
Morrisons is changing one of its systems (Image: Getty)
Morrisons has announced a new policy that would see it introduce new penalties from January. A “depot rejection charge” — £10 for every case, tray or out-of-box unit rejected at its depots — is to be capped at £750 per stock-keeping unit, a unique code created by a business to identify and track a product or variant in a delivery. The fines will be applicable to products across the Morrisons range and take into account quality issues, damage, short shelf-life, and if they do not meet specifications agreed upon, The Grocer reports.
But firms have said the new system is not clear and does not mean disputes can be properly processed. The new way of doing things could also be a “template” for other retailers and wholesalers, sellers say.
In addition, it comes amid a rise in the number of rejections over the past 12 months, with some suggesting these were for reasons outside their control or not proportional to the fault. A source told The Grocer: “Depots currently operate with widely differing levels of receipt accuracy, as well as numbers of claims and rejections, giving rise to the concern that the interpretation will not be uniformly applied.
“Many are concerned it could become a template for other retailers and wholesalers.” Morrisons told the website it is speaking with its suppliers about the new fines, calling them “balanced and proportionate”.
“Our customers rightly expect the products they buy from us to be of good quality and this starts with the delivery of products from our suppliers,” the firm said. “This new way of working will help ensure that together we meet those standards, every time.
“Where suppliers deliver stock in line with our agreed terms, no charges will apply. As with the introduction of any new ways of working, we understand that suppliers may have questions and we will shortly be providing them with a detailed FAQ which we are confident will allay any concerns.
“We are committed to working collaboratively with our suppliers with the aim of providing the best quality and value to our customers when they shop with Morrisons.”
It comes as Morrisons has launched flashing shelf labels to help customers find products quickly via their mobile phones. Customers can search for items on their phone via the product finder tool on the home page of the supermarket’s More Card app and select “flash price label”.
The app will share the in-store location, ask the customer to confirm if they are in the right aisle, and then the corresponding digital shelf label will flash magenta, making it easier for the customer to spot the exact product they want.
Morrisons Rule Change Could See ‘Penalties’ Rolled Out at UK Stores
Morrisons is preparing to introduce a controversial new penalty system from January 2027, potentially exposing suppliers to significant financial charges when deliveries fail to meet the supermarket’s requirements. The move has already prompted complaints from suppliers, with concerns that the new rules could create additional costs, increase disputes and place further pressure on businesses supplying Britain’s supermarket industry.
Under the proposed changes, Morrisons will introduce a £10 charge for every case, tray or individual out-of-box unit rejected at its distribution depots. The charges will apply across the supermarket’s product range, with a maximum penalty of £750 per product line, known as a stock-keeping unit (SKU), for each delivery.
The announcement has generated considerable discussion within the retail industry because suppliers believe the new system could have serious financial consequences, particularly for smaller businesses operating with tight profit margins.
Although Morrisons insists that the changes are intended to improve product quality and delivery standards, some suppliers fear they could face penalties for problems that are not entirely within their control.
How will the new Morrisons penalty system work?
The new depot rejection charge is expected to come into effect in January 2027.
Under the proposed arrangements, Morrisons will charge suppliers £10 for every rejected case, tray or out-of-box unit delivered to its distribution centres.
The maximum charge will be capped at £750 per SKU, per delivery.
For example, if a supplier delivers products that fail to meet the supermarket’s agreed quality or packaging requirements, the retailer could reject the affected stock and apply the relevant charges.
The new policy will cover several types of delivery problems, including:
- Damaged products or packaging.
- Poor product quality.
- Items with insufficient remaining shelf life.
- Deliveries that fail to meet agreed specifications.
- Other failures to comply with the supermarket’s delivery requirements.
The supermarket says the purpose is to ensure that products arriving at its depots meet the standards customers expect when shopping in its stores.
Suppliers raise concerns over financial penalties
Despite Morrisons’ explanation, the proposed changes have attracted criticism from suppliers who believe the rules are not sufficiently clear.
One major concern involves how rejected deliveries will be assessed.
Suppliers have questioned whether minor packaging damage could result in an entire pallet being rejected, even when the products themselves remain perfectly safe and suitable for sale.
There have also been complaints about inconsistent decisions between different distribution centres.
Some suppliers claim that certain depots apply stricter standards than others, creating uncertainty about whether identical deliveries could receive different treatment depending on where they arrive.
Another concern involves the evidence required to challenge a rejection.
Suppliers want clearer information about how photographs, inspection reports and other supporting documents will be provided. They also want a transparent process allowing them to dispute charges they believe have been applied incorrectly.
Without clear procedures, businesses fear they could find themselves paying penalties before having a reasonable opportunity to challenge the decision.
Could smaller suppliers be affected?
Smaller suppliers may be particularly concerned about the financial consequences.
Large manufacturers often have greater resources to absorb unexpected costs, negotiate contractual arrangements and manage disputes with major retailers.
Smaller producers, however, frequently operate with much tighter margins.
For these businesses, repeated rejection charges could create additional financial pressure, especially when deliveries are rejected for relatively minor issues.
Some suppliers also argue that delivery problems can arise from circumstances outside their control, including late changes to orders, booking difficulties and inconsistencies in depot procedures.
If these issues are not addressed, suppliers fear the new system could create unnecessary tension between supermarkets and the businesses responsible for keeping their shelves stocked.
Morrisons defends its decision
Morrisons has defended the proposed policy, describing the charges as balanced and proportionate.
The supermarket explained that customers rightly expect products to meet appropriate quality standards and that maintaining those standards begins when goods arrive at distribution centres.
A company spokesperson said:
“Our customers rightly expect the products they buy from us to be of good quality and this starts with the delivery of products from our suppliers.
“This new way of working will help ensure that together we meet those standards, every time.”
Morrisons also stressed that suppliers delivering products in accordance with agreed terms will not face charges.
The retailer said it was consulting with suppliers and intended to provide a detailed frequently asked questions document to explain how the system would operate.
The company maintains that its intention is to improve quality and consistency rather than generate additional income through penalties.
Could other supermarkets follow Morrisons?
Perhaps the biggest concern among suppliers is that the new system could eventually influence other supermarket chains.
Industry sources have warned that if Morrisons successfully introduces the charges, other retailers and wholesalers could consider adopting similar arrangements.
Suppliers have already pointed to comparable practices elsewhere in the retail sector, suggesting that rejection charges could become more widespread.
This would potentially increase the financial responsibilities facing manufacturers and distributors supplying multiple supermarket chains.
Businesses could consequently need to invest more heavily in quality control, packaging inspections, delivery planning and administrative procedures to avoid unexpected charges.
For consumers, the longer-term implications are less certain. Supermarkets argue that stricter delivery standards can improve product quality and reduce waste. However, suppliers will be concerned about whether additional operating costs could eventually influence wholesale prices.
What happens from January 2027?
The new penalty system is expected to begin in January 2027, with Morrisons continuing discussions with suppliers ahead of implementation.
Businesses supplying the supermarket will want answers to several important questions:
- What evidence will be required before a delivery can be rejected?
- Will minor packaging damage result in charges?
- How can suppliers challenge an incorrect rejection?
- Will all distribution centres follow identical inspection procedures?
- How quickly will suppliers receive photographs and explanations of rejected stock?
These details could determine how smoothly the new system operates.
Ultimately, Morrisons says the changes are designed to protect product quality and improve the experience of shoppers across its UK stores. Suppliers, however, want reassurance that the new rules will be applied consistently and fairly.
The controversy highlights the increasingly complicated relationship between Britain’s major supermarkets and the businesses supplying them.
While retailers want higher standards and reliable deliveries, suppliers need predictable commercial conditions and a fair opportunity to challenge disputed decisions.
As January approaches, the industry will be watching closely to see whether Morrisons’ new penalty system achieves its intended purpose or creates another source of financial pressure for Britain’s food and retail suppliers.
