Andy Burnham’s big plan is doomed to fail – and then he’ll come after pensioners . hyn

Burnham-welfare-claim

Andy Burnham’s plan to cut welfare may ultimately fall on pensioners (Image: Getty)

Britain’s welfare bill is spiralling out of control, with more than a million youngsters neither in education, employment nor training, known as Neets. Former New Labour minister Alan Milburn has come up with a plan to halve that number but it’s not going to work. It’ll cost a stunning £6billion and is unlikely to bring any savings in the next 10 years. Milburn admits that himself. History suggests he’s right. Previous government-backed attempts to generate jobs and cut the welfare bill have cost a fortune and delivered little. This will go the same way. And there’s another problem.

Andy Burnham's next move is 'electoral suicide' as bombshell plan torn apart - AOL

When former PM Keir Starmer tried to cut welfare benefits by £6billion, rebellious Labour backbenchers forced him into a humiliating U-turn. He lost control over his own party and was doomed thereafter. Now the same backbenchers are rebelling against Milburn’s plan, as are the trade unions. Andy Burnham needs to show some spine to see them off, but seems more likely to cave instead. Whatever he does, youth unemployment is far more likely to rise than fall, and the number of Neets will grow. And Labour itself is to blame.

Chancellor Rachel Reeves cooked up a disastrous £25billion jobs tax that made young people costlier to hire. The result? Unemployment is up more than 100,000 in a year. Angela Rayner chipped in by giving young workers so many opportunities to slack off and sue their own employers that small businesses won’t take a chance on them. Even Milburn has admitted Labour policy has made his job harder. Nice work, Reeves and Rayner.

Andy Burnham warned 'time is running out' over State Pension rule changes | Personal Finance | Finance | Express.co.uk

The fastest way to create real, sustainable jobs is to cut red tape, regulations and employment taxes, and encourage private businesses to create proper jobs. Not government-funded fake ones, which cost taxpayers a fortune, waste everybody’s time, and never come through anyway. But of course Labour won’t do it, because they hate the private sector. So what’s all this got to do with pensioners?

On the Left, there’s growing anger about what they see as Milburn’s assault on the young, as Milburn’s plan includes benefit cuts for those who refuse help. They think the under-25s have been singled out as a specific problem and want the Government to turn its fire elsewhere. Namely, onto pensioners.

Britain currently spends a staggering £334billion a year on welfare. That figure is set to rise to an unsustainable £431billion by the 2030/31 tax year. But here’s the crunch. That figure doesn’t just cover working age benefits, but the state pension too. Like it or not, the DWP deliberately defines the state pension as a benefit, not an entitlement. One that currently costs £146billion a year, around 44% of the entire welfare bill. As the population ages, that percentage is set to rise.

Andy Burnham issued blunt five-word verdict after State Pension triple lock change - AOL

Time and again, the Left has called for pensioners to take the burden of welfare cuts, rather than young people. Burnham won’t take much persuading. His first bold political decision was to say he will scrap the state pension triple lock in 2030 if he wins the next election. So he’s already pushing in that direction.

Note: there was no rebellion against his plan to attack the triple lock. It’s the only spending cut Labour MPs can get behind. They’re virtually cheering him on. Which will make it a lot easier for Burnham to target the state pension.

Andy Burnham should just get rid of this state pension payment | Personal Finance | Finance | Express.co.uk

The benefits bill has to be cut one way or another, but Labour’s left is pushing for pensioners to take the hit, rather than youngsters. In other words, cut payments to people who have contributed for decades, to fund those who have yet to work or pay tax in their lives. Seems back to front to me. Milburn’s reforms won’t save a penny, even if they somehow succeed. Cutting the triple lock will. Pensioners had better watch out.

Andy Burnham's big plan is doomed to fail - and then he'll come after pensioners - AOL

Andy Burnham’s Big Plan Is Doomed to Fail – And Then He’ll Come After Pensioners

Andy Burnham has presented himself as a politician prepared to tackle some of Britain’s biggest problems, promising a major transformation of public services, welfare, housing and social care. His ambitious programme is designed to offer voters a different vision for the country’s future. But beneath the promises lies a difficult financial question: who will ultimately pay for it all? And increasingly, pensioners are finding themselves at the centre of that debate.

Burnham’s plans have attracted considerable attention because they involve changes that could affect millions of households. He wants to establish a National Care Service, reform the welfare system, improve opportunities for young people and address the growing pressures on public finances. These are significant challenges, and there is widespread agreement that the existing arrangements are struggling to deliver the results people expect.

However, announcing ambitious reforms is considerably easier than implementing them. The Government must identify reliable sources of funding, overcome political resistance and demonstrate that its proposals can deliver lasting improvements. Without a convincing financial strategy, even the most attractive promises risk becoming another expensive political exercise.

One of the biggest questions concerns the Government’s plans to reduce the number of young people who are neither in education, employment nor training. The growing number of young people outside the labour market has become a serious concern, particularly as welfare expenditure continues to increase.

Former Labour minister Alan Milburn has been tasked with developing proposals to address the problem. His approach includes helping young people acquire qualifications, access training and move into employment. The intention is to reduce long-term economic inactivity while creating opportunities for people who have struggled to find a route into work.

On paper, the objectives are difficult to argue against. Helping young people become financially independent could benefit individuals, businesses and taxpayers. A successful programme could also reduce future pressure on the welfare system.

But the financial implications are substantial. The programme has been associated with an estimated cost of around £6 billion, while the potential savings are uncertain. Critics argue that government-funded employment schemes have frequently struggled to deliver the long-term results promised by their supporters.

There is a fundamental difference between helping someone find temporary employment and creating a sustainable career. Training programmes cannot manufacture vacancies where businesses are reluctant to recruit. Nor can they solve every problem affecting young people who face health difficulties, inadequate qualifications or limited employment opportunities.

The wider economic environment also matters. Employers make recruitment decisions based on demand, operating costs and confidence about the future. If businesses are struggling with higher expenses and uncertainty, persuading them to take on additional workers becomes more difficult.

Consequently, Burnham’s welfare ambitions depend on more than government programmes. They require a healthier private sector capable of creating genuine employment opportunities.

There are also political complications. Labour has already experienced considerable disagreement over proposed welfare reductions. Keir Starmer’s earlier attempt to introduce substantial benefit savings faced opposition from Labour MPs, forcing changes to the original proposals.

The disagreement demonstrated how difficult it can be for a Labour government to reduce welfare spending without encountering resistance from within its own parliamentary party.

Burnham now faces a similar challenge. If he attempts to impose stricter conditions on working-age benefits, he could encounter opposition from MPs, trade unions and campaigners who believe vulnerable people require greater support rather than additional restrictions.

If he retreats from difficult reforms, however, the promised savings may never materialise.

This creates a serious financial dilemma. The Government wants to reduce expenditure while simultaneously expanding public services and investing in new programmes. Those objectives are not necessarily incompatible, but they require realistic calculations and clear priorities.

And this is where pensioners enter the argument.

Britain’s state pension represents one of the largest areas of public expenditure. As the population ages and more people reach retirement, the financial cost of supporting older generations is expected to increase.

The state pension currently benefits from the triple lock, a mechanism that guarantees annual increases according to whichever is highest of inflation, average earnings growth or 2.5%.

The policy has played an important role in protecting pensioners against rising living costs. It also provides a degree of certainty for people who have spent decades working and contributing through taxation and National Insurance.

However, Burnham has announced plans to change the system from April 2030.

Under his proposal, the state pension would continue increasing by at least inflation or 2.5%, whichever is higher. The direct annual link to average earnings would be removed, with a separate mechanism intended to ensure that the pension maintains its value relative to earnings over a longer period.

The Government argues that this adjustment would protect pensioners while generating substantial savings to help establish the proposed National Care Service.

Official estimates suggest the change could reduce state pension expenditure by approximately £15 billion annually by the end of the 2030s, with the potential savings increasing further in subsequent decades.

That is a substantial financial commitment, and it demonstrates why the triple lock has become such a controversial political issue.

Burnham insists that the change should not be understood as abandoning pensioners. His argument is that older people need more than a regular pension payment. They also need access to affordable care, assistance with daily activities and protection against the potentially devastating costs of long-term illness and disability.

Under his proposed National Care Service, eligible older people would receive free personal care based on their needs rather than their ability to pay. The intention is to reduce the financial uncertainty that currently affects families dealing with social care costs.

This is an important argument because the existing social care system has left many families facing difficult choices. Some older people require substantial assistance but do not qualify for sufficient publicly funded support. Others face considerable financial pressure when savings and property become part of the assessment process.

Nevertheless, the question remains whether changing the triple lock will generate enough money to deliver the wider promises.

Opposition politicians have questioned the financial calculations, arguing that the proposed savings may not be sufficient to cover the cost of the National Care Service. If the projected funding proves inadequate, the Government could eventually face pressure to identify additional revenue.

That could mean higher taxes, further spending reductions or a combination of both.

For pensioners, the concern is that changing the triple lock could become the beginning of a wider debate about the affordability of retirement benefits.

The state pension is not simply another government spending programme in the eyes of millions of people. It represents financial security after decades of employment, taxation and contributions. Many retirees have planned their entire retirement around the expectation that the pension will maintain its purchasing power.

Any changes therefore carry significant consequences for household budgets.

The situation is particularly difficult for pensioners who rely almost entirely on the state pension. They may have limited savings, rising energy bills and little opportunity to increase their income through employment.

Even relatively small differences in annual pension increases can become important over a retirement lasting twenty or thirty years.

Campaigners have warned that weakening the existing protection could increase financial insecurity among older people. Organisations representing pensioners have also questioned whether it is appropriate to use reductions in future pension spending to finance a new public service.

There is, however, another side to the discussion. Supporters of reform argue that the current system must remain financially sustainable as the population ages. They believe that a reformed triple lock, combined with a properly funded care service, could offer older people greater protection against some of the most expensive risks associated with later life.

The disagreement is therefore not simply about whether pensioners deserve support. It concerns how that support should be organised and financed.

Burnham must also consider the political consequences. Pensioners represent a substantial voting group, and many are particularly sensitive to changes affecting their retirement income. Previous controversies over winter fuel payments demonstrated how quickly decisions involving older households can generate public criticism.

The Government will need to explain exactly how the proposed arrangements will operate, how much money they will save and whether pensioners will genuinely receive adequate protection.

It cannot simply assume that voters will accept changes because they are presented as part of a wider reform programme.

The wider welfare strategy presents another uncertainty. If the Government cannot significantly reduce youth unemployment and economic inactivity, the expected savings may take longer to materialise. If the National Care Service then requires more funding than anticipated, pressure could grow elsewhere in the public finances.

This is the central weakness identified by critics of Burnham’s approach: several ambitious promises depend on future savings and economic improvements that cannot yet be guaranteed.

Nevertheless, declaring the entire programme doomed would also overlook the scale of the problems it seeks to address. Youth unemployment, inadequate social care and growing pressure on public finances are genuine challenges requiring long-term solutions.

The real test will be whether the Government can turn its proposals into workable policies without transferring excessive costs onto households least able to absorb them.

For pensioners, the coming years will be particularly important. The triple lock is expected to remain in place until April 2030, but the proposed changes could reshape how retirement incomes increase for decades afterwards.

Older people will understandably want clear guarantees rather than reassuring political language. They will want to know whether their pensions will keep pace with living costs, whether social care will genuinely become more affordable and whether additional charges or tax increases could eventually undermine the promised benefits.

Burnham has placed significant political weight behind his vision for Britain’s future. Its success will depend on whether the financial calculations withstand scrutiny and whether the Government can secure enough public support to deliver the necessary reforms.

If the employment strategy fails to produce meaningful results, the pressure to find savings elsewhere could intensify. If the care service proves more expensive than expected, the Government will face difficult decisions about taxation and spending.

Pensioners therefore have legitimate reasons to follow the debate closely.

The question is not simply whether Burnham wants to reform the welfare system. It is whether his plans can deliver the promised improvements without leaving older generations with less financial security.

For millions of retirees, that distinction could make an enormous difference to their future.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *