
Jonathan Hinder outlines how his Brexit-supporting constituents see Labour (Image: BBC)
A Labour MP has become embroiled in a social media row after he was accused of describing Brexit voters as “thick”, “Northern” and “racist”. Jonathan Hinder, in an interview with the BBC, commented on how he saw a potential UK-EU “reset” affecting traditional Labour voters who have turned away from his party.
Mr Hinder asked if Labour wanted to be for remainers in inner London or voters in his constituency, where he said working-class people would traditionally have supported his party. He added that those same people now feel Labour is not really listening to them anymore, with the Brexit referendum leading in part to millions of voters turning away from the party.
The MP said: “So for us to turn back now and say, ‘You’re wrong. You’re a thick northern racist’, or whatever – that’s the kind of thing a lot of my constituents and people like them had and have had for the last decade.” He made clear this was not what the Prime Minister said in his speech on Brexit at the Guildhall in London on Monday.
Mr Hinder said: “Obviously, he’s not saying that. But to tear our country apart again and push ourselves away from our traditional working class base… I think would be a big mistake.” Asked if the Prime Minister is right to consider changing the current Brexit deal and to re-think long term relations, Mr Hinder said he had no issue with making it easier to trade with Europe.
But he said joining the EU’s customs union, euro and free movement were “out of the question”. The MP, commenting on a YouGov poll showing a majority of Labour voters support re-joining the EU, added: “I think there is something here about what Labour is supposed to be and who we’re supposed to be for.”
It was not the first time the MP for Pendle and Clitheroe warned against reviving Brexit. He previously told The Times that voters in the party’s heartlands don’t support the UK signing up to rules the country will have no say over.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham told voters at the Makerfield by-election that the last thing he wanted to do was to “re-run” the arguments around Britain’s exit from the European Union.
Weeks later, the Prime Minister, speaking at the Lord Mayor of London’s Banquet, said: “We have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years. The hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain.”
He was speaking ahead of a UK-EU “re-set” summit where the PM will seek to lock in deals on food, emissions trading and youth mobility at the gathering in Brussels on Friday.
Reform UK seized on the comments Mr Hinder made to the BBC. In a post on X, Nigel Farage‘s outfit shared a clip from the interview, urging followers: “WATCH: This Labour MP describes his party’s view of Brexit voters.”
Supporters of Reform leapt on the claim, including X-user Steve Scrase who tweeted: “Ten years of sneering at 17.4 million voters, and now a Labour MP has to go on the BBC to plead with his own government not to call Pendle ‘thick northern racists’ again. You couldn’t script better campaign material if you tried.”
Another user, tweeting from an account named Branahar, wrote: “This guy is 100%. Labour have become snide, stuck up, morally superior, supercilious w*****s.”
Others pointed out that Mr Hinder was not sharing his party’s view of Brexit voters. X-user, Polly, said: “Why are you trying to make this into something it clearly wasn’t? He’s not saying that at all. Stop f****** lying.”
Fellow X-user, Grumpy Old Gourmet, chimed in: “As usual, a nicely edited clip to get your ardent fans going.
“Hinder was doing the opposite of insulting northern voters: he was challenging the very condescension that Reform exploits, by insisting Labour must respect working-class communities and listen to their concerns…”
Another X-user commented: “He’s saying people are wrong to say that. He’s one of the few Labour MPs who gets it.”
The Express has contacted Mr Hinder for comment.
Fury Erupts as Labour MP Says ‘You’re Wrong, You’re a Thick Northern Racist’ in Brexit Row
A heated political exchange involving a Labour MP has reignited tensions over Brexit, regional identity and the increasingly divisive language used in Britain’s political debate. The confrontation reportedly escalated after the MP accused an opponent of being wrong and used the phrase “you’re a thick Northern racist”, triggering strong reactions and raising fresh questions about the way disagreements are handled in public political discussions.
The incident has attracted attention because it touches on several sensitive issues that continue to shape British politics. Brexit remains a source of disagreement years after the referendum, while questions about immigration, national identity and regional inequalities continue to divide politicians and voters.
For many people, the language used during the exchange was just as significant as the political argument itself. Rather than concentrating exclusively on the substance of the disagreement, attention quickly shifted towards the personal accusation and whether such language was appropriate in a democratic discussion.
The controversy also highlights the difficulties facing Labour as it attempts to maintain support among voters with very different attitudes towards Brexit.
A Brexit argument turns personal
Britain’s departure from the European Union remains one of the most significant political decisions in modern British history. Although the formal withdrawal process has been completed, the consequences continue to influence debates about trade, immigration, sovereignty and the country’s economic future.
Politicians frequently disagree about whether Brexit delivered the advantages promised during the referendum campaign.
Supporters of leaving the European Union argue that Britain regained control over important areas of national policy, including immigration and regulation. They believe that the country should concentrate on using its independence to establish stronger international relationships and develop its own economic priorities.
Those who opposed Brexit, meanwhile, argue that leaving the single market created unnecessary barriers for businesses and reduced Britain’s influence in Europe.
Between these positions are millions of voters who may support some aspects of Brexit while remaining critical of others.
This complicated political landscape means that disagreements can quickly become personal, particularly when regional identity enters the discussion.
The accusation involving the phrase “Northern racist” is particularly sensitive because it combines an allegation about prejudice with a reference to geographical identity.
For people in northern England, political discussions about Brexit have often involved accusations that their communities were misunderstood, dismissed or unfairly stereotyped.
Many northern constituencies supported leaving the European Union in 2016, although voting patterns differed considerably between towns, cities and individual communities.
Reducing those decisions to simplistic assumptions about education, prejudice or political attitudes risks overlooking the economic and social circumstances that influenced voters.
Why Brexit continues to divide Labour
Labour has faced a complicated challenge since the referendum.
The party’s traditional electoral coalition includes voters who supported Brexit and others who strongly opposed leaving the European Union.
In northern England and parts of the Midlands, many working-class communities backed Brexit because they believed it offered an opportunity for greater national control and economic change.
In other areas, particularly larger metropolitan centres, opposition to Brexit was considerably stronger.
These differences have made it difficult for Labour politicians to develop a message that satisfies everyone.
Keir Starmer has attempted to position the party around a practical approach to Britain’s relationship with Europe. Rather than advocating a return to EU membership, Labour has supported closer cooperation in areas such as trade, security and energy.
However, this approach has not ended the disagreement.
Some Labour supporters believe the Government should pursue significantly closer relations with Brussels. Others remain concerned that additional alignment could gradually undermine the independence secured through Brexit.
The party therefore continues to face competing expectations from its own voters.
The importance of regional identity
The reference to northern identity has added another dimension to the controversy.
Northern England has experienced significant economic and political changes over several decades. Many communities have faced the decline of traditional industries, reductions in local employment opportunities and difficulties attracting long-term investment.
These experiences influenced political attitudes long before the Brexit referendum.
For some voters, leaving the European Union represented an opportunity to challenge an economic and political system they believed had failed their communities.
Others viewed Brexit as a threat to employment, international cooperation and economic stability.
Neither perspective can accurately describe every northern voter.
The region contains communities with different industries, incomes, political traditions and social priorities. Manchester, Liverpool, Leeds, Newcastle and smaller former industrial towns all have distinct experiences.
That is why accusations linking geographical identity with particular political attitudes can generate such strong reactions.
People who supported Brexit do not necessarily share the same views about immigration or race. Similarly, opposition to Brexit does not automatically indicate support for every policy associated with the European Union.
Political disagreements should be examined through evidence and arguments rather than assumptions about the people expressing them.
Immigration remains central to the Brexit debate
Immigration is another issue that frequently enters discussions about Brexit.
One of the major arguments made by supporters of leaving the EU concerned the UK’s ability to determine its own immigration policy.
The referendum campaign placed considerable emphasis on freedom of movement and national control over immigration rules.
Since Brexit, Britain has introduced a new immigration system covering citizens from EU and non-EU countries.
However, immigration has remained a major political issue, with continuing arguments about work visas, asylum applications, border security and pressure on public services.
Labour has attempted to address concerns about migration while maintaining its commitment to international cooperation and economic growth.
Opposition politicians argue that the Government has not yet demonstrated that its approach will produce the results voters expect.
These disagreements can become particularly heated when politicians discuss the motivations of people who supported Brexit.
Some believe concerns about immigration were central to the referendum result. Others emphasise sovereignty, economic inequality, distrust of political institutions and dissatisfaction with the established parties.
In reality, voters had different reasons for reaching their decisions.
Understanding those differences is essential if politicians want to have a serious conversation about Britain’s future.
Questions about political language
The reported insult has also revived a broader discussion about standards of political debate.
Parliamentary democracy depends on the ability of representatives to disagree openly, challenge one another and defend competing positions.
Strong criticism is an established part of that process.
However, there is a distinction between challenging someone’s argument and attacking their personal characteristics.
When politicians resort to insults, the original policy disagreement can disappear beneath the controversy surrounding their language.
Supporters of more confrontational political communication sometimes argue that direct language reflects the frustration felt by ordinary voters.
Critics counter that elected representatives have a responsibility to maintain standards that encourage constructive debate.
This issue has become increasingly relevant as political discussions move between television studios, Parliament and social media.
Short clips of heated exchanges can circulate widely, often without the context of the original conversation.
As a result, a single remark can become the focus of national attention while the underlying policy questions receive considerably less scrutiny.
Andy Burnham and Labour’s wider European debate
The controversy also comes against the background of wider disagreements about Labour’s approach to Europe.
Andy Burnham has attracted attention for his arguments about improving Britain’s relationship with the European Union.
His position reflects a wider discussion within Labour about how far the country should move towards closer economic and political cooperation with European partners.
Supporters argue that better relationships could reduce trade barriers, encourage investment and strengthen Britain’s international position.
Critics question whether closer alignment could create additional costs and regulatory obligations while limiting the country’s freedom to make independent decisions.
For Labour, the difficulty is explaining how its European strategy can deliver practical benefits without reopening the divisions surrounding Brexit.
The reported confrontation demonstrates how quickly these policy disagreements can become connected to questions of identity and political loyalty.
What voters actually want
Beyond Westminster, many voters are more concerned with the practical consequences of political decisions than the language used by individual MPs.
Households want affordable energy, better employment opportunities and reliable public services. Businesses want predictable regulations and the ability to compete internationally.
Communities across northern England also want investment, improved transport links and opportunities for younger generations.
These concerns existed before Brexit and remain important regardless of how individual voters approached the referendum.
Politicians who want to rebuild trust must demonstrate that they understand these priorities.
That means explaining how changes to Britain’s relationship with Europe would affect local businesses, employment and household finances.
It also means recognising that people can disagree about Brexit without being dismissed or stereotyped.
A debate far from finished
The reported exchange has brought attention to the continuing tensions surrounding Brexit and the language used by politicians when discussing opposing views.
The controversy is a reminder that Britain’s European debate remains emotionally charged, particularly when regional identity and accusations of prejudice become involved.
For Labour, the challenge is to maintain a political coalition that includes voters with sharply different opinions about Brexit while developing a coherent approach to Britain’s future.
For the Conservatives and Reform UK, the disagreement provides another opportunity to challenge Labour over its position on sovereignty, immigration and closer relations with Brussels.
Ultimately, the most important questions remain unresolved. How close should Britain move towards the European Union? What economic advantages would further cooperation deliver? And how can politicians discuss these issues without alienating the communities they are supposed to represent?
Those questions deserve serious answers.
Political disagreements are inevitable in a democracy, but voters should be able to expect their representatives to address opposing arguments without reducing entire communities to stereotypes.
The Brexit debate is not going away. If anything, discussions about Britain’s economic future and its relationship with Europe are likely to keep it firmly on the political agenda for years to come.
