial breach brings fighters from positions the intelligence did not account for? Every lesson the regiment has learned in this country is present in the movements of the men working through that compound in the dark. The assault lasts several hours.

The exact details remain classified as SBS operations almost always do. What emerges in the weeks and months afterward through Andy McNab’s research for his  book the hunt and through British military sources uncomfortable with what is about to happen to the public record is the shape of what occurred. The compound is cleared.

Books & Literature

Ddoula is found. He is engaged. He is shot twice in the torso and once in the back of the head. The controlled double tap is the SPS and SAS method of ensuring a target is neutralized with absolute certainty, no ambiguity, no margin for error. Mulla DDulla, the one-legged butcher of Helmond, the man the Americans have been hunting since 2001.

Books & Literature

The man who laughed at drone strikes and gave interviews to Al Jazera and declared himself untouchable by anything the coalition could bring against him. Dead. His body is transported to Kandahar province where the governor displays it to reporters. An AP correspondent confirms the identification. The left leg is missing. Three bullet wounds, two in the torso, one in the head.

The SPS are already on the helicopter home. Chapter 5. The wrong headline. The world wakes up the following morning to the news that Mulla Dadoula is dead. Here is what they are told. NATO’s International Security Assistance Force releases a statement. The statement describes the operation as US le supported by NATO and Afghan troops.

American officials speak to reporters. ABC News runs the story crediting American forces. The Los Angeles Times reports a US military operation wire services carry the American version to every newsroom in the world. By midm morning on the 13th of May 2007, it is established fact in a 100 countries the Americans got ddoula. The men who actually got ddoula are cleaning their weapons at a forward operating base in Helman province and waiting for the next tasking.

There is no British press release. No Ministry of Defense statement. No SPS spokesperson giving a background briefing to a friendly journalist. The British government says nothing because the British government has been saying nothing about SPS operations in Afghanistan for years. And one successful kill, even the most significant kill of the entire Afghan war, is not going to change that policy.

The Americans had provided genuine intelligence support. Task Force Orange’s surveillance of the tracking devices confirmed Adulla’s location, and that contribution is real and acknowledged. But the deception operation that placed those tracking devices was British. The assault force that entered the compound was British.

The men who pulled the trigger were British. And the morning after the world was told it was American. NATO operations are routinely attributed to the coalition as a whole with the largest contributor the United States named by default. This is not a conspiracy. It is institutional habit. the default language of press releases in a multinational military structure, but the effect is the same regardless of the intent.

The men who built the trap, walked into the compound, and finished it are invisible in the public record. It takes the Times of London to correct this. Days after the initial announcement, The Times publishes a report that is flat and specific. The Taliban’s top commander was killed by British special forces, not American. The article names the SPS.

It identifies C squadron as the assault unit. It notes that British military sources are deeply uncomfortable with the public record as it stands and want it corrected. The correction runs on an inside page. It does not generate the same headlines as the original announcement. It never does. Chapter 6.

The man who wrote it down. Several years later, a former SAS soldier named Andy McNab decides the story needs to be told properly. McNab is by any measure the most prominent veteran of British special forces. He commanded Bravo 20 in the Gulf War. The deepest special forces penetration behind enemy lines since the Second World War.

Eight men, three killed, four captured, one evaded. McNab himself subjected to months of Iraqi interrogation that he survived through sheer refusal to break. His account of that operation became one of the best-selling military  books ever published. He is not a man who is easily impressed by soldiers. He is impressed by what the SPS did in Helmond.

He visits Afghanistan repeatedly through the years of the British deployment, speaking to the men of Ca Squadron and the broader SPS community, building the picture of an operational campaign that has never been publicly acknowledged at the level it deserves. He talks to the men who conducted the doula operation, who planned the prisoner exchange deception, who walked into the compound in Baharam Cha and did what years of American effort had been unable to do.

He takes everything to the Ministry of Defense for clearance. The Modi clears almost all of it because, as McNab notes with characteristic dryness, it makes them look good. The only significant change the Modi requests is the toning down of the language the soldiers use with each other.

the specific dark humor and profane vocabulary of men who process extreme situations by making each other laugh. The Modi feels this does not project the appropriate image. McNab, who has been in rooms with these men and knows exactly what the appropriate image actually is, complies. The result is The Hunt, a  book that treats the SPS campaign in Afghanistan as what it actually was.

Books & Literature

One of the most sustained and successful special forces operations in the history of British military engagement, conducted entirely in the dark, entirely without public acknowledgement against an enemy that the most powerful military in the world had been unable to neutralize. What McNab makes clear in his account is that the Doula operation was not a single brilliant improvisation.

It was the product of years of institutional knowledge accumulation, years of learning the terrain, developing the intelligence networks, understanding the specific dynamics of the Taliban’s command structure in southern Afghanistan, building the human relationships that allowed the prisoner exchange deception to be conceived and executed.

The SPS did not arrive in Bahram Cha in May of 2007 and get lucky. They arrived as the product of deep preparation for exactly this kind of operation. The Americans were told a story. The SBS wrote the ending. Chapter 7. Why the Americans couldn’t do it. This requires honesty because the answer is not that the Americans are bad soldiers. They are not.

Delta Force and SEAL team six are by any objective measure among the most capable special operations forces in the world. They have proven it repeatedly in Moadishu and in Abadabad and in operations that have not been declassified and may never be. The answer is structural and it begins with understanding what the British special forces tradition is actually built on.

The SBS traces its operational lineage to 1942 when six twoman teams paddled 100 km up the Giron River in occupied France to attack German cargo ships in the port of Bordeaux. 12 men went in. Two completed the mission. Two were captured by the Gestapo and executed. Six drowned in the river. The two who survived and completed the attack became the cockal shell heroes.

The men who died were not failures. They were the price of an operation conducted in the absolute minimum configuration with the absolute minimum footprint against an objective that could not be reached any other way. That philosophy of minimum footprint and maximum effect. The willingness to accept that the size of the force is determined by the mission rather than the comfort of the commanders runs through everything the SPS has done since.

It is in the Malayan jungle operations of the 1950s. It is in the Borneo confrontation of the 60s. It is in the Oman campaign of the 70s. It is in every night operation in Helmond between 2001 and 2014. The American military is built on a different philosophy. It is built on mass, on the understanding that overwhelming force properly applied resolves most problems.

This is not wrong. It is correct for the vast majority of military problems. But DDulla was not the vast majority of military problems. He was a man who had specifically engineered his existence to defeat overwhelming force and who moved through an environment where overwhelming force could not be applied without causing the civilian casualties that would undermine the entire coalition mission.

Against a target like that, the American toolkit had no clean answer. The SPS toolkit was built for exactly that problem. And there is another factor, the one that is hardest to quantify and most important to understand. Institutional memory. The SPS had been in Afghanistan since 2001, not rotating through, not deploying for six-month tours, and returning to home base to be replaced by a fresh squadron that had to start the learning process over.

The regiment maintained continuity of knowledge across its operations in a way that allowed intelligence developed in one operation to inform the planning of the next and the next and the one after that. the network of informants, the understanding of which villages could be trusted, the specific knowledge of Dadoula’s security procedures and movement patterns.

All of this was built incrementally and resided in the institutional memory of Sea Squadron in a form that could not be replicated by any amount of briefings or intelligence reports. The Americans had the technology. The British had the knowledge. And on the 12th of May, 2007, knowledge one, chapter 8, what silence actually means.

The SPS operators who flew out of Baharam Cha in the gray light before dawn did not hold a press conference. They did not call the Ministry of Defense to ensure that the morning’s NATO press release correctly attributed the operation. They did not brief a journalist on or off the record about what they had done. They cleaned their weapons, wrote their reports, ate their breakfast, and waited for the next tasking.

The announcement that went out to the world crediting American forces was to them not a theft. It was not something they were going to correct. It was simply the world being the world, which was not their department. This is the thing that is genuinely difficult for outsiders to understand about the British special forces tradition and especially for American observers who operate in a military culture that places significant value on the public  communication of achievement.

Communications & Media Studies

It is not modesty. It is not the performance of humility. It is the operational philosophy of institutions that learned in environments that punish disclosure that the value of a capability is precisely its invisibility. The SAS learned this in Malaya, where the regiment spent 12 years fighting a communist insurgency that the British government did not publicly acknowledge as a war until decades after it was won.

The SPS learned it in the Jerome River in 1942, where the success of the Bordeaux operation depended on the Germans not knowing how it had been done. Silence is not the regiment’s PR strategy. It is part of the operational methodology. What this silence costs over decades is public recognition. The Americans built Delta Force, an extraordinary unit that has done extraordinary things, and the world knows about it.

 Books have been written by its veterans. Films have been made. The name itself carries the weight of accumulated mythology. Delta Force is in the cultural imagination what American Special Forces excellence looks like. The SPS did not have this. After years of sustained operations in Afghanistan that had systematically dismantled the Taliban’s leadership structure in Helman province, after designing and executing the operation that killed the most dangerous man in the Afghan war, after conducting an intelligence deception of a sophistication that rivaled anything

Books & Literature

produced by any service in any theater, the SPS was a name that most of the world had never heard. They did not mind that indifference is not a posture. It is the product of selection. the process by which the SBS over years of attrition on the Breen beacons and in the jungle training areas of Bise and in the swimmer canoist qualification that is the regiment’s own addition to the SAS course finds the specific men who are constituted for this work of every intake that begins SPS selection approximately 10% complete it the 90%

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.