Nigel Farage’s Reform UK makes surprise pitch to Scottish independence supporters . HYN

 

Nigel Farage’s Reform UK has sparked fresh political debate in Scotland after making clear that voters who support Scottish independence are still welcome in the party, despite Reform’s firm position in favour of keeping Scotland within the United Kingdom.

The issue came sharply into focus following a debate at the Scottish Parliament on September 22. Reform UK’s Scottish leader Malcolm Offord argued that the 2014 independence referendum had settled the constitutional question for a generation, pointing to the roughly two million people who voted to remain in the UK compared with around 1.6 million who backed independence.

After Reform failed to prevent another debate on Scotland’s constitutional future, all 17 of the party’s MSPs walked out of the chamber.

However, Reform’s opposition to another independence referendum does not appear to mean shutting the door on voters who personally support leaving the UK.

Ahead of the 2026 Holyrood election, the party has increasingly sought support from Scots who may previously have backed the SNP or voted “Yes” in 2014 but have since become dissatisfied with Scotland’s political establishment.

A particularly eye-catching statistic emerged during the Holyrood debate. A Norstat poll cited by MSPs suggested that 30% of Reform voters in Scotland also support independence. The figures highlighted how support for a political party does not always neatly match voters’ views on Scotland’s constitutional future.

Offord has nevertheless maintained Reform’s opposition to reopening the independence question immediately. He has previously suggested that pro-independence parties would need to secure around two million votes before they could claim a sufficiently strong mandate to pursue another referendum.

The message from Reform is therefore unusual but increasingly explicit: voters can support Scottish independence while choosing Reform for completely different reasons, including concerns over the economy, public services, immigration or government performance.

That approach could further blur Scotland’s traditional political divide between the “Yes” and “No” camps — and potentially make the battle for disillusioned voters far more unpredictable.

Nigel Farage’s Reform UK Makes Surprise Pitch to Scottish Independence Supporters

Nigel Farage’s Reform UK has made an unusual political pitch in Scotland: instead of treating supporters of Scottish independence as an entirely separate political constituency, the party has sought to appeal to some of them by putting economic questions ahead of the constitutional divide.

The approach represents a notable change in the way a party associated with British unionism and Brexit is attempting to build support north of the border. Reform has not formally adopted Scottish independence as its policy. Indeed, its Scottish leadership has continued to describe itself as a unionist force. But its strategy has included arguments that could resonate with voters who previously supported independence, particularly those who are dissatisfied with the SNP but remain sympathetic to the idea of Scotland eventually becoming independent.

The distinction is important because Scotland’s constitutional debate has traditionally produced a relatively clear division between nationalist and unionist parties. Reform’s approach attempts to complicate that division by arguing that voters can disagree about the ultimate constitutional destination while still sharing concerns about taxation, economic growth, public services and government performance.

Reform’s unusual message to Yes voters

One of the clearest examples came from Lord Malcolm Offord, Reform UK’s leader in Scotland.

Ahead of the 2026 Scottish Parliament election, Offord argued that some independence supporters could find common ground with Reform. Rather than making independence the central question, he presented economic performance as the immediate priority.

Reform proposed reversing increases in Scottish income tax introduced under the SNP and argued that a more competitive tax environment could help strengthen Scotland’s economy. Offord presented this as a way of improving Scotland’s economic position rather than as a direct argument against independence.

That creates an unusual political proposition.

A voter can support the principle of Scottish independence while also voting for a party that currently supports the United Kingdom. Reform’s argument is essentially that constitutional questions need not determine every political choice.

Offord described his target audience as “rational nationalists” and argued that they could cooperate with moderate unionists around economic objectives. The party has therefore tried to separate the question of Scotland’s eventual constitutional status from questions about how the country should be governed in the meantime.

Why Reform is interested in independence supporters

The strategy reflects the changing political landscape in Scotland.

The SNP has dominated Scottish politics for much of the period since devolution, while the Conservatives, Labour and Liberal Democrats have competed for unionist voters. Reform’s emergence introduces another competitor.

Reports in early 2026 suggested that some former SNP voters and people who backed independence in the 2014 referendum were open to voting for Reform. A Norstat poll cited by The Times found that a portion of people intending to vote Reform said they would vote Yes in a hypothetical future independence referendum. Because the Yes subsample was relatively small, the figures require caution, but they nevertheless attracted attention because they challenged the assumption that independence supporters and Reform voters were mutually exclusive groups.

This does not mean that Reform has become an independence party.

Instead, it suggests that political identities in Scotland can overlap. A person may support Brexit, favour stricter immigration policies, be dissatisfied with the SNP’s record and still retain support for Scottish independence.

Reform is attempting to reach precisely that combination of views.

Farage’s own position is more straightforward

Nigel Farage himself has recently taken a clearer unionist position.

In September 2026, after a meeting of the First Ministers of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland in Cardiff, Farage said the gathering did not represent a threat to the United Kingdom. He also described Scottish independence as a “settled issue” and rejected suggestions that a future Farage government would automatically increase support for independence.

His comments demonstrate the tension within Reform’s Scottish strategy.

The party wants to attract voters who may have supported independence, but Farage has not embraced the constitutional objective itself. Instead, Reform has attempted to argue that independence supporters can vote for the party without abandoning their broader political views.

That is a considerably more complicated message than simply asking Scots to choose between unionism and nationalism.

The party’s Scottish presence has grown

Reform’s strategy also reflects the party’s stronger institutional position in Scotland.

The party entered the 2026 Scottish Parliament election with an organised Scottish operation led by Offord and a full slate of candidates. Reform’s own conference materials presented the election as an opportunity to establish the party as a major political force in Scotland.

The party subsequently became an important presence at Holyrood.

That has changed the political environment in which the independence debate takes place. Reform is now able to participate directly in parliamentary arguments over Scotland’s priorities, while its MSPs can challenge the SNP government on areas such as public finances, housing, healthcare and education.

But its relationship with the independence question has remained complicated.

In September, all 17 Reform MSPs walked out of a Holyrood debate on Scotland’s right to decide its constitutional future. Offord argued that independence was a reserved matter for Westminster and that Holyrood should focus on issues within its devolved responsibilities. Reform’s own account of the walkout said the 2014 referendum remained the constitutional settlement for a generation.

That position clearly separates Reform from the SNP.

The SNP’s response

For the SNP, Reform’s attempt to attract some independence supporters presents a different kind of challenge from that posed by traditional unionist parties.

The SNP’s argument is that voters who want independence ultimately need a political vehicle committed to delivering it. Reform’s approach instead says voters can support independence in principle while prioritising other issues when choosing how to vote.

That distinction could become particularly significant if Scotland’s political landscape becomes more fragmented.

The SNP continues to make the constitutional question central to its political identity, while Reform is attempting to broaden the debate towards economic and public-service questions.

The two approaches therefore offer voters different ways of understanding the relationship between Scotland’s constitutional future and its immediate political problems.

Economics at the centre

Reform’s emphasis on taxation is particularly important.

The party has argued that Scotland’s tax system should be more competitive and that reversing certain SNP tax increases could encourage economic activity. Its Scottish campaign has therefore tried to make the economy a central dividing line.

This approach also reflects a wider argument about the relationship between independence and economic sustainability.

Supporters of independence frequently argue that Scotland could use greater control over taxation, energy and economic policy to pursue a different model from Westminster. Unionist parties generally emphasise the fiscal and economic advantages of remaining within the United Kingdom.

Reform has attempted to occupy an unusual position between these arguments: maintaining the Union while arguing that stronger Scottish economic performance would give Scots greater confidence and opportunity regardless of the constitutional question.

The independence debate remains unresolved

Despite Reform’s unusual appeal to some independence supporters, the constitutional question has not disappeared.

The 2014 referendum remains the most recent nationwide vote on Scottish independence. The result was 55 per cent for remaining in the United Kingdom and 45 per cent for independence.

The SNP continues to argue for another referendum, while Reform maintains that the issue was settled for a generation.

In September, Scottish First Minister John Swinney’s government held another parliamentary debate on Scotland’s right to decide its future. Reform’s MSPs rejected participation in that debate, arguing that Holyrood should concentrate on devolved matters.

This illustrates the fundamental limit to Reform’s appeal to independence supporters.

The party can seek votes from people who support independence without supporting independence itself. But the closer the political debate moves towards an actual referendum question, the harder it becomes to maintain that distinction.

What Reform’s strategy could mean

The significance of Reform’s Scottish strategy therefore lies less in the possibility that the party will suddenly become nationalist and more in its attempt to break down traditional voting blocs.

For decades, Scottish politics has often been described through the language of nationalism versus unionism. Reform is testing whether other divisions — taxation, immigration, public services, economic growth and dissatisfaction with established parties — can become more important to some voters.

That strategy does not guarantee support from independence voters. Nor does evidence that some Yes supporters are considering Reform mean that the broader independence movement is shifting towards Farage’s party.

It does, however, demonstrate that constitutional identity is not necessarily the only factor shaping Scottish political choices.

For the SNP, Labour, Conservatives and other parties, the emergence of Reform creates another competitor for voters whose political identities do not fit neatly into traditional categories.

For Reform, Scotland presents a particularly difficult political challenge: the party must appeal to voters with strong national identities while maintaining its own unionist position.

The result is an unusual political proposition. Reform is effectively telling some independence supporters that they do not have to resolve the constitutional question before deciding how they want Scotland governed today.

Whether that message continues to attract support will depend on how Scottish voters weigh constitutional aspirations against economic concerns and the performance of the parties competing for power.

For now, one fact is clear: Reform UK is no longer treating Scottish independence supporters as an unreachable political constituency. It is actively testing whether some of them can be persuaded to look beyond the traditional nationalist-versus-unionist divide.

Discuss More news

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *