
Jonathan Hinder outlines how his Brexit-supporting constituents see Labour (Image: BBC)
A Labour MP has become embroiled in a social media row after he was accused of describing Brexit voters as “thick”, “Northern” and “racist”. Jonathan Hinder, in an interview with the BBC, commented on how he saw a potential UK-EU “reset” affecting traditional Labour voters who have turned away from his party.
Mr Hinder asked if Labour wanted to be for remainers in inner London or voters in his constituency, where he said working-class people would traditionally have supported his party. He added that those same people now feel Labour is not really listening to them anymore, with the Brexit referendum leading in part to millions of voters turning away from the party.
The MP said: “So for us to turn back now and say, ‘You’re wrong. You’re a thick northern racist’, or whatever – that’s the kind of thing a lot of my constituents and people like them had and have had for the last decade.” He made clear this was not what the Prime Minister said in his speech on Brexit at the Guildhall in London on Monday.
Mr Hinder said: “Obviously, he’s not saying that. But to tear our country apart again and push ourselves away from our traditional working class base… I think would be a big mistake.” Asked if the Prime Minister is right to consider changing the current Brexit deal and to re-think long term relations, Mr Hinder said he had no issue with making it easier to trade with Europe.
But he said joining the EU’s customs union, euro and free movement were “out of the question”. The MP, commenting on a YouGov poll showing a majority of Labour voters support re-joining the EU, added: “I think there is something here about what Labour is supposed to be and who we’re supposed to be for.”
It was not the first time the MP for Pendle and Clitheroe warned against reviving Brexit. He previously told The Times that voters in the party’s heartlands don’t support the UK signing up to rules the country will have no say over.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham told voters at the Makerfield by-election that the last thing he wanted to do was to “re-run” the arguments around Britain’s exit from the European Union.
Weeks later, the Prime Minister, speaking at the Lord Mayor of London’s Banquet, said: “We have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years. The hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain.”
He was speaking ahead of a UK-EU “re-set” summit where the PM will seek to lock in deals on food, emissions trading and youth mobility at the gathering in Brussels on Friday.
Reform UK seized on the comments Mr Hinder made to the BBC. In a post on X, Nigel Farage‘s outfit shared a clip from the interview, urging followers: “WATCH: This Labour MP describes his party’s view of Brexit voters.”
Supporters of Reform leapt on the claim, including X-user Steve Scrase who tweeted: “Ten years of sneering at 17.4 million voters, and now a Labour MP has to go on the BBC to plead with his own government not to call Pendle ‘thick northern racists’ again. You couldn’t script better campaign material if you tried.”
Another user, tweeting from an account named Branahar, wrote: “This guy is 100%. Labour have become snide, stuck up, morally superior, supercilious w*****s.”
Others pointed out that Mr Hinder was not sharing his party’s view of Brexit voters. X-user, Polly, said: “Why are you trying to make this into something it clearly wasn’t? He’s not saying that at all. Stop f****** lying.”
Fellow X-user, Grumpy Old Gourmet, chimed in: “As usual, a nicely edited clip to get your ardent fans going.
“Hinder was doing the opposite of insulting northern voters: he was challenging the very condescension that Reform exploits, by insisting Labour must respect working-class communities and listen to their concerns…”
Another X-user commented: “He’s saying people are wrong to say that. He’s one of the few Labour MPs who gets it.”
Fury Erupts as Labour MP Says ‘You’re Wrong, You’re a Thick Northern Racist’ in Brexit Row
A furious political row has erupted after a Labour MP was accused of making an extraordinary personal attack during a heated debate about Brexit, with the reported insult ‘you’re wrong, you’re a thick Northern racist’ triggering fresh questions about the increasingly toxic atmosphere surrounding Britain’s European future.
The explosive exchange has reignited divisions over Brexit, immigration and national identity, exposing the deep frustration that continues to exist between politicians and voters nearly a decade after the 2016 referendum.
The controversy comes at a particularly sensitive moment for Labour, as Andy Burnham faces mounting criticism over his plans to rebuild Britain’s relationship with the European Union.
For millions of people who voted to leave the EU, the argument was never simply about trade arrangements or economic statistics. It was about democracy, national sovereignty and the right of British voters to determine their country’s future.
Consequently, any suggestion that Brexit supporters are ignorant, racist or incapable of understanding complicated political issues risks reopening wounds that have never fully healed.
The reported insult has also raised questions about whether Labour genuinely understands the concerns of traditional Leave-supporting communities, particularly in northern England and the Midlands.
An extraordinary insult sparks political outrage
The controversy centres on an alleged exchange in which a Labour MP reportedly responded to criticism with the words:
‘You’re wrong, you’re a thick Northern racist.’
The language immediately raises serious questions about political standards and respect for ordinary voters.
Political disagreements are an essential part of democracy. MPs are entitled to challenge arguments, question evidence and defend their political positions.
However, personal insults have no place in serious democratic debate.
Describing somebody as thick because they disagree about Brexit is particularly damaging because it reinforces the perception that sections of the political establishment look down on people who supported leaving the European Union.
The reference to northern identity makes the controversy even more sensitive.
Many communities across northern England voted decisively for Brexit because they believed that Westminster and Brussels had failed to represent their economic and political interests.
They wanted greater control over immigration, stronger democratic accountability and an opportunity to change the direction of national policy.
Labelling people from these communities in insulting terms risks alienating voters who already feel ignored by politicians.
Brexit divisions continue to haunt the Labour Party
Labour has long struggled to reconcile the different political attitudes within its electoral coalition.
Some Labour voters strongly supported remaining in the European Union, while others were passionate supporters of Brexit.
This division was particularly evident in traditional industrial constituencies across northern England and the Midlands.
In the 2016 referendum, many working-class communities voted Leave despite the Labour leadership’s support for remaining in the EU.
Their reasons varied.
Some were concerned about immigration and freedom of movement. Others believed that Britain needed greater control over its laws, regulations and economic priorities.
There were also voters who felt that globalisation had benefited wealthy metropolitan areas while leaving former industrial communities behind.
These concerns cannot simply be dismissed as ignorance or prejudice.
They represent genuine political disagreements about how Britain should be governed.
Labour’s challenge is to represent voters with different views without creating the impression that one section of its traditional support base is less deserving of respect than another.
Andy Burnham’s European ambitions are making matters worse
The controversy comes as Andy Burnham attempts to reshape Britain’s relationship with Brussels.
The Prime Minister argues that closer cooperation with the European Union could improve trade, encourage investment and strengthen Britain’s economic prospects.
His proposals include closer cooperation on agricultural standards, energy and opportunities for young people.
However, critics fear that the European reset could gradually reverse important aspects of Brexit.
Conservative politicians and Reform UK have warned that Britain could become a country that follows European regulations without having an equivalent vote in determining those rules.
The argument has become increasingly controversial because Brexit remains an important political identity for millions of voters.
For many Leave supporters, the referendum represented a promise that politicians would respect their decision even if they personally disagreed with it.
If Labour appears to dismiss those voters while pursuing closer European integration, the party risks creating another major political confrontation.
The alleged insult could therefore become a symbol of a much wider problem: the growing distance between political representatives and the communities they claim to serve.
Why northern voters are particularly sensitive about being insulted
Northern England has experienced decades of economic and political change.
Former industrial communities have faced factory closures, declining employment opportunities and inadequate investment in transport and infrastructure.
Many voters believe that successive governments have failed to deliver the economic renewal they were promised.
Brexit became an opportunity for some of these communities to express their dissatisfaction with the political establishment.
The referendum was also a demonstration that voters outside London and the largest metropolitan centres could determine the direction of national politics.
This makes any insult directed at northern Brexit supporters particularly provocative.
People may disagree about the economic consequences of leaving the EU, but that does not justify questioning the intelligence or character of those who voted Leave.
Democracy requires politicians to engage with voters’ arguments rather than simply dismissing them.
Labour must be particularly careful because its traditional electoral strength has depended on maintaining support across working-class communities.
Alienating those voters could create opportunities for Nigel Farage and Reform UK.
Nigel Farage could exploit Labour’s divisions
Nigel Farage has consistently argued that traditional political parties have failed to listen to ordinary voters on immigration, sovereignty and Brexit.
The latest controversy provides Reform UK with an opportunity to reinforce that message.
Farage can argue that Labour’s attitude towards Brexit supporters demonstrates why millions of people have lost confidence in the established political parties.
For Reform, the issue is not simply the language used by one MP.
It is about whether Labour genuinely respects voters who continue to oppose closer European integration.
The party is particularly interested in winning support among former Labour voters in northern England, the Midlands and Wales.
These are communities where Brexit remains an important political issue and where frustration with Westminster can be considerable.
If Labour politicians appear dismissive or condescending, Reform could benefit electorally.
However, Farage must also demonstrate that his party can offer practical solutions to the economic challenges facing these communities.
Political anger alone cannot rebuild struggling towns, improve public services or create secure employment.
Is Britain heading towards another Brexit culture war?
The wider concern is that Brexit is once again becoming a defining political battleground.
For several years, British politics appeared to move away from the intense arguments that dominated the referendum and its aftermath.
However, Labour’s European reset has reopened many of the same disagreements.
Supporters of closer relations with the EU argue that Britain must be pragmatic about its economic future.
They believe that reducing trade barriers and cooperating with European neighbours could improve prosperity.
Brexit supporters respond that economic cooperation must not become a route towards surrendering democratic independence.
Both positions deserve serious discussion.
The problem emerges when political disagreement becomes personal hostility.
Calling people stupid or racist does nothing to resolve the underlying economic and constitutional questions.
Instead, it risks convincing voters that politicians are more interested in attacking their opponents than understanding their concerns.
Labour must explain its position clearly
If Labour wants to rebuild confidence among Brexit-supporting communities, it needs to demonstrate that it respects their democratic choices.
That means explaining precisely what the European reset involves, which regulations Britain might adopt and how Parliament will retain oversight.
It also means being honest about the financial costs and potential economic benefits.
The government cannot simply dismiss every criticism as political opportunism.
Equally, opponents must distinguish between genuine threats to sovereignty and exaggerated claims about what European cooperation actually involves.
A mature political debate requires evidence, transparency and respect.
The alleged personal attack has highlighted how easily these standards can disappear when Brexit becomes the subject of political confrontation.
Conclusion: Insulting Brexit voters will not make their concerns disappear
The furious reaction to the reported ‘thick Northern racist’ remark demonstrates just how sensitive Brexit remains within British politics.
For millions of people, the referendum was an important democratic decision about national sovereignty, immigration and political accountability.
They may have different opinions about whether Brexit has delivered its promises, but they are entitled to have those opinions respected.
Labour faces a particularly difficult challenge as Andy Burnham pursues closer relations with the European Union.
The government must convince voters that its policies will improve Britain’s economic prospects without undermining the democratic principles that motivated many people to support Brexit.
Politicians cannot expect to win back traditional Labour communities by insulting the intelligence, identity or political choices of the people living there.
If the party allows the impression to grow that Brexit supporters are viewed with contempt, it could hand Nigel Farage and Reform UK a powerful political weapon.
Ultimately, democracy is not about demanding that everyone agrees with the government. It is about respecting the right of people to disagree without being personally abused.
Britain has already spent years divided over Brexit. The last thing the country needs is another political culture war in which ordinary voters become the targets of insults from the very representatives elected to serve them.
