Andy Burnham could be facing his “biggest test yet” as at least 75 Labour MPs oppose plans to drill for oil in the North Sea. Speaking on the Daily Expresso podcast, Conservative MP and Daily Express columnist Esther McVey warned that the Prime Minister was facing a “very big backbench rebellion” from his own backbenchers over the controversial Rosebank oil field.
McVey suggested the growing opposition could explain why Burnham had taken a tougher public stance, as he faces pressure from Labour MPs who do not want the drilling project to go ahead. She called the situation as the “Rosebank Rebellion”, with as many as 200 Labour MPs potentially opposing the plans.
Daily Express’ Steph Spyro said: “I think this could end up being actually the biggest test for Burnham. So at least 75 of his MPs have signed a letter opposing the oil field in the North Sea. But there’s word that it might be as high as 200 who actually opposed the project.”
McVey explained the opposition was being driven by former Energy Secretary Ed Miliband and what she called his “protégé” Miatta Fahnbulleh, who is the current energy secretary.
She accused Fahnbulleh of using an “underhand” approach to rally Labour MPs against the project by circulating a letter arguing that drilling would not bring down energy prices.

Andy Burnham might be facing his ‘biggest’ test yet (Image: Getty)
McVey said: “The letter basically says, ‘oh, it won’t bring down energy prices. All sign.’ Well, that is true, it won’t. But what it does is gives us energy security and it also brings in billions to the Exchequer.”
The Rosebank field is one of the UK’s largest undeveloped oil and gas fields. Located off the coast of Scotland’s Shetland, it has become a major flashpoint in the debate over Britain’s energy security and climate concerns.
The project was originally approved in 2023, but that decision was successfully challenged in court. The Government has already approved the development of the Jackdaw gas field, but Rosebank remains a major political flashpoint within the Cabinet.
Andy Burnham Faces Huge Labour Backbench Rebellion: ‘Biggest Test Yet’
Andy Burnham is facing one of the most serious internal challenges of his premiership as growing opposition from Labour MPs threatens to undermine his plans for Britain’s energy future. The controversy centres on the proposed development of the Rosebank oilfield in the North Sea, one of the largest undeveloped oil and gas fields in the United Kingdom. With dozens of Labour MPs reportedly demanding that the project be rejected, the Prime Minister is facing an increasingly difficult decision that could expose deep divisions within his own party.
The rebellion has become known as the Rosebank rebellion, with at least 75 Labour MPs reported to have signed a private letter urging Burnham not to approve the project. Some political commentators believe opposition could eventually involve as many as 100 or even 200 MPs, although these higher estimates have not been independently confirmed. The scale of the reported opposition has raised questions about whether Burnham can maintain party unity while pursuing an energy policy that satisfies businesses, environmental campaigners and ordinary voters. <Cite refs={[“turn605013search0″,”turn605013news10”]}/>
The dispute is particularly sensitive because Labour entered government promising to accelerate the transition towards clean energy and achieve net zero emissions by 2050. Many Labour MPs believe approving Rosebank would contradict these commitments and damage Britain’s reputation as an international leader in tackling climate change.
However, other politicians argue that Britain cannot ignore its domestic energy resources while households and businesses continue to face concerns about energy security, industrial competitiveness and employment.
The Rosebank oilfield at the centre of the dispute
Rosebank is located approximately 80 miles north-west of Shetland in the North Sea. It is considered one of the largest undeveloped oilfields in British waters, with estimated reserves of approximately 300 million barrels of oil.
Supporters of the project argue that developing the field could provide investment, employment opportunities and additional tax revenue for the Treasury. The project could also support Britain’s offshore energy industry, including engineers, construction companies, specialist contractors and supply-chain businesses.
However, environmental campaigners strongly oppose the development. They argue that approving another major oilfield would undermine Britain’s climate commitments and encourage continued dependence on fossil fuels at a time when governments are attempting to reduce carbon emissions.
The previous approval of Rosebank was challenged successfully in court because the environmental assessment had failed to account properly for emissions produced when the extracted oil and gas were eventually burned. As a result, the project must undergo a fresh assessment before a final decision can be made.
This legal background makes the decision particularly complicated for Burnham. The Government must consider environmental obligations alongside the economic and energy-security arguments presented by supporters.
At least 75 Labour MPs oppose the project
The growing opposition within Labour represents a significant challenge because it includes politicians from different sections of the parliamentary party.
Several MPs believe approving Rosebank would undermine the credibility of Labour’s environmental commitments. They argue that Britain should prioritise renewable energy, improve energy efficiency and invest in technologies that reduce dependence on fossil fuels.
The rebellion has also attracted attention because of the involvement of senior figures within the Government.
Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh has previously expressed opposition to new oil and gas developments. Her political position is closely associated with the environmental agenda promoted by former energy secretary Ed Miliband.
Miliband previously described Rosebank as an example of environmentally damaging fossil-fuel development. His position has created an uncomfortable situation for the Government because other senior ministers support giving the project approval.
There have also been allegations that Fahnbulleh’s allies have encouraged Labour MPs to oppose the development. However, her supporters have rejected suggestions of inappropriate political pressure, and the extent of any internal campaign remains disputed. <Cite refs={[“turn605013news9″,”turn605013search3”]}/>
A difficult choice between jobs and climate commitments
One of the biggest challenges for Burnham is balancing environmental responsibilities with the economic interests of communities that depend on the North Sea energy industry.
Supporters of Rosebank argue that refusing permission could put thousands of jobs and investment opportunities at risk. They believe the project could help maintain specialist skills within Britain’s offshore energy sector and provide work for companies already operating in the North Sea.
The oil and gas industry also contributes substantial tax revenue to the Treasury. Supporters argue that additional domestic production could strengthen Britain’s energy security and reduce some dependence on imported supplies.
Conservative politicians and Reform UK representatives have therefore criticised Labour MPs opposing the project. They argue that abandoning domestic oil and gas development could weaken British industry while leaving the country dependent on energy produced elsewhere.
However, opponents point out that oil is traded on international markets. Increasing domestic production would not automatically reduce the prices paid by British households, because energy prices are influenced by global supply and demand.
This is an important distinction in the debate. Rosebank could generate economic activity and tax revenue, but it would not necessarily deliver cheaper electricity or lower household energy bills.
Burnham caught between senior ministers
The disagreement has created tensions within the Cabinet, particularly between politicians responsible for economic policy and those overseeing environmental and energy policy.
Chancellor John Healey is among the senior figures reported to support Rosebank’s development. Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds has also been associated with the argument that domestic energy production could support investment and employment.
On the other side, Fahnbulleh and Miliband have expressed concerns about the environmental consequences of approving the field.
This leaves Burnham facing competing arguments from people within his own Government.
If he supports the project, he risks angering Labour MPs who believe the party must maintain its environmental commitments. If he rejects it, he could face criticism from politicians, unions and businesses concerned about employment, energy security and industrial investment.
The disagreement is therefore much more than a technical decision about an offshore development. It represents a wider conflict over the direction of Labour’s economic and environmental policies. <Cite refs={[“turn605013search3″,”turn605013search8”]}/>
Could ministers resign over Rosebank?
Another concern is the possibility that the disagreement could lead to resignations within the Government.
Some Labour politicians have reportedly warned that approving Rosebank could make it difficult for them to remain in their current positions. The involvement of senior ministers makes the situation particularly sensitive because the decision could create divisions at several levels of the Government.
However, there is an important distinction between private threats, political pressure and confirmed resignations. No assumption should be made that ministers will leave their positions simply because they disagree with the Prime Minister.
Burnham will need to find a way to manage these disagreements without allowing the issue to develop into a wider crisis of party discipline.
Nigel Farage and the Conservatives watch closely
The internal dispute has also provided an opportunity for opposition parties to attack Labour’s energy policy.
Reform UK deputy leader Richard Tice has criticised Labour MPs opposing Rosebank, arguing that refusing domestic oil and gas development could damage British jobs and investment.
The Conservatives have similarly questioned whether the Government is prepared to support the North Sea industry while attempting to achieve its environmental objectives.
For Nigel Farage, the disagreement provides another opportunity to present Labour as divided over important economic questions. Reform UK supports further oil and gas development and argues that Britain should make greater use of its domestic energy resources.
However, the environmental arguments cannot simply be dismissed. Britain remains committed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions, and any decision on Rosebank must consider the climate consequences of extracting and burning additional fossil fuels.
The biggest test of Burnham’s leadership
The Rosebank dispute is particularly important because Burnham has previously promised to create a more open political culture within Labour.
He has indicated that MPs should be able to express disagreements without immediately facing disciplinary pressure from party leadership. His approach is intended to encourage discussion and prevent internal divisions from becoming destructive.
However, the Rosebank dispute could test how far this approach can work when senior politicians hold fundamentally different views.
Allowing MPs to express their concerns is one thing. Making a final decision that leaves a substantial section of the parliamentary party dissatisfied is another.
Burnham must demonstrate that he can listen to different opinions while still providing clear direction. If the Government cannot agree on its energy strategy, businesses and investors could face uncertainty about the future of the North Sea industry.
The Prime Minister also needs to explain how Rosebank fits into Britain’s long-term energy plans, including the development of offshore wind, nuclear power and other renewable technologies.
What happens next?
The final decision will depend on the regulatory assessment and the Government’s consideration of its environmental obligations. Ministers have indicated that the process must be handled properly and that political pressure should not replace the relevant legal and environmental requirements.
The Rosebank project therefore remains an unresolved issue, rather than a decision that has already been made by the Government.
Ultimately, the rebellion represents a major challenge for Andy Burnham because it brings together several competing priorities: protecting employment, maintaining energy security, supporting economic growth and meeting climate commitments.
For Labour, the question is whether these objectives can be balanced without creating a lasting division within the party. For Burnham personally, the decision will demonstrate how he manages disagreements among his own ministers and MPs when political and economic priorities collide.
The Rosebank controversy is unlikely to disappear quickly. Whether the Government approves or rejects the project, there will be significant political consequences. The Prime Minister must now convince his parliamentary colleagues and the British public that his decision is based on a clear assessment of Britain’s long-term interests rather than short-term political pressure.
